ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



Chelsea stops traffic on gay bar crawl

Posted: Saturday, April 19, 2008 12:47 PM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under: ,



From NBC/NJ’s Matthew Berger
PHILADELPHIA -- Chelsea Clinton stopped traffic Friday night as she wandered the streets of Philadelphia on a gay bar crawl, winning rave reviews for both her politics and her appearance.

Led around the neighborhood by Gov. Ed Rendell, Chelsea was mobbed by local gays and lesbians, as she walked from one club to the next. They ran up to hug her, posed for pictures and certainly invaded her personal space.

“I grabbed her ass,” one young woman exclaimed to her friends after snapping a picture with her arm around the former first daughter.

“Chelsea, the gays love you!” one fan exclaimed, as she took the microphone at Bump, a restaurant and bar that was her first stop. “Oh, gosh, I don’t know if everybody loves me,” she responded.

Most of those at the bar seemed to, squeezing past one another in the cramped space to get a photo. Even some patrons, donning Obama stickers -- a rally for the Illinois senator had taken place a few blocks away earlier in the evening -- tried to get a snapshot as well.

In all, she visited four bars in Center City, concluding her tour at Woody’s, the city’s most famous gay bar. Getting from one event to another proved difficult at times, as she was constantly stopped by admirers while walking down the sidewalk. She reached into car windows to shake hands and was followed by several young women who tried to pose for photos on their camera phone, but seemed incapable of properly saving the pictures.

Standing with actors Rob Reiner and Robert Gant, Chelsea appeared overwhelmed at Bump when the mob started complimenting her hair, which they had also done several weeks ago when she spoke at a Stonewall Democrats event at Woody’s. But she smiled and laughed throughout her very short remarks.

While she acknowledged she often is asked who her mother will choose as a running mate, this crowd had other questions, with one man asking what Hillary would wear on inauguration day.

“We have to get her there so we can make that choice,” Chelsea said.

At Sisters, a lesbian bar, Rendell reflected on Chelsea’s statement that her mother would be a better president than her father was, and suggested she may have angered former President Clinton in the process.

Rendell appeared to be in his element. As Chelsea posed for more photos inside Bump, the governor held court outside, quizzing onlookers about Pennsylvania history, and grabbing the phone of one voter to talk to his undecided mother. He acknowledged to the caller that there were two good Democratic candidates, but said he thought Hillary would do a better job.

“OK, governor, don’t run my minutes up,” the man said, trying to get the phone back from Rendell.

Rendell has toured gay bars in Philadelphia since the 1970s, he said, and made a similar trek for John Kerry in 2004.

“We’ll see tonight, easily, 1,500 people,” Rendell said. “And they’re all voters.”

There was no policy discussion for Chelsea, who usually fields questions from college students at town hall meetings but does not do interviews with the press. There were no questions about gays in the military or same-sex marriage this evening; mostly just polite chit-chat.

As the tour continued past a bar with a terrace -- open on one of the first warm spring evenings of the year -- Chelsea nearly ran up to shake outstretched hands.

“Are you going inside?” one woman asked.

“I don’t know,” Chelsea replied. “I’m mostly just following directions.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Ick.
It is clear from the responses being seen on these sites that McCain supporters know the general election has started. Does anyone else know? Is everyone else asleep or just distracted?
Did you guys go bar hopping too?  Ever going to post anything?  I know I do not get posted very often anymore, sorry, after a year or more I guess I wore out my welcome!
Obama was busy spinning and lying while Chelsea was out and about with the real Christians!
That was friendly and nice.  We need more politicians who get out and mingle with the people.
It's noon CDT on Saturday...still no coverage from you guys on Clinton lambasting Democratic activists at a private fund raiser? The story broke around 5 or 6pm yesterday on Huffington Post. C'mon, guys. There's more out there than just the AP wire and your own reporters on the campaign trail. You're supposed to be cutting edge. Pick up the pace.
I think most people "love her" because, unlike her parents, much of her personal life remains just that. Personal. She doesn't talk about personal issues, and I think most people can respect what she's doing going around campaigning for her mother (even if they don't support her mother).

Yea she's gotten some flack for dodging questions about her father's transgressions. But I think most people can understand why she would do that.

