ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Obama's speech: The Wright stuff?

Posted: Tuesday, March 18, 2008 9:10 AM by Mark Murray

Here is how the Obama campaign is previewing Obama’s speech, per an aide: “As the events of the last few weeks have pushed the issue of race to the forefront of this campaign, Senator Obama will deliver an address that seeks to understand the divisions that still exist in our society and begin an honest, open conversation about how our generation can begin to move beyond the battles and tensions of previous generations. He’ll discuss the controversy surrounding the offensive remarks made by Reverend Wright, but also why they were so contrary to the purpose of his candidacy, which is based on the recognition that there is far more that unites us than divides us.” 

The New York Times: "Obama, in a speech Tuesday in Philadelphia, will repeat his earlier denunciations of the minister’s words, aides said. But they said he would also use the opportunity to open a broader discussion of race, which his campaign has said throughout the contest that it wants to transcend. He will bluntly address racial divisions, one aide said, talking about the way they play out in church, in the campaign, and beyond. Mr. Obama continued to write the speech on Monday evening, which he believes could be one of the most important of his presidential candidacy, aides said. His wife, Michelle, had not been scheduled to travel with him this week, but hastily made plans to be in Philadelphia."

More: "Obama concluded over the weekend that he had not sufficiently explained his association with the pastor. He told several aides he was worried that if voters did not hear directly from him — in the setting of a major speech — doubts and questions about him might grow.”

Obama's church is not taking this criticism in stride, the Washington Post says. "To his supporters, the message Wright wove through more than 4,000 sermons is now disseminated in a handful of grainy, two-minute video clips that tell only part of his story. Yes, they acknowledge, he was sometimes overcome at the pulpit by a righteous rage about racism and social injustice. But he was a radical who also inspired women to preach, gays to marry and predominantly white youth groups to visit his services. Until he retired last month, Wright, 66, implored all comers at Trinity to ‘get happy’ -- to shout, to sing, to dance in the aisles while he preached the gospel."

"On Monday, Obama reiterated his criticism of Wright and scheduled a major speech about race. He said that on Tuesday in Philadelphia he will explore his relationship with his former pastor and the uproar it has stirred. ‘The statements that were the source of controversy from Reverend Wright were wrong, and I strongly condemn them,’ the senator from Illinois said Monday at a town hall meeting in Monaca, Pa. But he added: ‘I think the caricature that is being painted of him is not accurate. And so part of what I'll do tomorrow is to talk a little bit about how some of these issues are perceived from within the black church community, for example, which I think views this very differently.’” 

A viewer email had an interesting point on "Morning Joe": If Obama knew there was no WMD in Iraq in 2002, how did he not know what Rev. Wright was saying from the pulpit.

The Philadelphia Inquirer gives Rev. Jeremiah Wright the local treatment (he grew up in Philly), speaking to local pastors for reaction, including Rev. G. Daniel Jones, who leads Grace Baptist Church, which Wright’s father served from 1938 to 1980. 
 
The Washington Post also attends a young black professional fundraiser for Obama and notes how many of these folks, who were raised on the Cosby Show in the '80s, see Cliff and Claire in Barack and Michelle.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

This is the kind of speech that Obama could probably deliver with his eyes closed and one arm tied behind his back. It's a natural, because it plays to his message of bringing people of different points of view together. I expect his message to be thoughtful, respectful and still passionate. I predict that -- except amongst right wing extremists -- this issue will be gone within a few days.
Say what you will about Obama.

The man has guts.
This is going to be a great speech.  Wright is a Pastor, NOT a politician.  I don't agree with everything my white pastor says, but i still love the man.  Obama will overcome this and be a great president.  I am praying for Obama and for our right to freedom of religion.  In case it matters I am white (multi-ethnic), 44, a woman, and live in Montana.
He'll hit it out of the park today and come out of this stronger than ever.
Most commentators seem to miss the mark on what Obama needs to say.  This story is about Obama's lack of judgement.  

