ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



McCain links earmarks and Katrina

Posted: Thursday, April 24, 2008 2:50 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ’s Adam Aigner-Treworgy
NEW ORLEANS -- On the government's response to Hurricane Katrina, McCain said, “Never again. Never again will a disaster of this nature be handled in the terrible and disgraceful way that it was handled.”

When he was asked if it was fair to say that the failure of leadership extended all the way to the Oval Office, McCain said yes. But he added that he places "some of those responsibilities on the Congress of the United States, which funded pork barrel projects that were not only not needed and certainly not as important as some of the projects that were needed here."

He also said corporations should be asked to handle more of the response to a future disaster.

McCain then went further in his diatribe against earmarks and wasteful spending.

“I have never voted for a single earmark or pork barrel project,” McCain said. “Sen. Obama and Sen. Clinton have voted for hundreds of millions, hundreds of millions of pork barrel projects and earmarks and wasteful spending. They’re part of the problem. I’m part of the answer.”

While it is true that McCain has never sponsored an earmark -- by the strict definition of the word -- he has certainly voted for bills with earmarks, including some of the specific projects he criticizes most vocally on the campaign trail.

The campaign's four-block tour of the Lower Ninth Ward this morning quickly turned to confusion for McCain and the traveling media. Surrounded by at least 20 National Guardsmen, McCain walked with Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal down Caffen Street, past Fats Domino’s house and concluded his tour at St. David’s Catholic Church. But while McCain walked, members of traveling press led the way in two flatbed army trucks, stopping and starting while trying to listen in on the brief conversations McCain had with voters along the way.

At times the trucks picked up speed and left the senator behind, causing members of the press to scream, “Stop.” At other times, the candidate would catch up with the press, walking between the two trucks while McCain’s traveling press secretary yelled at the uniformed drivers to speed up and get ahead of the tour. 

The press conference that greeted the senator at the end of his tour -- where McCain made the comments on Bush, earmarks and corporations -- was also a cause for confusion. Several local residents complained there were no seats for hurricane survivors outside the church and no time carved out in McCain’s schedule for meetings with Ninth Ward residents. McCain tried to calm some of his detractors in the crowd with some of his patented “straight talk” on the government’s failures to respond effectively after Katrina and Rita.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

John is a true American hero both in war and in Congress.

If not Hillary, then McCain.
Don't pay any mind to the fact that he forgot that he voted for bills with earmarks in them... when you get to be your age (or apparently Hillary's age... see Bosnia) you forget things...
I agree.  If not Obama, then McCain.
Give John a break. He can't remember what he has voted for.
McCain love for American will never come under fire.
I give him a lot of credit for some straight talk on the Katrina disaster response and causes.  I would even give Bush credit if he ever uttered an honest word.
What? He doesn't agree with his pastor's inflammatory remarks about the Katrina disaster? Why doesn't the MSM play clips over and over and over of the horrendous views of McCain's pastor???
McCain on the trail given 'em hell, and catching hell.
As I was reading the comments in the "working class" thread, it occurred to me that what Barack Obama needs to stress to the media and the voters is that just because he doesn't talk or behave like them(i.e. downing shots of whiskey) it doesn't mean he's not campaigning for them.

From all I have heard in his speeches, he knows with all his heart that this election is about the families in this country who are having a rough go of it. The pundits do not talk about this.

He had enough respect for the young men and women of this country to speak up against the invasion of Iraq. The pundits do not talk about this.

Why should he have to bowl or anything else in order to connect? Because the pundits like it?

I don't know about anyone else, but I prefer my presidents to be smart and behave in a dignified manner.

And have sound judgment when it comes to wars. He knows full well it is our children who will be serving in the military.

Elitist? Think again.

Try intelligent, reserved, respectful.  Just the type of President we need right now.

McCain is no "maverick". He'd be the next in line to tow the neo-con corporate control machine. McCain = Bush III. McCain, another reckless underachiever just like W.
Go McCain GO... Obama is a profoundly wounded candidate and all his wounds--self inflicted.  He would be a great philosopher, university professor and/or political commentator but as a president he is too extreme and out of the fringes of the American electorate.  He has harmed his chances by simply being who he is; an extreme liberal with dubious associations and ties to hate mongering fringes of our society.  The president has to be president for all.   http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f8c_DP6Efkc

Let me see if I understand this correctly.
**Katrina was in 2005.
**The Repukes were in the majority in both houses.
**Bush was in the White House.
Therefore the Katrina aid disaster was the Democrats fault.  Right John!!!

