ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



McCain's tax returns

Posted: Friday, April 18, 2008 11:40 AM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under: ,

From NBC's Domenico Montanaro
McCain released his tax returns today. They include 2006 and 2007 and nothing previously. In addition, no returns or summaries are included for wife Cindy McCain, who heads a privately held beer distribution company. Also note, John and Cindy McCain have filed separate tax returns for every year of their marriage except their first year, 27 years ago. On questions of transparency, the McCain campaign points out that the Arizona senator has filed financial disclosures while he has been in public life. The campaign cites Teresa Heinz Kerry, John Kerry's wife, as precedent for not releasing Cindy McCain's returns -- even though Heinz Kerry loaned money to her husband's campaign.

But Clinton and Obama have both released their tax returns dating back to 2000 (Clinton released a summary for 2007, but not the full return yet), and Clinton further back than that, since the days her husband was governor of Arkansas in the 1980s. Additionally, the Clinton campaign has recently called on Obama to release his tax returns from 1997 to 1999 when he was an Illinois state senator.

VIDEO: The presidential hopeful reported a taxable income of nearly $259,000 for 2007, a figure that does not include his wife's wealth .  NBC's Kelly O'Donnell reports

McCain reported taxable income of almost $259,000 on his 2007 tax returns.

*** UPDATE *** While Teresa Heinz Kerry did not release her full income tax returns/schedules (in interest of privacy for her children, she said at the time), she did, in fact, release at least a partial return showing her income from 2003.

The New York Times wrote on Oct. 16, 2004: "Ms. Heinz Kerry on Friday released a small part of her 2003 income tax return, unlike her husband, Senator John Kerry, and President Bush and his wife, Laura, who have made their full tax returns available for public inspection. The Kerrys file separate tax returns, a common arrangement when one spouse is wealthy."

Here’s the release from the McCain campaign:
ARLINGTON, VA -- Today, U.S. Senator John McCain's campaign released his tax returns for 2006 and 2007.  Senator McCain's tax returns show that he paid $157,231 in federal taxes for 2006 and 2007.  In the past two years, Senator and Mrs. McCain have contributed $340,323 to charitable causes. Below please find summary information about Senator McCain's 2006 and 2007 tax returns.
To view the relevant documents, please see:

BACKGROUND ON THE 2006 AND 2007 TAX RETURNS
Senator and Mrs. McCain have kept their personal finances separate throughout their 27-year marriage. Accordingly, they have for many years filed separate tax returns. However, their home state of Arizona is a community property jurisdiction.  In community property states, individuals maintain a separation of all property brought to the marriage, or inherited during it, but share financial responsibility for other assets acquired through the efforts of each spouse during the marriage. This means that their tax returns report one half of each of their community property income and expenses (such as income each of them earn as salaries, Senator McCain's book royalties, and expenses attributable to both of them such as charitable contributions from community assets).

Accordingly, Senator McCain's 2006 and 2007 tax returns contain a detailed "Statement A" showing the allocation of his and Mrs. McCain's community property income and expenses to their respective tax returns (2006 - 2007). John McCain's 2006 and 2007 tax returns, including the community property income and expense allocation, are available for download below. (2006 - 2007)

Publication 555 from the Internal Revenue Service is also available for download below. This publication explains the community property filing rules for various states (including Arizona) and their effects on married taxpayers filing separate returns. View

SUMMARY OF TAX RETURNS
Taxes Paid:
For 2006, Senator McCain paid $72,771 in federal income, alternative minimum, and self-employment taxes (LINES 57 and 58) on taxable income of $215,304 (LINE 43), which is a 33.8% tax rate. View

For 2007, Senator McCain paid $84,460 in federal income, alternative minimum, and self-employment taxes (LINES 57 and 58) on taxable income of $258,800 (LINE 43), which is a 32.6% tax rate. View

Charitable Contributions:
Senator McCain donates his royalties from his books to charitable organizations. This sum has totaled over $1,800,000 since 1998 when he signed his first book deal. Senator McCain's book income of $256,898 for 2006 and 2007 is comprised of earnings for Faith of My Fathers, Worth the Fighting For, Why Courage Matters, Character is Destiny, and Hard Call.

Beginning in 1991, Senator McCain has also donated the increase in his Senate salary for that year and each subsequent year to charity because he opposed the Congressional pay increase at that time and pledged not to accept the pay raises. The cumulative total of these donations is over $450,000.

2006
In 2006, Senator and Mrs. McCain donated $129,390 from community assets to charity, of which Senator  McCain's one-half allocation was $64,695. This is 19% of his adjusted gross income.

2007
In 2007, Senator and Mrs. McCain donated $210,933 from community assets to charity, of which Senator McCain's one-half allocation is $105,467. This is 27.2% of his adjusted gross income for the year.

