ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Obama's speech: The Wright stuff?

Posted: Tuesday, March 18, 2008 9:10 AM by Mark Murray

Here is how the Obama campaign is previewing Obama’s speech, per an aide: “As the events of the last few weeks have pushed the issue of race to the forefront of this campaign, Senator Obama will deliver an address that seeks to understand the divisions that still exist in our society and begin an honest, open conversation about how our generation can begin to move beyond the battles and tensions of previous generations. He’ll discuss the controversy surrounding the offensive remarks made by Reverend Wright, but also why they were so contrary to the purpose of his candidacy, which is based on the recognition that there is far more that unites us than divides us.” 

The New York Times: "Obama, in a speech Tuesday in Philadelphia, will repeat his earlier denunciations of the minister’s words, aides said. But they said he would also use the opportunity to open a broader discussion of race, which his campaign has said throughout the contest that it wants to transcend. He will bluntly address racial divisions, one aide said, talking about the way they play out in church, in the campaign, and beyond. Mr. Obama continued to write the speech on Monday evening, which he believes could be one of the most important of his presidential candidacy, aides said. His wife, Michelle, had not been scheduled to travel with him this week, but hastily made plans to be in Philadelphia."

More: "Obama concluded over the weekend that he had not sufficiently explained his association with the pastor. He told several aides he was worried that if voters did not hear directly from him — in the setting of a major speech — doubts and questions about him might grow.”

Obama's church is not taking this criticism in stride, the Washington Post says. "To his supporters, the message Wright wove through more than 4,000 sermons is now disseminated in a handful of grainy, two-minute video clips that tell only part of his story. Yes, they acknowledge, he was sometimes overcome at the pulpit by a righteous rage about racism and social injustice. But he was a radical who also inspired women to preach, gays to marry and predominantly white youth groups to visit his services. Until he retired last month, Wright, 66, implored all comers at Trinity to ‘get happy’ -- to shout, to sing, to dance in the aisles while he preached the gospel."

"On Monday, Obama reiterated his criticism of Wright and scheduled a major speech about race. He said that on Tuesday in Philadelphia he will explore his relationship with his former pastor and the uproar it has stirred. ‘The statements that were the source of controversy from Reverend Wright were wrong, and I strongly condemn them,’ the senator from Illinois said Monday at a town hall meeting in Monaca, Pa. But he added: ‘I think the caricature that is being painted of him is not accurate. And so part of what I'll do tomorrow is to talk a little bit about how some of these issues are perceived from within the black church community, for example, which I think views this very differently.’” 

A viewer email had an interesting point on "Morning Joe": If Obama knew there was no WMD in Iraq in 2002, how did he not know what Rev. Wright was saying from the pulpit.

The Philadelphia Inquirer gives Rev. Jeremiah Wright the local treatment (he grew up in Philly), speaking to local pastors for reaction, including Rev. G. Daniel Jones, who leads Grace Baptist Church, which Wright’s father served from 1938 to 1980. 
 
The Washington Post also attends a young black professional fundraiser for Obama and notes how many of these folks, who were raised on the Cosby Show in the '80s, see Cliff and Claire in Barack and Michelle.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Most of what Rev. Wright said about the effects of "blowback" from foreign policy seems to me to be correct. I think white America is afraid, not of the content of his sermon but the style of delivery. Remember, we heard very little criticism of Mitt Romney who was a member of a church that preached black inferiority. Black people of Rev.Wrights age group suffered real and direct racism and anger is a rational response. The current Vice-President supported the repressive South-African regime and nobody makes an issue of it. Other then the AIDS being made by the government, I think what he said was true and is similar to what Ron Paul said many times in the Republican debates.
I hope Obama looses the general election. I still think he will get he nomination, but I would like it better if Mrs. Clinton did. I think it would be easier to defeat her. I don't care what his minister said. I care about his positions on many different issues. Health care, Iraq, the role of government in our lives. I like Mr. Obama and as an African American I would like to vote for him. But, I don't believe what he believes.