If people would stop asking for these request from the member of Congress, then they would go away.  Corporations need to learn to do things on their own, but if they want to maximize their profits, have the government do the work for them.  

To have the corporations do the work can lead to corruption and poor reporting. People can't change corporate officers, but people can change their reprensation in Congress.  There is an easier recourse when someone is in government than in the corporate world.  
He's never voted for an earmark, which is another way of saying he's never gotten anything done for his home state.

I agree that some earmarks are bad, but what about getting some earmarks that will prevent our bridges from falling into rivers?

What about earmarks that will give educational opportunities to underprivilged children?

McCain knows about war, but only has a superficial knowledge about everything else.
clarity is coming. Obama will smother mcsame in the general. hillary... please do us all a favor and begin other pursuits in government. I heard NY state is calling you to govern for them. I say fight for that position instead. NY likes to be governed by lying hypocrites.
John McCain is right we should have corporations handle not only disasters, but the Logistics and non-combat roles of the military, and maybe revenue collection - oh yeah W already tried that. Halliburton and KBR made loads of money, and the IRS actually spent more money on private collection agencies, then the collection agencies brought in.  

John McCain - wrong for the economy, wrong for national defense, wrong for the US

McCain is a lying old wind bag...he's voted for earmarks, but I guess that depends on what the definition of is is...

McCain is not a war hero. He was a POW. How can he have done anything heroic when he was sitting on his butt in a prison cell?

McCain is a flip flopping freak who'll kow-tow to the neo con republican establishment.

McCain is not a maverick, independent, or moderate...he's voted 99% of the time along with his republicans in the Senate.

McCain will destroy our economy...remember his involvement in the KEating 5 S&L scandal of the early 80's that led to the '87 stock market crash and the disasterous recession to follow?

McCain will bring us into WWIII.

McCain is McBush, McSame, Bush III....

ALL DEMOCRATS MUST VOTE DEMOCRAT REGARDLESS WHO OUR NOMINEE IS!
Torpedoyou--- WHERE in that article did he say the relief effort was Democrats' fault? Where? He ATTACKED BUSH and the Congress at the time. Then he said the kind of pork-barrel crap he voted against that was clogging the relief bills is what CURRENT candidates, Obama and Hillary, support all the time. They were the only Democrats he criticized. Do a Ctrl-F, and type "Democrat" --- YOUR POST is the first place it appears.

Amazing how blindness retards some individuals...
I thought McCain said the gays caused Katrina.  
Sounds like the next POTUS....
"When he was asked if it was fair to say that the failure of leadership extended all the way to the Oval Office, McCain said yes."

The failure of leadership extends all the way to the Oval Office and yet you still intend to carry on the policies of Dub?

Yeah, that makes plenty of sense.
Straight talk....yeah right. You won't hear it from this phony! No wasteful spending-at least not in America! He wants to send it all to Iraq for the next hundred years! Mccain is a fraud-bush all over again.
Now, McCain has demonstrated another similarity with Obama, Clinton and Bush. None of them have a clue about what's actually written in Federal Response Plan for dealing with natural disasters.
Senator McCain,

Tax breaks for the rich, that's is your shame. Your poor voting record will result in the same fate as all the other failed Presidential candidates that have gone before you, even to the time of the colonists, whom we hear you've met personally. Boy John, you've been around too long, not to know better than to use a doomed, patented, lazy, repub stump speech, in a 'change' election.

Increasingly, McCain's campaign appears to be in total chaos.
McCain supporters are already using the underhanded Big Tobacco method of securing loyalty from naive Hillary supporters: us against them.

In other words, "If not Hillary, then McCain."

This is pretty transparent to Democrats who realize it is the old-politics way of dividing the nation that GWB used to get elected.  Just remember where that got us.

Obama stands for an end of "us against them," i.e., "red versus blue."  This is why Obama supporters are more likely to vote for Hillary even if she somehow manages to steal the nomination.  We know it is better to support the potential for change than to fight amongst ourselves.

Try these McCain supporters in Hillary clothing trying their best to divide the bolosphere:
Patty,sd,ca
America the Beautiful
Mary, Ohio
The Truth Hurts
(and more)
They are Republicans no matter what they say about supporting Hillary.  We know who you are!

"McCain is no "maverick". He'd be the next in line to tow the neo-con corporate control machine. McCain = Bush III. McCain, another reckless underachiever just like W."

Amen, sir. It's like McCain has integrity and no idea what to do with it.

Obama '08


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=942979

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google