Most of Senator McCain's contributions were made to the John and Cindy McCain Family Foundation, which makes direct contributions to charities. The Foundation's tax returns for 2006 and 2007, which include a list of the charities to which Senator and Mrs. McCain contributed through the McCain Family Foundation in 2006 and 2007, are available for download below. (2006 - 2007)

SUMMARY OF SENATOR MCCAIN'S ACTUAL (NOT COMMUNAL) INCOME [FROM STATEMENT A OF TAX RETURN]
 
 2006
 2007
 
Senate Salary:
 $161,675
 $161,708
 
Book Royalty Income:
 $80,390
 $176,508
 
Social Security Income:
 $22,104
 $23,157
 
US Navy Pension*:
 $56,496
 $58,358

* [Non-Taxable and therefore not reported as income on Statement A]

Note About Mrs. McCain's Financial Information:
Since the beginning of their marriage, Senator McCain and Mrs. McCain have always maintained separate finances.  As required by federal law and Senate rules, Mrs. McCain has released significant and extensive financial information through Senate and Presidential disclosure forms.  In the interest of protecting the privacy of her children, Mrs. McCain will not be releasing her personal tax returns.
Note About Hensley & Company:

In her role as Chairman of Hensley & Company, a privately-held business founded by her parents, Mrs. McCain's main areas of responsibility focus on strategic planning and corporate vision.  Having served the greater Phoenix area since 1955, Hensley & Company is widely respected as an exemplary corporate citizen, and makes significant charitable contributions of its own.

###

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Incorrect. Clinton has NOT released her 2007 returns.
Nice job John. You have our vote.

What type of military pensions do Clinton and Obama pull down?
Democrats really need to hammer on the 'separation' of their finances and how -- for some inexplicable reasons -- her wealth doesn't 'benefit' him.  He used the same BS reasoning (along with a cheesy prenuptial agreement) to help get him off the hook for the Keating 5 as well, even though his was up to his butt in that mess.  
Pretty modest in comparison. A modest man.
Here's a man that, unlike Clinton or Obama, has never had the royal treatment. What this country needs right now is a common man that understands the needs of the country. John McCain is that man.
Sen Clinton only released a summary for 2007. Why does the media never talk about that?
"In her role as Chairman of Hensley & Company, a privately-held business founded by her parents, Mrs. McCain's main areas of responsibility focus on strategic planning and corporate vision."

---------------------------------------------------

She's also responsible for catering an annual company dinner using the many McCain traditional family recipes "borrowed" from the Food Network.
Social Security Income:    $22,104     $23,157


Why is a man who make $300,000 a year, + the multi-millions his wife pulls in, able to collect SSI? And more to the point, why isn't he refusing it so that someone who actually needs it can get it?

Hillary won't release her public schedule from 2000-2007.  No tax returns from 2007.  Hillary won't release her earmark projects.  Hillary won't release the names of foreign donors to the Clinton library.  Some transparency.

John McCain / Colin Powell 2008

No liars or racists in the WhiteHouse.

America deserves the integrity of John McCain.
(even if he is a closet democrat)  ;-)
But America needs someone close to the center.
Democrats need to wake up and realize thier party is so far left that it better represents the old USSR than America.
What is nice about McCain is that he doesn't have this so-called "celebrity" spouse. Getting a little tired of Democrats candidates spouses flailing around and looking like the goofs they are.
Modest man?  I'm sure he's not benefiting at all from his wife's beer fortune.  
Yes! Modest, middle class, never had the royal treatment. That's McCain for ya! I often picture him reflecting on his honest, modest all american life as he flys around the world on his own private jet with his billionare wife. Nothing like those well to do Democrats like that elitist Obama. Give me a freakin' break.
McCain is pulling a Keating 5 style of misinformation - his wife's wealth means he's living the life of luxury of an elitist!  People who say he's a modest man, are full of it!  McCain is a flipp flopping angry old man who'll wet himself and then start WWIII over it!
Where's the beer hubby stealer's tax returns?  Time for her to fess up so we can see just how "elitist" Tailhook Johnny really is.  His book income is rather pathetic compared to Bill, Hill and Barack. :-)
Modest?  Don't forget he is married to a woman of extreme wealth....what do they have, 8 homes?  Hardly modest.  Get real people! AJ
Talk about a snake oil salesman! Yeah, like he doesn't "benefit" from the trophy's wifes money......yeah, okay. Again, they think we are stupid. He has 6 or 7 houses, doesn't he? WHY, on earth, is he collecting social security when they are multi-millionaries? Give it to someone who acutally needs it.
Pam McBride:  You're fooling yourself if you think Cindy McCain isn't a celebrity.  EVERY Presidential candidate's immediate family will get celebrity treatment, especially once the general election rolls around.  Meghan McCain has become a celebrity in her own right, and Chelsea Clinton has been in the national eye since she was 12.  

