ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



In the rain, McCain talks about MLK

Posted: Friday, April 04, 2008 2:44 PM by Mark Murray

From NBC/NJ's Adam Aigner-Treworgy
MEMPHIS, TN -- The newest addition to the McCain campaign had his public unveiling today, but only a select few actually got to enjoy it.

While in town to participate in the Southern Christian Leadership Conference's commemoration of Martin Luther King Jr.'s assassination 40 years ago, McCain read the works of his newest speechwriter: Matthew Scully. A former employee of the Bush administration, Scully is perhaps most famous for writing this essay in the Atlantic Monthly in 2007 about his former colleague, Michael Gerson.

McCain delivered his first speech by Scully today in the pouring rain outside of the hotel where King was shot, but the senator's soft-spoken delivery mixed with weather conditions and a poor PA system meant that only a select few could hear what the senator was saying. The front row's reaction was audible in the back of the crowd, but if it weren't for a loud introduction and a wave from the hotel balcony on his way to the stage, most of the audience wouldn't have even known that McCain was there.

VIDEO: Speaking in Memphis to honor Martin Luther King, Jr., John McCain says that he "was wrong" for voting against a federal holiday for the civil rights leader.

According to prepared remarks provided to the media this morning, McCain's speech was a moving survey of King's lasting effects on society, and a candid account of the senator's own failures to move fast enough in recognizing the civil rights leader's true significance.

"Even in this most idealistic of nations, we do not always take kindly to being reminded of what more we can do... We can be slow as well to give greatness its due, a mistake I made myself long ago when I voted against a federal holiday in memory of Dr. King," McCain said of a vote during his first year in the House of Representatives. "I was wrong and eventually realized that, in time to give full support for a state holiday in Arizona. We can all be a little late sometimes in doing the right thing, and Dr. King understood this about his fellow Americans."

McCain's effective silence caused some in the crowd to remark on the strange symbolism of the situation -- all three presidential candidates were invited to today's event, but only Clinton and McCain agreed to come. Hillary's speech was delivered indoors, where the candidate was dry and well heard.

On the other hand, McCain's speech was outside in the rain, where only a select few could either see or hear him -- a physical reality that may reflect the reaction he will get from much of the audience at the polls in November. But you have to give the guy credit for showing up.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

According to Huff Post, McCain was BOOOOED !!

Why didn't you mention this, MSNBC ?

Could someone PLEASE ASK the AFT and AFSCME unions to comment on the Mark Penn - Columbia 'AXIS OF EVIL' ?

Hillary claims to be against these trad deals while her henchmen are secretly promoting them ...

Ask the AFT and AFSCME unions WHY they are supporting Hillary and her henchman 'union busting' Mark Penn ?

someone ask the AFT and AFSCME why they are supporting Hillary and her cheif of staff, Maggie Williams who operated a 'sub prime' predatory lender ??
As a few others said earlier, it's not necessary to go the place where someone was gunned down.

For those who want to pay their respects, each November most people tend to go to the JFK Library as opposed to Dallas. It is appropriate.

Rosie Grier I don't believe ever went back to the Ambassador Hotel. Yet he never forgot about RFK or that fateful night in June '68 and the role he played.

What's in your heart and what you have learned is all that matters.
I am an Obama supporter and a skeptic, and I often have trouble believing the sincerity of Clinton and McCain, but it was pretty awesome of him to admit he was wrong in voting down the MLK holiday measure... at least that's a step further than Clinton, who wouldn't admit to making a mistake in voting for Iraq... and even if he's pandering to get votes, the words are what will get recorded in transcripts and history books, so it is out there and he will be judged by those words.

Right on, McCain. You won't have my vote, but... right on.

As always, I urge everyone else to remain positive, while I try to stifle the pessimism I feel about whether it will ever be that way.
Credit, that is for his heavenly judge to pronounce.

The Presidency, is something else. I don't want someone bringing up the rear, when it comes to decency, justice, and vision. I want someone who can forge the way to a better America.

It is Senator Obama who has best evidenced these qualities.

Pulling for Obama '08
I know this: Obama or one of his surrogates SERIOUSLY needs to come out with a memo or have a press confrerence re: the Florida and Michigan "re-votes." He is getting absolutely panned on political message boards. HRC supporters are making him out to be the one who is solely responsible somehow. This is clearly not the case but that won't stop people from spreading mis-information. People tend to not care that HRC supported this supposed "disenfranchisement" up until the point that she started losing. Something should have been said a while ago but, instead, they have been keeping quiet and i think that is the WRONG THING TO DO. You've got to kill this rumor SOONER rather than LATER because, unfortunately, a lot of people are just not that smart and will eat up whatever ignorance is spewed on the internet or radiowaves or on the television. Soundbyte politics bytes...BIG TIME.
In memory of Dr King--I forgive Senator McCain for his vote.  I think that is what Dr King would have done.  
"We can be slow as well to give greatness its due, a mistake I made myself long ago when I voted against a federal holiday in memory of Dr. King.....I was wrong and eventually realized that, in time to give full support for a state holiday in Arizona."

Yes he was wrong and only realized it after being inundated with email and letters letting him know. It just goes to show his true colors.  I hope he was boo'd.  How he could bring himself to make a speech on this day is beyond me.  MLK and the King holiday mean absolutely nothing to this man.  His vote tells the story.

