ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



The delegate fight

Posted: Friday, April 18, 2008 9:16 AM by Mark Murray

The New York Times finds superdelegates are not yet moved by the new round of attacks on Obama. "Yet despite giving it her best shot in what might have been their final debate, interviews on Thursday with a cross-section of these superdelegates — members of Congress, elected officials and party leaders — showed that none had been persuaded much by her attacks on Mr. Obama’s strength as a potential Democratic nominee, his recent gaffes and his relationships with his former pastor and with a onetime member of the Weather Underground."

More: "In interviews, 15 uncommitted superdelegates said they did not believe that recent gaffes by both candidates would carry any particular influence over their final decision. They said they had particularly tired of all the attention, by the Clinton campaign and the news media, on Mr. Obama’s recent comment that some Americans were ‘bitter’ over the economy and chose to ‘cling to guns or religion or antipathy to people who aren’t like them’ as a result.

“And if there were some moments of concern reflected in the debate — the talk of Mrs. Clinton’s high unfavorability ratings, Mr. Obama’s flashes of annoyance — they all doubted that those moments would be deal-breakers, either. Instead, most of the superdelegates said they wanted to wait for the results of at least the next major primaries — in Pennsylvania on Tuesday and Indiana and North Carolina two weeks later  — before choosing a candidate."

USA Today and Gannett News also talked to a slew of superdelegates this week and found most won't make a decision based on the Pennsylvania results.

"Some female superdelegates backing Sen. Barack Obama are having their 'sisterhood' questioned, just as some black Democrats have been challenged for their endorsement of Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton," the AP reports. "No one has actually accused Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., of betraying her gender in supporting Obama over Clinton in the race for the party's nomination, but they've let her know they're disappointed. The reason some give: If Clinton does not win the White House this year, no woman will reach that goal in their lifetimes."

Here's the AP's list of female members of Congress supporting Obama.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Check it out!!!

http://nymag.com/daily/intel/2008/04/heilemann_robert_reich_to_endo.html

Carville's on the "Judas" train again
How low will Hillary Go ?

Hillary Supporters, if you truly care about her, try to be objective, do you really think that trying to cripple Obama before the general election is the best way to go?

If she does this, I predict that she will LOSE, and if Rudy Giuliani RUNS for senate in NewYork he will beat her.
THEN WHAT !
Steve B, Obama will cripple himself in the GE. He already can't take the heat. He couldn't handle ABC. They were too touph on him. The republicans will destroy him. It will be Hillary or 4 more years of McBush.
There is one thing that keeps nagging at me though. Would the NFL allow a rookie to set footbal policy? ... No way! ... No matter how good he had been in college ball,  the pro's are different.

So why would we let a rookie senator set policy for the Democratic party ...let alone the nation?

And after all Obama is only a rookie!
Hillary showed the world she is not ready to lead the country.  Obama did a poor job as well.  

Game. set and match to John McCain.
Senator Obama is a true leader.  He sacrificed his reputation on the strength factor by not engaging in clinton's constant verbal assault.  He did this to protect the democratic party and to keep her supporters from leaving.  They can not argue that he beat-up on her.  She did him and it did not and will not work.  

Obama 08
Was it just me, or did I not hear (straight from her mouth, I believe) that the younger of the two Congressional Sanchez sisters in the US House of Representatives was an Obama supporter also?
NO RACISTS IN THE WHITEHOUSE.

NO TO OBAMA.

NO(MORE)PROFESSIONAL LIARS IN THE WHITEHOUSE.

NO TO CLINTON.
McShame will see his own short comings..and will make a fool of the GOP before November....
You know, the superdelegates from the states that have already voted in this primary season have no excuse. They need to sh!t or get off the pot. Endorse already. You're constituents have already voted - they had to make their decision, now it's time to make yours. You are called "leaders" for a reason - not "followers".
I know MSNBC won't post this but I have to get it off my chest.

1) You say the debate was fair on Morning Joe, but ignore the fact that Hillary did not have to answer for Penn or Bill (one of which blew right before the debate).  If Penn was a liability and she claimed she fired him (but didn't), why not press her on this issue?  

2) After 21 debates she has yet to explain what Bill will do in the White House, and you know Republican's will have commercials about the Millions they got from Columbia and China.  Why is this not a fair question?  Won’t the Republican’s in the Fall have commercials about Hillary literally being in bed with a lobbyist for China? Won't this bring up the Hsu questions?  

