ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



McCain: pork, his sons, and health care

Posted: Thursday, April 03, 2008 9:16 AM by Mark Murray
Filed Under: ,

In advance of McCain’s speech at Cecil Field, Hotline On Call reports that Cecil Field is a big beneficiary of pork. “Between 2001 and 2005, Cecil Field received almost $10M in earmarked funds, according to Citizens Against Government Waste… In all fairness, McCain doesn't hail from the Sunshine State, of course, and he wasn't responsible for these particular earmarks. But he did vote for the 2004 and 2005 Defense Appropriation Conference Reports that contained the earmarks. The other three years, McCain either didn't vote or voted no on the reports.” 
 
Could both of McCain's sons be serving in Iraq in the fall? It's possible. The Hill: "Democrats have claimed that a McCain White House would be tantamount to a third term of President Bush’s Iraq strategy. But the dynamic of criticizing McCain on Iraq will be different than for the president, who did not serve in a war and does not have children serving abroad. GOP strategists say that McCain stands to gain more by keeping his sons’ military credentials off-limits than by drawing on them for political gain.”

“‘He is playing it right. He is not going for the cheap political lines,’ said John Feehery, who worked for former House Speaker Dennis Hastert (R-Ill.) and is a contributor to The Hill’s PunditsBlog. McCain has yet to mention his sons’ military credentials on his ongoing biographical tour. McCain spoke at his own alma mater, the Naval Academy, on Wednesday, and then traveled to his old flight school in Pensacola, Fla.”

The Boston Globe looks at McCain's health care philosophy. "McCain unveiled his healthcare proposal last fall, a journalist asked whether the Arizona senator's battle against skin cancer would make him sympathetic to the idea of requiring that insurance companies provide coverage to people with preexisting conditions. McCain flatly rejected the idea. ‘That would be mandating what the free enterprise system does,’ McCain said.”

“McCain's response highlights the challenge he faces as he prepares to try to sell his healthcare plan in the fall campaign. He says the country must provide access to healthcare for all our citizens, and that ‘we need to help people who need it.’ But McCain also wants to shrink government's role in healthcare and doesn't want to impose regulations on insurance companies. As a result, McCain's aides have been scrambling to come up with ways to satisfy those who want more coverage without violating what they call McCain's conservative principles on the issue."

Staying on the domestic front, GOP analyst Jennifer Rubin wonders how McCain can deliver an economic message that will sell. "[H]is first hurdle: avoid sounding like Marie Antoinette when delivering hard truths to voters. McCain will face another challenge in convincing voters that he is not a one-trick pony. If Mitt Romney could pull out McCain’s old quotes professing a relative lack of expertise about the economy, the Democrats certainly can. Hillary Clinton has conceded that McCain has impressive national security experience, but either of the Democratic contenders can argue that Americans are selecting a president, not a secretary of defense…

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

It doesn't matter if McCain has a military background.
People are sick of war.
And what they are looking at, McCain doesn't know much about.  Domestic policy and the economy.
In this, many republicans have chosen to behave like Hoover.
If health care doesn't cover pre-existing conditions, is it really health care?  Sounds like the economy isn't the only gap in McCain's knowledge base.
If McCain's sons go to Iraq, they will have my full support, as all the men and women in uniform do.

My opposition to the war in no way affects my admiration for those that answer the call to serve.

God bless them, they are in my thoughts each and every day.  I hope they can all come home to their families and friends and communities safe and sound very son.

http://twocanpete.blogspot.com/
Will his sons be serving in Iraq or present in Iraq? When his kids are partrolling in the Iraqi slums exposed to sniper fire and roadside bombs I will give him my respect for that. Until then I'll wait and see.
I am worried about electing a President who comes from a family of warriors.  The predominant philosophy in the McCain household while he was growing up must have been one-sided and dogmatic.  We condemn military coups in other countries, yet we too are being drawn in that direction.  McCain's psychological trauma from his prolonged captivity as a POW must become an issue to be openly discussed without being painted as "unpatriotic".  If Republicans can scream that Obama was somehow brainwashed by the rantings of Rev. Wright, then reasonable people can say McCain's anger issues reflect repressed rage against his captors.
"..he was'nt responsible.."  

He knew what was in the bill, helped pass it by voting for it, and is now pandering to the recipient's of 'pork'. Yeah, he'll look real innocent, whoofing down the basket-o-barbecue he want's for lunch.

So, Senator McCain hid, his own kids from 'the 100 years war'.

