ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Obama: 'It's politics' not race

Posted: Tuesday, April 15, 2008 2:40 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ’s Aswini Anburajan
WASHINGTON, Pa. -- Don’t read Clinton’s “elitist” attacks as racist Obama cautioned a voter at a town hall meeting with veterans and military families.
 
An older man, taking the mic for the first question, claimed Clinton’s attacks were trying to cast Obama as an “uppity” Black man.
 
“This isn’t political whatsoever, myself being obviously a white person, this term is the way it’s being used against you isn’t far from ‘uppity,’” the man began. “Okay. And I think the Clintons are getting away with something that they must be called on. They will continue to do this until somebody states, ‘Mrs. Clinton you’re really close to prejudice here. This is wrong. This man does not have anything elitist about his upbringing. He never will, and I desire a well-educated person as president of the United States. I am sorry. It’s got to stop.”
 
Obama disagreed and said it was not about race, but chalked it up to politics. “I don’t think there are racial overtones going on to the attacks right now. I think it’s politics. This is what we do politically, when we start getting behind in races, then we start going on the attack.”
 
He went on to say he found it amusing to be called an elitist, since he was raised by a single mother and had been on food stamps as a child. He said his wife Michelle had also grown up in a working-class home -- with two parents who did not go to college and held blue-collar jobs.
 
“We both had to finance our entire college, our law school educations, borrowing money, and we paid off our student loans about five years ago or six years ago,” Obama said. “You know we lived -- for the first 13 years of our marriage, up until three years ago, in a three-bedroom condo without a garage. So if you live in Chicago, it means you’re scraping ice every morning,” he joked.
 
He labeled the back and forth about his comments as a sign that the campaign is in “political silly season.”
 
“Hopefully it will come to an end fairly soon,” he said, “and we’ll start focusing on the issues that the people of Pennsylvania and the American people really care about.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Vote Obama next week!!!!

AverageJoe4Obama, Bethesda, MD (Sent Tuesday, April 15, 2008 2:58 PM)

_________________________________________

NO.
Actually, that was the first thing I thought of when I saw Senator Clinton in front of the cameras with all her feigned outrage.  How DOES she explain 'uppity'?
The difference in style and substance ... I mean even Hillary supporters must see this. This man is presidential.
He did not take the bait. He could have "gone there" but he chose not to ... wisely.
Teflon Obama!
Can anyone tell me if Hillary can come up with the same answer?
She would have said " AS FAR AS I KNOW...OR YOU HAVE TO ASK THEM ?"

I should stop .. just thinking of how she's run her campaign sickens me.
I really used to like her .

I ACTUALLY THINK THAT SHE WOULD MAKE THE BEST COMMANDER IN CHIEF !

But I think that Obama would make an excellent choice too.
But ALSO OBAMA WOULD UNITE THE COUNTRY !

The dillema has been solved .. He's got more delegates, more states won and more people have voted for him !

The politics of the Clintons just flabbergast me every day !
Pat Huntington,

why should anyone waste breath (or keystrokes) to try to explain something so clear to someone so thick and ignorant as yourself??  I for one won't even try.  If you can't see how things are w/o others having to explain it to you then please just move to Canada or something.  we don't need you.  and we certainly don't WANT you.
Pennsylvanians:  Save us from Billary, please!  These people would cut their own mothers off at the knees to further their own gain.

Nice response, Barack -- honest, calm, measured, fair.  Among the very qualities we need in a President.
Pat, Huntington

I swear you must be Pat Buchanan.  Regardless if Barack Obama showed character or not you want to bash the guy and say that he is completely unelectable.  I hope America knows that the electoral map is going to change this election year.  So many of yall are stuck in the same ole typical America.  I'm an Indiana Republican and I already know my vote is going Democrat.  I am not as naive to think that my Red state will do the same but I just want to forewarn yall that things are changing.  But please PA do us a favor and vote Obama, because I don't want to have to vote Hillary but I know I can't vote McLame.
When Obama attacks Hillary, it's ok, but when she attacks Obama, then its wrong.  Obamabots, explain this to me?

Pat huntington NY (Sent Tuesday, April 15, 2008 2:57 PM)

______________________________________

PAT, you are silly. How dare you ask a reasonable question. I don't know who is more brainwashed the people from the LDS or the Obamabots,
Pat, Huntington, NY - why don't you try referring to us as something other than "Obamabots" and perhaps we'd be inclined to respond.  As is, no thanks.