It doesn't matter that Obama may not have sat in the pews during some of the sermons.  Obama had to have known his pastor was considered incendiary yet he continued his close relationship with this Pastor.

Obama needs to explain the lapse in judgement, similar to his lapse in judgement with Tony Rezko.

Susan from Missouri: I wouldn't open the door for "lapses of judgement" for Obama unless you're willing to discuss similiar issues for Hillary and we don't have enough time or space for THAT one. Her entire LIFE is full of those and most of America (and other parts of the world) don't need to reminded of scandal after scandal. How she has ANY female supporters is beyond me.
Are ou kidding me?  THe guy (Obama) is a mster of deceit!  Syas what is expedient ather than what isss the truth.  We have such a pitiful choice for President this year-republicn or democrate.  WHere are Ronald Reagan prodigees of the world when we need them?
Susan,
  I don't think that the future of our nation rest on Obama judgeing a pastor of a church.  He has shown great judgement on the things that really matter.  Furthermore, I don't think there is anything more Christion than loving the sinner, hating the sin (pastor Wright)
What is Sen. Obama going to say when the truth comes out about his associations with William Ayers as well as the full extent of his 'association' with Tony Resko (17 years)?  

What's Sen. Obama going to say then?  

The American Public bought into his 'Change' we can believe in and 'Judgment' rhetoric  --without doing their homework !!

THANK YOU AMERICA !!  I am SO impressed with your uneducated judgments!!  I am not surprised however as after all, this is a country that voted not once, but twice for Bush --so, the intelligence level cannot be too high.
Obama says words are not "just words". The words we have heard his "spiritual leader" say are disturbing to say the least.
Until recently, all we have seen Barak Obama give a bunch of speeches talking about unity and now what we know is that he has surrounded himself with people who want anything but...

Sadly, from the moment he announced his candidacy, I wondered when the ugliness of racism, that this country still harbors, would come shinning through. What we have seen from Rev. Wright is that racism exits everywhere.

While I am not a supportor of Obama, I do feel badly for him. Today he will have to reject, repell, denounce, etc someone that he cares for very deeply and in the end will still not likely be elected president because of the words that apparently do mean something.

Lisa
the speech part Im interested is how he never heard Rev. Wright hatefull anti american rethoric for 20 years.  Thats the part that will do it for me.  How he spins "God Damn America" to a Kumpaya moment
In regrad to "not knowing" his pastor was like this...ummmmm, lets see, one of the sermons was given on Christmas Day. So you mean to tell me Sen. Obama would miss a Christmas Mass??

Are we REALLY expected to believe that Sen. Obama had no idea that his Pastor was like this?

C'mon Folks... WAKE UP !!

Shall I remind everyone
1. Tony Resko
2. William Ayers

I think come October  --we are going to see "The Best of Rev. Wright", right there on your TV's !!
I look forward to Obama's remarks. Addressing the issue head on is a good thing. I hope to see the true measure of the man.

Reverend Wright's 9-11 remarks are incendiary but he he isn't saying anything that hasn't been said before by many people of many races in many countries, including the United States.

So, while I strongly disagree with Reverend Wright, I wonder if the shock and anger has more to do with his remarks coming from an American of African heritage.

He's not the first preacher to say outrageous things from the pulpit and he won't be the last.

Should Obama be judged by the Reverend Wright's behavior? I hope we take Obama on his own merit.

wHY DOESN'T ANYONE QUESTION THE FAR RIGHT'S RELIGIOUS PASTORS?

Oh that's right the RNC doesn't care if they offend you or alienate you, unless you're rich.

Ask "Morning Joe" if he can stop obessing over Obama's FORMER PASTOR, to question Falwell or Robertsons comments.

