ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Clinton calls on Obama to accept MI re-vote

Posted: Wednesday, March 19, 2008 1:30 PM by Mark Murray

From NBC/NJ's Athena Jones and NBC's Lauren Appelbaum
DETROIT -- Clinton today stepped up the pressure on Obama to back a re-vote in Michigan, calling it a crucial test of whether he means what he says or not.

"Sen. Obama speaks passionately on the campaign trail about empowering the American people. Today, I'm asking him to match those words with actions to make sure the people of Michigan and Florida have a voice and a vote in this election," she told local members of the AFSCME union, which has endorsed her. "I have accepted the plan for a new vote in Michigan, proposed in draft legislation and approved by the Democratic National Committee. In fact the DNC put out a statement earlier this morning making clear that the proposal fits within the DNC rules. It is fully within the party's rules. I call on Sen. Obama to do the same."

Clinton said 600,000 voters in Michigan and 1.7 million Florida voters were at risk of being shut out of the Democratic process. "I think that's wrong and frankly it is un-American and we cannot let that continue," she said. "This goes way beyond this election and it goes way beyond who's running, because no matter where you were born or how much money you were born into, no matter where you worship or the color of your skin, it is a bedrock American principle that we are all equal in the voting booth."

Michigan has 128 pledged delegates, but the state has been stripped of all of the because it broke party rules by moving up its vote. Clinton won the uncontested January primary, but Obama's name was not on the ballot.

The comments came shortly after her campaign held a second conference call in two days to accuse her rival of standing in the way of the Democratic process, because the state's proposal for a re-vote can not go forward until he signs off. "This isn't about political gamesmanship," spokesman Phil Singer said on the call. "This is about counting votes."

"If the Obama campaign tends to allow voters in both Michigan and Florida to be disenfranchised, that's their prerogative," Singer continued. "Our belief is that the voters in these states should be counted and their voices should be heard."

Clinton needs a re-vote in Michigan and needs to do well in it to gain more delegates, add to her popular vote total, and convince superdelegates she should be the nominee. 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Hillary needs to cease attempts to undermine the DNC leadership and the established rules. If Clinton really cared about fairness and the voters right to express their will why does she want to disenfranchise the voters  and delegates who may have gone to Edwards, Biden and Richardson who were still in the race but not on the ballot at the time of the original vote. Why does she want to re-run the race with only two of the original competitors on the starting line? The Clintons ( like someone else we know) has no respect for laws, rules or fairness.
Get a life, Patty
WHAT "RED STATE" DEMOCRATS IN THEIR RIGHT MIND WANTS OBAMA TO CAMPAIGN FOR THEM NOW.

OBAMA IS RADIOACTIVE IN THE SOUTH BECAUSE OF HIS ANTI-AMERICAN RACIST PASTOR.

THE VIDEO OF OBAMA'S PASTOR WILL BE PLAYED OVER AND OVER AGAIN IN SWING AND RED STATE DISTRICTS, ESP "GOD DAM AMERICAN" AND AID/HIV COMMENTS.

THIS MEANS DEMOCRATS MAY LOSE SEATS.
The last thing Obama would want IF he gets nominated is an asterisk next to his nomination should these two states not get counted. He will definitely pay in the general elections should be continue to take this stance on the issue - IF he gets the nomination.

What's he afraid off? It'll be good for him to show he cared about those people's votes.
Even if he lose in those states, as his supporters claim, he has an insurmountable lead. So why not cooperate?
I want a revote in all the other states so Obama will win overwhelmingly and take the new super vote super tuesday in a landslide because by now the 40 states that have voted KNOW AND SEE CLINTON(S) AS THEY REALLY ARE! None of this only winning by 10-25%.  Noooo, Obama would win by 40-65% and that my friends would thankfully end the regime of Hilary
WHAT "RED STATE" DEMOCRATS IN THEIR RIGHT MIND WANTS OBAMA TO CAMPAIGN FOR THEM NOW.

OBAMA IS RADIOACTIVE IN THE SOUTH BECAUSE OF HIS ANTI-AMERICAN RACIST PASTOR.

THE VIDEO OF OBAMA'S PASTOR WILL BE PLAYED OVER AND OVER AGAIN IN SWING AND RED STATE DISTRICTS, ESP "GOD DAM AMERICAN" AND AID/HIV COMMENTS.

