ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



'An error in judgment'

Posted: Friday, April 04, 2008 1:19 PM by Mark Murray

From NBC's John Boxley
As mentioned earlier today, the Wall Street Journal reported that Clinton chief strategist Mark Penn -- in his role as chief executive of Buston-Marsteller -- met with Colombia's ambassador to discuss a free trade deal, which Clinton actually opposes.

Penn just released this statement: "The meeting was an error in judgment that will not be repeated and I am sorry for  it. The senator's well known opposition to this trade deal is clear and was not discussed."

*** UPDATE *** Change to Win, a federation of labor unions (like SEIU and the Teamsters), that has endorsed Obama, is calling for Hillary Clinton to fire her chief strategist, Mark Penn. "We have questioned Penn's role in the Clinton campaign in the past for his representation of union busting employers like Cintas," Change to Win executive director Greg Tarpinian said in a statement. "At that time, Penn said there was a wall between him and his firm's representation of union busters. The latest revelation that Penn -- whose firm represents the Colombian government in its effort to secure passage of a so-called free trade agreement -- is actively involved in securing its passage in the middle of Senator Clinton's presidential campaign is outrageous. It also suggests that he has been playing a double role - advising the Senator on what to say to curry Democratic voters and advising the Colombian government on what to say to curry a majority of votes in Congress."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

2008 Presidential Election Weekly Poll
http://www.votenic.com
New Poll Started, Vote to See Previous Results!
Thanks for your Support!
Yeah. Right.

You you believe this, I have an adjustable rate mortgage I would like to sell you.


Obama '08
...In December, according to an Associated Press tally, Clinton led Obama by 106 superdelegates. In February, her lead had been cut to 87. As of Thursday, it was 30...

http://www.latimes.com/news/politics/la-na-superdelegates4apr04,0,2459713.story
Yeah. Right.

If you believe this, I have an adjustable rate mortgage I would like to sell you....


Obama '08
And the columbian Gov. was "unsure" if Penn represented Clinton or B-M!!!  Just imagine an aide of Sen. Obama did that.  Remember Ohio?  Again, the Clintons STARTED that, and the Obama advisor there was just that, an unpaid advisor, not Penn, the head-honcho of the CLintons, who never bother to make it clear what hat he was wearing?!?!?!  Literally UNBELIEVABLE!  

It's all about judgment.

 
You can pick your campaign managers and your husbands...

This is an OUTRAGE.  Let's have some more reporting on Hillary's contacting the Canadian govt about NAFTA...Clearly, that's been under-reported and therefore misunderstood by many.
Damage control- spin away!
With friends like this, she doesn't need enemies!  
And the Columbian vovernment was "unsure" if Penn represented Clinton or B-M?!  Literally UNBELIEVABLE!  Remember Ohio?  The Obama advisor was just that, an unpaid advisor, plus the whole thing started in the Clinton campaign.  Here, this is PENN we are talking about, the CLinton Guru!  
wink wink nod nod
Hope they get blasted for this.
I really hope that the MSM stay with this story. This is why so many people dislike the Clintons. I know KO will love to report this on countdown.
There seem to be a lot of those in the Clinton campaign.
You know, if I didn't dislike and distrust Hillary so much, I'd almost feel sorry for her at this point.  This is another story that's going to have legs for a few days and she has it comming for hiring a lobbyist to be her chief strategist.  
McCain's chief strategist, Charley Black actually works for Mark Penn at Burson-Marsteller Worldwide ...

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/graphic/2007/02/20/GR2007022000447.html

(via Kausflies)
An error in judgement is supporting a candidate who uses Lobbyists for positions she purports to disagree with in her campaign at all

An error in judgement is supporting a democratic candidate who has taken large sums of money from Ruport Murdoch (or from fundraisers sponsored by him)

An Error in judgement is thinking that Clinton is the embodiment of the archetype of leadership that we need as president.

Average Joe's for Obama
Does this mean Mark Penn will be on Leno tonight joking about the meeting?
Mrs. Clinton, can we go on the Merry-Go-Round again!

WHEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!

"Error in Judgement"?

Had any Obama advisors held such a meeting the Clinton supporters would be playing Whack-A-Mole with his candidacy.
"ERROR IN JUDGMENT"??  I can't believe he used those words... underscoring Hillarys BIGGEST weakness:  JUDGEMENT!


And that was a written statement... talk about SABATOGE!
he's only sorry he got caught.
He just "misspoke." If I'm Obama's camp I jump on this, because you know she would.
Oooooo! Trouble! Will Mr. Penn be able to take out what he dishes out?   I believe that Mark is sorry "as far as I know."  A word of advice, I probably would not have said "judgement" that's too easy.
"ERROR IN JUDGMENT"??  I can't believe he used those words... underscoring Hillarys BIGGEST weakness:  JUDGEMENT!


And that was a written statement... talk about SABATOGE!
This is the problem with having a lobbyist as your cheif campaign strategist. Conflict of interest, something Obama consistently rails against.  Say Clinton elected president... I know which lobbyist I would go to in order to gain the most influence.. Mark Penn
Another "wink, wink... nudge, nudge" meeting by the HRC camp. Big surprise there.

Are they now going to turn this around with another big lie and say that it was the Obama camp that did this, they way they did with the NAFTA/Canada issue?
Wow!?!

I believe it was Hillary's strategy to stay in the race until Obama made a misstep and swoop in to rally the voters.  Hmmm...seems she is the one that must becareful of a misstep.

Her campaign has been based on her close circle and "loyal" supporters/friends.  Seems her administration will be as well.  I do not want any part of that.
Let us reflect back on Mrs. Clinton's words in OH.