The role of should be to provide a way not take care of us. He would give a fish when teaching someone to fish is the only meaningful answer. I like senator Obama. I think he is a great man, I just think his policies will enslave rather enrich the lives of those he wants to help. Good intentions. Bad results.
I am ashamed that Senator Obama has any need to explain 'his association' with his church or pastor.Hillary and McCain haven't been asked to 'explain their associations'. Remember the Declaration of Independance? It guarantees all Americans the right to religious freedom.  Hillary is not only dragging the Democratic party in the dirt, she is dragging America throught the mud too.
Shame on the news media, Shame on all of us for allowing this.
The audacity of poor Judgment...

The poor judgment to attend a church with an outright racist for twenty years will not go away no matter how Obama tries to spin this today. His personal judgment to have Wright as a spiritual will have devastating effects on his campaign. There will be no free passes given to Obama by the public on this issue of poor judgment. The public would not accept Hillary Clinton or John McCain attending a church that had a spiritual advisor that was an outright racist and this is why the public will not whole heartily buy Obama’s defense today. Twenty years of poor judgments writes you off as legitimate candidate.
What's more Susan - do you not think that people know the position that Hillary is in?  The earned delegate lead that Obama has over Hillary and the closing of the Super-delegate gap means that even with a FL and MN revote or them being seated as per the original vote, even with the next 10 primaries - Obama will retain a lead by the end of the primary voting.  And it is pretty clear that there is also a more insidious factor at play now that McCain has become the presumptive nominee.  Quite contrary to prior trends, Republicans have started cross voting for Clinton.  As Clinton supporters in Texas said for themselves Republicans were turning up saying that Rush Limbaugh sent them and the Clinton supporters were resentful because they wanted to win Texas fair and square.  If we removed the Republicans muddying the waters to extend the race so the 'Dems could tear each other apart' Obama would have won the popular vote in Texas by 18,000.  This pattern played out in OH and Mississippi as well - affecting results by 5% in each.  So what can the Clinton campaign bank on now?  Something that will personally destroy Obama - that is all.  I can only conclude that her continued presence in this race means that the campaign is fully working behind the scenes to facilitate such an event.  To conclude that as despicable is quite an understatement.  
People need to get over this outrage over insensitive remarks from a pastor. Of course they say things like this from the pulpit.

Do you agree with everything your pastor says? If you're a regular church goer who doesn't have the most-progressive pastor, you will likely have heard incendiary remarks about gays. You scoff at it, get over it, and in the end all you care about is the overall message.

Rev. Wright's overall message is not "God damn America" - that's angry, righteous rhetoric to get a point across (and black Americans still DO have a reason to be angry). His overall message has always been one of hope, unity, and forgiveness.

He's a guy with a temper who sometimes goes overboard, and it's absolutely silly to believe therefore Obama has the same opinion on everything the pastor ever said. If you really believe that, then please, take a look at the far more incendiary remarks by the right-wing preachers that endorse John McCain. Nobody is making a big deal about those for some reason.

Let's face it: there still is a lot of racism in this country, and a lot of it isn't overtly expressed, but shows its ugly face only in situations like this when white Americans all the sudden feel threatened.
I just wish Obama and his campaign would stop creating opportunities to "not talk about race" by constantly demanding television time to talk about race. Everyone in the Obama campaign knows that they benefit when they cause these controversies by spinning the issue. If he is down, be it in New Hampshire or Pennslyvania, he monopolizes the media with the subject. He was on every network within 24 hours the Wright tapes. He is getting full coverage of his speech. When Clinton gives a major speech on helpful issues like Iraq or the economy, the public gets bits and pieces. I wish the media would stop rewarding and promoting these "sensational" events. Maybe Obama would have to talk about his competence to serve as President. I don't care what color or sex the President is--I want my life to improve.
104,000+ Republicans voted for Hillary in the Texas primary because Rush Limbaugh suggested they should to tilt the votes in her favor and to stop Barack.
The republicans know that if Barack wins the Dem nomination. He will win the general elections in Nov.
Rev. Rivers is a HILLARY CLINTON SUPPORTER! Please stop having him on as an objective representative on your shows. It's so outrageous and needs to be stated he is a supporter of HRC!
I, for one, respect a politician who is willing to stand before people and speak from a human place about his own judgment calls and what is true to and for him. In the past week he has tried to be as open as possible, laying everything out on the table (about Wright and Resco). I don't expect a president to be perfect - he/she is human - but I like them being willing to be honest - to show a true face. He's written two books on his life, laid it all out there. Why is it that Hillary (who I experience as being more persona than authentic) can now stand back and cry foul that his campaign asks her to reveal her taxes and pet projects and such - calling it dirty campaigning? What? Being open, being honest and asking for the same is dirty playing? Her campaign has roused so much against Obama on a PERSONAL level, and all he has done is try to answer to it, while trying to stay on task of running for president on the issues.

