ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



McCain: Speech gets a mixed reaction

Posted: Wednesday, April 16, 2008 9:14 AM by Domenico Montanaro

The New York Times on McCain's economic speech yesterday: "The speech, delivered on the deadline for filing taxes, afforded the clearest view to date of what McCainomics might look like. There was a dash of populism, as Mr. McCain criticized executive pay and corporate wrongdoing.  There was a strong supply-side bent, with Mr. McCain focusing on cutting corporate taxes and making permanent the Bush tax cuts that he once opposed. And there was a decidedly less hawkish note on deficits, as Mr. McCain called for spending cuts but did not mention balancing the federal budget."

The LA Times: "Though the package of ideas drew support from some economists for its pledge to cut taxes and simplify the tax system, many analysts called the proposed holiday in the 18-cents-a-gallon gas tax a gimmick. Others questioned whether McCain's plans would bloat the federal budget deficit."

“McCain's staff is drafting a bill to suspend the gasoline tax and the 24.4-cent tax on diesel fuel between Memorial Day and Labor Day,” the Boston Globe writes, adding, “But the bill would probably be dead on arrival. Similar proposals in recent years have all failed in Congress, and the proposal was immediately greeted with skepticism by some tax analysts. Leonard Burman, director of the Brookings-Urban Tax Policy Center, said it would have little effect and ‘as a matter of fiscal stimulus, it makes no sense at all. ... In the campaign season, there is an irresistible pressure on candidates to promise giveaways.’” 
 
Let the McCain-Bob Dole comparisons continue. MSNBC.com's Tom Curry writes, "If it seems like there is something familiar about the gasoline tax 'holiday' being proposed by Sen. John McCain, there is. You may have heard the Republican presidential nominee propose something similar before -- 12 years ago when the GOP nominee’s name was Dole, not McCain."

“Often accused of hawkish policies, McCain told MSNBC's ‘Hardball’ it would be difficult to convince the American people to go to war against Iran. ‘I believe we can act with nations with values and principles that we hold dear and exercise enormous pressure -- diplomatic, trade, financial,’ he said. If he decided he had to attack, McCain said he would have to make an ‘even more convincing argument that it was necessary to do so because of our failure to find weapons of mass destruction’ in Iraq.” 
 
“Cindy McCain is eating humble pie after being caught lifting recipes from the Food Network and posting them as her own on her husband's campaign Web site,” the New York Post writes. “The ingredients of at least three McCain ‘family’ recipes -- ‘ahi tuna salad,’ ‘passion fruit mousse’ and ‘farfalle pasta with turkey, sausage, peas and mushrooms’ -- were plagiarized, word for word, from Food Network chefs listed on the culinary company's Web site.” The Huffington Post broke the story. 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

McCain then turned to Cindy and said, "ooops, I made doodoo in my diaper. Please change me!"
You mean to tell me that as long-lived as McCain's family is, that Cindy could not find at least one original recipe.
McCain has admitted on several different occassions that he does not understand economics. McCain's so-called economic plan amounts to continuing Bush's failed economic policies of the past eight years. We need a President who has a good understanding of the economy, can present plans to reduce the deficit, reduce America's debt to foreign nations like China, and get America back to economic independence and prosperity. This person is NOT John McCain!!!!!
McCain is drooling to drag American into another endless war with Iran! I cannot believe that any American, conservative or otherwise, can be fooled by this mess. Simply put: AMERICA CANNOT AFFORD ANOTHER ENDLESS WAR!!! Iraq is a mess and has cost this country dearly in lost American lives, lost dollars, and lost clout with the International Community. Admittedly, Iran's President and leaders are not saints by any stretch of the imagination, but unless Iran poses a clear and immediate threat to America's well-being, then any talk of war should be out of the question. Fix Iraq first and fix our domestic issues also, then we can worry about Iran.
REP's got Milk

NOPE just Poop...
Perhaps Cindy has not had the time to cook and needed something right away to prove that she knows how to cook.
Seems like recipegate is something the republicans continue to repeat, didn't Nancy Raygun have a recipe problem?
A favorite family crabmeat recipe looked too elitist and they changed it to macaroni and cheese to look more everyday.
Being out of touch with average americans seems to be a problem the republicans continue to have.
The economy is souring for everyone and tax cuts for the rich are again their only solution, no more trickle down, more solutions for working class and lets just stop giving recipes to show you are just another average american.
I don't care what they like to eat, I want to know what kind of underwear the candidate wears and does he shower everyday, does Cindy clean the house on her own, what cleaning products does she use?
And the most important issue, what reality shows do the McCains watch?
Vote Democrat and Give the McCains more time to play house together.
Pat, Huntington NY