So now you have learned the importance of remebering MLK day!!!! Well good for you, even though you voted it down in your home state. I know you feel like you have to pander to the black vote just in case Hillary wins, but I for one will not vote for you. I think I will have to agree with Sharpton ( and I hate to say that)but I will vote for the other fossil nader!!!
A rich, old, white Republican lecturing on racial inequality! How... irrelevant.
MLK was a good man, however there are thousands of people who deserve a lot more praise for the civil rights movement than MLK does. All those brave people that came before MLK, people who's children did not gain financial benefits from their parents sacrifice as the King children have. I'm black by the way
I think the that McCain deserves credit for showing up. It's not an easy thing to do to show up and admit your mistakes and I think it took a lot of courage for him to do it. Especially when dealing with something as explosive as race relations. I applaud him. I think it matters more what he thinks now. We've all made choices in the past that we're not proud of. Besides if HRC snatches the nomination from Obama, he may have an opening with the African Americans that Republicans haven't had in decades.
"Most of the audience wouldn't even have known that mccain was there." Most wouldn't even care. His pandering is a testement to his hypocricy.
First Read, could you PLEASE play MLK's speech on the Vietnam war. I think that would stop this Wright argument right then and there.
No, no, no Mr. McCain.  You should be booed.  I lived in Arizona when the likes of you, Meacham, and Goldwater were there.  You need to tell the whole truth.  Yes you voted against the MLK holiday in 1983 and you ALSO went along with the racist Gov. Meacham when he rescinded the holiday in Arizona.  Arizona was one of the states that resisted the MLK holiday but the Democratic governor at the time...I believe his name was Baron or Babbit or something used an executive order to recognize the holiday in spite of Arizona's racist legislature.  The next governor, Meacham, immediately rescinded the order and stated that Dr. King didn't deserve a holiday and he used to use ethnic slurs to describe him and any other Black people very candidly in front of others and the camera.  He called Black children "pickaninnies".  This man Meacham was so racist that he eliminated all of the Black TV programs (the very few that were in existence then).  I remember when people were just happy that "Benson" was allowed to be on-air in Phoenix.  McCain needs to get his photo-op, hypocritical self out of there right now.
Some truly heartfelf words from deep within his...SPEECHWRITER!
I dare say Dr. King would be ashamed at the hostility directed towards Senator McCain after he admitted his earlier mistakes.  The irony of this anger is clearly lost many of those who have commented.  Clinging to the past and dwelling on previous wrongs prevents reconciliation - reconciliation that must, like it or not, include "rich, old, white Republican[s]"
I have to say that I have learned a lot today from Michael Erick Dyson. I had no idea that Dr. King was working on a speech indicating America could go to hell. That really opened my eyes about the whole situation with Rev. Wright. Could that have an impact with voters if they realized the truth of what Obama was saying about the generational bitterness that exists among some blacks. Why hasn't the media talked more about that?
OMG!!

You think "we" will not vote for McCain.... Ha think again.


Your *hunch* is wrong, way off the mark... I have been a democratic supporter for years. But millions of us are fed up with what we see. Like how is it that a candidate can win the popular vote of a state and still lose the delegate count. This so called democracy of the democrats is absurd.

And how is it that voters in Houston and Dallas Texas votes count more than the votes of the citizens out in the rural areas of the state. Seven votes in Houston equals ten votes down around the Rio Grand, with regard to awarding delegates.

Then screaming Dean strips Florida and Michigan of their (votes) and delegates, "strips" them.... These states are critical to the election, were not taking about Idaho or Utah, states that the democrats don't stand a snow balls chance in hell of winning. But the party and Obamaphiles who seem to be one and the same, point to and say look at "our baby" he's won Idaho and Utah, he can win the Election. He is not running against a Republican there "baloon heads" it's a fellow Democrat.

Obama's effort to disenfranchise millions of voters and the crazy democrats, back him up doing it. The Party moved up South Carolina, and Nevada, so the minorities could play a more important role in the election process and they then turn around and *strip* Florida and Michigan of their votes. It's a Constitutional right to vote in this country, and now the AA hold the party so tight in their grip that Democrats are afraid of a Kenyan style like election if they don't nominate Obama. In other words it's taking to the streets burning and killing things because they are unhappy, if they don't get the results, they deserve..

I will never vote for a candidate that crushes votes of his own party for political gain, nor those who back him up. The Democratic Party is so dramatically unfair and corrupt, this has been the real learning experience for me as this election plays out over time. I'm thankful to Hillary for that, the neophytes who writes all these hate mail, blogs about the Clinton's, are for the most part incredibly naive and shallow. Obama is already far more slippery than the Hillary will ever be.

As a Democrat, after I vote for McCain in the fall, I will change to an Independent, this country is in desperate need of a "Third Party" something in the middle, between the Left Winged Liberals of pseudo superimposed guilt, Democrats. And the Right Winged Conservatives, who feel the world is (their's) play ground Republicans.


Hillary/McCain, 2008
http://twocanpete.blogspot.com/
If McCain made a campaign speech and nobody listened would it still sound like a bunch of lies?
John says he was wrong in voting against MLK DAY.
But now that I am candidate for President I will say that.

He was against it so he could hold his government position as a rep of Arizona. They would of voted him out if he voted for it as I remember they were against it as a STATES RIGHTS issue.
wow, the lead on the story is a new speechwriter for the senator? What I would really like to see is to see the guy speak off the cuff without a written word.  what would come out of his mouth?  anyone know?
That was an interesting speech by McCain. You often don't hear the thoughts of white politians about race and civil rights....well..atleast in a candid manner. Thanks Mr. McCain.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=860317

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google