She seems to be a genuinely sweet girl, and pretty "normal" considering her life. She doesn't say controversial statements, she doesn't go around ranting and raving. She's a sweet girl, and people like that.

OBAMA IN 2008!
It's noon CDT on Saturday...still no coverage from you guys on Clinton lambasting Democratic activists at a private fund raiser? The story broke around 5 or 6pm yesterday on Huffington Post. C'mon, guys. There's more out there than just the AP wire and your own reporters on the campaign trail. You're supposed to be cutting edge. Pick up the pace.
The pure filth and shame of the ""Article""! This is straight out of the gutter like her father!  This article shows the scum of America and the sick bastards America has to contend with!!!  Grabbed ""HER ASS""? Msnbc , You have reached a "New" level of reporting the filth which the Clinton's represent! The Clinton's are pure filth and the daughter follows in the parents foot steps!!!  Totally outrageous! Totally pure filth! Totally pure troll filth!!  

Just how much more "" PURE FILTH "" Do the Clinton's represent???

The Clinton's  """ GO TO AMERICAS GUTTER LIFE FOR THE VOTE"""
I think this is the definition of shilling.

The Clintons have consistently said one thing to GLBT voters and done something else when they entered office. The list includes Don't Ask Don't Tell and DOMA. I'm always confused why the GLBT community still flocks to Hillary's side simply because of some lip service. Wake up, people! Fool me once ...
Educated gay men don't buy the slice and dice Clinton politics that pits African Americans against gays and lesbians.  Obama bravely took the African-American community to task for its homophobia in his speech at Ebeneezer church in Atlanta.  This trumps Clinton's warmed over 'Don't Ask Don't Tell' compromised rights philosophy.

Gays for Obama.
Chelsea got better photos last weekend with the 2,000 "gay" cross-dressers in Portland:

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/2003608/posts

Show these to all those "bitter" values voters in rural PA.  Or NC.  Or Indiana.  Or...
Ed Rendell is tough, he would make a good vp.
Chelsea won't take questions from the press, but will freely let lesbians grab her ass?  WTF???  
Stan McCauley, you really don't expect MCNBC to report on Clinton lambasting Democratic activists at a private fund raiser??? Didn't you know that is not news worthy? They don't have the guts to dig into it!
It's off limits for FirstRead to talk about Chelsea raking in a million dollar hedge fund salary from Dad's buddies, skimming obscene profits from the sweat of the very lower middle class voters her mother hoodwinks. It's off limits for FirstRead to talk about the beloved Chelsea out on the campaign trail with her prevaricating parents, dodging all of the hard questions and rudely dismissing anti-war questions. It's OK, and no one mentions it, when a rigged debate masterminded by embedded operative extraordinaire George Stepalloverus continually shows a darkened hall with a single row professionally bathed in golden light to illuminate the untouchable Chelsea. These stories are not newsworthy for FirstRead; a public relations, celebrity culture made for TV pub crawl reaching out to the gay community deserves some easy, content-free press. Listen: this is a grown woman, an almost 30 year old millionaire who dismisses those who dare to criticize her mother's craven vote to authorize a war that has sent thousands of young Americans, members of her own generation, to untimely and horrible deaths. Stop treating her like she's a child who needs protecting--she's out there promoting this vile pack of neo-con liars; how about calling her on it?
If this is not pimping out, I don't know what is. Clintons will say and do anything.
"I grabbed her ass"  one young lesbian exclaimed to her friends after snapping a picture with her arm around the former first daughter.

Now if thats not front page news, I don't know what is.  I really don't know what to say except.

            NOW AINT THAT SPECIAL!!!
What does almost ran up to greet gays mean? I want to know about what she said and did when her butt was grabbed? Her not going into the gay bar excuse is I just do as I'm told, lame.
And this is news because? Politically relevant because? I'm sure I'm very happy to know that Chelsea can once again do things her mother and father can't to nuance a point, but I fail to see why I should care, why this has anything to do with anyone's vote--except as a flag to wave at the far right or far left. I'd like to see something besides Chelsea's shining face as support for why her mom is running for president.
If I were gay or lesbian, I'd not be too sure whether I was being courted or patronized.
Obama supporter here.  I admire this effort from Chelsea and Gov. Rendell.  It's a good start--something long overdue.  Took courage.  