3) Obama received 4 out of the first 5 questions, is this not an Ambush?  How can you say Hillary stood up to the heat when the only time the heat was turned on she stumbled on the Driver's License question? If I recall wasn't her answer to the lack of jobs in New York that she thought a Democrat would win? What a great answer to a tough question, not . . . Furthermore, the moderators never followed up on any question outside of the electable question.

4) When did Chris Matthews become a Clinton Supporter? I don't care since my minds made up, but since rumors started about the Senate he has veered strongly to her camp.  I wonder if Clinton owning the entire Pennsylvania Machine has anything to do with this?

5) Stop putting up Ford as if he is neutral just because he has not endorsed anyone (and he happens to be a black male). Point out that he is part of the DLC, the same group that Hillary, Bill, and Bayh are a part of and created. He is not neutral and it is obvious when he speaks.
 

From someone who doesn't mind hard questions, as long as they don't ignore the 10,000 pound Gorilla in the room named Bill Clinton.  
Grandfather,Albany,NY.  This ain't football...Barack Obama is not a rookie at being intelligent and knowing how to get things done.  Politics are alot easier than playing a sport.    Obviously, the "rookie" theme doesn't mean a thing.  Look at the current President...he was a so called politician for years...The governor of the biggist state in the land and he will do down in history as the worst President ever... NO body's stupid so leave that sports anology stuff where it belong..with the coaches.


Barack Obama for President of the U.S.A>
To Brother:  Obama is "tough" enough to handle the repubs in November.  He could very easily bring up countless things about Hilary and look "tough".  He is smart enough to know that doing that doesn't do any good for the party.  In fact, look how well it's working for Hilary.  Taking the high road doesn't mean he's not "tough".
OBAMA IS A ROOKIE!

IF HE WAS IN THE NFL THEY WOULD NOT ALLOW HIM TO SET FOOTBALL POLICY.

No matter how good a footbal rookie was in college ball the pro's are different... so they wouldn't let him even try to run policy.

SO HOW CAN ANYONE THINK OF PUTTING A ROOKIE SENATOR IN CHARGE OF DEMOCRATIC POLICY ...LET ALONE NATIONAL POLICY ..AFTER ALL THIS IS THE PRO'S

OBAMA IS ONLY A ROOKIE
Boo hoo Hillary got booed for all her efforts to defrock Obama of his frontrunner status. What a waste of our time.

To take the position that the duplicitous Hillary Clinton is the only viable female candidate for President, is to say that Tanya Harding is the only ice skater who could win a gold medal in the next Olympics.

Obama '08  
Why do I keep seeing posts about how those posts won't be printed?

A little paranoid, folks? For whatever reason, we're all having posts not show up now, regardless of content. Maybe MSNBC needs to add another hamster to the wheel?
Unless you are planning on croaking in the next four years or so (perhaps eight :) ) there are TONS of women with the potential to be President, let's start with the  ever increasing numbers of Women Senators and Governors.  For pete's sake.  A bad woman candidate sets you back.  I don't see HRC as my role model, nor a good role model for my daughter.  The leader role is much too important to elect a "token" anything.

No, the superdelegates should not just look to PA, there are afterall, 49 other states and some territories too.  We matter too.

Obama 08 (a 40-something white woman for Obama)
Jerry of cc I suggest you take your game,set and match comment along with your kool-aid to a certain compound in Texas.
How can you even being to say politics is easier then footbal? ...that's just plain naive.

We're talking about running the country ...the most powerfull country in the world.

YOU DON'T LET A ROOKIE RUN THIS COUNTRY!

OBAMA IS A ROOKIE

His political back ground is in the minors ...college ball
This country is in sad shape if Monica Lewinsky's boyfriends wife, is considered the best choice for President.  We have waited 232 years for a female president.  Another 4 or 8 years is worth the wait, if we get the right person.  Jennifer Granholm, Nancy Pelosi, and Kay Bailey Hutchison would all be excellent choices.  Hillary Nixon, I mean Clinton, is really scraping the bottom of the barrel.  We can do better.
"If Clinton does not win the White House this year, no woman will reach that goal in their lifetimes." ????????

This is a reason to select a President?
Hillary has guaranteed that their will be a female president with in three to four cycles and it could well be her. The question of if she could handle the job is not even a question. No one doubts it. The only thing in question is electability and margin of victory...coattails!
Grandfather- I guess Abraham Lincoln was also a ROOKIE considering he had about the same or less experience. Spare us all your sport's anology! Furthermore, Darth Vader (Cheney) explain that one to me!
Hillary's not whining ...She just got OUTCLASSED!
She's licking her wounds and thinking up more trash to heave...Keep shoving it...you do it so welll..?
Remember if he's a elitist you have to throw uphill
not down hill like you visualize in YOUR ELITIST MIND!!

