ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



Obama: 'It's politics' not race

Posted: Tuesday, April 15, 2008 2:40 PM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under: ,

From NBC/NJ’s Aswini Anburajan
WASHINGTON, Pa. -- Don’t read Clinton’s “elitist” attacks as racist Obama cautioned a voter at a town hall meeting with veterans and military families.
 
An older man, taking the mic for the first question, claimed Clinton’s attacks were trying to cast Obama as an “uppity” Black man.
 
“This isn’t political whatsoever, myself being obviously a white person, this term is the way it’s being used against you isn’t far from ‘uppity,’” the man began. “Okay. And I think the Clintons are getting away with something that they must be called on. They will continue to do this until somebody states, ‘Mrs. Clinton you’re really close to prejudice here. This is wrong. This man does not have anything elitist about his upbringing. He never will, and I desire a well-educated person as president of the United States. I am sorry. It’s got to stop.”
 
Obama disagreed and said it was not about race, but chalked it up to politics. “I don’t think there are racial overtones going on to the attacks right now. I think it’s politics. This is what we do politically, when we start getting behind in races, then we start going on the attack.”
 
He went on to say he found it amusing to be called an elitist, since he was raised by a single mother and had been on food stamps as a child. He said his wife Michelle had also grown up in a working-class home -- with two parents who did not go to college and held blue-collar jobs.
 
“We both had to finance our entire college, our law school educations, borrowing money, and we paid off our student loans about five years ago or six years ago,” Obama said. “You know we lived -- for the first 13 years of our marriage, up until three years ago, in a three-bedroom condo without a garage. So if you live in Chicago, it means you’re scraping ice every morning,” he joked.
 
He labeled the back and forth about his comments as a sign that the campaign is in “political silly season.”
 
“Hopefully it will come to an end fairly soon,” he said, “and we’ll start focusing on the issues that the people of Pennsylvania and the American people really care about.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Hard to imagine the reverse situation, where Hillary has an opportunity to put a ridiculous notion to bed and seizes it. Instead, she'd play it to the hilt.
Amen, Senator Obama! Enough of the silly season. It's time to rally around our nominee and fight John McCain!
As a Hillary supporter I must say I am getting a little tired of this story line. Hillary is the candidate for PA -- her story is their story -- so let's move back to the issues, where we can wallop Obama.
It's clear that almost everybody sees through Clinton's baseless attacks.


ya but Obamb's supporters will play it as racists - they always do --Obama is uppity

If not Hillary then I am for McCain
Obama is such a classy guy! Hope to have the opportunity to pull the lever for him in November 2008!
“Hopefully it [the silly season] will come to an end fairly soon,” he said, “and we’ll start focusing on the issues that the people of Pennsylvania and the American people really care about.”

Senator, from you mouth to God's ear.  I'm getting really tired of all the politics of division.  

And I agree with the 'older gentleman', I want a well educated person as our next president, one who actually spent time learning while they were in school, and not just being a frat boy cheer leader.

Vote with your head, vote for the economy, vote for jobs.

Vote Democratic 2008 -- don't let the corporations and their Republican stooges win again.
I watched the event live. I so like the tone Obama strikes. What a breath of fresh air in politics.
Obama '08 Yes We Can!!
Unless we walk in anothers shoes, none have any excuse for calling another "Elitist"
Owl
He is a class act, across the board.  