I used to go dancing at gay bars with other hetero friends in my younger days, and was always given a warm welcome.  

Let's work towards a UNIFIED America with true equality, liberty and justice for ALL.  
It is so great to see Chelsea out and about like that. She seems like such a smart, nice person.

By the way, when will MSNBC mention that Clinton overtook Obama in Gallup's daily tracking poll today? A 12 point swing in 5 days. That is huge!

PRINCETON, NJ -- Gallup Poll Daily tracking shows that Hillary Clinton now receives 46% of the support of Democrats nationally, compared to 45% for Barack Obama, marking the first time Obama has not led in Gallup's daily tracking since March 18-20.

These results are based on interviewing conducted April 16-18, including two days of interviewing after the contentious Wednesday night debate in Philadelphia and the media focus that followed. Support for Hillary Clinton has been significantly higher in both of these post-debate nights of interviewing than in recent weeks.

http://www.gallup.com/poll/106606/Gallup-Daily-Clinton-46-Obama-45.aspx



As a gwm, the thought of following around HillBillies baby girl was ridiculous, at best. I certainly found more substance on the lawn of Independence Hall during that time while Mr. Obama spoke to the people from his heart. Considering the size of the crowd, there was not only more substance, but more people, as well.

I was an enthusiastic supporter of Rendell and a solid backer of Mayor Nutter, but the two of them do not speak for all of Pennsylvania and for very few in Philadelphia. Publicity STUNTS do just that; stunt the message and sidetrack the issues.  Kudos for and all of us, gays included, who support Sen. Obama and do not buy into this paparazzi parade poop.
I think it is absolutely wonderful that Chelsea and Governor Rendell would visit the gay bars of Phili. As a gay man (yes this is the firs time I've ever wrote this in public and I'm 29 years old) It fills me with pride to know that they care about all kinds of people. Yes they are trying to get votes, but we are all Americans and ALL need jobs, education, and a secure world. I wish people wouldn't be so cynical about the Clinton's. You don't know them from a hole in the way, and just because the news tells you one thing DOES NOT MEAN ITS TRUE. I think they love all fellow Amercans, just like Obama and just like McCain. I think the times of hate are over in America, and the language of hate too.

GO Hillary 08
Strange that Hillary sends her daughter out to these 'crawls' instead of going herself.  Its probably her aim to keep a comfortable distance between herself and the gay community at large, yet to use her daughter as a surrogate she can later dismiss if it gets dicey.  Her husband's support of the Defense of Marriage bill and the "Don't ask, Don't tell" policy can either be derided or embraced to her advantage if future developments indicate which she should flip to.
 Chelsea would appear to be as much of a shield in this instance as she was in Bosnia.
I'm gay, and the Clintons gross me out. No way would I vote for Hillary. She's dishonest and untrustworthy. And let's remember it was Bill Clinton who sold us out by implementing "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" and signing DOMA. No thanks, I'll take my chances with Obama.
Wow. Somebody sure likes the word "filth." Maybe a little too much...
What are you trying to say, here, filth? Are you homophobic or something? Or just one more neoconservative god-nazi that Jesus Christ would be ashamed of?
Personally, I think it's great that someone is at least making a show of reaching out to the GLBT community, even if Billary back in office is the nightmare that keeps on giving. Has Clinton promised actual American freedoms to us yet? Is there any chance she will do so? I doubt that.
I think it's about time we stopped judging others by their color or orientation and saw the person inside. This is the 21st century, after all.
Chelsea is in a difficult position, and she is holding up very well.  Totally agree that she is under no obligation to talk to reporters about her or her parents' personal lives.

IS this a good time to remind people about John McCain joking that the reason Chelsea was so ugly is that Janet Reno was her father?  Puts his public insulting of his wife into context, and the context is that John McCain is angry old chauvinist unfit to lead.


Pimped out, Chelsea?

Probably not.

Please hear HP whining and print her erudite and thought-provoking posts.

Every day.

She is one of the best reasons on the board to vote Obama.

It's only rock and roll, but...

