ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



McCain: Foreign policy reactions

Posted: Thursday, March 27, 2008 9:34 AM by Domenico Montanaro

The Washington Post on McCain's major foreign policy speech: "In his first extensive policy speech since securing the delegates needed to win the Republican presidential nomination, McCain delivered an impassioned argument that achieving democracy in Iraq is necessary for a peaceful world. ‘Those who argue that our goals in Iraq are unachievable are wrong, just as they were wrong a year ago when they declared the war already lost in Iraq,’ he said, without naming Democratic candidates Hillary Rodham Clinton and Barack Obama. ‘Those who claim we should withdraw from Iraq in order to fight al-Qaeda more effectively elsewhere are making a dangerous mistake.’
 
“But even as McCain offered a defense of President Bush's current war policy, he outlined a sharp critique of the administration's dealings with foreign allies.”
 
L.A. Times lead: "McCain, carefully distancing himself from President Bush and seeking to sound a moderate tone, called Wednesday for stronger ties with allies and cautioned that American power "does not mean we can do whatever we want, whenever we want."
 
The upcoming issue of Time has an extensive profile of McCain the reformer and his relationship with lobbyists. From Michael Scherer's piece: "For most other senators, especially those lacking presidential ambitions, such untoward appearances would not raise much of an eyebrow. On any given day, thousands of lobbyists work their connections on Capitol Hill, hoping to obtain letters on their behalf or legislation in their favor. But for McCain, such questions become an issue of integrity. He is the one, after all, who regularly breaks the Senate's code of silence by alleging corruption by his peers. ‘Elected officials do act in particular ways in order to assist large soft-money donors,’ McCain wrote in a sworn statement from the 2002 Supreme Court case over his campaign-finance bill. ‘This skews and shapes the legislative process.’
 
“The McCain campaign answers questions about discrepancies between the candidate's words and actions by asserting that his motivations are different from those of his more crass colleagues. ‘John McCain takes positions on legislative and regulatory issues based on his perception of the public good,’ writes Brian Rogers, McCain's campaign spokesman, in an e-mail. His position in favor of Ergen, aides say, was nothing other than an effort to bring more competition to cable providers, to lower prices for consumers. Likewise, his opposition to FCC ownership caps for television stations resulted from a long-standing belief that technological changes had made the old laws obsolete." 
 
In a pre-buttal to Obama's economic speech today, the McCain campaign treats Obama as the Dem nominee. From the campaign: “ ‘This election provides a clear choice. John McCain offers a common sense agenda to cut taxes, eliminate wasteful government spending, and get our economy back on track, while Senator Obama embraces the failed liberal policies of the past that lock down the ingenuity and entrepreneurial spirit that has always grown our economy, created jobs and expanded opportunity for the American people.’”
 
The DNC plans to go after McCain’s viability in the West with a conference call with Democratic Party leaders from Colorado, Utah, Arizona and Nevada. It will also release a memo called “McCain: Losing in the West,” which will say, in part, “After representing Arizona for more than two decades McCain failed to break 50 percent in his home state's February 5 primary, and turned in big losses in two other potential swing states that surround Arizona. In Nevada McCain lost to Mitt Romney and even to Ron Paul, earning a meager 13% of the vote. In Colorado McCain received only 19 percent of the vote. Going all the way up the Rocky Mountain West, McCain won just one of six states. “ More: “Polls show Democrats leading or running even in a generic presidential horse race among independents in Colorado (46-18), Arizona (32-18), Nevada (28-20), and New Mexico (28-24).”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Why do I feel like a third Bush term is on the horizon if McCain were to be elected president?

http://www.politivine.com
A year after the next presidential election we will still be mired in Iraq, we will not have national health care, and our trade policies will still be crap. This is regardless of who is elected they have three names but they are all the same people. Im going to take a hard look at Ralph Nader.
Cory-
Because you are narrow minded and not listening to the candidate. McCain is right on, both in his economic proposals and his assessment of the successes/failures of our current domestic policy!
The current banter seems to be that the Dems are destroying their party and McCain will waltz into the whitehouse.  I disagree.  Right now the eyes of America are on Barrack and Hillary, that's where it's exciting and juicy.  McCain is doddering around being boring.  How do you think John McCain will look debating with either Obama or Clinton.  Americans will be shocked.  They'll be shaking their heads in wonder, "Gee, he IS too old,  too rigid, too dumb, just a tired old worn out bureaucrat that should be thanked for his service and put out to pasture."  I don't think McCain will have a chance with either one.
does mccain ever watch the news, the surge doesn't seem to be working anymore, there will be no victory in iraq, those people were killing one another before we occupied iraq and they will be killing one another after we leave, the whole police action is pointless, we are sending kids to their death for nothing, and that 'my friends' is stupid
There is absolutely no daylight between the failed Bush policies and those that Mc Cain is a cheerleader for.  These two guys are virtually indistinguishable except Mc Cain is older and did not avoid service in Vietnam.  Electing John Mc Cain would very clearly continue the vastly unsuccessful foreign and domestic policies of the 100% flawed Bush.
Kathryn...exactly what economic policies is mccain right on? He has no economic policy except more of the same...how has that worked for you these past few years anyway?

