ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Clinton speaks on the economy

Posted: Monday, March 17, 2008 11:39 AM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

From NBC/NJ's Athena Jones
WASHINGTON, DC -- In remarks after her speech on Iraq here this morning, Hillary Clinton said she was watching the developments in US financial markets closely after efforts by the Federal Reserve over the weekend to try to head off a crisis. 

The Fed has lowered the discount rate to increase liquidity in the market and helped JP Morgan buy troubled firm Bear Stearns.

Clinton said she had spoken this morning with the Treasury secretary and the president of the New York Federal Reserve about the steps taken yesterday to restore confidence in the market and said that as a senator from New York, she was concerned about the impact these developments could have on workers and families -- both on Wall Street and on Main Street -- and on the city's economy as a whole.

"I'm particularly concerned about the many employees of Bear Stearns and their families and the ripple effect through the economy that this is going to cause," the senator told reporters.

She did not directly answer questions about what she would do to help shore up the falling dollar or whether the Fed had done enough.

"Clearly, the consequences of inaction were deemed to be much more difficult for the economy than having the Fed step in. The extension of the $30 billion of backstopping JP Morgan Chase is a big commitment on the part of the Fed, but clearly they have the resources to make that commitment. I think that from what I have been told the worry was that there would have been a chain reaction that would have quickly required much more significant resources, so I'm not going to second-guess the Fed either on their movement to get the sale consummated and to back up the JP Morgan commitment or to cut the discount rate," she said, calling this a "really serious piece of business" for the Fed to take this action.

Clinton repeated her call for more urgency to deal with the mortgage crisis as a way of dealing with the credit crisis and said she would do whatever necessary in the Senate to help get the economic situation under control.

"When I first called for a lot of these steps, I was ridiculed by the Bush Administration and frankly my Democratic opponent," she said. "Now we are in the soup and we better get ourselves out of it before the consequences are drastic. There are lots of people who are talking about using tools we haven't used since the Great Depression -- legal tools that give the government the right to do certain things. You know, I haven't looked at the legal background, but some say that even the Fed's unprecedented intervention has roots in what was necessary then. I mean, I cannot stress to you we are in a very dangerous period in the economy. We need vigilance and we need leadership and we've gotta get it from, you know, this Administration."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

P.S. WE'RE JUST GETTING STARTED. THE "HILLARY CAMPAIGN", COME JOIN THE CONVERSATION, hillaryclinton.com.
BO comments "I agree with Hillary"...sorry I was having a debate flashback.
Republicans are voting for Clinton for multiple reasons, most of which have to do with winning the general election:

Many voting for Clinton to boost GOP
http://www.boston.com/news/nation/articles/2008/03/17/many_voting_for_clinton_to_boost_gop/
I appreciate the discussions on issues (even as her campaign is trying to bend or break every rule to get her elected...) and I hope we see more of the same from all the candidates (the speaking on the issues not the rule-breaking).

Obama 08
Obama is tanking in the polls!!!!!
His lead over Hillary is only .08% nationally.
At the beginning of this month he was ahead of McCain by as much as 4 points in some of the polls....now he TRAILS McCain in most of them.
They can't say he beats McCain by a larger margin than does Hillary, because it is now SHE who beats JM head to head!
Super Delegates Take note!

Hillary for President 2008!
I'll sayt it real simple for Hillary; It's because you took the jobs! How do these fools expect people to make house payments when all of the good paying manufacturing jobs have been sent to China and Mexico to be performed by slave labor! Let's outsource are politicians and lawyers so their wages can go in the toilet too. Maybe then they'll get it!
http://twocanpete.blogspot.com
Hilary's plan to freeze interest rates and the long term negative impact that will have on the economy has yet to be scrutinzed by the media. Every leading economist says this would be one of the worst things that she could do.
So let me get this straight.  She voted for the war, she didn't read the NIE, she won't say voting for war was a mistake and yet she thinks she is the authority on this topic.  WTF!  Please Sen. Clinton, leave the race and let the Democrats heal and move on to the general election.  If you care about this country at all you'll step aside.
Perhaps, Senator Clinton can get the market to agree to a "time out" so that she can figure out what to do about intenational trade, mortgage rates, and health care.  Her plans for "time outs" display a complete lack of understanding and even an arrogance that she, as president, would be in a posisiton to halt the economy for days or weeks, or months, while she finds the solution.
When will First Read finally acknowledge the Limbaugh effect? Check out the Boston Globe!
"I mean, I cannot stress to you we are in a very dangerous period in the economy."

