ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Clinton talks jobs; hits McCain

Posted: Tuesday, April 01, 2008 1:17 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ’s Athena Jones
PHILADELPHIA, Pa. -- Hillary Clinton told a union crowd in the Keystone State Tuesday that investment in rebuilding the nation's roads and bridges and in public transit would create three million new jobs.

"My rebuild America plan will create a $10 billion emergency fund to identify and repair critical infrastructure problems and will modernize our transportation system," she said. "We can put at least 3 million Americans to work. We're also going to create at least five million additional jobs in green energy."

Spokesman Mo Elleithee said the three million jobs refers to infrastructure jobs over 10 years plus five million green-collar jobs over the same period for a grand total of eight million jobs.

The Economic Blueprint only had five million, because Clinton had yet to "assign a number" to the infrastructure jobs promised.

As has become common in recent days, the New York senator continued to criticize presumptive Republican nominee McCain for what she sees as his inability to manage the economy.

"John McCain admits he doesn't understand the economy -- and unfortunately he's proving that day after day on the campaign trail," she said. "He looked at the housing crisis, and he blamed consumers. His plan for the economy is to extend George Bush's tax cuts for billionaires and give a $100 billion additional corporate tax cut. The Bush/McCain philosophy could not be clearer -- it's the "ownership society,” which really means, "You're on your own. If you're not a crony, if you're not wealth, if you're not well-connected, you fend for yourself."

She said even fellow Republican Sen. Mel Martinez had given McCain's economic plan an "incomplete," because it does not do enough to help families.

Notably, the senator did not take the opportunity to criticize McCain for gaffes made during his trip to the Middle East, instead keeping the focus on the economy.

Today's speech, which followed a visit to a nearby sheet metal plant, kicked off the fifth day of an economy tour aimed at highlighting Clinton's ability to be commander in chief of the economy, but at nearly every stop along the way, the New York senator has also addressed calls by some Obama supporters for her to get out of the race.

"Sen. Obama says he's getting tired of the campaign,” she said. “His supporters say they want it to end. Well, could you imagine if Rocky Balboa had gotten half way up those Art Museum stairs and said, ‘Well, I guess that's about far enough?’ That's not the way it works. Let me tell you something, when it comes to finishing the fight, Rocky and I have a lot in common. I never quit. I never give up.”

Obama himself has not called on Clinton to get out of the race.

The "Rocky" theme has been recurrent here in recent days, with songs from the movie often blaring before and after speaking engagements. Mark Nevins, the campaign's state communications director, argued in a briefing earlier today that people here can connect with Clinton's profile and that many see her as a fighter in the same vein. Keeping with the underdog-who-eventually-conquers theme, Clinton also campaigned with Sean Astin of “Rudy” movie fame while in Indiana.

Polls have consistently shown Clinton ahead in Pennsylvania, a must-win state for her. But Nevins acknowledged that did not mean the race here would be a cakewalk.

"Recent polls show some tightening. I think this is a natural process and not unexpected," he said. "The Obama campaign is outspending us in the state in the neighborhood of probably 3-to-1."

In fact, NBC News reported Obama is spending about $2 million a week in television advertising here as compared to Clinton’s $400,000. Obama is also spending about the same in Indiana and North Carolina. Clinton is not yet on air in those states.

Nevins added Obama's strengths were in the big cities like Philadelphia and Pittsburgh, but that Clinton would give him a run for his money.

In introducing Clinton, AFSCME president Gerald McEntee noted that Sen. Bob Casey had spoken earlier to let everybody know that he was for Obama, but that he wanted everyone to know the 1.4-million member union was for Clinton. Still, he assured the crowd his union would support whoever becomes the Democratic nominee.

"We do have two great candidates. They are 10 times, 10 times, 10 times better than the boob that's in the White House and, arguably, also, and I hope this is true of American labor, whomever gets the Democratic nomination, you may rest assured that our union will carry the flag for that individual all the way to the White House," he said, adding that labor would lead the fight. "All the unions combined in America are prepared to spend $275 million" to keep McCain from winning.

