ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Obama's tax returns, rising fortunes

Posted: Tuesday, March 25, 2008 2:28 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC’s Jim Popkin
The tax returns for Sen. Barack Obama and his wife, Michelle, offer insights into the power couple's rising fortunes as Obama became a U.S. Senator and then a potential presidential candidate.

Obama today released his tax returns from 2000 to 2006. They show a steep increase in income. In 2000, for example, the Obamas' combined income was $240,505. That includes Sen. Obama's salary as a young state senator in Illinois, his fees ($16,500) as a "foundation director/educational speaker" and Michelle Obama's salary as a hospital administrator.

In 2006, by contrast, the Obamas' combined income was $983,826. Obama had become a U.S. Senator by then, making about $165,000 a year, and his wife's income at the University of Chicago hospitals had climbed sharply to about $265,000 a year. Sen. Obama's book-writing career also had become profitable, earning him $551,240 in author fees in tax year 2006 alone. Mrs. Obama also made $51,200 that year, as director of TreeHouse Foods, "a food manufacturer servicing primarily the retail grocery and foodservice chains," according to the company's website.

The Obamas' best financial year came in 2005, when their total combined income was $1.6 million. That included $1.2 million in author fees for Sen. Obama's best-selling books. Michelle Obama's salary that year was $316,962 plus another $45,000 for her role as director of TreeHouse Foods.

The Obamas became more charitable as their incomes grew. In 2000, the couple gave $2,350 to charity, or about 1 percent of their gross income. In 2006, they donated $60,307 to charities, or about 6 percent of their gross income. In 2005, the Obamas list a $5,000 donation to their church, Trinity United Church of Christ in Chicago, where the controversial Rev. Jeremiah A. Wright, Jr., was Sen. Obama's pastor. If Sen. Obama tithed more regularly to the church, there's no record of it in these tax returns.

The tax returns also don't appear to shed any new light on the Obamas' controversial purchase of their Chicago home in 2005. They bought their home that year for $1.65 million, at the same time that the wife of indicted Chicago businessman and campaign contributor Tony Rezko bought the adjoining lot for $625,000. Critics have said that Obama could not have bought the house unless the Rezkos bought the joining lot, and Obama has apologized for the "bone-headed mistake" of getting involved with a campaign contributor who at the time was under scrutiny for alleged political corruption.

The Obamas don't appear to have substantial stock holdings. Their 2005 return, for example, lists modest dividends for UBS, JP Morgan Chase and Northern Trust Bank. It also lists a $2,072 gain for the sale of Biopharma stock and a $15,208 loss for the sale of SkyTerra Communications stock.

While the Obama tax documents released today cover the basics for the seven-year period, there are many supporting documents that have not been released. Sen. Hillary Clinton has yet to release her tax records at all, but a spokesman says they will be made public in the next few weeks.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Diane, Chicago, Illinois:

Hillary Clinton's tax returns are available only for the twenty years prior to 2001.  Every tax return since has not been released.  So what is Hillary hiding?  Bill's shady dealings?  Evidence that will incriminate her in the Paul v. Clinton lawsuit?  Deals that she does not want the American public to know about until she is safely in the White House?  it is time for her to release these records so that the American public can decide whether she is trustworthy or if there are more Bosnia's, SCHIP's, NAFTA's.....
As a woman and a thoughtful Obama supporter, I must say that I'm proud to see Michelle contributing so much to the combined family income.  It would be interesting to see how her salary increase compares to the rise in median income for similar positions in the Chicago Metro Area.  Also, to know exactly what her job title/description has been over that time.  

I am a resident of Illinois, and these figures to not seem out of the ordinary to me.

Like many others, though, I will be eager to see the difference between this and the Clinton's tax record disclosure.  
Will joint tax return of Hillay and Bill Clinton show how much Bill had been expensing on Escort Services? Those should be counted as charitable donations as well.

