ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



McCain camp demands apology

Posted: Saturday, April 05, 2008 1:41 PM by Mark Murray

From NBC/NJ's Aswini Anburajan
At a North Dakota Democratic Party fundraiser yesterday, a liberal talk radio show host called McCain "a warmonger," a term that has the McCain campaign pointing fingers at Barack Obama and questioning his commitment to running a positive campaign devoid of personal attacks.

According to pool reports and a local story written by the Grand Forks Herald, Ed Schultz "warmed up the crowd, attacking the Arizona senator as 'a warmonger,' before Obama arrived in the room."

The McCain campaign is demanding an apology. "Barack Obama's willingness to stand-down after a surrogate of his campaign callously called John McCain a 'warmonger' demonstrates an incredible comfort with the old-style politics he claims to reject," McCain spokesman, Tucker Bounds said in a written statement.

Bounds pointed out that when Bill Cunningham, conservative talk radio commentator, attacked Obama at a McCain event in January and repeatedly used his middle name, McCain immediately apologized for Cunningham's remarks. "I absolutely repudiate such comments, and again I will take responsibility -- it will never happen again. It will never happen again," McCain said at the time.

"All you can hear right now are crickets," Bounds said of Obama's lack of an apology. He added that McCain apologized even though he had not heard Cunningham's comments himself, indicating that aides had flagged them as inappropriate and took prompt action to ensure that the senator distanced himself from them.

When Obama took the stage yesterday, he thanked Schultz, saying he was "a voice of progressive radio."

An Obama aide says that the senator, who hadn't heard Schultz's remarks, was thanking Schultz for speaking rather than thanking him for his attack on McCain.

The aide also said that the lack of an apology should not be surprising since there are sharp distinctions between the two events, pointing to the fact that Cunningham had endorsed McCain and was speaking at a McCain event.

"This was not our event. He's not our surrogate. And the tone of the remarks were very different," the aide said.

The tone of Schultz's comments and the full extent of his remarks have been hard to judge, since only two pool reporters were allowed into the fundraiser and arrived at the tail end of Schultz's speech. No audio or video of the remarks exists.

*** UPDATE *** Obama spokeswoman Jen Psaki says in a statement, "John McCain is not a warmonger and should not be described as such. He's a supporter of a war that Senator Obama believes should have never been authorized and never been waged."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Typical Obama. He is to above everything and everyone. He wouldnt do anything earlier when all said he should do something when Hillary was done wrong. This is the new politics we all want. get used to it. He dont need to apologise to no underlings.Typical white folk wants a sorry imagine the nerve.Our new society at work. To late now we have seen .
Since I saw Bill Cunningham make his repulsive remarks (and the repulsion does not come from the repeated use of Senator Obama's middle name, please!) and I read that Bill Schultz said "war-monger," I can only conclude that Senator McCain's campaign is having trouble making legitimate comparisons.

Senator McCain wants to stay in Iraq until there is victory (whatever that means) and he seems intent on attacking Iran.  Senator Obama would not use the descriptor "war-monger," but I don't see it as an out-of-bounds adjective for what Senator McCain actually proposes.  Mr. Cunningham, on the other hand, implied so many things that have nothing to do with Senator Obama's life, actions or policy positions that comparing the two is an extremely fallacious comparison-- rather like comparing semi-trucks with horse drawn carriages.  
"Bomb, bomb, bomb, bomb, bomb, Iran."

During the Republican primaries McCain ran as a warmonger.  He's voted again and again to raise the debt ceiling to borrow more money from China to pay for the neocon adventurism he supports fully.  He thinks that American policy should include wars of aggression that result in permanent occupations of sovereign countries.  I don't see anything inaccurate about the description "warmonger".  He should defend his positions rather than whine about terminology.
give me a break. mccain IS a 'warmonger'. he hasn't shied away from it. he even found great pleasure in singing "bomb, bomb Iraq." And there's no comparison between the two events. Cunningham made a very personal, nasty, incendiary, conspiracy-theory indictment of Obama and mccain had no choice but reject it. THIS is nothing more than policy difference. mccain should just explain why he thinks it's appropriate to stay in Iraq for 100 years, how can he sustain the 12billion dollars per year costs while we're in a recession, how he plans to build the military such that we have troops to combat Al Quaeda itself, whether if he knew where Al Quaeda was at and had a chance to take them out and pakistan refused, whether he'd take them out. he should explain why Iraqis are paying 1.36 dollars for gas at the pump while our soldiers protecting them in Iraq are paying 3.49 dollars. if that doesn't make him a warmongernut, i don't know what will.
Obama should probably apologize for the rhetoric (name-calling is not Barack's style).  But the apology should be followed up with a factual statement about McCain and his support of the Iraq War, his inappropriate "bomb, bomb, bomb Iran" joke (not too funny for the 10,000's killed or injured from such a venture), and finally he should factually state all the remarks and instances that McCain has recently made that shows him to be pro-war (by any other name a "warmonger".)  There is a stark choice in the upcomeing GE between a warrior and peacemaker- I choose a peacemaker that will actually make us more secure and well-respected in the World.  

