ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Clinton: Chelsea's negative press

Posted: Friday, April 18, 2008 9:14 AM by Mark Murray

The Los Angeles Times does a tough piece on Chelsea. "For the first time, she is facing the kind of scrutiny that has bedeviled the candidates and their surrogates along the campaign trail. During a long day of campaigning in Oregon on Saturday, she mentioned at two different stops that during the course of the campaign a 7-year-old and an 11-year-old had separately asked her ‘with terror in their eyes’ what will become of the Social Security system. It's possible they were precocious, or that their parents put them up to it, but one skeptical blogger wrote afterward that the story was ‘stunning in its absurdity.’ (When asked for details, such as where and when Clinton met the children, the campaign could not provide them.)"

The University of Pennsylvania's student newspaper endorsed Clinton. "But while Obama's charisma far outshines that of Sen. Hillary Clinton, her public service, political experience and tenacity tell us not only 'Yes we can' but also 'How we can.'"

Clinton poked fun at her own readiness-to-solve-problems mantra, during a taping of Comedy Central's The Colbert Report last night, NBC/NJ’s Athena Jones reports. John Edwards was also on the show, and he and Clinton chatted backstage before she taped a minute-and-a-half bit with comedian Stephen Colbert. Details regarding what she and her former rival spoke about and how long they talked were not forthcoming.

The bit began with Colbert introducing a segment on Wednesday night's debate. The giant screen behind him shows color bars instead of a picture of what is supposed to be the city's Liberty Bell. Colbert asked his technician -- a disembodied voice whose owner we never see but whom he calls Jimmy -- to fix the picture. Jimmy says he can't because all the technicians are back in New York.
Colbert: Are you telling me there's no one in this theater who can fix the mess we're in?
Clinton: I can. I can, Stephen. (The crowd continues to whistles, yelps and cheers.) Well, let me handle this. Jimmy?
Disembodied voice known as Jimmy: "Yes, Sen. Clinton?"
Clinton: About the screen. Are you using a digital or analog production truck?
Disembodied voice known as Jimmy: It's digital.
Clinton: Well, you've got a signal so the lamp is good. How are you feeding this? Through the router or the aux buss on the switcher?
Disembodied voice known as Jimmy: It's an aux.
Clinton: Well, try toggling the input.
Clinton: You know what, Stephen? Your forehead is a little shiny. Makeup, makeup can we get some translucent powder please?
Colbert: Wow, Sen. Clinton, you're so prepared for any situation.
Colbert: I just don't know how to thank you enough.
Clinton: That's ok, Stephen. I just love solving problems. Call me anytime.
Colbert: Really?
Clinton: Sure. Call me at 3 am.

The segment came off as fairly rehearsed, Jones notes, but the crowd ate it up.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

*GASP*

How *DARE* they question Chelsea!
The only people calling Hillary Nixon, er, I mean Clinton, at 3AM are bill collectors.  C'mon, Senator Nixon, I mean Clinton, how about paying your campaign bills.  You made 109 million dollars over a ten year period.  Pay up deadbeat!

Are we so desperate for a female president, that we are willing to scrape the bottom of the barrel?  Nancy Pelosi, Kay Bailey Hutchison, and Jennifer Granholm would all be better choices for our first female president.  Why would we want to settle for Hillary Nixon, er, I mean Clinton?

Chelsea's taking after her mom - making up stories.  Soon, this will also be called a misstatement.  What 7 year-old kid even knows what social security is or would ask questions about it.  I'm a 24 and I don't worry much about it.
The Penn newspaper endorsed Clinton but the over 3000 in number Penn Dems endorsed OBAMA.  Woot.  Why woot?  Because there membership is pounding the streets for Obama.  Rather have the people on the ground than even the biggest newspaper endorsement.  Go Penn Dems!!!  Thank you for voting your head and hearts and standing up to the Penn Dem. machine.

YES WE CAN!
Her mother makes it tough on others..why not the same for her child...or is what Hillary accuses  just more cowshit...

Caville 101...stick and stones will break my bones but words will never hurt me....

Growup to this lesson... the truth will be tne truth today and for ten thousand years....

No switch-a-roo's or fix it later....NO TIME OUT
Chelsea is no more honest than her parents. She backed Hillary in her Bosnia lie. Now she is embellishing about little babies worring about Social Security.

Obama '08
I hope we keep a journal on Chelsea's fibbs, and have it at the ready to block her run for President, should Bill want another possible 5th, and 6th term when he's 90.
Early in the campaign, Chelsea stood mute on the stage with mom and dad, sometime clapping her hands on cue. Later, she started doing softball "news" conferences and townhall meetings. When that happened, we realized why Hillary didn't want Chelsea to talk, she really doesn't have anything intelligent to say.
Lieing...it runs in the family...
I'm a little confused...I thought this was a blog about Chelsea's negative press...and yet we get a transcript of Hillary's canned comedy routine on the Report.