As Jon Stewart said last night, shouldn't we have a president who is smarter and better than we are.
Good response Obama. She is condescending voters into believing she is an average Jane. In reality, she was born to privelage and is worth $110 million. Meanwhile, you were raised in a single family household with the assitance of your grandparents, just finished paying back your student loans and worht almost $1 million. She wants the voters to believe she is not an elitist. Please. Her comments are nonsensical.
i don't think it makes much sense to try and figure out what is going on with HRC.  Hillary Clinton is comical at this point; cartoonish even.  I am sure every one can see her lines coming a mile away.  It's old.
I agree with the guy in the audience. This whole suggestion that he is elitist and put his chin in the air when he speaks just screams "uppity". Barack will never say it because he has to much class and won't allow Hillary to drag him into accusations about race knowing that Clintonfans will then cry that she is being attacked.
This is not the first time criticism of Obama has been labeled "racist".  It's going to be fun trying to criticize him as president.
Rule #45 - Never refer to Obama's race, his racist pastor, his terrorist associations, or his criminal associations. In general, if you don't have anything good to say about Barack, don't say anything at all.
Obama, you are proving the demeanor and mind of a true leader. I first was drawn to Obama because to see a man of color as President of the USA would be a dream come true. But i beleive Clinton was reight about one thing, that the contest must continue to make sure that the candidates are tested. You sir have passed all of the test and the longer the priamries continue you wil continue to show the country who is ready on day 1. I can not think of any other person who we as citizens of this great nation wants to receive that 3 AM phone call. We do not want a candidate that confusses Iran and Iraq and definetly not a person looking for a fight...

Obama '08 and '12 I look forward to visiting your Presidential Liabrary.
Hillary-backer Bob Johnson apparently doesnt agree... he's come back out in the forefront to support Geraldine Ferrarro's comments. He said that people dismissed what she said because it came from a white woman, but he hopes that because it's now coming from a black man, it'll be seen for its truth.

I cant wait until we can get back to the issues, rather than debate this nonsense. We need to come together as a country, and rise above it all.
When Obama attacks Hillary, it's ok, but when she attacks Obama, then its wrong.  Obamabots, explain this to me?
Hmmm, how would hillary have answered a similair comment replacing sex sexism with racism. I think it would go something like this, as far as I know it isn't sexist, you would have to ask the Obama campaign if they mean anything sexist, I have to take them at their word.  Make sure to leave a little doubt there.
Right on Senator!!! You know this guy is not perfect, but he rises above the fray. If he is elected, he will be looked at by the world with strength, class, and confidence. My heart will beat a little stronger with pride. This is the leader who reprsents my country, compared to ol George W!
What a man of honor!  Thank you Senator Obama for not stooping to the level of "the politics of old".  Keep up the message of hope for all of us who are struggling to keep afloat.
Rumor is that John McCain is holding out to announce his VP so that Hillary could be asked.

McCain/Clinton 08
It's not racism, its vindictive desperation from someone who is incapable of seeing the forest for the trees.

Pennsylvania, please do the rest of the country a favor, and shut Senator Clinton up.

Vote Obama next week!!!!
I heard a veteran gave Obama a flag pin today. Is it true that Obama is wearing the flag pin?

I am sure the patriotic police will be out in full force to condemn him
Clinton is treading on dangerous ground!
Leave it to him to take the high road, yet again. He is always telling us the truth about ourselves; some of which is hard to take, but we need to hear it nevertheless.  Until we can admit that there ARE  problems, how can we solve them? This is the fundamental difference between him and Clinton....he tells us the truth, even when it hurts and she panders to us without any conscience as to the consequences.        
I just Love this man!  He's our next President no doubt!
I agree with the gentleman at the town hall.  I certainly heard "uppity" when Hillary and McCain were saying "elitist."  It's ridiculous that Obama, who grew up poor and pulled himself up by his bootstraps to make a life could be "elite."  His statements above are proof of his decency and that he is way more charitable than I am.
Excellent response.  Now this shows the class Obama has that Hillary lacks. He could have gone negative with it.
Clinton is treading on dangerous ground!
That is a great contrast to the "Clinton Life", which in itself could be a reality show...  

I laugh when I think about him out there scraping the windows.  To think they call him elite when their combined income for their lifetime is probably (don't know exact numbers) less than the 15 MILLION Clinton's averaged yearly over the last 7.  I can only hope this will end soon.

I am glad and understand why Obama claimed Clinton's attacks were political and not filled with racial undertones.  But let's face the truth, she really was insinuating to voters, especially working class white voters, that Obama was behaving as an uppity Black man.  

Obama knows that in his heart which is probably one of the reasons he struck back so hard against Hill - I really think this attack by her pissed him off.
Note how easily he could have agreed and cried a "RACE" but didn't.