GO Pennsylvania...It's given to you...

Vote Obama
We need a rookie in the White House.
Trey, you are absolutely right on every single issue you brought up.

Chris Matthews - MSNBC allows him to use them as he gears up for a run in PA - he has done an about face - as far as I'm concerned, PA can have him. Anything to get him off the air. One big phony with a big mouth.

Harold Ford, Jr. is a Clinton supporter. Nothing wrong with that - just don't anyone be fooled - that's all. He'll never admit it.
It was not that Obama could not handle himself. He also knew that it was a set-up. Hillary had his questions before she went on the stage. She read her ad on statements to each negative question towards him.Obama is a rookie wow thatis a good one. Cant you think up something better than that. That is about as stupid as saying Hillary wears plaid panties so we cant vote for her.   There have been plenty of what you call rookie presidents and most of them did a good job. Dont be mad at the McWar people they are feeling left out because granpa Monster is less interesting than the two Dems .
"If Clinton does not win the White House this year, no woman will reach that goal in their lifetimes."

You have got to be kidding!! Is this what these women think??? Is there noone else among our gender these women BELIEVE can ever be President??? HRC is our ONLY shot at ever holding the Presidency?? I am ashamed of this comment. I am ashamed of these so-called women Super Delegates. Get a grip!!! What you basically are saying is that there is no other intelligent, capable, experienced, ambitious woman out there that could ever be POTUS!!! You are insulting your own gender.

SHAME ON YOU!!!! SHAME ON YOU!!!!
hummmm....

Does Hillary have any Brothers? I wonder where they are..... she's framing herself as the only child.... I wonder why..... oh brothers oh brothers... where art thou brothers??????
The Superdelegates need to come together and overthrow this whole deal. When are these people going to finally grow a pair and put this puppy to bed??

http://www.politivine.com
.
NEWS FLASH ----

HOWARD WOLFSON ANNOUNCED THAT THE 'FAT LADY' WILL SING SOON FOR HILLARY...

.. "no mas, no mas, Hillary, no mas ............."

.
As far as behaviors go,concerning arrogance and hatred....ObamaNation is sounding and acting much like AryanNation.
"The reason some give: If Clinton does not win the White House this year, no woman will reach that goal in their lifetimes."
And this is a reason to pick the worst candidate? As a woman, I am totally disgusted.
I am less than amused by the bickering that seems to start with the Clinton campaign, and subsequently the Clinton supporters.

As an Obama supporter I have been called naive, a freak, a fanboy, a robot, a sheep - not to mention having weathered hearing and reading about how my canidate of choice is a racist, a liar, an elitest, and now, weak. I do not believe these things about Barack Obama, so save your breath.

But what gets me is this desire to diminish the passion we as Obama supporters have for our canidate. What is the purpose? Does it help this country for you to try and disengage us from this process? Or does it simply help YOUR canidate?

Either way, it will not work - not on me. You will not sway me from the excitement I have for this process, rekindled by this very exciting and hopeful canidate.

Yes we can.

Obama '08.
What's the difference between Barack Obama and a dog?

At some point the dog stops whinning!
I,too, think Chris Matthews has unofficially launched his run for the PA senate just this week on Hardball.
He's going to need the PA "Clinton" machine behind him and he will do all the shameless pandering that he has to to accomplish that.
Boo Hoo Jay, I seem to recall enormous amounts of bashing and viciousness from the Obama people when Hillary was miles ahead...so in other words, shush big baby.Your acting like your cult leader, weak and ineffectual.
Like many of you, I'm tired of the same politics. Hillary will say what people want to hear, she is not prepared to lead our Country. It's time to get a person that knows what we need and really cares about delivering for the American people.
I still believe that most of the superdelegates are intelligent and objectively-minded people. As such, of course many of them would not be swayed by what was clearly (by any rational account) a bias debate against Obama. Stephanopoulous and Gibson had every intention on spending the bulk of the ABC debate on stupid, trival, and wholly unimportant matters. Forty-five minutes of gossip and hype is not a debate!!!! While American soldiers are dying, the U.S. economy is sinking, and the healthcare crisis grows, Stephanopoulous (who arguably is leaning toward Clinton since he worked for her husband) and Gibson spent more time re-hashing very old and very irrelevant issues! They really should be ashamed of themselves...especially if they call themselves so-called "professional journalists". In using Obama's admittedly weak performance at the debate, Clinton has clearly proved to me that she will say and do anything to secure the Democratic nomination. This is exactly the reason I WILL NEVER VOTE FOR HILLARY CLINTON! I do not want another shoddy Clinton Administration. I am just plain pissed over the entire situation.
Why does everyone act like McWar is untouchable???? He is a continuation almost right down the line of the WORST PRESIDENT EVER. Really, I know Republicans are justifiably arrogant with 2 steals ..errr I mean wins in a row.  But this isn't Kerry or Gore. It's more like Clinton before he went silly.