Chelsea is a surrogate. She's not a child. She knew what she was getting into when she stepped into the spotlight. No doubt she's practicing for her own future political career. Nothing wrong with that, but no one should be surprised at the extremely mild negative press she's getting now. She needs to savvy up.
hey...the 20th is coming...we will see just how BROKE Clinton really is...
Chelsea.  No, I don't like blasting a young lady.

But I will say that to me, she's like any other surrogate at this point (had she only done a little, I could have left her in more of a bubble but she hasn't only done a little).

And my question for her, just a curiousity on my part, is why a hedge fund?  With the whole world open to her, she chose that...I don't get it.  Even had she been interested in the financial world, isn't there something else she could have done then the pure quest to make lots of money?

Anyway. A question I will probably NEVER get answered.
During a long day of campaigning in Oregon on Saturday, she mentioned at two different stops that during the course of the campaign a 7-year-old and an 11-year-old had separately asked her "with terror in their eyes" what will become of the Social Security system. It's possible they were precocious, or that their parents put them up to it, but one skeptical blogger wrote afterward that the story was "stunning in its absurdity."

(When asked for details, such as where and when Clinton met the children, the campaign could not provide them.)

Like Mother like daughter
The daughter has learne well from the lies of the Mother....

Hillary Rodham Clinton has recently stopped telling the story of a pregnant Ohio woman who lost her baby then died because she lacked health insurance and proper prenatal care. The New York senator had recounted the story as it was told to her, but the account turned out to be oversimplified and wrong on some key details, according to news reports.

Still, Chelsea Clinton continued to tell it, even getting the woman's age wrong. (She was 35, not "younger than me," as Chelsea Clinton reported Saturday.)

I guess Chelsea didn't get the memo from Mom to stop lying on the campaign trail.....


If Chelsea is going to eat at the grownups table, she better be preapred to eat all her veggies as well!
I am so sorry for Chelsea. She had no choice of parents and these two cannot seem to tell a straight tale. At least she will be sought after-papparazzi and all, for her money, to come of course. Now this "culture" needs to be changed, desperately.
Seven and 11-year-olds asking about social security? Yeah, that's believable. My kid is 10, and I doubt he even knows such a program exists.

And let's talk about parenting - if kids are worried about their retirements, isn't that a pretty good indicator they are being raised to pretty much fear everything? So are we to assume these are the kind of parents who are supporting Sen Clinton? Okay, that was a cheapshot, but too fun to pass up.

Instead of focusing on this dumb lie about what kids might ask Chelsea Clinton, perhaps we should focus on the one thing I read about the debate that was intriguing - Sen Clinton's bizarre proposal to reallign U.S. Middle East policy into a strategic containment zone oriented against Iran.

Does this mean she basically is saying the U.S. should now be in the sectarian battle between Sunnis and Shi'ites? Don't see any other way such a dumb thing would turn out - and I mean dumb. Its like George Bush dumb - one of those ideas that just gets spouted off without anyone thinking two moves ahead on the chess board.
CHELSEA IS JUST ANOTHER 'LIEING' CLINTON.

CHELSEA IS A FLAT OUT LIAR.

CHELSEA RIVALS HER PARENTS IN THE LIARS CATEGORY.
"Like Mother, Like Daughter".  Chelsea pulls a "fib", but why be amazed when both parents are champions at this.  When's she running so she can tout at least 16 years experience as "First Daughter".  I'd better be quiet or they'll give me away just like they did "Socks" after the second term.

Bottom line!  Save us PA, IN, NC, OR and the rest.  This "Dracula" needs a "sake" in the heart or we'll see another run. Yuck!
Chelsea, if you know what's good for ya, stay out of politics and make millions in your private job.
you don't get to pick your parents,you are stuck with what you have.if they are teaching you a high moral standard you are a lucky child,if they are not you will most likley turn out just like them.
Chelsea will one day become a great leader like her Father and Mother! She is honest, intelligent, and has a true desire to help make America great once again. We had 8 good years under Bill and 8 years of hell under Bush. We need Hillary now!
I like Chelsea but if she cant handle the press then she shouldnt be envovled with the campaign.
Unfortunately it sounds like Chelsea has at least a little of her mother's delusional thinking ... I don't understand why anyone even cares to hear her speak. What has she ever done besides work for a hedge fund?