Would any of you readers knowingly vote for a member of the "Third Sex" for president of the United States?
Sounds like a fun night. Why didn't she do this in Columbus? I would have loved to meet her.
This is what I admire the most about the Clinton family.  They don't care if we are White, Black, Hispanic, Indian, Asian, gay, straight, whatever........they stand up next to all of us!  I love this country so much and this is the reason why.  Because we have the right to be who we are and we are free to live as we wish.  Hillary is for Freedom!  HILLARY IS FOR HOPE!  HILLARY IS FOR CHANGE!
secrets, so many secrets....Chelsea..why didn't your mother kiss Sir Elton on the lips?...

Pack of liars....
You go GIRLS!!!  ANYONE would be better than WHAT we got!!
Gross!!!
Interesting that the "gays" love her, considering that Hillary has not really "said" or done anything about gay rights in this campaign. At least Obama has adddressed, Don't Ask, Don't Tell.

I think Chelsea might just end up as a hag.

Would have loved to see Robert Gant though.
Why would her parents subject her to that?
I bet she was mobbed by more lesbians than gays
It is nice to see her out with the people who really
matter most in this country. Being a "straight" taxpayer, married, father of two doesn't matter to
the Clintonians...typical scum, embracing typical scum....can't you find anything better than this dribble to print...anything REAL going on????
I want to see Chelsea's face when her ass got grabbed!

Does this make it official that she was "pimped" out?

Clintons' will do anything to get the votes from their perceived "base" of "regular" folk. Drinking boilermakers?  Hanging around gay bars?  What's next? Sex clubs? Biker bars?  They seem more like the low class oaf in the White House now.

Obama is classy without being patronizing.  He defines what a leader should be.  




Al Gore invented ass-grabbing.
Doesn't anyone realize that this type of behavior is what prompted GOD to destroy Sodom and Gomorah!! Read Genesis 19.
It's almost understandable for lesbians to have a higher degree of support for Clinton, but it amazes me that gay men tend to as well. Wake up guys, they screwed us with "don't ask-don't tell" and especially DOMA. Gay guys liking Hillary is similar to their like of Bette Midler, Joan Crawford, Liza Minnelli, etc. Can't say why, but it seems to fit.

Obama '08
How low will the Clintons go.  Pretty low I think.  They will do anything to win, bend the truth, play dirty and complain when someone calls then out to point out how low they will go.  Check out what she said about the left side of the base.  This this act of theater, so much for the conservative vote.  She has lost mine.  
How low will the Clintons go.  Pretty low I think.  They will do anything to win, bend the truth, play dirty and complain when someone calls then out to piont out how low they will go.  Check out what she said about the left side of the base.  This this act of theater, so much for the conservative vote.  She has lost mine.  
I hope Chelsea remains untainted!  The only ethical Clinton!
I think Chelsea is hot but I have enough human respect to not sexually asault her like the woman in the article did.
Did anyone ask her how those 2 children she claims quizzed her about Social Security?  Oh no, I forgot she is allowed to say anything she wants but the press is not allowed to talk to her.  Say HILLARY, if it is too hot in the kitchen don't send your daughter out for you!  Oh I forgot, you needed her to convince the university students to vote for you.  

Hillary wins PA by less than 5, claims a HUGE victory and goes down to defeat in North Carolina and Indiana.

GO OBAMA GO!
Chelsea has no shame.  How pathetically desperate that Hillary would allow a presidential daughter to go bar hopping for votes.

Let me ask you Chelsea would you have gone to heterosexual bars and let someone grab your ass?  If you and your mom think this is okay.... and that this is your family's way of fitting in with the middle class...then YOU BOTH HAVE NO CLASS!

A president should be above that.  Very sad.
...did somebody try to grab Ed Rendell's ass, too?
This has got to be the funniest thing I have ever read. They are seriously getting desperate now. If convicts could vote, they would send their daughter into prisons looking for votes. What's next, her walking the red light district looking for votes amoung prostitutes? No wait, that's a job best suited for Bill. Rendell appeared to be in his element huh, I bet he did. I am sure he is a frequent customer in that district. Wonder what Hillary's redneck, rural roots, God fearing, gun toting followers think of her daughter having her butt grabbed by a lesbian. Oh, and for the record, I am not gay bashing, just finding how ridiculous the Clintons are in their attempts to garnish votes.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=921148

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google