The only remaining children who haven't been blanketed by the media are Malia and Sasha Obama.  Of course, they're 9 and 6, so that's to be expected.

As for the Democrat spouses you complain about...Michelle Obama is, much like her husband, a curiosity as a public figure, because there's relatively little known about her.  With Bill Clinton, I assume his celebrity status hardly requires an explanation.
So Grampa is a triple dipper in addition to marrying into a trust fund---but he still shills for lobbyists.  Who owns John McCain?
"Here's a man that, unlike Clinton or Obama, has never had the royal treatment."
______________________________________________________

WTF?  When has the press been critical of McCain?  And when has getting shot down over the wrong target and "talking" during "harsh interrogation" made someone a hero?  Tax breaks for his wife and a continuation of a fraudelent war are all you need to know about McSame.  And where are his HEALTH RECORDS!!!  Can he even make through a single term?
If Bill's income is used to judge Hillary and Michelle's to judge Barack, then Cindy's should be used to judge John. And the earlier comment made by someone is fascinating.  No wonder the SS Fund is going away.  You have wealthy people like John collecting it and then he tells other fulks to suck it up and don't depend on the government.
Jay Biggs, learn to read.

First Read clearly states: "Clinton released a SUMMARY for 2007, but not the full RETURN yet."

He forgot to list his earnings as the beer truck driver for his wife. Actually, part of his contributions went to Joe Lieberman as being the silent writer of his books.
if the media truly ignores the elephant in the room that is worth $100mil+, then they are making it clear that McCain gets a full-on free pass
He paid into SSI he has every right to recieve his money. Any other stupid questions? I guess you think he should reject his navy pension also?
I think that McCain is the only Rep. that Powell would run with.  McCain has shown much more restraint than Clinton when it comes to taking advantage of BO's "typical white person" comment, which I think was not that big a deal given the setting (a sports radio talk show host, very informal, was mainly a big deal because the Wright issue was so recent.)  McCain said also that Obama had distanced himself from the Wright remarks and said it was over for him.  Can't imagine Clinton being that classy.

I'm an Afr. Amer. independent who is probably going to vote for McCain if Hillary is given the nomination.  Though I disagree w/ McCain on many things, he's clearly more principled that Hillary.  I and two other friends, Afr. Amers, have declared that we will go w/ McCain if Hill is nominated.  I believe that a significant minority of Afr. Amers. simply won't vote if Hill is the nominee.  Those of us that appreciate McCain's apology over not supporting the King holiday and being man enough to go to Memphis and not slam Obama respect him, and I believe there are internet campaigs in the works that could push black support to 18-20% for McCain (!) if Hill is the nominee, almost as a sort of protest vote.

That said, I think it's slightly more likely Powell will be BO's sec. of defense than McCain's running mate.  Hopefully.
Pam McBride,
I suppose you prefer pill-popping, stealing (pills, reciipes) spouses?
As for Social Security, income has no bearing on receiving it. When McCain reached age 65, his Social Security checks started. If you refuse your Social Security, the govt. doesn't give it to someone who needs it. They just waste it on some give-a-way program.
"Social Security Income:    $22,104     $23,157


Why is a man who make $300,000 a year, + the multi-millions his wife pulls in, able to collect SSI? And more to the point, why isn't he refusing it so that someone who actually needs it can get it?"

What a retarded question!  He paid that money into the system.  Its HIS money that he is entitled to.  Why not refuse his Navy Pension while he is at it?  Heck, why doesn't he just refuse his Senator's salary altogether and donate all of his wife's money?

This has already donated $1.8 million from book royalties and who knows how much to the McCain Family Foundation .  He has refused the increase in Senator's Salary.  What other senators have done that?  How much has Clinton donated from his book?

John McCain has my vote.

I can praise McCain for refusing his salary increase but why has he not refused the SSI that he obviously does not need?
a modest man with no star treatment ,are you kidding me or our you just the type of person that the media and most politicans love...someone who beleives everything that they say.This man is married to one of the richest woman in Arizona and he won't release her taxes because of her children...yeah right !!!!What does her children have to do with her no releasing her tax info ? He does benefit from her income doesn't he ? they do still live together don't they ? or has he gotten rid of her too , like he did his 1st wife after she was injured in some sort of accident.A modest and honest man ...have you forgotten about the Saving and Loan scandal that cost us hard working Americans well over sevearl billion dollars ? But he is sailing thru now because the media won't do their job ,just as they didn't do their jobs in the run up to the War either...this article is a shame just as most of the so-called journalism of today is also a shame...thank god for Compuetrs and the world wide web ...we do not need you clowns to get info and longer...
Thank You PRESIDENT John McCain. Just sounds so much better than the other options. We need somebody who can relate to the common person. Things are looking better and better. Keep up the good job, PRESIDENT McCAIN
It's amazing when i hear people call Barack a racist. That would mean he's racist against 50% of himself and against his mother, sister, grandparents, cousins...  
Recipes stolen from the Food network are nothing compared to Bill Clinton's baggage or Ms. Obama saying "this is the first time she is proud of her country". Also, the McCain's say that an intern did it and you will not be able to prove otherwise. What happened to the Obama plea for addressing issues instead of gaffes? Do you think that reverend Wright, William Ayers, the flag pin, the small town bitter comments etc. compare to stolen Recipes?