As for the Colbert Report last night: Hillary was stiff and not at all funny (I completely disagree that "the crowd ate it up"), Edwards was pretty good, but Obama was the real winner. He was charming, bright, and really funny.  
That a 7 and 11 year old would ask about Social Security has to be the most implausible, laughable line I've heard this entire campaign.  And the Clintons have quite an archive of tales by now.   I  hate to pick on someone who's not responsible for their parents, but as a surrogate she is completely worthless.  She's supposed to bring in the youth vote?  Hello-has anyone noticed who's raking in the youth vote?  
 she has a true desire to help make America Great Once again and be a champion of the people with her job at a hedge fund. That is truly inspiring me.
Hey Chuck, how come you guys edited out the part about Senator Obama being on the Colbert Report?  It was included in the article 30 minutes ago but has mysteriously vanished....
You would think a University Newspaper would do its research. Anyone who looks at the Experience claim will see that Clinton has precisely 8 years of legislative experience to Obama's 12 or so - and Clinton's public service - her work for the Children's Defense Fund - was less than a year; Obama worked as a community organizer for several years. The bulk of Hillary's experience has been as first lady and as a CORPORATE Lawyer...The bulk of Obama's experience is as a community organizer, civil rights attorney, and legislator.

Don't get me wrong, Hillary is to be admired for her work and her advocacy for children and women - but she is hardly as experienced as this paper claims. Wow, embarrassing.
Please, please let us end the family political dynasties.   Chelsea has got to be getting what if stars in her eyes these days and she is showing all of the traits of her parents.

Yuck.
You would think Chelsea was the Holy Grail (from DaVinci Code), offspring of Jesus.

Thankfully young people are not entranced by the Clinton mystique.
Wondering what antics the clinton campaign will pull  ~3 days prior to this primary, I predict Chelsea will be asked a 'tough' question at some stop and begin crying.  Hillary gets to be outraged appearing both tough and motherly at the same time.
Wow we are an angry American public. When did we all get so bitter, resorting to name calling and finger pointing. Do any of you remember that feeling after 9/11 when we all stoped yelling at each other, held hands, prayed, rolled out our American flags across the nation and brought our country together.....

Divided we fail. We should no better. We continue to repress ourselves. It's sad really.

Cheers, in hopes of a brighter tomorrow. I hate non of you, I'll listen to all of you and show you respect. That is what democracy stands for and American pride.

I am an Obama supporter. It's time to bring this all to an end. I know it's easier to yell and name call but now it's time action so lets come together and get to work on building America again.
I really like my Mommy!  My Mommy can really do a good job!  My Mommy is the bestest Mommy in the world!
The Clintons (including Chelsea) are really getting good at story telling (fiction).  How can Clinton supportes overlook all the lies and forgeries committed by this family. Who has forgotten the scandalous 90s? The Clinton supporters are fooling themselves to think that this campaign has been anything but scandals and lies and it is evident of what kind of an administration she will offer if given a chance.  Just see how many times she has tried to change the rules in the middle of the game?  How many lies has she already fed to her naive supporters? We don't need more years of lies and deceit, we deserve better than that. I do hope sometime in the future there will be a woman president, BUT THIS IS NOT THE RIGHT WOMAN.  If the superdelegates really care about the country's future they should put an end to this madness and let the Democratic Party start the preparations for the General Elections.  They should put all the loyalty they might have for the Clintons aside and think about all the pressing problems that we are facing as a nation.  The voters have done their job, now it is up to the superdelegates to put an end to this. This is not a game, this is our lives and our children's future.  WE REALLY CAN'T RISK LOSING THE ELECTION THIS YEAR, JUST BECAUSE WE ARE DEALING WITH AN UNSCRUPULOUS AND STUBBORN CANDIDATE WHO IS WILLING TO DO AND SAY ANYTHING TO WIN BECAUSE OF HER SELFISH QUEST FOR POWER.
please save us from the clintons--all of them!!!!!!!!!!!
Hillary...As "unfunny" as several people in my own family here in Florida.  Hillary, I will vote for you if you claw your way to the nomination, but God, you sure come up so scripted when you try to be clever.  
Kudos to the LA Times for finally taking the gloves off and questioning Chelsea Clinton's comments.  Her parents are pimping her off to the younger set hoping her good looks attracts the male college crowd. She's an adult and should face adult scrutiny, otherwise she should stay at home and keep her yap shut if she can't take the adult questions.  As always the Clintons think they can make or break all the rules.

Go Obama!
MSNBC:  didn't you WATCH Colbert?  Obama was the surpise highlight as the show ended.  ...And Edwards was the funniest segment of all--far more notable than Hillary's 'sketch'.
Just as I have suspected, the Clintons have warped poor Chelsea.  How could they not affect her.  We are all aware of the impact the parents have on a child.  I am always amazed at how parents think their children are unaware of what is going on.  Children live in small worlds and are self-centered -- they hear and see everything.  Chelsea, continue to love your parents, but get some therapy soon.
Ohhhhhhhhhhh whoever did that piece on Chelsea will be fired now. Mr. Murray you may want to be careful repeating it as well. They may come after you to.
Fruit does not fall far from the tree.  Our children reflect what we are.  Chelsea is a liar just like her mom.