Please, stop being so filthy. Your level of disrespect has no bounds.
Lies, more lies, and damn lies!
I see that descrimination against older Americans is allowed here.  What about descrimination against women?  Or African-Americans?  I seriously doubt that that would be allowed.  Old people jokes are tolerated here because the Republican candidate is the target.  If the Democrat candidate were the target the comments would not be posted, even if it were "old people" jokes.  It's easy to make an ass out of yourself in a forum that is friendly to your side, isn't it Pat?
more of the same from john and cindy mcshame...john john wants tax cuts he once accurately described as a payoff to the rich and cindy is caught stealing recipes from the food network...is there no end to the mcshame on the right?
What are the qualifications for the comment approval job? You guys are encouraging mean tasteless rhetoric.
Pat said "McCain then turned to Cindy and said, "ooops, I made doodoo in my diaper. Please change me!"

Grow up! you are not even fit to tie that mans shoes and what he has given up for this country.  What have you done?  I would guess watch South Park and work at the quicky mart.
McCain didn't say how he's going to pay for his hundred-year occupation of Iraq and the new wars he wants to start. Someone should ask him if he's going to continue relying on foreign countries like Communist China to finance his wars, and what he's going to do when the foreign governments want to collect on what's owed them. It seems that the corporate media is too busy bashing Obama to worry about minor little financial quibbles like that.
“Cindy McCain is eating humble pie after being caught lifting recipes from the Food Network and posting them as her own on her husband's campaign Web site,” the New York Post writes. “The ingredients of at least three McCain ‘family’ recipes -- ‘ahi tuna salad,’ ‘passion fruit mousse’ and ‘farfalle pasta with turkey, sausage, peas and mushrooms’ -- were plagiarized, word for word, from Food Network chefs listed on the culinary company's Web site.”

-----------------------------------------------

It is to laugh!

Between Senator Clinton doing the whiskey (Canadian) and beer chaser and making an absolute caricature of herself in the process and now Cindy McCain's "traditional" family recipes (passed from generation to generation...er...IP address to IP address) it's hysterical the way these women are completely stumbling over themselves trying to look like ordinary people.

It's like you can hear Senator Clinton going, "Whiskey, eh?  Oh, Crown Royal, I've heard of that!  I'll have some of that!"

As for Cindy McCain, how much cooking do you think "Barbie" the heiress to a Hensley & Company actually does?
Does anyone really believe John McKeaton really cares about executive pay and corporate wrong doing?  What do you think we are schmucks?
I'm staying out of this one. McCain seems a charitable and respectable individual and he did lay off the personal stuff agains Hill and Barack on hardball so I think he should be addressed on issues and issues alone. Yes Cindy's gaffe is a personal thing but she never was promoted as an intelletual asset so it is not important to my decision.

The gas tax thing is obviously dead words as they are spoken (considering the effect is about $2 on my full $40 tank and it takes away money used for road construction and so will represent job cuts unless the money is drawn from somewhere else). I'd rather keep my job and my house, have a better energy policy where we do not spend in Iraq while they keep their oil revenues, stop fighting wars whose motives have been debunked etc. and I will gain more than I would with this symbolic gas tax cut.

But McCain is still a class act and it seems fun how he matches Barrack gesture for gesture in the gentlemanly campaign area (Barrack shot down questions yesterday querying whether Hill was being racist in the elite remark and he flatly would have non of it instead calling it just politics). Yes McCain is still things the old way, continuation of the past 8 years with soome trivial changes and is wrong for the country. He should be honored but not with the presidency where things will continue same as before.

- from someone that votes Repub on issues related to war and crime and moral issues. this time the economy is the key and we need to direct hings differently.
The state of Indiana suspended the sales tax on gas a couple years ago for the summer months - didn't really have an impact.  For information purposes, Indiana has a the a 18 cent per gallon state gas tax in addition to the sales tax charge and the federal tax - woohoo!

And our April surprise - an additional increase in the sales tax to 7%.

I just want to know who's pocket all the various tax money goes into, because I sure do not see much in the way of results.  Pot holes in roads, bridge collapses, poor graduation (50 - 60%), plant closures, increasing state and federal debt, home foreclosures on primary residence - but second homes can be renegotiated in bankruptcy court (I guess you need to own two).  I guess this makes me a bitter person, because it galls me.  Check the definition of galls, it fits.
McCain will own Obama come November
To First Read:

Do you not monitor this site?  There is no excuse to post comments like the one that Pat Huntington NY made this morning.

I do not support McCain in the general Election, but really must we revert to insults that say more about the person that posted than it does about McCain?



SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=901460

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google