McEntee also argued Clinton was against NAFTA from the start, saying, "Anybody that tries to hang it around her neck, is hanging it on the wrong neck." 

Clinton repeated her commitment to renegotiating NAFTA in her speech.

Early in her remarks, she hailed the importance of the labor movement, saying it had changed America for the better. "Unions are America," she proclaimed, before quoting Martin Luther King, Jr. "Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. summed up labor's significance before an AFL-CIO gathering much like this one. The labor movement, he said, was the principle force that transformed misery and despair into hope and progress," before going on to note that King was killed 40 years ago this week. 

Clinton also had a rejoinder for Sen. Casey early in her remarks. "I know that Sen. Casey was here earlier and I'm looking forward to inviting him to the White House," she said.

*** UPDATE *** The RNC responds: "Senator Clinton’s attacks on John McCain are a desperate attempt to change the focus away from the divisive battle within the Democratic Party.  Rather than attack Senator McCain, Clinton should explain how she will pay for her massive, new spending proposals and why she plans to raise taxes on hardworking Pennsylvania families and businesses. On a side note, Rocky Balboa has spoken, and he’s with John McCain."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Hillary will say anything to get votes.  Check her past promises regarding jobs..again she lies.

Obam '08
Republicans are voting for Hillary in the Primaries but will vote McCain in November.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/23898341/
"Let me tell you something, when it comes to finishing the fight, Rocky and I have a lot in common. I never quit. I never give up.”


I wonder if she watched Rocky, or is just wanting to pander to Pennsylvania.

Because in the end, Rocky lost after 15 rounds on a split decision to Apollo Creed.
I am an Obama supporter and I agree that the super delegates should vote according to their conscience and based on who is more electable in November. They should not blindly vote based on who wins most pledged delegates.

The reason we have Primary elections is to determine electability in November so guess what, Obama is proving that he is electable, which he has done against Ms. Clinton who was the presumptive nominee up until January. Hillary is the one who is unelectable. She couldnt even win the primaries, how can she win the General Elections. Besides she has the highest disapproval rating of any candidate. 45% of the electorate will never vote for HRC. So she only has a 55% electorate to work with. Both Obama and McCain have disapproval ratings of 26% and 27% respectively. Go figure who is more electable.

Democratic nomination was Hillary's to lose and she is losing it. How can anyone argue that she is more electable in Nov when she screwed up the primaries. It takes strategy and smarts to win elections... different strategies for primaries and general elections. Hillary has failed in the first test, and is now asking us to trust us with a bigger test in November. Obama is a once in a life time candidate who is winning against odds. And those of you who are calling him racist, you really belong in the other party, please vote for McCain whoever the democratic nominee is. I am an Obama supporter but will vote for Clinton, if she is our nominee.
This woman cannot tell the truth what so ever.
I for one will not be voting for a lying, cheating & stealing from the voters will HRC. These are not quailties that should be in the white house, we already have that.

HRC should just let it go.

If HRC steals the nomination, a lot of the Black
and young voters will not show up.

Point being HRC is not for the people just for her- self. HRC will lose the white house, and I`m not saying that they will vote for McCain, they will not vote period.

HRC can not win the white house W/O the black & young voters. They will just say it was rigged and will not commit to anymore of the same political mess that has been tearing this country apart the last 7 years.
HRC says McCain will be a better president than Obama. Now someone please tell me how stating something like that will bring the democrats together?
Bill states that it would be good if we had two people that loves this country in Novenber to fight for the presidency ( meaning HRC & McCain) how in the HELL is that bringing the democrats together?

The Clintons make me SICK!!

She lies about her experience on foriegn policy, NAFTA, White Water, Bosnia, Wal-Mart, where Chelsea was during 911, and to top that off she just FLAT OUT LIED and said that Obama wants to stop the voting process.

This Woman Cannot be TTRUSTED.