What am I saying??? Nevermind, get Keith Oberman to string together a montage of right wing preachers, blaming aids on gays, saying 911 was God's vegeance or any of the other bigotted rhetoric that slides right pass the moraaly outraged masses!
Many of those who support Obama have been uneasy about the Wright matter, and his speech will go a long way to mollify them.

Those conservatives (like Pat Buchanan) who are continuing to express or feign outrage would never support Obama whether or not he has pastor who has made objectional comments at times during his sermons.
Alexus from Dallas TX needs to go back to school.  Spelling and grammar are not your forte.
Obama never grew up in our black society. I think this is what makes me so upset. We worked togeather to get past this all. Maybe it wasnt all done but I think he set us back decades for his own end. He wanted to be pres. He wanted to be state senator  and than us senator now pres. what is next . He never marched and saw what went on here.He went to good schools lived a privaledged life. He chose to stay in Hawaii didnt go with his mother. He wasnt even there when she was sick and died. Now he will promote his dna and be white for white voters in these states. He professed his love for his mother.Would she have been comfortable in this white hateing church?Now states comeing up are more white. Now will come the  I am white speeches. He is so pathetic. We will never win in Nov. if he is our choice.He will and does use blacks,poeple of Ill, his own mother now .I think all he is  is a racist who has a great speech.
I believe B. Obama is who he says he is. I think Hillary Clinton is whatever the poles say she should be.  Check this out;

http://www.dailykos.com/story/2008/3/17/0031/18073/736/478265

The arragance shines forth. How many times have we heard If I can talk to them in a speech they will follow.When someone is as close as he says to pastor you listen to his tapes .maybe he wasnt in a pew but please. The pastors friendship with Farrakhan he had to know about that. Farrakhan endorsed him not as the savoir of the country but of the world. Obama used to say we will change the country after endorsement he said country and the world.Might have changed that after it was brought out. A lot of Black people ,men of church and position have said he cannt fix this one. I believe that.
Because the Far Right is not running for president you MI coma-head, the Far Left is and it shows his lack of Judgement (look it up in a dictionary Demos)for associating with such a radical who he calls his "uncle".
One good thing that has come out of the Wright controversy is that now we understand Michelle Obama's statements better. ("first time I'm proud of my country..America is a mean place") She has set and listened to this vile, anti-American hate for 20 years. Folks, it soaks into your soul and being when repeatedly exposed to it. Repetition is a key component in brainwashing!
I have more questions than comments.
Can any one tell me what was untrue about Rev. Wrights statements? (I'm sure Sen. Clinton has never been called the "N" word.)

If you are a Christian do you think droping atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki was a good thing?

Do you know the connection between Al-Qaeda the United States and the Soviet War in Afganistan?

Last but not least what did your paster preach about two years ago on the second Sunday in June?
Can we all be human beings here - don't every one of you have someone in your life who you love, but who you totally disagree with and at times are embarassed to hear what comes out of their mouths???

Let's judge all the candidates on "the content of their character" and their voting records/accomplishments, not what their friends or supporters say out of context!

Wake up, America.  We're the ones who are making this campaign devisive, not the candidates.
Rev. Wright, as well as many of his white counterparts, who make incendiery comments are a part of a different generation.  I'm about to turn 30 here soon and Obama's spirit uplifts me because I do believe that we desperately need to have a President who will bridge the divide between the Baby Boomer generation and the younger generations (X & Y).