Uh, yeah, we know the economy's a big deal.  Trust me, we know.

But is the LANGUAGE OF FEAR so necessary?

I'm sorry, but it just (for me) conjurs up images of George W--getting Americans scared so he can do whatever he wants to do, including (he hopes) voting for his party.

Could we skip the fear language, please.....?
CHICAGO, IL – Margie Gavin Woods, a superdelegate from Illinois, announced she is supporting Senator Barack Obama for President today, citing his ability to unite the country:

I support Barack Obama for president because he is an inclusive candidate who is trying to unite our country, democrats, independents and republicans, around a common purpose. I have spent decades in public service, and I’ve never seen our young people so engaged and enthusiastic. Barack Obama hasn’t forgotten where he’s come from, and I believe he has the experience and the character to lead this great nation forward.

Margie Gavin Woods is the Minority Leader of the Will County Board and a member of the Democratic National Committee.
Yes, she's watching but what can she do.  Over the past two weeks, we've all realized that she has NONE of either the foreign policy experience or domestic policy experience that she's told America she has.  Her "signature" domestic policy accomplishment (SCHIP or children's vaccines) turns out to be the accomplishment of others (Kennedy, Hatch, etc).  Her signature foreign policy accomplishment turns out to be a speech (how ironic) on women's rights in 1995.  It's  shame so many Democrats have been duped.
How about it firstread, can we get an update of the superdelegate count since Obama picked up one today!!!
So, basically, Hillary says "there's a problem!" and "we need a leader who can fix this problem!" but never says "I'm going to fix it by ________"?

See, that's the problem with this economy debate right now.  I know there's a problem.  And I know we need a leader to fix it.  But how?

I'm not convinced that Hillary can "work the economic miracles" that Bill did.  I still don't know what role she played in any of his economic endeavors, since they won't release the White House documentation from that time period.
When will First Read report the voter fraud of the Limbaugh effect? Boston Globe prints hard evidence today! Someone needs to start prosecuting crossover fraud!
Limbaugh's exhortations seemed to work. In Ohio and Texas on March 4, Republicans comprised 9 percent of the Democratic primary electorate, more than twice the average GOP share of the turnout in the earlier contests where exit polling was conducted. Clinton ran about even with Obama among Republicans in both states, a far more favorable showing among GOP voters than in the early races.
Walter Wilkerson, who has chaired the Republican Party in Montgomery County, Texas, since 1964, said many local conservatives chose to vote for Clinton for strategic reasons.
"These people felt that Clinton would be maybe the easier opponent in the fall," he said. "That remains to be seen."
Wilkerson added, "We have not experienced any crossover of this magnitude since I can remember."
In the Mississippi primary last Tuesday, Republicans made up 12 percent of voters who took a Democratic ballot - their biggest proportion in any state yet - and they went for Clinton over Obama by a 3-to-1 margin.
John Taylor, the GOP chairman in Madison County, said he toured various precincts and witnessed Republican voters taking Democratic ballots to vote for Clinton.
"Some people there that I recognized voting said, 'Hey, I'm going to vote in this primary this year, right now. But don't worry, in November I'll be back,' " Taylor said. "They were going to do some damage if they could."
Another popular conservative radio host, Laura Ingraham, who had also encouraged voters to cast ballots for Clinton, crowed about her apparent success the day after Ohio and Texas voted.
Once upon a time, banks loaned a certain percent of the money held in the name of their investors, paying a set interest rate based on their return on loans. Clearly there have been drastic changes in the banking world. I wish someone would explain how it helps to keep cutting the interest rates. Doesn't that encourage more borrowing rather than encouraging more investment? I cannot help but think that all this financial trouble began when Greenspan started lowering the interest rates so drastically. How do 1% interest rates encourage investment? How do they not encourage reckless borrowing?
I used to enjoy Wall Street's troubles ... now I know too many retired people who have re-entered the work force. Unbelievable that an 8 year presidential term can end with the market lower than when it started.