McWar isn't all that great and it's not like he's been vetted much either. Calm down, you haven't won yet, and I don't think you will.
Fred Dobbs -

You have just demonstrated the class, integrity and intellect of the Hillary supporters. Or I maybe mistaken and you are really Wolfson in disguise.
Has any one ever seen "A League Of Their Own", the Jimmy Dugan character played by Tom Hanks says "crying? There's no crying in baseball". Someone should tell Obama there's no whining in politics. This is a cheap trick to get sympathy votes.

George W. Bush had the experience of running the state of Texas and just look at the devastating impact we are experiencing as a result of his presidency!  9,000 jobs to be cut by citi.., people are going into their 401k's to get money just to buy food and gas.  We are in serious trouble and everyday gas and food prices go UP more and our President/VP are oblivious to it!  There is no response or effort at all to do anything about it!  These people should be impeached for the high crimes of neglect and abuse on the American people.  I'll take my chances with a vote for CHANGE!  Something sure has to and soon!
I was hoping the Pope could help solve this conflict.
http://politicalgrafitti.blogspot.com/2008/04/papal-politics.html
Wow we are an angry American public. When did we all get so bitter, resorting to name calling and finger pointing. Do any of you remember that feeling after 9/11 when we all stoped yelling at each other, held hands, prayed, rolled out our American flags across the nation and brought our country together.....

Divided we fail. We should no better. We continue to repress ourselves. It's sad really.

Cheers, in hopes of a brighter tomorrow. I hate non of you, I'll listen to all of you and show you respect. That is what democracy stands for and American pride.

I am an Obama supporter. It's time to bring this all to an end. I know it's easier to yell and name call but now it's time action so lets come together and get to work on building America again.
Was it just me or did Obama look like an arrogant ***hole brushing off his shoulders yesterday.  Give me a break...what a loser!!  I would like to see him brush off his shoulders after he meets with Middle Eastern dictators!
I get a real laugh out of the repugnant ones who claim Tailhook Johnny will destroy Obama in November.  TJ's clueless comment to drop the 18 cent federal gas tax during the summer shows how little he knows about economics.  Yeah cut the gas tax during the peak driving season and watch our demand grow and watch the OPEC jerks jack up the price of oil.  Yeah we'll cut out paying the federal government thus further increasing the budget deficit and making the dollar weaker making oil higher.

Tailhook Johnny will say anything to get elected because most Americans aren't smart enough to understand the ramifications of his gas tax cut nonsense.  Just more tax cut bribery from the repugnant ones who don't have a winning platform with their foolish decrepit faith values!

Go Obama!
Yes--I believe he was annoyed as he wanted to discuss the issues and not rehash that same old insignificant issues...  He also did not strike back at her as he most certainly could have because, unlike her, do not want to damage the Democratic Party...  He managed to get to her though when he mentioned about the commuting/pardoning of the two members of the Weather Underground...  He is a statesman and a gentleman--not a pushover...  He won't be as nice if John McCain come this fall--it will be mano y mano!
zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz (still sleeping until the bull doodoo is over).

Sports analogies... I like those, too bad they dont mean a thing when people are losing their homes to foreclosure due to predatory lenders who talked them into these crazy mortgages, which by the way, Hillary supports, because they work for her. Ok... nap time again... somebody wake me up Wednesday morning.

Onama '08
Grandfather, your analogy is weak. The Dolphins turned over their franchise to a rookie, Dan Marino, and that worked out pretty well. :)

It depends on the rookie. The Colts picked Manning and he did okay too. Had they picked Ryan Leaf, they'd be second-guessing themselves for years.

Seems to me that the US chose Leaf the last time and now at the mess you're in! Time to rebuild the "franchise".
I want more inforation of the Clinton's gaffes relationship with Mr. Peter Paul. Can anyone including the new media shed more light on the subject?


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=915571

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google