The younger generations don't harbor these same racial tensions because most of the bitter fights were fought before us.  So, while we want to learn about and remember those bitter fights from the past, we do not want to repeat them.
I see so many people trying to shoot down Obama by focusing on the few things that indicate he's not a perfect politician.  Obama's at a disadvantage only because its easier to over-analyze the few things we find wrong with him than it is to choose from the library of baggage Clinton brings to the table.
Before you condem Rev. Wright's clips of 2 sermons over the 20+ years that Sen. Obama's membership I would ask that you PLEASE see this post from one of THE FOUNDERS OF THE RELIGIOUS RIGHT and what he says about what Rev. Wright says then ask why is Rev. Wright being singled out? It is things like this where the "APPEARANCE OF RACISM" rears its ugly head because worse has been said by WHITE pastors. The only difference between what Rev. Wright said and what Revs. Falwell and Robinson said is that Rev. Wright was A BLACK MAN who said it.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/frank-schaeffer/obamas-minister-committe_b_91774.html
This guy is a racist just as Keith UBERdumb is an idiot. Since Barak is black and Keith is a liberal, we can't actually comment on this, as it is not allowable on the Peacock network.
I'm trying to figure out what WMDs in Iraq have to do with what a pastor is saying in Chicago?  How is that an interesting observation?
Susan your right. Judgement is the issue cause he made it so. With lack of experience and not able to stick with anything he tries(thats scarey too)his record is not that great so he clingggggggggs to that vote Hillary made and maybe he said later he might have too.He made that his whole basis for electability. His judgement is better than anything else even experience. Judgement-wright in church -he knew it was a problem cause he disinvited him to his addressing his canadacy. But he prayed in private ,That I think tells us a lot. He would hide his pastor, he was so close to, to get his own  way.Is this honesty and judgement we want in White House. I would like to hear what changes really he would make. There is a debate comeing up. This will not go away.
Does anyone know if and if so where the speech will be streamed?
Seems funny to me that when Pat Robertson and Jerry Falwell used to regularly shoot off their mouths on subjects, such as those the Rev. Wright has addressed, were considered 'right-headed' and therefore OK, especially with the same pseudo-conservatives that now are trying to crucify Rev. Wright.

I do not condone his remarks--they are incendiary and divisive, but the words are not new. It is only that they come at this particular time that they become important.

Senator Obama's relationship with his pastor on religious matters should be his personal right.  He has condemned the remarks that have been published, and will speak on the subject as well.  That should be enough--except, of course, for the more bloodthirsty among us who need controversy rather than issues to munch on daily.
"A viewer email had an interesting point on "Morning Joe": If Obama knew there was no WMD in Iraq in 2002, how did he not know what Rev. Wright was saying from the pulpit."  
That is an "interesting point"?  That is a poor comparison.  The first half of the statement is off base, and a very poor explanation of Obama'a 2002 Iraq War stance (and speech).  That's not an "interesting" point, it's misleading and unproductive.
Sooner or later the fraud trial of Peter Paul v Clinton will come out and hillary monster "George Wallace" clinton will have to answer questions about how she defrauded Peter Paul and why she broke federal election law.  A judge will set a trial date on April 25th and the trial will be in the middle of the GE.  Nothing like a candidate being a defendent in the middle of a campaign.

Aside from the Obama haters that would never vote for Obama no matter what, has anybody ever stopped and thought about the Rev. Wright issue and put it into context.  I understand people questioning Obama about why he has stayed in the church for 20 years with this man as his pastor.  If all I knew about the church was the five minutes of "cut-and-paste" sermon's that Wright gave then I'd be shocked as well.  What people haven't heard is all of the great things that Rev. Wright has said over the 20 years.  

Secondly, perhaps the reason Obama stayed in the church was BECAUSE he disagreed with Rev. Wright.  Obama has said that Rev. Wright has said things with which he disagrees.  Perhaps he wanted to be a counter force to what Wright was saying.  I believe Obama when he says that he never heard Wright say those remarks but I also choose to believe that the church is more than just one pastor.  The church probably does an amazing amount of good and that could be the reason he stayed with the church.  

Also, if Rev. Wright is this incendiary then perhaps Trinity United Church of Christ needs Obama now more than ever.  Perhaps Obama is needed as a counterweight to Rev. Wright.
Some of you people still do not get it.  Yes, there are right wing pastors, the difference is that none of the conservatives belong to their church or where a member of their campaign staff.