I post the following in hopes that someone in Obama's campaign or the DNC will read it - Seat the elected delegates from Florida, but impose punishment for violating the rules by refusing to seat its superdelegates. Same in Michigan, except support the re-vote (on any day except June 3, because that's not fair to South Dakota and Montana.)
Clearly very schooled and ready to lead on day one, unlike some others.....
Obama has no economic plan, whatsoever.
The only thing Obama will do for us, is to tell us every Memorial Day how horrible our grandfathers were for winning WWII against the Japanese.
Could anyone imagine Obama laying a wreath at the Tomb of The Unknown Soldier on Memorial Day, after his pastor's comments were published last week?
I sure as hell can't.
Hillary -
You talk about "When I first called for a lot of these steps, I was ridiculed by the Bush Administration and frankly my Democratic opponent," she said. "Now we are in the soup and we better get ourselves out of it before the consequences are drastic. There are lots of people who are talking about using tools we haven't used since the Great Depression -- legal tools that give the government the right to do certain things..."

Hello...there are many, many factors that have created this mess over decades. During the first Clinton era the credit crisis began and has continued to be a problem. Consumer lending is a downright black market and has been WAY out of control for years. During the Bush administration we have seen the emergence of MANY agencies who try to help borrowers get out from the burden of consumer credit. That made it where the average borrower's credit was tainted, weak or slow - creating the necessity for a mortgage market catered to those people. That is where Subprime lending, which was a blessing for many people even while being a curse to others, came in to play and gained popularity. This, coupled with corporate greed and a newly accessible mortgage industry that bred individual greed, created an environment where EVERYBODY was able to jump on the real-estate bandwagon. With the weight of the entire economy on that real-estate cart, it was bound to crash and burn...and has.

I am frustrated that Hillary thinks that she can say blame Bush's administration for this 'bust'...it was a LONG time coming, beginning in the Clinton era and snowballing.
"She did not directly answer questions about what she would do to help shore up the falling dollar or whether the Fed had done enough."

Of course not.  She never answers any questions or gives specifics.  She just gives speeches full of nothing and says how she'll investigate, or look at something, or form a commitee..  she DOES nothing and has no PLANS to do anything.  Just a lot of smoke an mirrors.

"You know, I haven't looked at the legal background, but some say that even the Fed's unprecedented intervention has roots in what was necessary then. "

Translation:  I have no clue what I'm talking about but I'll use other people's words and work to make it look like I'm experienced.
She's a socialist! We should listen - but not heed...
I'm watching closely too,  but what could she possibly do to help lil ole Wall & Main?????? THe damage is done people. THe only thing left to do is hunker down, put your dough under the mattress, and tough it out.
Talking about the economy is helpful, blaming Obama is not.

I want to know if Hillary is owned by Wall Street too. We can't afford another president who puts Wall Street's priotities above all else.
That's right HRC,go ahead and blame all this on Obama.  For the love of G-d woman, have you no shame?
Sen Clinton you express concern for the rich workers at Bear Stearns what about the workers all over this country who have been out of work longer than Bear Stearns.  Open your wallet and write yourself 5 million in your campaign open your wallet and write 5 million to those out of work and struggling if you really want to do something.
If she were so concerned she should have been here in NYC doing her job.
She is such a liar......
What we need are some huge inefficient government programs to fix the economy. That, and taxes need to be raised, a lot.
"was ridiculed by the Bush Administration and frankly my Democratic opponent"

>>>> Can someone please inform Ms. Clinton that this is NOT NOT NOT about her?!?!?! Obama did NOT ridicule her, she's just being sensitive. But, leave it up to Clinton to take such horrible news and use it to trash Obama.  Classic Clinton.  But, it begs the question, at least in my mind: Is THIS how she would act as President?  Whining, "well when I said that, I was ridiculed".  Doesn't sound very commander-in-chief like to me - it sounds more like complainer-in-chief.
Clinton was way ahead in terms of releasing a plan to deal with the economy.  If immitation is the sincerist form of flattery, Clinton has been flattered a lot by both Democrats and Repbulicans
It is true, Senator Clinton WAS ridiculed by Bush and Senator Obama beginning a year ago over her prediction that the economy was heading for a crises.