Classy, not elitist.
I agree with the gentleman at the town hall.  I certainly heard "uppity" when Hillary and McCain were saying "elitist."  It is ridiculous that Obama, who grew up poor and pulled himself by his bootstraps could be considered an "elite."  His statement above is proof of his decency and that he is way more charitable than I am.
Clinton thought it was perfectly okay to say that the "Average American goes around looking for someone to blame" when things are going from bad to worse.  While Obama said people tend to cling to the issues they know (guns and religion; which is mainly voting for/against abortion issues), Clinton says Average Americans look to blame other people.

"There are signs of festering intolerance even among Democratic audiences, noticeably in Iowa, which has seen a surge of Latino immigration in recent years. The Democratic candidates are uniformly in favor of comprehensive immigration reform, including a path to citizenship for those who have entered the country illegally. But they receive sharp — pointed — applause when they say illegals should "have to speak English" before becoming citizens. When I asked Hillary Clinton about that, she said she'd noticed it too and added, "During the 1990s, I cannot remember being asked about immigration... Why? Because the economy was working... And average Americans didn't have to go around looking for someone to blame."

http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,1688794,00.html

Here's the explanation - its wrong to attack Obama if you are Hillary...but its ok to attack Hillary if you are Obama because Obama is....
Another sign of class that this man has. He could have used the comments of this man to stomp on Hillary but instead he took the High road way to go Obama.We smell the stench of the dirty politics that you are trying to be baited into. Keep it up and you will show the Clintons what class and integrity are and that no matter how much money you make it doesn't make you a better person like the Clintons seem to believe.
Well, there is an important part of the population -- not necessarily the "elite" -- that thinks Obama was exactly right in what he said the other day.  Hillary Clinton got in trouble for making stuff up to make herself look like she's ready for the white house.  But Barack Obama's insight (even if the wording offended some people) is nothing to be ashamed of.  It's true!  

My extended family is from, and still lives in Western PA.  And a lot of them feel frustrated to the point where they have almost NO expectations from government.  People can be cynical and skeptical and, well, in some cases bitter.  The challenge the Obama campaign faces is to get voters to step out of that mindset.  It's a tough thing to get over the inner fear that you will be disappointed AGAIN by elected officials.  I tell you, I'm working on it myself.

I commend Obama for not letting someone label this flap as racial.  The fact is, Hillary Clinton has just discovered something that will distract people from her own dishonest candidacy.  So, she's milking it for all it's worth.  

Let's get back to talking about issues.  Let's hear how these people are going to solve real problems for real Americans.