Calm down people, it is a joke. I can't wait for the late night shows when Clintons get back into the White House. America is going to be just fine. We have lived through 8 yrs of Bush, another 8 yrs of Clinton in nothing in our 200yr history. At least we will get top quality late night shows :-)
Maybe McCain can release his tax returns from his Keating Five days...
Wow....Obama is a cheapskate.  He makes 1.6 million and only donates 60k to charity?  Typical liberal ... wants to take 30-40% everyone elses money and give it away but doesn't walk the walk.
I love the Obamas' openness. He is truly doing as he speaks - being honest, and open.

Hey Hillary - where are your tax returns?????

I am a typical 60 year old white woman who will be voting for and supporting Barack Obama.
The reason why Michelle Obama's salary was so high is because of her husband.  Research it yourself.  Also..looking through Obama's earmarks...available on his website...he has a lot of them that are related to food/production/research.  I was not aware that his wife was involved in the food industry.  Kind of suspicious if you ask me.  

I will be sure to look into this.

Obama supporters need to quit speculating about the Clintons returns and start researching their own candidate's past.

A candidate for change??? Not!!
Barack and Michelle Obama are an example of a successful, proud and honest American couple! Their transparancy and fortitude is praiseworthy...bravo!
Patty...you are reaching. I'm starting to wonder if all the Clinton fans think that she will solve all of your problems thru gov't, so you won't have to work and etc...Get Real!! I'm sorry to say this....but I'm starting to wonder if some of the support that Hillary gets..comes from workers who are just safe and complacent by the Clinton name. People wake up and use your brain and real thru the lines. If anyone tells you the truth..whether you agree with it or not...then quite frankly those are the ones to listen too. Patty..in your observations you are reaching, there isn't even any rumors that his tax deals are bad. Back your accusations up with facts
Obama's tax return shows one important thing: he and his wife are ordinary working people like the rest of us.  Granted they are Ivy League educated which will put them in the upper echelon of income, but aside from his book income (well earned writing, no ghost writing for mere commercial benefit), he's a normal white collar guy.

He's one of us!!  Time for Change!

Too bad so many middle class voters don't see that he can identify with them...
She made over $300,000 one year as a Hospital Administrator or some type of Hospital Job.  Seems like a lot to me as a physician of 23 years I have yet to ever make that in one year!
What I would like to see is his tenure in the Illinois state house?  How many bills that he sponsored from 1996 to 2002 actually became law?  We know in 2002 when Emril Jones became majority whip of the Senate he gave Obama high priority bills , that even though others where working, to Obama so to raise his run to the US Senate.  In return , Senator Jones district, recieved large money earmarks, from US senator Obama.
diane, chicago, il--

Obama just release all of his OLDER returns, he had already released his 2007 returns.
Obama Clean? come on give me a break, his advisors were the one that looked into Clintons and Mccain files along with his? to make it look like he was not involded?to be sure why dont you all settle down and let Clinton release her tax file than you all can hash it out, and i am sure you all will be at her throat again- God help this country you all are being led by his talk, and his lies
knock!!!!
Knock!!!!

Hillary????
are you out there????
 
 


TAX RETURNS????

You must have forgotten.....
to release them!!!

SEE....
OBAMA...
RUN...
for PRESIDENT...
and HE has time...
he is not too busy...
to RELEASE HIS TAX RETURNS!!
Obama...
Man of honesty...
Man with integrity...
WORDS of....
 CHANGE
 EXPERIENCE
 KNOWLEDGE
 JUDGEMENT
and

           F I N A N C E S ! ! ! !

What are the sources of your FINANCES HILLARY??????
Are you H O N E S T
enough
to
release
your
tax
returns
from 2000
until
2006!!

The VOTERS are WAITING

in P E N N S Y L V A N I A ! ! ! ! ! ! !

I am one of them!