OBAMA for Peace in '08
Obama seems to think no one but him can can say whatever they want to about other people.

He still hasn't answered the questions people want answered and why he has lied so many times to the American people.

Obama's friend and partner Rezco and his property dealings and contributions,

Obama's friend terrorisy William Ayers,

Obama's racist, white hating anti American Pastor Wright who preaches hate and says  God Dam_ America. And say America got what we deserved on 9-11, and that America infected blacks with the aides virus

Why Obama's wife is ashamed to be American, and why she thinks America is mean.

Obama's Black Liberation racist, hate filled church,
p.s.- my previous comment was sent before the "update" remark.  It is nice to know the way your candidate will react.  Obama has class, integrity and wisdom- just what this country needs!
The dictionary describes a warmonger as a person who encourages war, usually for personal reasons.  McCain does encourage war and it is for personal reasons, those being that he wants to continue the Bush plan inorder to win the presidency.  Why does this offend him?  It appears petty at best.
McCain IS a warmonger!  Stand by Republicans, you're about to get your a@@ handed to you this election cycle.
i love the update even better! lol...not a war monger, but a failed war supporter. GO BAMA!
THE OXFORD AMERICAN DESK DICTIONARY AND THESAURUS: Second Edition - warmonger: war-mon-ger, a person who seeks to bring about or promote war.

Senator McCain,

The American people will decide, for themselves, whether or not Senator Obama is a Muslim, or you are a warmonger.

Make your case with the voters.

Pulling for Obama '08
Typical of a man who hangs with anti american pastors antisemitic  beliefs. Typical of people who are "not proud" of America.. MCCAIN=HERO Obama=ZERO
OBAMA needs to come out and apologize himself and reject Ed Schultz, just like McCain did after Bill Cunningham made those remarks...

If Obama doesn't, he's a hypocrite..... saying one thing publicly and doing the opposite.... not exactly a "new style of politics"
Well McCain does seem to see every foreign affairs problem as a military one and cheerfully suggests the solution is bomb,bomb, bombing.  

And can we all just let people say what they think without asking candidates to issue apologies or denunciations every time some supporter exercises the right to free speech?  

It's getting really tiresome and it's hardly as if any of us wouldn't have to issue apologies on a regular basis if anybody paid attention to what we and all of our friends, family and associates say on a minute by minute basis.  I have one uncle who could make that a full time job for me!
McWar, you are a warmonger. 100 years in Iraq, did you forget already old man.... The Iraqi people dont want our military in there country and McWar does... Fight, fight, fight....Pathetic

Support bringing our troops home and ending the war in Iraq and we will stop calling you McWar the warmonger.

Obama supporters keep up the pressure!!! Good Job
Why is the truth hurting McWAR. Every problem that the US has is because of this war and you want it for 100 more years!!

OBAMA 08.
Just goes to show once again, and again, and again, that Barack is just another politician, his surrogates are no different.

He's a fraud and a liar and the sooner people get their heads out of their asses and see Obama for what he REALLY IS, the better off this country will be.

STOP THE OBAMA LIES
war·mon·ger  (wôrmnggr, -mng-)
n.
One who advocates or attempts to stir up war.

Fits.
Hmmmmm, if it walks like a warmonger and talks like a warmonger . . .
Crickets??!! - I do not think so.  Silence and winter wheat growing may be, but crickets no.

John: It will be hard for you to live down your rendition of Barbara Ann and 100 years.
id say "bomb bomb bomb, bomb bomb iran" is warmongering.
Thanks, Obama campaign, for setting the record straight. That remark really rubbed me the wrong way, and I'm glad the campaign responded quickly.
You know, there's a difference between making a personal attack and being exceptionally candid in stating the truth.
Um. . .big difference between Cunningham and Schultz: Cunningham was attacking Obama's heritage, Schultz was attacking McCain's policy choices.  If McCain doesn't want to be called a warmonger, then he shouldn't advocate starting wars with Iran.
Hey Barack, if you and your sidekicks are gonna call McCain names, maybe there's at least a few names out there in the real world for you.