Admitted Lies
•  Chelsea was jogging around the Trade Center on Sept. 11, 2001. (She was in bed watching it on TV.)
•  Hillary was named after Sir Edmund Hillary. (She admitted she was wrong. He climbed Mt. Everest five years after her birth.)
•  She was under sniper fire in Bosnia. (A girl presented her with flowers at the foot of the ramp.)
And she took Chelsea with her.
•  She learned in The Wall Street Journal how to make a killing in the futures market. (It didn't cover the market back then.)

Whoppers She Won't Admit
•  She didn't know about the FALN pardons.
•  She didn't know that her brothers were being paid to get pardons that Clinton granted.
•  Taking the White House gifts was a clerical error.
•  She didn't know that her staff would fire the travel office staff after she told them to do so.
•  She didn't know that the Peter Paul fundraiser in Hollywood in 2000 cost $700,000 more than she reported it had.
•  She opposed NAFTA at the time.
•  She was instrumental in the Irish peace process.
•  She urged Bill to intervene in Rwanda.
•  She played a role in the '90s economic recovery.
•  The billing records showed up on their own.
•  She thought Bill was innocent when the Monica scandal broke.
•  She was always a Yankees fan.
•  She had nothing to do with the New Square Hasidic pardons (after they voted for her 1,400-12 and she attended a meeting at the White House about the pardons).
•  She negotiated for the release of refugees in Macedonia (who were released the day before she got there).
With a record like that, is it any wonder that we suspect her of being less than honest and straightforward?

This woman cannot tell the truth what so ever.

I for one will not be voting aslying cheating & stealing from the voters will are not quailties that should be in the white house, we already have that.

HRC should just let it go.

Obama '08......
Yes We Can.....
Not this Time..
And how will Hillary PAY for this $10 Billion emergency fund? She certainly doesn't give out many specifics.......as you anti-Obama people are always accusing Obama of doing.
Clinton also had a rejoinder for Sen. Casey early in her remarks. "I know that Sen. Casey was here earlier and I'm looking forward to inviting him to the White House," she said.
---------------------------------------------------

Is she going to be delivering the message from President Obama?
Does anyone doubt that the woman will say anything for a vote?
HRC wants to "modernize our transportation system"???

Now, that's a good April Fool's joke.  Hillary's inability to modernize has been the reason that Obama's overtaken her once ordained lead.  She knows LOTs about 'the internets' and 'the you-tubes'...and let's not forget about 'XEROXing'!!
"The Truth Hurts,"
Whoever you are, I appreciate the response yesterday in regards to my comment about Hillary Clinton not being fully vetted.    However, your response had no facts in it, just the typical ALL CAPS.  So, again I'll say it.  Just because you, Hillary, Bill, Mark Penn, and Howard Wolfson say she's been fully vetted doesn't mean that it's true.  We've unfortunately found that out the past 2 months.  Her claims about Bosnia that she's been making for 3 months are not misspeaking.  They're lies.  Yes, lies.  When you repeat the same thing for 3 months, it’s not misspeaking.  

Because you believe strongly in your position, precisely what are the 3 things that Hillary Clinton has accomplished in domestic policy and foreign policy that give her the vaunted experience she claims she has?  And please don't respond by saying "well, what has Obama done."  HIllary Clinton is the one running on this deep background of experience; other than being a woman, her entire campaign is built around the experience theme.  I've moved to support Obama in part because she has been so arrogant in her resume buffing.  If somebody walked into my office to interview and I later found out that at least one of the 3 biggest things they had claimed was a lie, I MOST CERTAINLY would not hire him or her.  I suspect you would do the same.

... looking forward to inviting Casey to the White House? Hmmm.

... just like she's looking forward to having Barack Obama as her vice president?

Hillary, if you're such a fighter, why didn't you fight Bush & Cheney tooth & nail against sending our young American troops into Iraq?

