ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Chelsea says parents disagree on NAFTA

Posted: Sunday, March 30, 2008 11:04 AM by Mark Murray

From NBC/NJ's Carrie Dann
DURHAM, NC -- Asked yesterday how her mother's stance on NAFTA would correct economic problems without "contradicting" her father's engineering of the policy, former First Daughter Chelsea Clinton said that the trade deal is one area of disagreement between her parents.

"Well, we don't agree on everything as a family," she told the questioner at a Q&A session of North Carolina's Young Democrats in Durham yesterday. "My mother and father agree on most things, not everything," she added. "And what you're talking about is one example of that."

NAFTA is likely to be a major issue in the state for the presidential primary, as many residents blame the loss of textile and manufacturing jobs on the trade deal spearheaded by Bill Clinton's Administration.

Chelsea Clinton also delivered an impassioned defense of her mother's candidacy when a friendly questioner asked if she thought her mother has been mischaracterized by the press and the public during the prolonged nomination fight.

"I didn't really get how much sexism there was in this country," she said, citing examples of voters who had approached her with concerns about a woman's capacity to be commander in chief. She singled out gag gift figurines of her mother as a "nutcracker" ("not in anything that I'd consider a respectful posture," said Chelsea) as particularly offensive.

During the session, which lasted well over an hour, the former first daughter said that she feels compelled to campaign, not by familial duty, but by passion for her mother's cause.  "My mom never asked me to do this," she said. "My dad never asked me to do this."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Chelsea, it would be nice if the media could ask you which side of NAFTA you're on...your father's or your mother's alleged side.

Too bad Mommy and Daddy say you're off limits to being asked questions by the media.
Chelsea,

George Orwell would be so proud of you, historical revisionist that you are.
I think First Read spends way too much time covering Bill and Chelsea.  
THIS BLOG SITE PICKS AND CHOOSES WHAT IT WANTS YOU TO SEE. I HAVE SENT IN NUMEROUS COMMENTS ,WHICH ARE NEVER PRINTED.
After Chelsea's rebuke to the young college student, it looks like the questions posed to her will be more gentle.  I wonder why the questioner didn't point out that even though she denied it, we now have evidence supporting the fact that Hillary helped pass NAFTA.
Hey folks… I have submitted two comments to this blog (not this particular discussion/session) about Hillary: none has been published although I followed the rules. If this one doesn’t get to the blog either I will find another way… there are always other sources that would love to look at censored things—and their reasons.
Hillary is a mercenary. She doesn’t need small money contributions. Her husband is being honest: they need some small-time contributions to cover the big under-the-table money. As usual, Bill more easily expresses his emotions, the way he expressed if to Monica. But Hillary is the one that fumes underneath, to get the final result (like staying with her betraying husband to get power). In Freud’s view, Hillary is the one who waits for a long time to use the restroom.
Hillary is two faced: she supported the war, and now she acts like she is against it (without acknowledging her initial “mistake”). Why? Perhaps to get votes from both sides!
The American public loves honesty/integrity in their leaders. I prefer even McCain over Hillary, even if I am a Democrat.
the media are wimps. If Chelsea is a surrogate and campaigner she should be questioned.  She isn't a baby. She can't have it both ways.
she should get back to her job at the Hedge fund, her apt and dog.
No Surprise here!  Sense of entitlement to the White House by a Clinton.
Cheslea, Was Hillary against it before or after she headlined at a pro-NAFTA event in the White House in 1992?
Is any one surprised by her answer....What did they actually expected her to say...?
"Her father would actually be a better president than her mother"

This is not even big news....Big News would actually be the Truth.....
Chelsea,

Did you misspeak when you confirmed your mother's version of the Bosnia Trip????
Oh please! Chelsea obviously learned how to lie from the best of them... Go back to the hedge fund job your daddy got for you, honey.
Ok Obamatons, when are you going to yell and scream for Mrs Obama to speak to the press?  How time has Mrs O taken questions from an open audience? Haven't seen that happen and dare say you won't since they have to fear what kind of anti-American, racist will come out of her mouth.  For "Which Clinton is running for Office": why do you care what Chelsea thinks on NAFTA? She isn't running; her mother's position is what counts. Again, though, when Mrs. anti-America gives press conferences and answers unfiltered questions from an audience, you can bitch about chelsea then.
The Clinton campaign appreciates all the positive press given their daughter.  My question is this:  Why does the press give her any coverage if they cannot ask her questions?  Just ignore her...we would not allow anyone else actually out stumping for a candidate to get away with that.  The press needs to grow a spine and not let the Clinton's get away with this.  She is not 11 anymore and does not need to be protected.  
http://twocanpete.blogspot.com/
All hail the Warrior Princess! Let it be written, Let it be done.
Even if true, which is doubtful, Hillary's private views on NAFTA a dozen years ago are irrelevant. The fact is that she campaigned publicly for NAFTA, urged its passage, and took credit for it. That's what voters in Pennsylvania who oppose NAFTA should keep in mind.
It's amazing to see how the "playing fast and easy with the truth" gene has slipped to yet another generation of Clintons.
Dear future Queen Chelsea,