No child asked Chelsea about social security or any other campain issue.  They could care less.  Chelsea should learn to think before she speaks.  She is now lying like her other.
To the Intellectually Challenged:
Stop making it as if "everything" coming out of anyone related to the Clinton campaign are liars. Has anyone questioned Senator Obama on his "immaculate" conception? When did his parents meet and when was he born? When did he actually hear or bring to Mr Wright's attention about his controversial remarks? Oh, I know, Obama was not in church a few days after Sept 11th, he was contemplating on becoming President by then.
Sen.Clinton, at the debate said those children asked HER about SS.
Chelsea is NOT a child!! Stop acting as if she were made of glass. When I was her age - yes, my demopgraphic is showing - I had 3 kids and a mortgage. I lived in Pennsylavnia and I was planning to vote for Bobby Kennedy. Barack Obama is the first politician to inspire me since that time.
Go Bama!
I supported John Edwards once.  He is one of the Supers that I hoped would come out, like Richardson, in support of Obama...or even Clinton.  Instead he keeps hiding under the bushes.  Either, he still can't figure out where HIS best interests lay....or since he can't be President himself, he really does not care.  I realize Elizabeth Edwards prefers Clinton's health plan to Obamas, but the fact is that Obama IS our Dem nominee.  Hillary should have been closed down long ago. Her antics have cast an ugly pall on the democratic party.  By refusing to get off their butts and endorse, these prominent Super delegats like Edwards have shown a lack of Democratic leadership.  As far as I can see they are cowards.
The Clintons seem to have learned from the Ronald Reagan playbook that a good anecdote is better than the truth.
If no one was convinced of the unmitigated bile oozing, gushing from ObamaNation, one need only look as far as their piling on Chelsea - someone they really know nothing about.  This is becoming an elementary school fight.  If you're wondering why any non-Obama Dems might opt for McCain, look only as far as this.  For all their "high-minded" ideals, they can slither through the muck with zeal equal to any neocon.
Obama can't win PA (or OH) b/c he's got SERIOUS problems w/ Archie Bunker Dems....that means he can't win the general
SUPPORT CHELSEA'S FUTURE.

HOPEFULLY CHELSEA WILL FOLLOW HER MOMMY & DADDY INTO THE FUTURE --- "OBSCURITY".

I watched the Colbert Report last night featuring Hillary's two minutes (cute), and ending in bigger-than-lifesize Obama (impressive) on the very screen Hillary supposedly fixed. I'm for Obama so that's my take on it. But it is interesting to note that no one is commenting on the guest in this same show, featured in between Hillary and Obama. That was the Representative Patrick Murphy (D-PA), who gave Obama his support publicly while brilliantly laughing it up with Colbert. Representative Patrick Murphy served in Iraq. Colbert quipped, "So, you were against the war in Iraq, but then you volunteered to serve in Iraq; and at the same time, Hillary Clinton was for the war in Iraq, and _volunteered YOU_ to serve time in Iraq..." It was pretty funny. I think Colbert is definitely pro-Obama. Thank God.
Now that we've decided to talk about their families and trash their kid.....

Somebody explain how Obama's parents win any prizes?  Seems to me, like many others from his element, Obama was abandoned by his father and then, unlike most, deserted by his mother....well, not deserted...she just had something more important to do while he was being raised by his typical white grandma while he was gaining resentment for his mother's (that would be white) race.

So is this how y'all want to roll?  Be careful what you wish for.  I'm a novice....the Republicans are masters at this sort of campaigning.....can't wait until they get a copy of what Michelle had to say about whites oppressing blacks....I'm sure there will be some really juicy quotes to be used to demonstrate the Obama's ability to unite.
Chelsea's intelligence and poise are obvious. Everyone who meets her seems to like her. So, why is it that she won't sit down with a journalist and do an interview? What are the Clintons afraid that we might learn from her? The longer she continues to shun journalists, the more I worry that there is something about the hedge fund she works for that is trying to be hidden.

She is 28, which means that she is an adult. She is a child of a FORMER president, and not the current one, which means she is no longer the First Daughter. Campaign funds are being spent on her trips. Why does she still get the special Anti-Journalism shield? You know, the one that apparently deflects questions from all of those vicious 9-year old reporters as well as the paid ones?

Chelsea, do a sit-down with Matt Lauer, Diane Sawyer, Katie Couric... somebody! The campaign's donors deserve that much. The Democratic party deserves that much.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=915562

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google