if you want to be America president you have to represent America values. What type of man will not file income tax with his wife. Apparently, this old man think we all stupid.
McCain is actually taking social security?!
Rob, AZ

You are an idiot.  He worked and paid SS taxes and that is why he gets to collect them.  Don't try to tear down any honest hard-working candidates and go back to your liberal hole!
I agree about the social security comment, why would a man of that income want to keep that money when there are other worthy lower class citizens that could use that money, my mother being one of them. The soft exterior of a elderly man can only play sympathy for so long before we see what true disaster lies ahead with John M. as president.
RH, Oregon, Powell is not going to be endorsing McCain anytime soon much less accepting the Vice Presidental nominee.  McCain needs full discloser, so I'll ask what is his wife hiding on his behalf?
Sadly, McCain's wife will gain some celebrity when the stories about her stuggles w/ drug dependency come out.  Not that it should matter, but in this day and age where you get attacked for people you know, i'm sure this'll come up.
I am for McCain, not the political mongrels.
My only question - IRS taxes me on my $16K US Navy pension.  How does McCain skate by not paying IRS on his $56K???
Rob, John McCain is collecting Social Security Income because this is the money he contributed while working over the years. He is 71 now, so clearly over the SS withdrawal 65 age requirement.
IT'S THE DEMS THAT DON'T WANT TO FIX SOCIAL SECURITY
WHY SHOULDN'T HE COLLECT WHAT HE'S PAID IN. DEMS
AND LIBS WOULD RATHER GIVE IT PEOPLE FROM OTHER COUNTRIES.
To Rob,  McCain doesn't take pay raises from his senate salary since 1991.  He has saved the taxpayer's 450,000.  The Clintons and Obamas take pay raises.

To Rob,  McCain donated all his royalties from his book which were 1,800,000 to charity.   Hillary, Bill, and Obama take their book money.

Rob, McCain pays into social security so you get the check back that isn't your choice.

Ok, now let's not be silly, Republicans.

The McCain's file separately and most of their income come from his wife's side.  What you are looking at is strictly his senatorial income.

It is admirable that he donates his published works proceeds to charity.  On the other hand, he doesn't really need the money so long as he's married to a liquor baron.  

McCain is keeping the real income hidden from view to try to make himself look like something he is not to a very large group of delusional people.  Since it is obvious that the previous posters are as typically oblivious to the fact that the wealth comes from his wife and that he is by far the wealthiest of all of the candidates, I will serve to remind you of that fact.  

I am never surprised at the blindness that Republican supporters have regarding their party's ideology and just how underhanded they run their campaigns.  Have you really gotten any of the precious anti-abortion, softer gun laws, or religious support you thought you would get from your present or previous candidates?  I thought not.  Know why?  Because those are campaign topics that no politician in their right mind would touch.  They are moral issues that should be taught at home or in church, not things that the government has any business intruding in.  They may outwardly state it as their position, but they will never act on it.  It is a distraction from the real issues such as the economy and war.

I pray for all of you that you will see what the Republican party is actually doing to you and realize that they will do nothing short of destroying you unless you earn over $100,000 per year.
What is nice about McCain is that he doesn't have this so-called "celebrity" spouse. Getting a little tired of Democrats candidates spouses flailing around and looking like the goofs they are.

Pam McBride, Salam, NC (Sent Friday, April 18, 2008 12:00 PM)

Yeah, that is nice. Too bad he is wrong on all the stuff that really matters. You know, like policy.
So what? he's gonna loose anyway. He has the Bush legacy & he's too old for the job! He can't even raise his hand!

It will be HILLARY this November!
sorry about the language guys, forgot this was a coperate fourme. You guys do a good Job monitering these fourmes, I know a lot of people really appreciate the hard work you do. I work in costomer service my-self, so I really empithise with effort you put into keeping the stupidity and vulgarity off this site, to appease all those little old ladies in fargo.
I am little confussed: If McBush is collecting Scocial Security Income, shouldn't he be retired by now?
While I am not against old age…but I can't help but say McSame is too old.
Rob,

So McCain cannot get SSI according to you?  He's paid into it all of his working life, but he can't draw now that he is over 65?  He has donated all of the profits from his books, has Obama done that?  I don't think so, we need a man with true integrity in the White House, and he will be our next president...

McCain 08!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=916355

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google