We, the American Subjects of the Clinton Dinasty, want to thank Mr., Mrs., and Ms. Clinton for your help to keep the White House rule by one single family. Forget democracy, it's all about power and your mommy knows how to get there.

By the way, WE NEED AN UPDATED DELEGATE COUNT, WITH UNALLOCATED, SUPERDELEGATE AND TOTAL DELEGATES THAT REMAIN TO BE CONTESTED... PLEASE
A chip off the old lying block...
Chelsea's loyalty to her parents is commendable. How clever to bring up sexism and ignore racism - both of which are still part of our society. The real challenge is deciding who will best lead this country.

For me, when her Mother stood on the platform and shamed Obama, embellished the Bosnia story, played so coy about the lie that Obama is not a Christian and is a Muslim and would said she'd leave a church, when she herself has had involvement with less than perfect people did it for me.

Obama has vision and honesty to help all of us understand the challenges we face as a Nation. Healing is needed. I can no longer see how HRC will bring that.  
Most of the time the wife knows best. Why do you think Bill done so good while he was in office!!
Chuck, any possibility that you could do an update on Texas?  The article I read was fairly confusing.  I understand that they are in the process of finalizing their delegate awards to the candidates.  
It doesn't matter which side of the NAFTA debate either parent sides on.

The number of lost jobs in America speak for themselves.

Correct me, but didn't Hillary help and stand by her
husband to help pass NAFTA.

Obama '08
Is it just me or are Chelsea, and especially Bill, doing all the talking. We barely hear anything from Hillary.  Are we really electing an entire family to President?  That is a scary proposition!

http://laststopmidwest.blogspot.com/
IMPRESSIVE! She is a better liar than her mother and her father together! Now: does she agree with her mother about ther Bosnian snipers' story? Do her parents agree on releasing or not their tax returns? etc. Come on, girl, tells us some lies again.
You guys should really stop covering Chelsea as long as she won't take questions from journalists. Talk about nut-cracking. Get some cajones!!
I think it's great.  The question about sexism is real.  Especially on MSNBC.  They are the most sexist reporters I have ever seen.  God forbid the race goes on and Hillary actual wins the nomination.  
Chelsea,
  The White House records and statements made by people actually involved contradict your statements.
Maybe you "misspoke" and are still suffering from running low to get away from all that sniper fire.  
The Obama generation comments do not real discuss the issues, they only spew negativity.  Just like the media only negative words for the Clinton campaign, and misquotes or errors from Obama.  
I've heard Chelsea speak... she's really good.... even better than her mom, but prob not as good as her dad

But it's not speaking style that makes for a good president... it's ideas and implementation of those ideas
Cash-strapped Clinton fails to pay bills


Good Sunday morning.

Politico's Kenneth P. Vogel just posted a hot talker about livid vendors: "Hillary Rodham Clinton’s cash-strapped presidential campaign has been putting off paying hundreds of bills for months — freeing up cash for critical media buys but also earning the campaign a reputation as something of a deadbeat in some small-business circles."

American people are going to trust her with its economic future?
I bet Rudy Giuliani had this type of support from his daughter.  Maybe he would have done better.
Typical Clinton "triangulation".

She claims economic experience in that "35 years", then won't claim the bad economic stuff too.  How typical of her.  

Lies lies lies lies lies lies lies enough already!
Chelsea,
Please tell your mom to fight for Florida and Michigan. We realize that the Republicans do not want this to happen and pretend that rules must be followed but at the same time do not want the rule for using Super delegates be followed.  
IM SORRY CHELSEA I DONT BEIIEVE YOU. THE FACTS DOESNT SAY THAT. ONE THING I WILL SAY ABOUT THE CLINTONS IS THEY STICK TOGETHER.