Senator McCain admits he is better at war than economics.  America is swinging by a thread...it is critical that we vote in Clinton.  She will turn the economy around.  You may not like her, you may hate her...but EVERYONE enjoyed jobs and growth during the Clinton years.  She wants to revisit NAFTA (A REPULICAN IDEA) and the WTO.  It is time America starting leading in Manufacturing again vs. outsourcing...it is time America starting leading again in science, technology...and according to Clinton, it is time to get RID of No Child Left Behind and start leading in Education.
I don't understand what Hillary said in this article. Is she just running her mouth to get a sound bite in? Obviously a lot of knowledgeable people decided that it was prudent to keep Bear Stearns from going under over the weekend. How it plays out, we won't know for a little while, but the banking system is relatively quiet today. Why doesn't she provide us with her plan to resolve all of this credit and liquidity problem, and push it throught the Senate?
Bush's plan - bribe folks with Fed cash to go out and spend twice the amount on their credit cards. What a moron!
Hillary needs to start speaking about HER Earmarks, HER Tax Returns, HER Peter Paul lawsuit, HER not winning Texas and Ohio by a large margin and still not conceding, HER LYING about her foreign policy experience, how she robbed those elderly folks in her White Water scam,  and I am sure we all want to know how she turned $1,000 into $100,000 in one year, in the stock market.
Hillary's so predictable. Just when you think you're going to hear where she stands on the economy and what she'd do to help Americans, she takes the opportunity to attack Barack Obama. This is the first policy speech I've heard from her in a long time. She and her campaign have been working full time slinging mud.
Once again, she is leading will real substance and an understanding on how to really lead in challenging times. This women is brilliant and if it weren't for people trying to paint her as something that she isn't she would be our nominee today. I mean wake up people this women knows what she is doing and knows how to get these things done. Yes Obama has policy positions too, but he is following those positions, not leading with new ideas of his own. Great ideas Senator Clinton, I hope we have a real debate about these issues because if we do you will be the next president of the United States without a doubt.
It appears that after a week of irrelevancy we might be back to something of substance. I think it's a bit late for Hillary to address the economy now. I'd say this is where American voter turns on their interests.

All the econonmy candidates are gone, Ron Paul, Dennis K, Edwards are out of the running. These folks platform was on the economy. Nobody cared.
We were to busy electing based on popularity.

Now we still are arguing who hass the best church/pastor. Whose surrogate can say the dumbest thing or whatever non-issue pundits can propose.

After starting the Dem. primary on this downward spiral it's poor form I think for Hillary to change strategies now. But who knows, maybe Obama drinks FASTA and that will tank him.
Instead of commenting on the economy, she needs to worry about her own finances and her dealings with Peter Paul.  
Hillary needs to start speaking about HER Earmarks, HER Tax Returns, HER Peter Paul lawsuit, HER not winning Texas and Ohio by a large margin and still not conceding, HER LYING about her foreign policy experience, how she robbed those elderly folks in her White Water scam,  and I am sure we all want to know how she turned $1,000 into $100,000 in one year, in the stock market.
"I cannot stress to you that we are in a dangerous period in the economy. We need diligence, we need leadership, but I have a plan for the mortgage issue". Clinton

Now that is what I call real specific suggestions to improve the economy. We need diligence, we need leadership. More rheteroic. Hillary has not a clue what to do about the economy but she has her backers convinced she does by stating we need diligence, we need leadership......duh! We see you don't know how to financially manage a campaign Hillary. What makes you think you can manage the US economy?

Were are your tax statements Hillary?  
HILLARY SPEAK: IF I REPEAT THE OUT RIGHT LIES ABOUT OBAMA AND MCCAIN STAND ON THE ISSUES ENOUGH TIMES THE AMERICAN PEOPLE WILL START BELEIVING THEM!I!HILLARY SPEAK:BUSH AND MY HUSBAND HAVE TAUGHT ME WELL.
How can Hillary fix a trillion dollar deficit when she cannot manage her campaign's finances, she even needed to loan herself.... I wonder if she can loan $5 billion dollars to the nation (w/ interest of course) if she mess up...