I wonder if Senator Obama is going to bring up the fact that if he was white, his campaign would be over.
This morning on the today show news, they said Obama called this problem with his Pastor Rev. Wright a Distraction..  `Oh poor baby`.  AS I said a few weeks ago -- all you people who were posting nasty disgusting remarks about Hillary , and even digging up old, petty dirt on her Husband President Bill Clinton,  Such as -- what the definition of is - is , and also I never had sex with that woman..  THAT STUFF IS SO LAME in comparision to Obama's mentor Rev. Wright.  He was Obama's Pastor and friend for 20 years.  He gave Obama the Title to his book.  The horrible statements he made about 9/11 being the fault of Americans, and God Damn Americans is deplorable!  "Not to even mention his Racists Remarks.  As I said once before "look a little deeper into Obama's closet"  you may be shocked at what you find.  I personaly was not born yesterday,  and I always keep my eyes and ears open.  TO HEAR OBAMA SAY HE NEVER HEARD HIS PASTOR RANT AND RAVE AND SAY THOSE THINGS--YOU WOULD HAVE HAD TO BEEN BORN YESTERDAY TO BELIEVE HIM!  HE IS LYING, AND MAKES ME WONDER WHAT ELSE HE IS LYING ABOUT.  Many Great Presidents, Thomas Jefferson for one, has had sex scandals while he was President.  He had an illegitimate child with a black woman slave while he was president.  HE WAS STILL ONE OF THE BEST PRESIDENTS THIS COUNTRY EVER HAD.--SO IS BILL CLINTON ONE OF THE BEST PRESIDENTS WE EVER HAD.  Obama's shady friends and Pastor will cause the Dems. to loose the General Election in Nov.  That is why we must vote for Hillary Clinton for PRESIDENT!
Next let's hear McCain explain his "spiritual leader," Ron Parsley who hopes to extinguish the "false" religion of Islam.
What Rev. Wright said was reprehensible.  But not any more so than many of the things said by other incendiary "reverends" (Falwell, Robertson, Dobson, Bob Jones, John Hagee, etc.).  America has voted for white men who were chummy with the likes of them for decades.  IF Obama wants to distance himself from a pastor with a big mouth, that might be a refreshing change from what we've received from so many of our "pious" Republican Presidents.  Which reminds me, Didn't McCain just gleefully accept John Hagee's endorsement?  Check out some of the outrgeous things that man has said from the pulpit!    
Gail from Stamford needs to pay attention to the message and not strictly spelling and grammar.  I guess that is the difference between Yankees and Southerners.  Obama is a smooth talker who says exactly what YOU want to here.
obama and rev. wrihgt are wolfs dress in sheep clothing.
http://twocanpete.blogspot.com
Twenty years in the same church, wouldn't Obama have known that his pastor could have at least seemed to be a racist to the casual listeners? Billy Cunningham from WLW 700 radio has been all over this for months.
Susan and Voter in PA,

Until you've listened to the entire, hour (plus) long sit-down Obama had with the press at the Chicago Tribune last week where he explained EXHAUSTIVELY his 17 year associations with Rezco, you need to shut up and STOP asking for explanations you wont bother to read/hear.  There is nothing more maddening than the willfully uninformed insisting that a politician "has some explaining to do."  

Obama answered the "charges" against him so extensively and the reason you haven't heard more about what came out of that Q & A session is because NOTHING CAME OUT OF IT.  There was no impropriety on Obama's part in relation to the land sale.  He admits buying the extra strip of land was boneheaded b/c Rezco was under suspicion at that point, but he wanted room to build a playset for his kids!

In their 17 year history, Rezco never asked for a favor from Obama and Obama never volunteered a favor.  There were no favors to volunteer.

So, there.  I've informed you all.  Now QUIT implying that there's more to it than that unless you want to go listen to the audio and come back with some real gripes.  Which you won't because heaven forbid you have your assumptions challenged!