I am not saying I agree with his pastor's remarks, but I will say that I think the shadow of this country is coming to roost. We say "free speech." But we expect some sort of perfection from our public figures and they too often try to play that role, and all too often their own shadows come out to play (ahem..Spitzer, Bill Clinton). Spiritually many Americans claim to follow the way of Jesus - who was, historically a religious and political revolutionary who did not do and say the "nice" thing, but the truth of his day - who stood up against oppression of his people and in a peaceful manner spoke and acted in ways against the domination system. Words spoken in passion, one trying to stir people into change are not always going to be "pleasant" and "nice." Again, I do not say that Wright's words were appropriate or right, but he was obviously stirred by passion to anger and a feeling of injustice. I wasn't there. I do not know the man and refuse to condemn an entire career or person on passionate remarks made. God, I would hope I wouldn't be judged and held as all of who I am by words I have spoken in my past in moments of passion.

Okay, I'm done now. I just wish people, who want change, would be willing to take the truth of someone fully - good, bad and ugly and be grateful for a human willing to stand to the scrutiny with integrity and honesty rather than hiding.
Kudos to Barack for facing controversey head on. This is the behavior we expect and applaud from our leaders.

Unlike others who blow smoke to hide things such as tax returns, earmarks, etc., etc., etc.....                          
This is what is called "Presidential."  

It takes a real leader and statesman to tackle such issues of race, and I applaud Obama loudly for having the courage to come before us and have a dialogue about race and racism.  

Sure, the recent events have necessitated such a conversation, and it's one he probably wanted to avoid until he'd secured the nomination because so many are apt to judge him for the very attempt to discuss the painful issues of race, but I think he's going to have another shining moment tonight, and that's what it takes to be president:

A willingness to have a tough conversation, to discuss an issue that is still very raw and emotional for so many of our citizens--black, white, and other.  But this is what Obama has always said he will do: tell it like it is, tell us what we might not be ready to hear.  I think it is time we had an honest conversation about race and racism in our country and he's just the man to do it.

I wish Obama all the courage and wisdom in his speech to once again inspire and unite those that wish to divide and to be divided.

Can someone please tell me what Bill or Hillary Clinton has ever really done for Black, Hispanic, Asian American's. While Bill Clinton was in office he passed more laws to protect wall street then he did for middle income people. The extreme mortgage crisis and job loss are a part of his decisions and laws he passed while in office.
The U.S. gov is not innocent by a long shot and has been responsible for allowing social injustice to flourish here. The constitution did not include justice and liberty for all during slavery and still does not. There is much work to do here and it seems that our Gov as is, is not stepping up to the challenge in a way that has been as affective as we the people need. Racism in
America, no matter what its source or direction, is the bastard child of U.S. Gov policy. i love America but i am ashamed of our Gov's lack of liberty and justice for all.
I have been known to have shady friends who have radical and even offensive political or social opinions. But I don't buy into their philosophy, and knowing them makes me a more rounded person.  Why can't the leaders of our society also be afforded the same social liberty?  This country is full of radicals, and you can't expect to bring it together if you refuse to associate with anyone who has ever said anything offensive! Obama's willingness to learn from anyone, regardless of political position or past commentaries, is what will make him a bold new president. His openness plays into his opinions on foreign policy as well... keep your enemies closer than your friends. Enough of the political "better-than-thou" attitude. It is absolutely absurd that the country is ganging up against a man who is willing to listen.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=778124

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google