This is exactly what is playing out in PA - people a) recognize the code word "elitist" for the empty political point-scorer that it is, b) find it elitist for people to tell us how offended we should be when we aren't, and c) know a real elitist when we see one.  Not only does this attack link Clinton directly to a standard, useless GOP talking point, it gives Obama a totally fair opening to reveal the more rags-to-riches portion of his own life story and also to contrast it directly with Clinton's own experience and current status as a true elite.  Har har har har, I can't wait until the debate tomorrow.  How much could Clinton possibly know about PA to think this would work?  Underestimating Obama's political ability has been the single most detrimental element of her entire campaign, and it may finally do her in this time.  You should see the Obama energy on the ground here.  Go PA!
“Hopefully it will come to an end fairly soon,” he said, “and we’ll start focusing on the issues that the people of Pennsylvania and the American people really care about.”
**************************************************

Indeed.  However, with the play that this 'story' has been getting in the media - I seriously doubt that it's going anywhere anytime soon.

Where is Bill Clinton with his gaffe-machine when you need him?

http://thepajamapundit.com/
Every political season has someone for change (anyone remember W's rhetoric 8 years ago?) and a "Teflon man". It will be interesting what the press will do when they have to choose between the original "Teflon John", who actually allows the press on the back of the bus, and Obama.