I'll be watching the next debate with interest.
Isn't it time we had an adult in the White House? Is Obama perfect, not by a long shot. I don't agree with everything he proposes and he has made mistakes in his campaign. In short, he is a human being. I agree with him the most of all the remaining candidates. I think he would bring a maturity in action as well as a tone of professionalism that has been missing from the executive branch most of my adult life. I do believe that his agenda reflects a genuine concern for the American people and American values. his reponse here is nothing but class. The easy road would have been to just let it hang out there, not agreeing or disagreeing and allowing the race issue to be the news. "PA finds Hillary racist" great headline. Instead he calls it exactly what it is. He had the chance to play politics and he played integrity instead. This is the what we need. We are in a hole and we don't need a fighter and we don't need someone who thinks we can get out by digging deeper. We need someone who will look at the problem, find the solution and then executing that solution.
Obama knew what he was saying. It was Not a poor choice of words, it was a Poor choice of strategy. He was probably trying to use is as a rallying cry to vote for him and for the Pa voters to show their frustration with the government, but it backfired and was an insult to the PA voters in small towns and in small towns all across America. One cannot assume that people are bitter and cling to guns and religon as he stated. It ony shows his inexperience in dealing with the American public. Imagine how foreign leaders would feel is whatever he says he later states that it was a poor choice of words. This is a dangerous world we live in and cannot afford for someone to give poor choice of words or press wrong buttons. Furthermore, I don't see why he was criticizing Hillary for taking a shot and then a beer when he was videoed drinking a beer himself, bowling (a low score at that), being asked what his favorite movie was, and what actor should portray him. Who is using the media now? I'm surprised they didn't ask him what his favorite color was? Maybe they did and I missed that part? Our country cannot have further misinterpretations ike that, First, from his his wife Michelle, then his pastor and mentor the Rev. Wright, and now Him. Hillary is the Best choice to turn the economy around. Vote for Hillary!!!
Which of the three candidates is most out of touch with rural working class Americans?  
I am a rural working class American. I worked a blue collar job for 24 years.   The pay was not great but we had benefits.  Then people started being pushed out of their jobs, so the employees could hire non-benefited workers.  I was one of them.  Since then my husband and I have managed to get by on his construction work.  We're not church goers or hunters, though we own guns and believe in the right of the second ammendment.  John, Hillary and Barack would possibly look down their noses at me.  That's ok.  We come from different worlds.  We're not going to be having dinner with any of them.  
What I want to know is, in spite of our different worlds,  which one wants to put a stop to the unbridled corporate greed,  the shrinking middle class and innocent people being slaughtered in ill-conceived occupations of other countries.  McCain will continue the course we are on.  Clinton will change little as her main agenda is to achieve personal power.  To me,  Barrack Obama is head and shoulders above the other two.  If he will really try to turn our country in a better direction, then he can look down his nose at me all he wants.
 An older white woman for Obama no matter what.
I agree with the gentleman at the town hall.  When I heard Hillary and McCain say "elitist" I thought "uppity."  It's ridiculouse that Obama, who grew up poor and pulled himself by his bootstraps could be considered an "elite."  His statement above is proof of his decency and that he is way more charitable than I am.
Many individuals seem to forget that elitism does not necessarily equate to wealth.  Mr. Obama in many ways has lead a privileged life that many Black Americans and many middle Americans have not had.  He has experienced living in other cultures, traveled and has had a priviledged education from one of the primer universities in the world. His family left Kansas when his mother was in the 6th grade, never to return, so much for Kansas roots.  Like some women, apparently, his mother made some very poor choices in regard to men in her life, deserted, remarried and divorced. The fact that she was a single mother bring up a child was her choice, this is what she selected for her son.  I think the shoe fits, Mr. Obama and definitely his wife appear snobs to a certain extent.    
I agree with Obama - it's not racism, it's do-everything-you-can-to-win politics.  And labeling Obama an elitist is never going to work for anyone who looks into the facts.

What the Republican politician said the other night (calling Obama 'boy'), that's racism.
This is why he's winning.  He's a class act.  He never came out and attacked her for Bosnia lies.  He doesn't stoop to that kind of politics.  
Pat as i stated in an earlier post, America is sending Hillary back to New York for ya.America has No further use for her, maybe New Yorker's still may, but i Doubt it.

Again Barack shows Presedential Statesmanship!This time in front of Veteran's, who obviously see thru Hillary & the Illiterates.So many times he could have Knocked her out flat on the Mat, but chose time & again to be the kind of Preseident, America can be Proud of.

Refreshing Indeed!
Obama is a class act, and is far too "real" for Hillary to follow.

It's nice to know that at least one of the democratic candidates has some class.  Senator Clinton would have pounced all over that type of question, and probably would have turned it into another negative attack ad.
I interpretted some of the GOP's attacks on Obama being 'uppity' yesterday. Oh he's just an 'out of touch black man looking down on whites'..etc etc. That is what is between the lines and I think it's real, but like some said Obama doesn't want to get stuck in that trap. But it's a dangerous theme to flirt with, especially when Obama's history shows the exact opposite. Nobody should question his education or any candidates but we all know the conservative anti-education playbook.
If you attack Obama, well you are a racist.  That's what the media labels you.  The media wants obama to win..so they force you to shut up by calling you a racist.  This has been going on for months.  Nothing new here.  


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=893729

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

More First Read

Recent Posts:


Archives:


Topics:

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google