THIS MEANS DEMOCRATS MAY LOSE SEATS.
How can Hillary thrust responsibility for Michigan's right to primary vote on Obama?  Right now it is not his decision--although he never pushed against it.  But neither does Hillary have that decision.  That's arrogant.

Right now it is up to the Michigan state legislators to decide.  And it doesn't look like it will happen.

But it is rather interesting that Hillary never worried about Michigan's right to vote until now.  A few months ago she signed a pledge that Michigan's primary votes would NOT count.  Why the moral high-ground this late in the game?
HILLARY CLINTON HAS NOW RULED OUT ANY POSSIBILITY OF OBAMA ACCEPTING A RE-VOTE.

IF THERE'S A REVOTE, SHE WILL CAMPAIGN IN MICHIGAN ON THE PREMISE THAT OBAMA WANTED TO SHUT THEM OUT.

STICK TO THE RULES - NO REVOTE! UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCE.
Obama made this a race issue.  He made a speech telling me about the racial divide in this country and made me look at myself to see where I am in this whole race thing.  The problem is that he is diverting the issue from himself to our "broken"country   Man all you had to do was go up there and say I should of left the church a long time ago.  I disown the anti-american pastor and that's it.  No he goes out there and brings up race like this country has made no progress over the last 40 years.  There will be more racial divide now because of this and it's a shame.  As a white man he was not talking to me yesterday and I am sure most white men (not elite progressive liberals) will not appreciate bringing this stuff up.
THIS IS NOT GOING TO JUST FADE AWAY. WE WILL TAKE ANY LEGAL MEANS TO HAVE OUR VOTES COUNT AND OUR DELEGATES SEATED AT THE DEMOCRATIC CONVENTION. THIS IS NOT ABOUT HILLARY OR OBAMA, IT'S ABOUT OUR LEGAL RIGHTS AS US CITIZENS. AND WE ARE DAM WELL NOT GOING TO SIT SILENT ANY LONGER. 8 FRIGHIN' YEARS OF THE BUSH FIASCO. AND NOW HAVE THIS HAPPEN TO US. NO WAY LADIES AND GENTELMEN.WE WILL TAKE THIS TO THE STREETS IF NECESSARY. OUR LEGAL RIGHTS ARE BEING STEPED ON.
Clinton only wants a revote because she won the illegal election.  If she was ahead right now, and Obama had won the illegal elections in Florida and Michigan, than she would not be pushing for a revote.  She is something else.  God help us if she ever becomes President of the United States.  She cannot even run her own family.
What's it called when you change the rules in the middle of the game? hmmm... Oh yeah, cheating.
Billary will do what she has to to benefit her campaign.  Dirty tricks, the Kitchen Sink Strategy, Race, lawsuits, you name it.  Billiary is the Poster Child of Washington-- more of the same: division, fighting, manipulating to get her way.  If she weren't Bill's wife, she would not be where she is today.

Obama 08  
Chuck, please post the letter from Obama Lawyer to the Clinton camp which clearly points out why this revote will send the Dems into an endless round of lawsuits, primarly becuase the Dem Primary is an open primary and the Rep and Independents that already voted will not have had a choice to participate in the revote if they have already vote.  Guranteed to be an circus.  Its time to move on.  

The goal post is set Hillary
ANYONE BUT OBAMA

OBAMAS SOLUTION WHITE AMERICAN IF YOU ELECT ME ALL YOUR SINS WILL BE FORGIVEN
Is this an election or an episode of PUNK'D?
<sarcasm on>

Hillary's Right!!!!

Not only should we redo FL and MI, but all the Caucus states. Hillary has told us how evil and un-American that process is, and I'm pretty sure those totals aren't in the popular vote. Let's do them all by June.

Isn't it Un-American to have redo in only two states? Every vote should count. That's what I'm hearing from the Clinton camp.

If Hillary doesn't come out and publicly support my proposal, it can mean nothing other than she hates America.

<sarcasm off>
The Michigan and Florida legislatures both said that Obama and Clinton had to agree on a revote before they passed any legislation to authorize one.  Obama refused to approve any legislation in FL or MI.  So he killed it.  Obama killed the revotes.
UPDATE:

OBAMA IS RADIOACTIVE IN SWING AND RED STATES BECAUSE OF HIS ANTI-AMERICAN RACIST PASTOR. JUST, LIKE BUSH IS RADIOACTIVE IN ALL STATES.