Obama '08
WORDS WORDS AND MORE WORDS. I was in awe over Obama but now by eyes are open and I am so angry with Obama. How can anybody say they aren't playing the race card when he is and worse then anyone else. He couldn't say even GOD BLESS AMERICA until either yesterday or the day before. Oh I see now he is trying to appease us AMERICANS. Now he is delivering a speech to cover up what we really didn't hear. What does he think all Americans are stupid. I have been to some black churches and not heard this kind of spew in my life coming from a church. He must not have had insight into know betterthen leave the church so will he really have insight into major issues or will Wright be sitting at Obamas right hand.
Thank you Linda B.

Well said.  I could not agree with you more.  
"If Obama knew there was no WMD in Iraq in 2002, how did he not know what Rev. Wright was saying from the pulpit."

Obama never claimed to KNOW 100% that there were no WMDs in Iraq. That was not the entire basis of his opposition to the war.

Secondly, there is no similarity. Basically you're saying "If Obama was paying so much attention in the Senate in Washington, why wasn't he paying as much attention to every sermon from his church in Chicago?"

Well - and this is just for starters - they're two different cities?

Talk about comparing apples and oranges.
I agree with what others are saying-- this is an opportunity for Obama to shine as unity is his message.  On the other hand, the media response to Wrights comments illustrates that there is a racial divide in our country.  I am white but I've attended a black church on occassion and fiery speeches about social justice are commonplace, in many churches.  No politcian could get away with words like Wrights-- but within the realm of the firery  pulpit, his words make sense.  Chickens coming home to roost, is something I've heard many many times with regard to 9/11.  Sorry!  Our country is not innocent.  It is the largest arms dealer in the world.  Reagan armed both Iran and Iraq-- including Saddam Hussein.  The CIA trained Osama Bin Laden.  These are just facts.
As we begin to make excuses for Rev. Wright, in the name of "change," how does that compare with the various condemnations toward others, whose single uttered comment -- though despicable -- somehow wipes away decades of service and forward thinking? If Bill Clinton can be tagged as a "racist," then why shouldn't Rev. Wright? Is it because racism doesn't exist in the black community?
As pastor, who should promotes peace, love... as well as guiding people not to become violence or radical.  Wright speech at his church after 9/11 was such a bad.  He accused everything to white but forgot about this great country has been helping the poor in Africa and around the world more than any other countries.  As an asian, I am so grateful for everything that this country has done and provided opportunity for me.  The freedom that I can enjoy every single day.  May God bless America and whomever become president will be a great leader to serve his/her people.  Of course, Obama is a great man and he can be a great leader.
Sen. Obama has made racial reconciliation the very heart of his message from day one, so it is misleading to portray this as an unwelcome intrusion of race into the campaign. Oprah and Obama started barnstorming Iowa with a message of racial unity in December, 2007. The fact that he has also unapologetically leaned on such a racist pastor as his closest spiritual mentor until a week ago leaves a large credibility gap with voters. It reinforces the very different attitudes toward race that mark his two books, one before his election to represent the south side of Chicago, the other before his election to represent Illinois at large.
Rather then you knuckle dragging Obama supporters that are naming yourselves "Hussein" who are trying to defend Obama's pastor by bringing up other bigots word, why don't you defend Obama's pastor's words on there merit? Please, explain to us how Obama's pastor is uniting, and not dividing America.
Voter in Pa.....you are so right about the intelligence level in this country when we can vote not once, but twice for Bill Clinton, and then even THINK about voting for Hillary is beyond my imagination.  BUT.........voting for a man who we know NOTHING about, in Obama, is so mind-boggling.
MCCain is also not my favorite, but he is the lesser of 3 evils.  Neither Billary or Barack Hussein have done anything worthwhile to make them Presidential material.  Most people in this country are gullible to the political game that BOTH Dems and Republicans throw at us.  ALL politicians say what their masses want to hear.  It is why they are called "politicians" people.  Wake up!!!
Sue in OH


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=778124

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google