READ YOUR MOMS PAPERS BEFORE YOU MAKE A STATEMENT LIKE THAT BECAUSE THE FACTS DO SHOW THAT SHE DISAGREE WITH THE NAFTA STORY.

THOUGHT YOU WERE ABOVE THE LIES BUT I GUESS YOUR BEING TOLD WHAT TO SAY AND NOT SAY ON THE CAMPAIGN TRAIL AND REPORTERS ARE NOT ALLOWED TO TALK TO YOU SO PLEASE STOP ON THE COLLEGS SENE TALKING LIKE
YOUR PARENTS...

DO YOU REALY BELIEVE WE ARE GOING TO TRUST WHAT YOU SAY?
I'm sorry, but I live in upstate New York, where your carpetbagging mother came after your Felonious Father was shown the door.  Tammany Hall is still quite effective at getting the undeserving a seat at the national assembly, as your mother's new career is evidence.

However, dear child, your mother's "destiny" to become Chief Executive shall, one can hope, run into the brick wall of reality, and that quite soon.  She is a chimera, reinventing herself and spewing lie after lie, often contradictory, in her quest.  Your mother is EVIL, Chelsea.  It's time you accepted it.
Do we really need to know what side Chelsea comes down on in the NAFTA issue?  She's not Hillary, right...and if you can't attribute Rev. Wright's views to Obama, then what difference would it make to know Chelsea's stance on NAFTA?  

I have an idea: why don't we ask Michelle Obama about the comments she has made about Hillary Clinton ("if you can't run your own house, you can't run the White House") and why she is proud of her country for the first time in her life.  And how about we ask her about her rise in her position in the University of Chicago hospital system, which seems to correlate with Obama's rise in politics.  That would be interesting.  

My perception: Obama supporters who tout his message of "hope" and "change" are full of it.  All anyone has to do is read these message boards to see that Obama supporters post the most venomous, most disparaging, most negative comments on this board.    
It seems an unfair advantage to me that Hillary has Bill and Chelsea to campaign for her. But even with that advantage, Obama is winning.  

I never realized until this campaign how America has "royal families."  I imagine Chelsea looking at the boy from Indiana saying "How dare you ask me that question,  peasant!"   They are elitists-- and they try to intimidate Nancy Pelosi with threats from other Elitists.  

I would be proud to have a Nancy Pelosi as the first female president, but not an elitist like Hillary.
chelsea is a good liar!! She has learnt from her parwents that half of America is uneducated and will vote for anyone with the name Clinton, just because he hwas lucky to get the economic boom actually creatwed by his preseccsor.
I hope america wakes up to the vilifying ways of the clinton's.
OK For all the wondeful people want obarma he seems so proud of America (YA Right)Why won't he wear a America pin on his suit like Macain and Hillary? why won't he pledge to the flag Of United States?? remember he went to a church that had nothing but down grading about white folks OOPS I forgot remember GOD__D___America Obarma seems real proud of the United States bull or could it be cause he is Muslim .Hillary you go girl and win I know Hillary is proud of America she's always smiling look at obarma he always looks mad . Well I'm proud to salute The American Flag. (Hillay Clinton 2008)
Oh, I like it. She was 13 at the time NAFTA was signed into law. And now, 15 years later, she remembers that her parents had a disagreement? What a memory!
CHELSEA YOUR A LIAR LIKE OUR MOMMY AND DADDY EVEN IF THE TRUTH IS OUT ITS I DIDNT HAVE SEXUAL RELATIONS WITH THAT WOMAN OR I MISSPOKE OR EVEN BETTER I CANT FINED THE PAPERS ON WHITEWATER.NAFTA IS YOUR MOM AND DADS DOING SO DONT SAY THEY DISAGREED ON IT,THE EVIDENCE SHOWS YOUR MOM PUSHED FOR NAFTA AS MUCH AS YOUR DAD DID.
Ahh alas welcome back to clintonia its never going to change. Hilary is slick willy's wife for a reason. And obama if you all want malcome x and his black panthers in office then vote obama.

Goodness im so glad our country is so ignorant no wonder people jump our borders.

Stay Sane Vote McCain 08'
The hero we need!
Honestly, I really really don't care about Chelsea's opinions on much of anything.  One assumes she will be out there vouching for her mother and father until they tell her to stop.  What of interest and relevance does this young woman have to offer?  Get back to your day job would be my recommendation and, unless you are running for office yourself, leave the heavy lifting to your mother.  


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=842107

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google