WHAT "RED STATE" DEMOCRATS IN THEIR RIGHT MIND WANTS OBAMA TO CAMPAIGN FOR THEM NOW.

THE VIDEO OF OBAMA'S PASTOR WILL BE PLAYED OVER AND OVER AGAIN IN SWING AND RED STATE DISTRICTS, ESP "GOD DAM AMERICAN" AND AID/HIV COMMENTS.

THIS MEANS DEMOCRATS MAY LOSE SEATS.
On a side note - the recently released records of Hilary as First Lady is very impressive indeed - both on Local and International front.

Whatever happens, I am proud to have someone like her running for President. The Country should be proud that it had produced someone like Hilary.

look, it'll either be obama or mccain. so either i'll have a brilliant man as president or i'll get to keep the bush taxes cuts. either way i win! yea me!!!!
A Lansing insider IMs to explain the latest development:

The Senate Dems just had a long caucus meeting following their long phone call with the Gang of Four [as Carl Levin and others pushing a re-vote are called], and the result is that no one moved. Votes aren't there. Thus, it will not go to a vote in the Senate. And barring some other last minute miracle that doesn't involve those four, the governor and Hillary traveling to Michigan, it is dead as a doornail.

UPDATE: State Sen. Tupac Hunter, an Obama supporter, confirms the outcome of today's meeting.
----
http://www.politico.com/blogs/bensmith/0308/Doover_is_dead.html


But of course, Clinton, the deceptive disgusting politician that she is, will try to blame Obama, even though the measure lacked support from enough Michigan politicians.

First Read, normally, you stay up on the story updates, where is your revision?
Hello, Michigan clintonians, is anybody home?  Clinton did not give a crap about your voices being heard until she decided she might need your votes.  Do not be deceived by her current lies.  She was happy to throw you under the bus when she thought your votes wouldn't be necessary.  Do you honestly think she would be pushing a revote if she had more delegates than Obama? Would she care about your voices being heard? Seriously? The Clinton campaign is shameless.
He won't step up and man up because he lost both states. He's just a little boy that keeps crying to the media to help him out. He want's only the votes for him to have a voice. I'm sick of his camp. They have torn apart our party by racial lines and now don't want to count votes. He's toast.
For Mad as hell florida voters, i thought the hanging chad and missing ballots from florida elected Bush?  Seems to me Florida has trouble understanding what rules are, what elections mean, and how to hold a legal valid primary.  Don't blame Hillary or Obama, blame and talk to the your elected officials
All you can do is laugh at her.  Let's start it folks....  and extended MSNBC.com laugh at Hillary Clinton.  I'll start.

Ahahahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha......
This is one Democrat who will give McCain serious consideratin in Nov. if Obama prevents Michigan and Florida from revoting
Why do you guys in the media continue to allow Sen. Clinton to espouse her untruthful rhetoric and then try to pass it off as factual news.  She is desparate and it shows.  Everyone knows that if a) she lost the decertified primary b) Michigan was a small state c) her husband didn't already have political machinery in the state d) had Sen. Obama's insurmountable delegate lead-- she would not even care.  Desparate people are dangerous people and the Party needs to step in now and end this farce.  Let us move into the General Election with the best candidate, Senator Barack Obama.  The only reason that she remains in this race at all is because the media (along with the RNC)continues to prop her up.  If her and Obama's standings were reversed, this would have been over.
Does Obama want to “unite” the country by disenfranchising the millions of voters who voted in FL and MI?

Of course, he knows he is going to lose both of these primaries.  Hillary already won FL and both these states are typical of the LARGE states that Obama loses all the time.

In other news:

Hillary picks up 2 more super delegates including Rep. Murtha / PA which is huge considering his anti Iraq credentials

New Public Policy poll shows Hillary in a dead heat with Obama in a state where he is (or was) heavily favored to win.

2 PA poll released yesterday show Hillary with a GROWING double digit lead in another LARGE important state that democrats must carry in November

NEW Gallup poll released today – Hillary LEADS Obama 49% to 42%

And I continue to ask:

Obama runs on “Change” yet didn’t have the guts or will to change his Reverend’s warped and destructive views.