I really don't know what to say. So I will sart with this: Over the last few weeks I have following this political event. I can't understand why that Obama stands beside his Pastor. The church is supposed to be a house of God and not a political arena,nor should you teach or preach anything in it except fot the word of God. All the things that Pastor Wright talked about has nothing to do with the word of our LORD and Savior. However, it does hold a lot of teaching on hate. It makes me wonder why that Obama continued to go to Trinity. If you are going to stand up and tell everyone that you are standing for Change and unity. Then how can you stand on one side or the other. To me UNITY means evryone standing together as ONE. I just can't see where he stands for this. He talks the talk, but doesn't walk the walk. We need to know and always remember that, we are all Children of God and its time that we stand up for the Lord and know that he is in control of everything and we are not. Its time to stop using his words to justify the things that we choose to do. There is only one way and that is THE LORDS WAY. So, how about keeping Religion out of Politics.    
Obama wrote "Audacity of Hope" and donated $60K to charity (including $22500 to Trinity United Church of Christ).

Clinton wrote "It Takes A Village" and donated $1 million in royalties to charities.
There were O'Bama earmarks for Michelle's hospital. She did get a very healthy raise. But more importantly, this is a non-profit hospital that reported a large profit. I really think Michelle has some influence on O'Bama's health care proposal. At her hospital they charge 3&1/2 times for the same services to the uninsured. When O'Bama was asked what would happen if someone went into the hopital that had not signed up for his health care proposal, he responded they would be fined. Sound familiar? Hopefully this one will get posted.
I really have become quite disgusted with blogs. It's fairly simple, no person is without a few skeletons in their closet.  I really don't care if its Obama or Hillary, as long as this War with Iraq is ended. So get over yourselves and stop bickering, as democrats, all we need is this war to end and than go about fixing the other items that need fixing.
Fellow democrats:

There are some good comments here and, unfortunately, a lot of hissing and snarling.  I'm sure the republicans are just LOVING these little diatribes we are having - liberal democrats trashing their own.  We are doing their work for them.  Folks, if we don't stop bashing our own candidates, we are going to end up with another republican president.  Are you prepared for that?  All of these elements are legitimate concerns, and we all have a favorite candidate.  Let's please get civil (even if our candidates appear to be playing dirty - (that's what the spin docs call for these days)- stop vilifying the candidates and each other and work toward the positive result we all want - a democrat in the white house!  Stop letting the media bate us into squabbling!  Save the venom for the real fight - after the primaries are over!!!
Obama has put himself and his family out there again and for better or worse he is making himself an open book. Albeit he has been dodging a barrage of verbal strafing from the Clintons, but apparently Hillary remembers how to do that vs. the reality of REAL BULLETS.

If there is a Commander in Chief test I am sure there must be a rule about CHEATING or EXAGERRATING on the test when it comes to answering questions on EXPERIENCE!

On top of which if she expects to lead the nation and wants the voters to view her as a person of character and willing to show how they manage their finance she will release her finances IMMEDIATELY.

Let’s see what else the Clintons are MISSPEAKING about!! Could it be all the SPECIAL interest that makes it possible for her to loan her campaign 5 Million dollars.


If there is a Commander in Chief test I am sure there must be a rule about CHEATING or EXAGERRATING on the test when it comes to answering questions on EXPERIENCE!

On top of which if she expects to lead the nation and wants the voters to view her as a person of character and willing to show how they manage their finance she will release her finances IMMEDIATELY.

Let’s see what else the Clintons are MISSPEAKING about!! Could it be all the SPECIAL interest that make it possible for her to loan her campaign 5 Million dollars.
MSNBC and NBC have to be on the Obama payroll.  I wonder how much they get.
With the Bosnia "mis-spoke" and clearly as written transcript of the then First Lady's NAFTA meetings are showing up, I don't think she will try to add more question by coming up with her's and Bill's tax return before the Pennsylvania primary. Lots of folks there are hit hard by NAFTA, which by the way, was previously describe by her "as one of his husband's administration accomplishment" Enough of hypocrites.
when mrs obama stated she was"finally proud of her country" did she just find out from the accountant how much money was made in 2007?
Hillary 'misspoke' and she is evicerated and laughed at and made fun of by all the MSNBC talking heads and their panels.And Obama makes 'a boneheaded mistake' tsk tsk ,yeah he is okay! Obama can save his money on TV ads he has entire MSNBC talkshow hosts pulling for him and ofcourse NY Times columnists help out too.Thanks guys,for making the case for me to vote Republican,if she is not on the ticket! I am now more interested in defeating the woman hating media pundits!
Dee, Tampa said

Obama's tax return shows one important thing: he and his wife are ordinary working people like the rest of us.