Where is the updated delegate count? Obama just got another superdelegate endorsement plus dont forget to mention the unallocated delegates... thank you...
What i find interesting is today,Hillary referenced Mccain by saying He want's to keep us in Iraq for a 100 year's. Less than 2 week's ago, she said Mccain is as Qualified as she is.We don't forget that easily Hillary!Some of your Ignorant supporter's may let that pass, but Not Voter's who actually pay attention.

As a Barack supporter, it was very encouraging to see the makeup of voter's attending his townhall meeting in Pennsylvania today.It tells me that voter's there see the Wright thing as Nothing more than what is was, Gotcha Politic's.

American's won't be Fooled this time around as the stakes are too High!As alway's, some will be, but the majority of Independent thinker's see thru the MSM this time around.

Barack Obama should hire Roland Martin as Campaign Spokesman,he sure shut up Rick Sanchez of CNN real quick like yesterday.As Barack supporter's know, We will not be Fooled by the constant barrage thrown at Barack,because We Can see the Forest thru the Tree's.The MSM may be more concerned with Gotcha Politic's, but voter's are Worried about Food, Gas, Mortage payment's, $12 billion a month being spent in Iraq, al-quida stronger than before 911, etc.

American's are Very Aware!We know longer have to depend on MSM for answer's we may be looking for. With the Click of a button, We can find out All we need or want to know. So it's best that the MSM report the Truth, because in 3-5 second's we'll Know the Truth.

YES WE CAN!
Hillary is switching to the economy now that her National Defense 'experience' has been proven a fraud. How about reporting on Clinton vs Paul, Hillary is accused of knowing accepting 1.2 million dollars in illigal campaign funds in a federal case. what is she hiding in her 2006 tax return, this would not be an issue for her if there wasn't something there she doesn't want voter's to see until after the election. Hillary has run a non-issue campaign based on gender "We can make history by electing the first woman president", race and religion; now it's time to address the real issues surrounding Hillary. No more 'free pass'.
Clinton’s interest in speaking with the Treasury Secretary and President of the New York Federal Reserve is to protect the interests of her New York constituents.  And if you believe that, then you’ll also believe that John McCain’s trip to Iraq is to protect the security interests of Arizona residents.  

Right.  


Obama/Webb 08
Hillary has the goods to help our country.  With so many questions revolving around Obama, we need to get behind Hillary so we can win in November.  If Obama wins the nomination I see all the republican fire killing him.  He will go down.  We need a democrat-  Hillary is a terrific choice.  Obama's judgement has cost him the Presidency.  Thank god we found out now.  we still have a chance.  With re-do's in Michigan and Florida, and Pennsylvania coming up she will take the lead in the popular vote.  The super-delegates will smarten up and go with the candidate who has the best chance to win.  Hillary.  (this night not get posted on the Obama network)
I wonder if she would have any comment on the economic impact on folks in upstate New York...you know, the people she promised jobs to and failed to deliver?  Who is she to talk now???  The only experience she has in building up the economy is with regards to her own pocket and accounts.

WHERE ARE THOSE TAX RETURNS?!?!?!?
I am so glad Hillary is in DC. doing all she can to help this country. She is willing to give up campaign time (again) to over see first hand what is happening. Things sure do not look good. Obama on other hand is again today harping on the vote she made with his supporters years ago and he said couple years later maybe he would have made same one. He is sure in a qagmire himself.If his supporters ask what he would do now  all they can say is well Hillary made that vote before or we wouldnt be here now.Any solutions??Well Obama has better judgement his mindset is so much better.  Rezko-boneheaded decision I made.Pastor Wright -well i did disinvite him so speech would go smooth and I could keep my money and votes comeing.But I didnt know he said thoughs things.NAFTA- there was no meeting  well yes meeting  we didnt mention Nafta- Well maybe it was mentioned oh please  on and on  yep  judgement to base your whole campaign on  NOT
Hillary wouldn't know anything about the economy if it fell on her.  Let the experts sort it out.  Recessions are a normal cycle in our oscillating economy.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=775363

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google