That's what a fighter does. They stand up to imperial presidencies.
Not to be repetitive (as many other posters have pointed these things out), but is Hillary really in a position to criticize ANYONE on the economy?  I mean, she keeps running her campaign funding into the ground.  And that budget PALES in comparison to the national budget.  Furthermore, of all the bills they are behind on, her campaign's healthcare premiums is in the list!  (Also, let's not forget a little thing called NAFTA.)  <sigh>
Clinton needs to stop repeating the LIE (big surprise, Hillary is lying) that Obama said she should get out of the race.

She needs to focus on her plans to improve the economy instead of pulling out the "Poor Victim Hillary" card again. I'm getting tired of it! As a woman, watching Hillary make a specticle of herself by pulling this Victim card out again and again - is just infuriating - she is playing to stereotypes on purpose...to win sympathy from women.

She's got good plans and a good argument against McCain - she doesn't need to continue the dishonesty, because she will only dig herself in deeper - people don't trust her as it is - why would she up and fabricate something else? I think she can't help herself - "Misspeaking" (read: LYING) just comes so easily to her - it's second nature.
At least he got the "boob in the WHite House" part right.


But the funniest thing was "I look forward to inviting him to the White House"

I guess she didn't get the memo: Rocky lost.

GAME OVER.  YOU LOST.  DO NOT PASS GO.  DO NOT COLLECT ..........

According to Deans comments earlier today, the undecided supers are to come out and endorse BEFORE the convention.  I guess HRC little scam to STEAL the election isn't  going to work.


MORE DELEGATES.
MORE STATES.
MORE POPULAR VOTE.

Oh, and one more thing, people in PA, you may want to ask you Governor Ed Rendell about the Peter Paul FRAUD trial comimg up April 24.  He may have some questions to answer along side his "girl" HRC.



Obama 08
So she's found the jobs she helped lose with NAFTA? I'm sure the vendors, and their employees will be thrilled Hillary has found them a job, now that they've had to file chapter eleven, over the uncollected fees she bailed on.

This is one time I hope McCain will be his cranky self, and sock-it-to-her. But he won't. He'll think, as his neck starts to swell, and redden,..... ah... why bother, it's only Hill.

Pulling for Obama '08
She can claim she is like Rocky all she wants. However, Rocky was never given a chance to win (kinda like Obama)and his opponents were always the "presumptive winners" kinda like Hillary's nomination before the Feb 5th primaries. If there is an underdog in this campaign its Obama. He took the hits and now he is fighting back with the best ground organized team in the history of the presidential race. He built his support from NOTHING unlike Clinton who has all the tools at her disposal.
Obama--Excellent rhetorical, and communication skills. Great Communicator.

Hillary--Childish rhetorical (raises her voice when she does not get her own way) skills.

Obama--Excellent business/campaign manager: is able to speak in the language of economics. Raised and managed the most impressive campaign in the history of American politics.

Hillary--Very poor business / campaign skills: she cannot even pay her campaign bills. She had to borrow money from herself. Companies want their money up front.


Obama--grass roots organizer on the side of the working person. (Spent half his career working for his community, and did more in the senate in one year than most senators due in a full term.)

Hillary--corporate lawyer who has taken more money from special interest than anyone--ever.  

Obama--leads by example, loyalty, trust and inspiration.

Hillary--leads by threats, negativity, and exaggeration to the point of absurdity (comments on pledged delegates switching sides, and the Bosnia Lies)

Our country deserves better than Hillary: Our country deserves Obama.
Let's be honest. Hillary Clinton is using the tech boom of the 90's to try and make us believe that 1) the president controls the economy, and 2) she has economic credentials. Both are easy to believe, but totally false.
Today, Clinton says, "The Bush/McCain philosophy could not be clearer -- it's the "ownership society,” which really means, "You're on your own. If you're not a crony, if you're not wealth, if you're not well-connected, you fend for yourself."
---------------------------------------
From the March 26 USA Today:  Presidential candidate Barack Obama, largely ignoring his Democratic rival for now, ridiculed likely Republican nominee John McCain on Wednesday for offering "not one single idea" to help hard-pressed homeowners facing foreclosure.

