ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



You’re the GOPer! No, you are...

Posted: Sunday, April 20, 2008 3:57 PM by Domenico Montanaro



From NBC/NJ’s Athena Jones
BETHLEHEM, Pa. -- The latest tactic in this protracted primary race? Comparing the other candidate to the Democratic Party's Grand Ole bogeyman: The Republican Party.

Obama did it after the debate on Wednesday, saying Clinton's hits on him were part of the lesson she learned when the Republicans were attacking her back in the 1990s. And Clinton did it Sunday, bringing up last week's Philadelphia debate and painting her rival as the candidate who says one thing and does another.

"This week we had a debate, and it showed you the choice you have, and it's no wonder that my opponent has been so negative these last few days of the campaign, because I think you saw a big difference between us," she told the crowd.  "It's really a choice of leadership. I'm offering leadership you can count on. You know where I stand; you know what I've done; you know what I will do. I'm offering my experience, my strength and my readiness for whatever comes our way. I'm ready on day one to be the commander in chief, and I'm ready to fix this economy."

In an indirect reference to Obama's controversial "small-town" remarks, the New York senator suggested he was being divisive.

"I am looking forward with great anticipation to leading all of our people in every city, every town, every village across America, because I want to bring our people together," she said. "I know the best way to do that is to set I highs goals again: goals that we can agree on as Americans, goals that we can achieve together as Americans. My campaign has been about that; it's been about leaving no one behind, but instead bringing us all forward together. We're going to work on behalf of these big goals and we're going to produce results for America. So while my opponent says one thing and his campaign does another, you can count on me to tell you where I stand, and you can count on me to tell you very specifically the solutions that I'm offering for America."

The comments, in line with themes the campaign has been pushing for months, are the latest in a series of tit-for-tat attacks between the candidates as the heated race enters it final days.

Clinton brought up Obama's ad about not taking money from oil companies, saying that no one did so, because it was illegal and then linked him to “Dick Cheney's” energy bill. She said that when given a chance to match his words with his actions, he had failed by voting for a bill with big giveaways to those very same companies.

"I was raised, you know, by my family to, you know, say what I meant, mean what I say, but also that actions speak louder than words, and I still believe that today," she said.

Later, she returned to the health-care issue, criticizing Obama for ads and mailers that she said misrepresented her plan for universal coverage and sounded like they came from the Republican playbook.

"The last thing we need is to have somebody spending as much money as he has downgrading universal healthcare. We need to try to achieve universal healthcare not create political opposition to universal healthcare," she said. "That's what the Republicans do, not what the Democrats do. Because here are the facts: my plan covers everybody; his plan doesn't. His plan would leave out about 15 million people."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Filp flop Queen is at it again... Hillary enough is enough....We only have 48 hour to put with you.... Game Over.....
"I was raised, you know, by my family to, you know, say what I meant, mean what I say, but also that actions speak louder than words, and I still believe that today," she said.

Except with respect to international trade, Bosnia, party activists and MOVEON.....
There is no way Hillary can bring people together.  The most she will bring together is the right wing opposition to her.  She is a very divisive figure whom alot of people have a very negative view of. Even the way she talks in her campaign goes against the idea of bringing people together - she talks about being a fighter all the time.  Fighting is what we've had for too many years.
Really Senator Clinton?  Then how come you have stated over and over that Caucus states should not count?  And that only the big states (read that: the ones where you won) should count?  I don't see you as being a potential President of all the people...I see you as exactly the same as what we have now.  

And by the way...since it seems to be important to people...where is your flag pin?  I guess we have to assume that you are not patriotic since you have allowed Senator Obama to be accused of that during a debate.  
"...I want to bring our people together....".

-Hillary

First she tried to steal his delegates, now she's stealing his whole stump speech.

Obama '08
Blah, blah, and the beat goes on with her.  She left out the part that she will garnish their wages, even if they can't afford it.

She is so much in denial of herself, it's unbelievable.  No wonder she is able to lie without remorse; what kind of lady is this?

As much as I despised Bush, even he looks better as a president.  Today with him, we know what we were going to get, we know Cheney don't care, but with her; good grief!

The American people deserve better!    
Please PA, put us out of HER misery and Vote Obama! The woman is so shameless she will say anything. Democrats HAVE to get behind Obama, she's a republican in everything but name.
From the statements of Sen. Clinton, it easy to see why people are gravitating to the message of Sen. Obama.  Senator campaigns as though she an use rhetoric to make the seem obscure.  San. Obama is right, she is playing the old politics game - the one we have rejected .
Sen. Obama is indeed the better candidate.
Are Hillary Clinton's positions on the issues best described by her endorsement from Richardson Mellon Scaife of "Right Wing Conspiracy" fame or by her attack of the activists of moveon.org, which was formed to defend the Clintons during impeachment?
Hillary has a great track record of bringing people together to solve problems - that's why we've had universal health care for the last 15 years. Oh yeah, I forgot that somehow with a democratic president, democratic congress and polls showing 80% of Americans favoring universal coverage she managed to fail.