I would suggest you call your lying pastor to see if you should again up the ante.
Confusion and not real issues..
Why do these candidates always try to evade the issues?
Sticks and stones can break my bones but...you all know the rest...
BOO HOO McShame...
Suck it up McCain and stop being a baby.  I thought this guy was tough.  What a joke.  Somebody tell him he's running for President and not Miss Congeniality.  If Iran's leaders call him names, is he going to cry?
What is the definition of a warmongerer if it is NOT a supporter of the war, particularly an overly long, financially disastrous, and unsuccessful war? What absurdist semantic hairs is the McCain Campiagn trying to split here?

I'm glad to know that McCain doesn't understand economics, foreign policies especially pertaining to Sunni's and Shi'as, or the finer points of the English language.
Wrong response. The term "warmonger" is so stupidly Kos-like that it has no place in serious discourse. Follow McCain's lead, disavow the remark, and it dies a quick death. Let it sit out there with a half-hearted denial of the sentiment, and it stays alive for awhile.
Obama's campaign has no class. McCain is wrong but not a warmonger. Dick Cheney is a warmonger.
This is getting petty. McCain IS a warmonger--who knew that was an offensive description? Thank goodness there is no audio or video of Schultz's remarks. I'm getting tired of the negativity about topics that don't matter.
I see that silly season is in full bloom.
war·mon·ger (wôrmnggr, -mng-)
n.
One who advocates or attempts to stir up war.

http://twocanpete.blogspot.com/
Yeah, that's pretty close.
McCain may not like the term "war monger" but by his own words, ""Overall, it's a remarkable success — overall with significant challenges ahead", he is.  His entire platform is based on continuing Bush's War in Iraq for the next 100 years.  His words.  If Iraq is such a "remarkable success", why is necessary to keep U.S. troops there indefinitely?  If Iraq is such a remarkable success, why does McCain, Bush, and Cheney have to creep into the country under cover of darkness, unannounced, wearing hefty flack jackets, surrounded by helicopters and thugs employed by Blackwater - yet the President of Iran, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, announces his visit 2 days in advance and is welcomed with open arms by the Iraqi's?  What's remarkable is that McCain, like his mentor Bush, is so out of touch with reality and so committed to their never-ending war regardless of the cost in human lives and the billions being drained monthly from the U.S. Treasury.  They should be ashamed and McCain should be soundly defeated in his run for the Presidency.  The country does not need another Bush dressed up in a different suit.  
Ed Schultz is yet another talk show host that has nothing to do with any campaign.  Ed spoke three speakers before Obama even arrived at the building so "Super Surge John" needs to grow a brain.  John McCain wants to keep the war going 100 years so This makes him what Ed called him.  
I think the Obama campaign was a bit quick to apologize!  From dictionary.com:
"One who advocates or attempts to stir up war."

Sounds like John "100 years" "bombbombbomb bombbomb Iran" McCain to me!!!  To a "T"!!!

Obama 2008 -- Yes, WE CAN!!!
I'm not quite sure what would constitute the use of "warmonger" by most people's definition, but McCain's little "Bomb, Bomb, Bomb Iran" ditty qualifies him for that title in my book.
Well let's be honest. McCain is a warmonger. Our government has become a bunch of warmongers.
It was definitely not an Obama even.
HILLARY was there too, and spoke shortly after Obama.
Calling an American hero a "warmonger" is just the kind of pandering decent people should expect from the fringes of the far left -- the "bureaucracy mongers" -- who would say anything to beat the drums of kool-aid crusading.

Hey Schultz, Soros would be proud. Maybe, he'd let you sip from his batch? I'd suggest working your way up to his level of kool-aid before he lets you; man, you know that's got to be some strong, potent stuff!
Ummm.  Earth to people of USA.  John McCain IS a warmonger.  The definition is:

war·mon·ger    /ˈwɔrˌmʌŋgər, -ˌmɒŋ-/ [wawr-muhng-ger, -mong-] –noun
a person who advocates, endorses, or tries to precipitate war.

Perhaps dictionary.com could add a picture of McCain next to their definition.  McCain sings about bombing Iran.  He is a war-provoking neoconservative when it comes to foreign policy.  Obama has no reason to "repudiate" a truth.  John McCain is a warmonger and the American people should know that before he tricks them into putting him in office
McCain is a warmonger if he thinks we ought to keep fighting this stupid war in Iraq with no end in sight. At this point it is fighting for fighting's sake - there is no objective to be won anymore. McCain and those who side with him on this issue are making America less secure every day.
Obama should apologize on behalf of Shultz just like McCain apologize during the Cunningham gaft.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=862795

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google