Obama runs on “Hope” yet he sat in the pews and did nothing while his Reverend told parishioners that there was no hope for them

Obama runs on “Judgment” yet brought his two young, impressionable daughters to a church  where the Reverend spews racial division and Anti – Semitism.
Please spare us more of the blood sport the Clintons’ are playing.   I hope that the Obama campaign does not agree to any kind of “re-do” in Michigan and especially now that Florida has decided not to do a “re-do”.  It is pointless because it 1) would sacrifice principle, 2) will not change the numerical outcome, 3) and in the case of Michigan not doing a “re-do” won’t have any long-term ramification, 4) would contaminate what has been, so far, a clean process.
At least in Michigan they don’t have the Republicans to blame for their mess.
If the Clintons had the numerical advantage that Obama has they would not agree.  As you read this, they are trying to sabotage an honest process in Texas.  They were refused a request to delay announcement of the results of the caucus in Texas, knowing full well that will move Texas to the Obama column.

This is where the Obama campaign needs to show TACT  and TOUGHNESS.  
Can't wait 'til Rev Wright gives the invocation at Obama's inaugural.  God bless America?  No, no, no...God damn America for electing Obama President!
Why doesn't someone ask Clinton point blank why she signed the "no campaign" pledge acknowledging that these votes wouldn't count in the first place. Where was her concern over disenfranchising these voters then?

Why is one of the architects of the decision - Harold Ickes - a prominent figure on her campaign? Presumably she should want to fire him for robbing these voters of their rights.

The answer to all of this frankly is that she thought she would be annoited on Super Tuesday. Do we really want a leader who fails to plan for all contingencies?

The hypocrisy is simply breathtaking...
Why does Chuck Todd or someone at first read not point out the missing factors of Edwards and Richardson in a re-vote? At the time of the Florida and Michigan primaries Edwards and Richardson were still in the race but not on the ballots. Edwards was collecting a consistant 20% of the votes and delegates and Richardson 8%, so who is to say what the results would have been had these missing factors been factored in?....Let it go and move on
Obama, give her the election! You are to intelligent to want to be president of this pathetic, ignorant, prejudice country!!!!! She deserves to run a country of SHEEP! You advanced world view cannot be appreciated here. I'm leaveing the country as well, I am DONE WITH AMERICA FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!!!
Who's trying to disenfranchise voters ?
Hillary wants to delay the Texas results
WHY ?


From Huff Post:

'...Texas Dems reject Clinton effort to delay caucuses

By Anna M. Tinsley | Fort Worth Star-Telegram

Posted on Tuesday, March 18, 2008 email  

Texas Democratic leaders said Monday that they will not delay the March 29 conventions that will help determine how many delegates are awarded to Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama or set up "unnecessary" verification processes to review those who already cast their votes.

Clinton's camp sent a letter Friday asking that the March 29 conventions at the senatorial district or county level — the next step in the state's hybrid of a primary election and caucus — be delayed until signatures from the conventions held March 4 could be verified.

The party said no. "The overwhelming majority of problems reported in Texas do not affect the legitimacy of delegates allocation," Texas Democratic Party Chairman Boyd Richie said in a statement. "The Texas Democratic Party will not do as suggested by one campaign and circumvent party rules to set up an unnecessary, ad hoc 'verification' process that could effectively disqualify delegates selected at their precinct conventions after the fact."

Read the full story at Star-Telegram.com.
To patty,sd,ca

Do you have a job? Who goes around blogs and spews hate and lies in all caps?

You've been doing this for months. Make a legit case for your candidate instead of making divisive remarks. Your one of life's losers.

Bush 08

JK!
Patty

Anyone but Obama for President?  OK!  How about me?  Of course, I will need a running mate.  Forget about Hillary, though.  She might "Vince Foster" me, to get me out of the way!

Seriously, why are so many people determined to put Hillary back in the White House?  Did she promise to give you some of the furniture that she steals at the end of her term?

Now, let's look at her legislative accomplishments.  Oh wait, she doesn't have any!  Give her an A for effort on health care.  She did what no Republican could do in 50 years:  she put the Republicans in charge of the House of Representatives!

Obama in 2008



SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=784367

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google