Oh and to her comment that she will tell you specifically her solutions - well I'm still wiating for a specific answer about social security.  The only thing I've heard her say is that she'll form a commission - that's not a solution that's Washington speak for I don't want to tell you what I think.
Since Shrillary was taught to "say what she means and mean what she says", I guess she said what she did about coming under sniper fire in Bosnia because she meant what she said. What a joke. She's just another lying, cheating, dishonest, and pandering politician just like Obama and McCain. If these are the best candidates America can choose then we as a People are bound to fail to keep this Nation strong. Vote for NONE of these three. Vote for WRITE-IN. America will thank you for it.
Live by the mud----
lose in the mud....
I have to say that this morning's "Meet the Press" was the most entertaining episode I have seen in a while.  No offense to Mr. Garin personally, but if that is who she has representing her, it's no wonder she retained Mark Penn's services on the side.  He's definately not the pit bull Penn was.  He frequently looked down instead of at Russert when he was asking questions, he hemmed and hawed and stammered, and "didn't know" about the 100% negative campaign commercial playing in Philly yet RECITED FACTS USED IN IT.  Axelrod called him on that, and Garin did not have a good answer for it.  

Obama is NOT the "messiah"; however he does seem to connect with people in a way that I don't see Clinton doing.  You, the voter, are going to see the candidates through whatever prism that use to look through life.  Some see an "uppity" black man, but others see respect for people that have different way of thinking, speaking, and living.  Correct me if I am wrong (and I know you HRC supporters will) but I thought that diversity is what we WANTED in our country?  A place where people could be who they wanted to be, not where you were "stationed".  Obama's story is the epitome of that.  Of course he's bit of an "elitist" - he's a law "lecturer" and senator, for Pete's sake - but who among you would accept a candidate that DIDN'T have the education he has?  Yeah, I thought so.  

Molly - you are either ignorant or you just want to stir up debate.  Obama is just as American of a name as many other people with ethnic names.  In 20-30 years we'll see A LOT of people with "weird" names.  If you ever crawled our out from under your rock you would take a look at some of the names that I see in the birth announcements every day.  Sheesh.

Tyrone - how does Obama STEAL this nomination exactly?  According to Russert this morning, he is ahead in pledged delegates, popular votes, and overall totals with SDs.  He is still leading the Gallup daily poll.  He is within 5 pts of HRC in Penn.  Again, how is THIS stealing?  

Lastly -  I read in my local paper this morning that HRC was insinuating to crowds yesterday that if you vote for Obama, you are not thinking.  Actually, that may be the wrong tactic to take.  You see, her attitude is that SHE should do all YOUR thinking FOR YOU.  So maybe she should stop trying to attract the "thinking" crowd.  Most of them already know she's a fraud.
Hillary you were born and raised a Republican...

Nothing has change.
Here's Hillary's List of Undesirables and Criminal Affiliations:

Susan and George McDougal (prison)
Norman Hsu (prison)
Peter Paul (Was in a foreign prison)
Marc and Denise Rich
Liu Chao Ying
American Muslims Association
Hugh Rodham (Her brother she's hiding until the election is over)
Aaron Tonken
Sant S. Chatwal
International Profit Associates (IPA)
Yah Lin "Charlie" Trie
John Huang
James Riady
Johnny Chung
Roger Tamraz
Jeffrey Epstein
John K.H. Lee
Pauline Kanchanalak
Ng Lap Seng
Abdul Rehman Jinnah
Ron Burkle

How come nobody’s asking Hillary who these people are?


What's next...

I'm rubber your glue..what you say bounces off me

and sticks to you!!!!
What are the details of the defense alliance Senator Clinton is proposing to commit our military to in the Middle East?
OH HILLARY CLINTON we all know you are a Republican. Just look how you are running your campaign.

Tell the American People Everything and give them nothing.

But you almost maybe worst because you never take responsibility for anything. The Republican just don’t give a dame.
To cold...attacking his mother and his up bringing..

That sounds like a bitter ELITIST..to me
I know Chuck Todd likes numbers, so he should probably chew over these about the line of questioning in the Obama/Clinton debates on various networks.  The results were surprising to me.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/04/20/debate-analysis-abc-asked_n_97599.html
Hillary, God willing, it is too late to play this word game.  We don't believe anything you say.
Please view this clip of Bill Clinton's view on"God Gays and Guns"
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GYaJHAnmjtk
Hillary says she says what she means and means what she says.  Oh really?  Does that mean she meant to lie about Bosnia landing under fire?  About her role in the Irish Peace talks?  About opening the border so Kosovo refugees could flee?  About the Levin agreement?  About "The Cheney Energy Plan"?  See www.Factcheck.org on this one.  It takes more away from the oil compppanies than it gives.

I have no idea what her parents did or didn't teach her but obviously, telling the truth wasn't one of them.  My parents and grandparents taught me the lies will always catch up with one.  Caught in so many lies, she continues to repeat them, over and over again.

In the largest newspaper in IN today, there were several editorials touting Obama's comments.  
Hillary,you said: "You know where I stand, you know what I'be  done, you know what I'll do".

YOU ARE CORRECT, We Do know these things.

THATS WHAT SCARES US!!!
will somebody please explain to the voters by obama gave hillary the finger and no a word is anywhere about it ???/ if that had been hillary they would have interrupted every channel for it and would have been all over msnbc  -=--- press get over your bias and tell the voters what they have a right to know-not just what you want them to know... do your job.  


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=924808

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google