ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



HRC gives closing argument in Scranton

Posted: Monday, April 21, 2008 11:16 AM by Mark Murray

From NBC/NJ's Athena Jones
SCRANTON, PA -- After a long weekend of campaigning, marked by a bitter back-and-forth between the candidates, Clinton left the negativity behind as she kicked off the last full day of the primary race with a fourth stop in the northeast Pennsylvania town where she has deep roots.

The New York senator made her closing argument in the small, packed ballroom of a cultural center, entering to the now common strains of John Mellencamp's anthem "Small Town" and speaking in front of a banner that read "Scranton's behind you Hillary." She was accompanied by her mother Dorothy Rodham and her brothers Tony and Hugh Rodham, and the crowd interrupted her frequently with cheers and shouts.

"I wanted to come back the day before the primary to be with all of you and to thank you. We started this Pennsylvania campaign here in Scranton at the new high school, and we're going to bring it to victory," she said. "We need to really bear down. The last day is here and the entire world is watching. I appreciate your having my back and here's what I want you to know -- as your president, I'll have your back."

Clinton's great-grandparents settled in Scranton and her grandfather and father grew up here. She talked about the time she spent here in her youth and about her family's faith in America. "We cared about our family. We cared about our faith. We believed in working hard and we had an abiding faith in our country, an abiding faith that never ever quit," she said.

In a speech devoid of the kind of negative rhetoric the candidates used all weekend, Clinton touched on her goals of ending the war in Iraq, winning the war in Afghanistan, taking care of veterans and turning the economy around, making college affordable and achieving universal health care among other issues.

Polls show Clinton has retained her lead over Obama in a primary some analysts say she must win by double-digits, and today she thanked her supporters and volunteers and urged people to help turn out the vote. "Please, in the next 36 hours, do everything you can: convince people to go vote who say that they're not voting, take them to the polls, call your friends and neighbors, make the case for the kind of result that we desperately need in America again," she said.

Clinton did not mention Obama or McCain by name, but she did take a subtle dig at her colleague from Illinois' "Yes we can" mantra at the very end of her roughly 20-minute speech.

"Some people say that America's best days are behind us," she said to shouts of "No!" from the crowd. "Some people say 'Yes we can', but that doesn't mean we will. I believe we will, if we have the right leadership. If you stand with me I will. I will go to the White House and fight for you every single day."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Sometimes the trainer has to "throw the towel in" for the fighter who's too bloody and confused to see that "she" is still fighting but has already lost. Come on Hillary PA supporters consider voting Obama and help Hillary to her corner before she causes herself much more harm.  
Follow Bill's advise.  Vote for a candidate who makes you think and hope.  That candidate is Barack Obama.  Hillary's scare tactics and scorched earth campaign make her unfit to be a Democrat much less president.
Hillary should tell all the working class people that thinks she walks on water that remember her and her husband passed NAFTA and this is a major reason why Pennsylvania working class people can't find jobs. The reason is they were shipped out of the country. Thank you Bill Clinton.  
PA LOVES HILLARY....you Obamapuds sit down, you've had your turn - time to put a woman in charge!
if I win I'll have your back and if I lose "screw you all!"  Ain't she sweet.  
STOP THIS NONSENSE.  Please PA vote for Obama; this country needs all the HOPE and help it can get, or do we want more Clintonitis.
Check this one out.  Ed Rendell praising Farrakhan! A little over sight I guess.  Got to go VET my dog.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DXum_-8I1TA
Politico has video of Ed Rendell praising Louis Farrakhan! On Democrats blog and Youtube!

I guess Hillary won't be mentioning Farrakhan again!

Will she denounce Ed Rendell?
Politico has video of Ed Rendell praising Louis Farrakhan! On Democrats blog and Youtube!

I guess Hillary won't be mentioning Farrakhan again!

Will she denounce Ed Rendell?
The minute that untruthful witch started telling the story of her grandfather, I doubted it.  How can you believe anything she says?
Hillary may whoop Obama's butt in PA (not by much)but she'll still not have enough SD's or the popular vote needed to win the Presidential nomination, even with Florida counted, haven't you been listening and watching, you're waisting your time and piling on unnecessary stress to your poor body!  Be kind to yourself, Hillary is going nowhere in this election but further in debt.  THE WOMAN CANNOT RAISE ENOUGH MONEY OR MANAGE WHAT MONEY SHE DOES GET!!
Interesting YouTube clip of Gov. Rendell speaking before Louis Farrakhan and the Nation of Islam in Philadelphia. Very enlightening, especially after Hillary's debate assertion that any peripheral connection of Farrakhan to Obama should be used to condemn him. Not too many degrees of separation between HRC and Farrakhan after all. Check it out:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DXum_-8I1TA
I see the boneheaded Clinton bashers are out today!

Rather than look at Mr. Obama's background and who he hangs around with which are KNOWN facts, you continue to bring up the lies that the news media has spread about the Clintons over the years.

Why sould you admit that the Clinton years were the best we have had in this country since Kennedy?  Yeah, go ahead and vote for a guy who has a "mentor" who says God Damn America!  Now that shows just how smart you really are.

Unfortunately, Obama will probably get the nomination because the DNC and the news media has steered things his way from the beginning.  That is surely America's loss.

Those of us who are not fooled by the liar that is Barrack Obama will be voting for MCCain in the fall - and that is probably about 75% of America!
I find that any time you try to say anything bad about Obama on this site it is not printed.  What is up with that?
Three more weeks and she'll be gone. Now, that's hope!
What does Hillary have to say about her big supporter, Pennsylvania Governor Ed Rendell's praising of Louis Farrakhan and the Nation of Islam?
I would like to believe that the majority of Pennsylvania voters are not as ignorant as the press makes them out to be, or that Clinton hopes they are. You don't need a college education to see the pandering she has been doing.  
HAS ANYONE SEEN THIS VIDEO!

IT IS ALL OVER YOUTUBE!

YOU WILL NOT BELIEVE IT! IT COULD CHANGE THE ELECTION!
To those touting Obama's finances. Wonder who he's getting the money from, who are his backers? Nope not the general public mind you. Even with the money from the young college ones aren't enough. Think people think.

Pam NC, I like your post - http://tinyurl.com/2zwwte
thanks for the link. He is as slimmy as it gets. A wolf in sheep's clothing. Pied pipper.


By the way, to the Obama paid bloggers, stop copying my name.
This is a new era for us americans.the best is ahead with God and hillary number one lady president.......
Obama is far ahead in campaign funds and gets millions of free advertising and support from most media types.  While they deny it,  anyone with a brain can see how biased Olbermann, Matthews and other non neutral commentators are in the bag for Obama.  Even when he couldn't offer a decent response to tough questions in the last debate,  Olbermann came to his rescue and tried to interpret for us dumb Americans.  Even people who post here offer the same lame, childish comments about her.  Whats the matter, intimidated by a smart, powerful woman?  Obama has wonderful oratory skills but if he isn't scripted, he isn't much.  Just like the debate-it took the next day before he had cutish, crafted responses.  Puppet.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=926894

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google