This will be fair game in the GE. Obama, here is the card that will trump the Rev. Wright scandal, 'any day', and yes, twice on your supposed un-patriotic 'sundays', spent in church. If the GOP pulls it out of their hypocritcal hand, throw it, and take 'em down.    
First Read this is pretty lame.  Is this the best you could do because McCain didn't take earmarks like your boy Obama, or the other Democrat you occassionaly mention?  This like some other recent far reaches in hopes of damaging McCain only shows how bias some are.
It doesn't matter if McCain has a military background.
People are sick of war.
And what they are looking at, McCain doesn't know much about.  Domestic policy and the economy.
In this, many republicans have chosen to behave like Hoover.
diane (Sent Thursday, April 03, 2008 9:22 AM)


Another bogus argument by the left.  What experience doesn the Community Organizer from Chicago have?  None What experience does the ex First Lady have?  None  At least McCain has leadership experience and has managed something larger than a Senate office, and like any other President will appoint others with experience.  Not to mention the President doesn't run the economy nor does he have any say in how much oil China, India, or the rest of the emerging world consumes.
Give me a break, Mccain!  YOU'RE A SENATOR!! I'M PAYING FOR YOUR HEALTHCARE, YOU FAUX CAPITALIST!!  Senators get lost of good healthcare benefits...courtesy the taxpayers' hard-earned money, even taxpayers who can't afford their own healthcare. MAKE ME PUKE, JOHN!!!
Oh I so agree with you David Kolva! I, for one, have wondered about McCain's psycholgical trauma due to prolonged captivity as a POW. Many, many soliders that came back from Viet Nam are STILL suffering psycholical trauma and they weren't neccessarily "tortured" by the enemy as McCain was. I think it's a fair question and one, no doubt, that needs to addressed in the General election.
Every time there is a vote, there is  the possiblity of "pork" in it.  Just because he doesn't offer any "pork," doesn't mean that isn't going to vote for it.  This is the same trouble that I have with Ron Paul.  You can say that you don't like something, but you might end up doing it anyway.  

As for his sons serving in Iraq, that is their choice to do that since we have an all volunteer military.  I hope for their saftey and the saftey of all our service members.  This should not be brought up in the campaign at all.  His sons serve; that is good for them.  
Prince Harry was not allowed to serve in a combat unit openly for obvious reasons. He is a high value target and would endanger the mission, himself, and his comrades.
McCain's sons are to be praised for their service to the Country. But with such a high profile father I would imagine that the Marine Corp has the same concerns as the British. I don't know and I don't want to know in what capacity either of the McCain boys are serving in Iraq. That could endanger them and their comrades. But I will guess that they are kept secure. And if they are not now assigned jobs that keep them out of harms way, they will most certainly if John McCain is Elected President.
Dunno. First Read already dropped the ball on this by ignoring the website of the United States Marine Corps[News],which observed that LCPL Jim McCain already served a full tour in Iraq returning only weeks ago.[among his duties,was patrolling for roadside bombs. That answers your question twocanpete]. Say what one will regarding McCain,he puts his money where his mouth is,potentially sacrificing more than any political family since FDR[whose four sons all served in WWII]. Another son,Andrew,will be commissioned a Marine 2nd Lt. upon graduation from Annapolis. ''Brown bars'',having among the lowest life expectancy of any ground combat soldier.

www.marinecorpsnews.com
To not cover pre existing medical conditions         in health care reform is immoral. My wife has been a diabetic since she was 2 years old and she has all sorts of complications. I guess under McCain`s proposal she would be ineligible for health insurance. Great news for her.
Lee Holmes: Errata. Change ''Andrew''McCain[who was a naval flier serving on USS EISENHOWER and AMERICA],with ''Jack''.
McCain's son already served a tour in Iraq please correct your headline.  He returned in february.
Its funny becuase I just read an article saying that the republicans want Obama as the nominee becuase it will be "easy" to defeat him.....

go to McCains website and you will see that he has no plans for the economy (he doesnt understand economics)he wants to lower taxes for Corporations,  he has no healthcare plans unless you are big business (as shown above) He has NO educational plan, he thinks No Child Left Behind is doing great, and has no plan for the housing crisis except that it will play out like it should without govt. help......

If anyone watched Obama on Hardball listen to his quick and smart responses....he WILL beat mccain by his plans and answers, support and enthusiasm...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3JnJo4XMUq4

BTW experience and tenure in washington has proven to be a bad thing....

whatever McCain's morals and principles were when he started politics have been sold off to his lobbyists and corporations.....same could be said of clinton...


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=854132

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

More First Read

Recent Posts:


Archives:


Topics:

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google