ORDINARY WORKING PEOPLE.  Are you serious?

I'm not sure what planet you and the rest of the Obamanoids are from but a MILLION dollars a year does not classify anyone as ORDINARY.

But if you are too stupid and don't know your elbow from a hole in the ground, I'll give the facts about Ordinary people.

In 2006, the median annual household income according to the US Census Bureau was determined to be $48,201.00 dollars per year.

The median income per household member (including all working and non-working members above the age of 14) in the year 2006 was $26,036 dollars.

According to the US Census Bureau in 2006, 84.07% of the US population earns less than $100,000 dollars a year.

Now according to you Dee, from Tampa, you consider Obama and his wife to be ordinary working people like the rest of us even though they do not make less than $100,000 dollars a year like the 84.07% of the US population; no they make more, a hell of a lot more.

Therefore, Obama and his wife ARE NOT ORDINARY and people who have to work two and three jobs to keep a roof over their families heads, to pay for electricity and buy Ramen noodles for $.25 cents a pack to feed their families would take offense to people like you and all of the other Obama lovers that seem to think that everyone in this country is running around making $100 grand a year or more and sending their kids to the best PRIVATE schools and to BALLET lessons.

Get real!

You and the rest of the Obama freaks don't have a clue.  You obviously have NO IDEA what it is like to have to go hungry so that your kids can eat the only pack of Ramen noodle by candle light because your electricity was shut off because you needed to pay the rent late so you and your two young children won't end up on the street sleeping in a cardboard refrigerator box because the father ditched the family.

You F*****G Hypocrite, it's people like you and the rest of the sick Obama supporters that make me and a lot of other TRUELY HARD WORKING PEOPLE IN THIS COUNTRY, SICK!
We have a lousy selection of candidates. With McCain we should worry about who the vice-president is going to be. There is a big gamble there that the vice-president will be the president. And McCain is still in the last century.
Hillary has been after the presidency since before good old boy Bill.Correct me if I am wrong but didn't she get her education in government by traveling around the social and capitalistic countries in Europe and Asia. There was something about it when Bill was running the first time.
BO didn't just fall in out of the sky.
His life has been carefully planned to reach toward the presidency. The planning has been done over many years. He is slick and knows how to say what people want to hear. His years of careful coaching and programing has got the wool puled down over peoples eyes. I for one if I didn't approve of what my preacher was preaching I would find another church. Anyone who believes BO's story about that preacher has a problem. Their lights are all on but nobody is home.  
The Clintons life has been an open book since Bill was the President.  I am sure Sen Clinton will release their records.  I have nothing against Barry Barrack Obama but this country needs immediate help--this is not the time Barrack.  No one has time to train you!!!!!!
Clinton's tax returns will be released on April 15th. Get over it already.
The Obama followers are playing the blame game again.
As for experience, Obama has spent more time running for office and trying to climb the econimic ladder. than doing anything constructive for anyone.
Wait until the Republicans start digging in. Or, do you really want to go there??
Hillary has had to release her returns when she ran for the Senate. Senate records should be available from all Senators' campaigns.
If you love Obama so much, that is fine. Maybe he should win, then you all will be able to join Illinois constituents with our lost jobs, our Nuclear waste in our groundwater, our slum neighborhoods with high crime, our partial birth abortions, our Savings and Loan Scandals, all of which Obama promised to deal with and did not.