More interestingly will be what everyone is saying about Obama a year after he gets into office when he proves himself to be just another politician..
When Obama attacks Hillary, it's ok, but when she attacks Obama, then its wrong.  Obamabots, explain this to me?
Pat huntington NY (Sent Tuesday, April 15, 2008 2:57 PM)
````````````````````````````````````````````````````````

Pat, please tell us when Senator Obama has attacked Hillary?

I want a specific instance and I want to know exactly what he said?

I think you are talking out of your arse, as I have yet to see Obama "attack" Hillary?

We are all waiting for your answer Pat.

CHUCK, I am a rural voter, and you know what? I am bitter, and I am sick of all of the wedge issues (Gays, Abortion, Guns). I am bitter that politicians have been using issues like these to garner support while they ship our jobs overseas, and give tax cuts to the wealthy. I don't need 600 dollars, I need for my government to worry about the economy and international relations, not banning abortion or homosexuality. I need my government to be fiscally responsible by not fighting wars of choice and lowering taxes, bankrupting our economy and signing my children and their children into indentured servitude. Stop talking about this non-story, or you will lose a viewer of MSNBC and NBC forever. There are issues that are actually important, talk about them instead of playing gotcha, with a comment that while poorly phrased was ultimately true. Talk about how this is a misstatement, and Clinton's remark about Tusla, and her comment that she wanted to join the Marines in the 70's were LIES. How about fair play?
So the lady worth 109 million is accusing the guy worth 5 million that he is an elitis !?!

While the guy worth 32k a year actually agrees with what was said......

... After i get laid off and the republicans give a tax break to the CEO that just took my job. The republicans coem to me with Gay marrage and gun control as the reason i should vote for them...

i am so confused, if you try to lead this country and show people another way to think then your an elitist, but if you pander ENDLESSLY.. then your an honest politician..

Good for that questioner for getting some of it.

  Good to stay on the high road. A McCain/Obama race
will be civil. (So far John McCain's taken the
classiest way to be tough and make points.)

Will be so glad to get out of this Clinton gutterball politics.
 
 

 
http://twocanpete.blogspot.com/
If Obama's remarks weren't racist why didn't he mention the millions of inner city blacks who are unemployed and happen to own guns or go to church or want an end to illegal immigration? I guess being bitter is just a 'white thing', but don't tell that to Obama's pastor.
Racism by who?  Read Bob Herbert's op-ed in todays NYT.  

It was a comment by BO that had racial overtones that started all this - "they cling to guns or religion or antipathy to people who aren't like them.".  He never criticized the same type of voters in Mississippi or Louisiana or South Carolina when they voted for him or do they not cling to religion and guns, or maybe their economic situation is much better than in Ohio and Pennsylvania?  The question is why did they vote for him but after millions of dollars in advertising, the same type of voters seem unmoved.  We know what BO thinks is the reason (and it's confirmed by the statements of his wife and his spiritual adviser).
This man, Barack Obama, is healing; he is kind; he is classy; and he is a gentleman.  To know this, one needs to look no further than his reply to this elderly supporter.  It is no wonder he inspires hope.  He appeals to the best in us.  We have needed such a leader for a very long time.  
The sad fact is, there are a few racists left in America.  But thankfully, most of us are moving beyond that old painful mindset.  It really has no honest place in this election.  Our issues of Iraq and a failing economy need to be front and center, without all this foolishness.  As for attacks on Obama, both side have had their venomous supporters.  I don't blame either candidate for what a few loose cannons on the internet boards and blogs tend to spew.  The candidates have no control over that.  Candidates are responsible for their positions, not for every person with a computer and loose fingers typing nastiness.  Supporters of both sides are pointing the finger at each other, and both need to look in the mirror.  All the white noise going on here is not going to change this outcome, no matter how many ALL CAPS, exclamation marks, or snide remarks some bloggers churn out.  
This is not the first time criticism of Obama has been labeled "racist".  It's going to be fun trying to criticize him as president.
John Doe, Seattle, Wash.
**********************************

Did you even read the article? Obama wasn't being called racist, dummy, Clinton was. YEEESH!



*********************************************

ya but Obamb's supporters will play it as racists - they always do --Obama is uppity


WOW. I think you forgot  Yee_Haw!! I wish 1st read or one of the pundits would point out the trend of the Clinton's. Ferroro, Bill's South Carolina remarks and this. It's the definition of class to ignore it and chalk it up to politics. Hillary DEFINITELY would not have done the same.


Sen. Obama:  you've badly damaged your chances of winning in Nov....please step aside for the good of the party
obama reminds me of gw. He is arrogant too. GW never admits when he makes a mistake or that he has done anything wrong. If he had, maybe the country wouldn't be in the shape it is in now; i.e., he would have taken opportunities to correct some of his mistakes. No. He just keep making mistakes and never owns up to them. I blame some of obama's arrogances on his supporters, just like obama they makes excuses for his ill remards and behaviors, thereby enabling him to not be responsible for his actions or behaviors. Somebody  had better tame that monster now!!!. Another elitist president in the white house would be disasterous. Remember the New Orleans debacle.  
Sally Mae Quinn (Sent Tuesday, April 15, 2008 2:56 PM)

That's what my 5 sets of foster parents taught me.  That's why I have nothing to say about Hill and Bill.
Obama is right. Anybody notice he did not invoke the congressman from Kentucy who called him 'boy' either?

That's why we love this guy.

Pulling for Obama '08
Jon Stewart had a great bit on The DAILY SHOW last night.  He asked, doesn't 'elite' mean good? And if (you're running for Pres.) you aren't, then what the
f are you doing???  
 The questioner gets it. We need a smart president who has struggled financially and also gets it.
We're talking about electing the PRESIDENT here, people.  Leader of the free world.

He SHOULD be "better than me" in nearly every way!  Shouldn't that be a GOOD thing?!?
When Obama first used the term "silly season" it wasn't a term I particularly liked.  Suffice it to say, it has really grown on me, it very aptly describes what we do to each other, what our candidates do to us during heavy campaigning.

Both Obama and the older gentleman are right...it is silly season, it is politics as usual (particularly when one is so behind that they are grasping at straws) and there have been (I believe) racial overtones throughout this campaign leveled in somewhat surprising (and usually covert) ways.  We don't know if that is really what is going on from Team Clinton expressly, but when you have everyone talking about how Obama can't get the "white" working class vote, they're is quite possibly something racial going on.  And with some of the quotes I've read about how people will or won't vote for a black person, its pretty out-of-touch to suggest that there isn't some prejudice going on.

But its hard to put a finger on it.
elite: the choice or best of anything considered collectively, as a group or class of persons: the elite of the intellectual community.
elitism: practice of or belief in rule by an elite. pride in belonging to a select and favored group.
Obama is telling the "uneducated" voters that since he is intellectually so superior we are not to question his mistakes, just blindly follow and support. It has nothing to do with money. His sense of intellectual and moral superiority make him an elitest.
Isn't it sad that sometimes you are forced to apologize for your education?

We've had nearly 8 years of an ignorant SLOB, so I'm ready to move forward with an intelligent SNOB.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=893729

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google