Same thing with his iraq policy...he has none except for more of the same...by the way kathryn, how many in your family have died in Iraq? I always want to know that cheerleaders are sacrificing too
Mccain is nothing but bush all over again, older and no wiser. Even though he doesn't seem to know what's going on there, he should be running for president of Iraq, since that is all he seems to care about! Over 4,000 fine Americans killed and 12 billion of our tax dollars a month!
McCain is a war mentallity. He knows nothing about ecomomics and is a phoney conservative.

Third Term Bush.  You bet but I believe it will be worse because McCain is War, that all he talks about.
His 100 years of war was not taken out of context. He means it.
Ronald Reagan needed Nancy to whisper in his ear, and John McCain has Joe Lieberman to whisper in his ear when he makes mistakes.
Does he have Alzheimers disease or is he just plain stupid.
Sorry Bonnie,

The eyes are on barrack and hillary? Eyes are also on Britney and Paris. Say much?

National healthcare is a joke. Medical insurance is cheap; and a socialized healthcare system would be abused. It ridiculous...

For America to be successful is to cut costs, keep the liquid cash in the pockets of people so they can build a business and drive economic health. This is how America has innovated and been successful in the past. If you don't think so please please move to another country.

1) It's only McCain whose relations with lobbyists is above board. Everyone else is a crook, but not John Sidney McCain. He did not have political relations with that woman. Honest.
2) What the hell does new technology have to do with limiting corporate ownership of TV stations? That's called a diversion. Typical McBushCo Straight Crap Express spin.
The eyes are on barrack and hillary? Eyes are also on Britney and Paris. Say much?

National healthcare is a joke. Medical insurance is cheap; and a socialized healthcare system would be abused. It ridiculous...

For America to be successful is to cut costs, keep the liquid cash in the pockets of people so they can build a business and drive economic health. This is how America has innovated and been successful in the past.  

I agree that we shouldn't have gone to Iraq; but at this point if we leave it will be every militia for itself and tons more that you can imagine will die because of it. We should have overpowered afghanistan instead. America did nothing to deserve an attack on our homeland.
So McCain has decided to adopt the Kerry approach to foriegn policy - actually talk to our allies and our enemies. Who said a old dog can't learn, well, old tricks.
McCain admits that he does not know much about the economy, that he is more the foreign policy guy. What a joke! He knows nothing about both. I just hope that MSNBC would donate more coverage of McCain and how clueless he is and stop wasting our time with Obama's pastor.
I believe McCain is the best choice of the three. Hilary is nothing but lies, Obama is an angry black man with an agenda, and both of them will destroy this country by trying to implement communist/marxist ideals. Liberalism does not work. It was the downfall of Europe. Read your history books folks. It just doesn't work. Quit acting like sheeple. The government is already too big, it doesn't need to get bigger with social programs that will make people reliant on the government instead of themselves. PS, I just joined the Army because I believe in what we are doing over there.  11Bravo Baby!
I believe McCain is the best choice of the three. Hilary is nothing but lies, Obama is an angry black man with an agenda, and both of them will destroy this country by trying to implement communist/marxist ideals. Liberalism does not work. It was the downfall of Europe. Read your history books folks. It just doesn't work. Quit acting like sheeple. The government is already too big, it doesn't need to get bigger with social programs that will make people reliant on the government instead of themselves. PS, I just joined the Army because I believe in what we are doing over there.  11Bravo Baby!
if McCain wins, then i'm betting the house on war profiteer companies like Haliburton, DynCorp, Lockheed, et al.  if the troops don't have a problem w/ the rich making money off their blood, then they shouldn't have a problem w/ my middle class butt making money off their blood either.  thanks for the cash, troops!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=825625

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google