Obama Campaign Finance Chair Involved in Superior Bank S&L Scandal http://www.bostonnow.com/blogs/oldmole/2008/02/12/obama-campaign-finance-chair-involved-in-super

http://www.beyondchron.org/articles/The_Obama_Craze_Count_Me_Out_5413.html

Senator Obama on the Run From Rezko Story  (Chicago NBC News with Carol Marin)
http://youtube.com/watch?v=jOFT8jtuVpo

Obama: I Trusted Rezko  http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/politics/chi-obama-rezkomar15,0,2968927.story

Obama missing in action as Chairman of the Senate Subcommittee on Europe to strengthen NATO in Afghanistan. Obama admitted in Ohio Debate he has not held one hearing since he was appointed the Chair in January 2007, due to being too busy campaigning for President.  http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/story?id=4355006&page=2

Barack Obama and Dick Morris in Kenya
http://noquarterusa.net/blog/2008/01/31/obamas-african-hubris-2/
...Leader of the Kenyan Orange Democratic Movement opposition leader, Raila Odinga, is Barack Obama's cousin...wants to be president...two of Kenya's tribes...are killing each other over a disputed election that Odinga, Obama's cousin, claims was stolen from him...Former Clinton aides currently working for Obama...directed Dick Morris to Kenya to advise the Odinga campaign in November of 2007, shortly after Odinga visited with Obama in America. Morris was an extremely divisive factor in the Kenyan elections...Kenya currently teeters on the edge of political chaos and civil war...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dick_Morris
...Morris went on to become campaign manager of Bill Clinton's successful 1996 bid for re-election...his tenure on that campaign was cut short...when it was revealed that he had allowed a prostitute, Sherry Rowlands, to listen in on conversations with the President...Morris has emerged as a harsh critic of the Clintons...

Just a few issues in addition to friendships with indicted Tony Rezko, domestic terrorist William Ayers, Dick Morris, James Crown, Ms. Pritzker his Finance Chair, and Rev. Wright, Obama needs to answer regarding his judgement before November election.
So what if Hillary is making more money than Obama.  She is older and has worked more years than Obama has.  Give her a break.
$ 315,000 salary for a hospital administrator is steep.  Why do we need them?  Doctors should run hospitals.  Doctors have 12 to 16 or more years of college, med school, etc.  Many doctors are earning much less than administrators.  This doesn't even make sense.  Doctors save lives.  Hospital administrators look out for the "bottom line."
Your turn, Hillary! Did you misplace the folder with your 1040?

Try looking on the coffee table next to the La-Z-Boy in the den (no, not him).

Right next to your copy of "Sure Fire Profits in Commodities: How to Turn $1000 into $100,000 Without a Losing Trade".

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/politics/special/whitewater/stories/wwtr940527.htm



Did you file jointly? Did Bill report his foreign income from dictator human rights violators??

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/31/us/politics/31donor.html




How much of Obama's millions have gone toward Tony Rezko's defense?  
Where are Hillary's tax returns.

Given the ties her advisers have to lobbying for corporations, it would be very interesting to see where she is making her millions.

Link to a good article on politico.com that describes Hillary's connections to corporations.
http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0308/9204.html

Particularly interesting is Mark Penn's connection to Saudi Arabian oil.

Howard Wolfson works for Glover Park Group which represents American Health Insurance Plans.
Wonder if obama's spouse was proud of this country when they are making all that money. Not according to what she said.

The obama's are PATHETIC unAmerican and undemocratic as they come.
Will Hillary's tax return be a joint return or married filling separately? I bet this stuff if it comes out at all will be marginally revealing.
Obama and his group have shown an overall fantastic record of organization and transparency. They have run a clean campaign and been willing to answer the tough questions head on. I cannot say the same for Hillary. I am not sure if now is the time to brand Hillary’s campaign as irrelevant; that may be Obama’s best strategy, just ignore her and focus on McCain. Maybe she will get the hint...


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=805820

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google