"I don't think people should come to Ohio and tell the people of Ohio one thing and then have your campaign tell a foreign government something else behind closed doors," Clinton said then. "That's the kind of difference between talk and action and that I've been pointing out in this campaign."

"I would ask you to look at that story, substitute my name for Senator Obama," she also said. "If some of my advisers had been having private meetings with foreign governments and basically saying ignore what I'm saying because it's only political rhetoric … I think it raises serious questions."

If Goolsby resigned, why not Penn? Oh yea he's a highly paid advisor....wait, that's not right....maybe the media is in the tank for Hillary?

As Edward R. Murrow (when there was actual journalism amongst the media) might have said to Hillary at this point:

Good night and Good Luck....oh yea, and don't lie!
Wow!?!

I believe it was Hillary's strategy to stay in the race until Obama made a misstep and swoop in to rally the voters.  Hmmm...seems she is the one that must becareful of a misstep.

Her campaign has been based on her close circle and "loyal" supporters/friends.  Seems her administration will be as well.  I do not want any part of that.
All of this misspeaking and theses errors in judgment...I tell ya' I might even be able to get through all of this (I doubt it, though) if she hadn't voted for Bush's war.
I pray that Obama gets this nomination (not only because he is the best person to come around in a generation) because try as I might, I will never be able to bring myself around to vote for Hillary in the general.  No, I wouldn't vote for McWar either.
God save us from the Clintons.
Obama '08
Hillary has officially wink wink on a neoNAFTA deal w/ Colombia by sending her top campaign official to discuss the last details of this new Clinton era for the millionaires...
So are we suprised by this? Isn't this do anything say anything for votes as usual and we will forget and forgive? There have been so many things to forgive too. Remember Filegate during the Clinton administration? You know where it was discovered early in the Clinton Administration that White House staffers had illeagally requisitioned, were illeagally holding, were apparently illegally poring through and perhaps disseminating the personal information contained in 900 raw FBI files on Republicans who had worked in the White House for REagan and Bush? Gee the Clinton's do dirty tricks and say dirty things. You think?
Keith Oberman is going to have a field day with this one....
On Bosnia Hillary "misspoke". With Richardson she "misheard"; guess Mark Penn can "Mismeeting".
Yeah, Hillary supporters can talk "judgement" all they want.....they've got nowhere to hide! He'll just have to do a better job of having his meetings in a more secret fashion. I'm sure Hillary can help him there.
Darvin, great find on the quote.  Now, will she have Penn resign?
Oh I can't wait for Countdown with KO.  He is going to a coniption field day with this!  LOl
Looking forward to seeing how Hillary fits the "shame on you, Barack Obama" square peg into this deep round hole.
...And Hillary will be Ready From Day One to control her staff the way she's controlled this clustermess.
Repeated "mis-speaks", "misunderstandings" and "errors in judgement" only reinforce why I choose not to back Senator Clinton's campaign. They seem to be coming at an alarming rate, these days.
An error in judgement?  Oh, just like the errors in judgement on how to spend campaign money...the error of thinking she was inevitable and this would all be over by Super Tuesday...her error in judgement about how and when she was dodging sniper fire...error in judgement about attending prayer breakfasts sponsored by the Fellowship...

Someone wrote in a previous post "god bless" Hillary - I think "god help her" would be more like it.  God help us all.
Time for HRC to go heck she cannot even control her own SENIOR PEOPLE AMAZING!!!!
If this has legs, it could spell the end of Clinton in PA. If the Clinton campaign is caught promoting trade deals, it could really hurt and it will emphasize that she really wasn't against NAFTA but is a closet free trader. 5-10 points in PA could make all the difference.
There are too many 'Mis-this' and 'Mis-that' in the Clinton camp.  That means that US will be 'Mis-Ruled' if she wins.  We should not allow that to happen.

EOM.
Why can't I find this story anywhere else?
This seems big to me.
The erroneous Clinton campaign has been all but derailed by the shenanigans of her so called advisors.  Hang it up Hill should just vacate the race, resume her place in the Senate and be done with presidential politics.  
Was it the Clinton campaign who actually told Canada to take the Nafta discussions with a grain of salt?

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20080305.wnafta06/BNStory/National/home
Apologizing today is not the matter.
Whats the time line here: This happened (the prep meetings and talks) while the NAFTA was going on Ohio?. And no one in the camp knew that the Strategist is meeting on another <?>FTA. And has a Strategist he did not know that this will send shock waves to the candidate's position? Again talk about Consistency here ...discussions by a Advisor Vs Chief Strategist
IT JUST GOES TO SHOW YOU THE THE CLINTON ARE NOT FOR UNION JOBS.

THEY HAVE A MAN LIKE MARK PENN ON HER STAFF AND HE IS A UNION BUSTER, WHAT DOES THAT TELL ALL OF US THAT ARE UNION PEOPLE. HE SHOULD BE FIRED:

ALL THE CLINTONS DID TO OBAMA OF THE CANADA MESS SHE PLAYED TO THE HILT AND THEN WE FIND OUT MARK PENN IS A UNION BUSTER AND TRYING TO TALK TO ANOTHER COUNTRY ABOUT PASSING A TRADE BILL.....


DAMN HILLARY I NEVER THOUGHT YOU WERE THAT STUPID BUT YOU JUST SHOWED YOUR TRUE COLORS

AND BY THE WAY MY LOCAL IS UNITED STEELE WORKERS OF AMERICA LOCAL 2958
She has no control over her own paid staff. She can not pay her bills. she can not pay her staffs health insurance.
OOOOPPPPPSSS,Guess she is experiencing life in America.
Owl
I would only add that it doesn't "suggest" that he's been playing a double role...clearly he HAS been playing a double role.  The union federation is correct to bring attention to that.

Obama 08


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=859814

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google