"George Bush called this the ownership society, but what he really meant was 'you're-on-your-own' society," Obama told a town hall meeting here, tying McCain to a president whose popularity is low. "John McCain apparently wants to continue this."

  Plagiarism?????   LOL!

All the while Obama was defending his pastor and than week on vacation Hillary was talking issues with no coverage.This is so Hillary . Not for the cameras like Obama but for the people.She just works on. Day before Obama came back from vacation Hillary was ahead in NC by 1 point. Day he got home and saw that NO NO NO. He was ahead by 20 HAHAHAHA  not to obvious. Now they will have him, ahead in Pa. before it gets here.We can see where that is from. Hillary needs every vote though. Just dont be put off not to vote cause of polls or anyone saying they want to shut system down.She will fight on. If this is stolen from her and she is pushed out and not all votes done yet write her in.If this election is stolen from her  Obama will not win in Nov.
Oh that is rich - now Hillary is now invoking Rocky because she's the "underdog" in this race????  What's next, she puts on an Eagles jersey and yells E-A-G-L-E-S! EAGLES!!!  

You forget Hill, that Philly people know a BS'er when we see one. We even booed Santa. And just like Santa, your campaign is based on a fairy tale.
bill clinton proclaims - The Bush/McCain philosophy could not be clearer -- it's the "ownership society,” which really means, "You're on your own. If you're not a crony, if you're not wealth, if you're not well-connected, you fend for yourself."

that is also the clinton philosophy, and there is no proof showing otherwise, why don't bill and hillary release their tax returns so the voting public can see who they are 'connected' with?
If the DNC can stand aside and watch HRC make a fool out of herself, a former Presidency and democrats in general  then I certainly see why an undecided would consider McCain. End this soap opera now while there is still some party respect to be preserved. Some times we must help those who cannot help themselves.
She does have one thing in common with Rocky. As a fictional character, his background was made up, too.
HRC can't manage the campaign funds in her race for the White House, so what would make anyone believe that she'll know how to turn the economy around if she was elected?
But how many jobs will she create on DAY ONE. 8 million jobs over 10 years. Sounds like double talk to me. 10 years from now, I will be retired...I hope.
Lets get Obama in : His father got caught up in Selma walk and he was concieved.-Oh wait no not right. Well Kennedy paid for his father to come here to go to school.-oh wait that didnt happen. Gave NAFTA talks in Ohio.Said no one went to Canadians to tell them just talk dont pay attention.Proven there was a meeting. ok meeting but NAFTA not talked about.proof. ok but we fixed it.Obama 1996 said no gun ownership or manufacturing,said he didnt know anything like that. His handwritng found on second copy. Well he didnt read it.Had an interview about it. After backing away from it now same people helped him than for state senate will not endorse him now.He at that same time said no capitol punishment too.?? Really truthful huh??He isnt a prof. like he likes to portray him self he is a speeker. My daughter is a professor and it takes a lot for that title.Obama another wannabee.So cann't be truthful.Bad judgement on how he handles these things.Parses the truth as he gets proven wrong.Guess no to Obama
You all can criticize Hilary's economic plans if you like. Barry Obama's is easy: Want something? Here, take it; we'll just raise taxes again and again and again. Free ice cream on Fridays? Sure, why not; serve everybody; put it on the taxpayers' tab.
Let's be honest. Hillary Clinton is using the tech boom of the 90's to try and make us believe that 1) the president controls the economy,
********
Wilson in Seattle, she has a better chance of impacting the economy than Barry Obama has to changing the climate in Washington!  And, why are you making that statement only about her? Barry has said the same things.
The Bush/McCain philosophy could not be clearer -- it's the "ownership society,” which really means, "You're on your own."

That sounds a whole lot like Obama's recent stance on the issues. Plagiarism, anyone?
Kind of hard to believe Hillary will deliver jobs when she could not do that in New York state.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=847360

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google