ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



Hillary on Rev. Wright and Bill Clinton

Posted: Monday, April 28, 2008 12:45 PM by Mark Murray

From NBC/NJ's Mike Memoli
GRAHAM, NC -- While saying -- once again -- that she would not have attended a church led by Rev. Jeremiah Wright, Clinton said she regretted that Republicans have “politicized” the matter and criticized McCain for not acting more strongly to put a stop to ads by local Republicans that invoke Obama’s former pastor.

“I believe that if Senator McCain was serious, he would do more than send a letter,” Clinton told reporters this morning. “He is the putative nominee. I think he could very clearly tell the North Carolina party, tell the Mississippi party that he would not tolerate to those kinds of advertisements and I am waiting to see whether he does that.”

Asked later whether new public comments from Wright, particularly those mocking Presidents Kennedy and Johnson, reflected on Obama, Clinton was terse, saying only: “You’ll have to ask him that.”

Clinton also was asked about reports that her husband has seized a larger role in the campaign. “I’m very proud to the role my husband is playing in the campaign,” she said. “I think it’s very helpful to have the only successful two-term Democratic president since Franklin Roosevelt campaign for me.”

But she did not answer -- even in a follow up -- concerns that have been raised by some party leaders, most notably Rep. Jim Clyburn, that some of his public comments are having a detrimental role.

In addition, Clinton continued to say that the prolonged nomination contest is good for the party, and called on the Democratic Party to move quickly to resolve the status of delegates from Michigan and Florida. “I’ve thought this has been good for the Democratic Party, and I think that the excitement that we’ve seen in the states since the last couple of contests has been terrifically encouraging,” she said. “We’re gonna go through these next contests, we’re gonna see where we end up. And we’ll take stock of where we are after they finish. But I also believe we’ve gotta resolve Michigan and Florida.”

The press avail came in the same fire station where Clinton earlier spoke about her plan for a gas-tax holiday to ease the impact of escalating gas prices. “Everything is headed in the wrong direction,” she said, noting rising costs and declining incomes. “It feels like people are just, you know, running in place. And it’s not just the morning commute. It is a toll that is basically put on each and every person who drives anywhere.”

McCain has also proposed a gas tax holiday. But the Clinton campaign emphasizes that his plan is not funded, while hers would offset the loss of revenues by imposing a temporary windfall profits tax on oil companies. “While we are seeing these high gas prices, the oil companies are enjoying record profits,” she said. “Last year Exxon Mobil had $40 billion in profits. So you paid through the roof and they made out like bandits.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

It is time for the Republican-controlled Media to give this   Wright controversy some fairness and enquire of Hillary Clinton and her surrogates the following:  Is it true that, (1)  Hillary surrogate, Congresswoman Shiela Jackson Lee, is also a devotee of Rev. Dr. Jeremiah Wright; that he's been preaching at her home church, where she is actively involved, annually for the past 15 years and has an open invitation to return, and, that she sat in the pews for his visits and did not bat an eye?

Is it true that (2) Hillary surrogate, Rev. Marcia Dyson was not only a longtime member of Trinity United Church of Christ but also still considers Rev. Jeremiah A. Wright her pastor? That Rev. Marcia Dyson's seminary education, in part, was sponsored by Trinity UCC and encouraged by Rev. Wright? And was it  not at Trinity were she first met her husband, Rev. Dr. Michael Dyson, who's been very vocal in his defense of Rev. Wright.?

And, lastly of Hillary Clinton, that if Rev. Wright would not have been her Pastor, then why did she and Bill when going through Impeachment, turn to Rev. Wright for Prayer and Support and invite him to the White House?  These things should be asked and answered.

Comments mocking JFK and LBJ?? Mike Memoli and I didn't listen to the same speech......once again the MSM zeros in on a small soundbite to make a story that ISN'T there!
She would not have continued to attend Wright's church, but she had no problem going to work for communists:

http://www.thenation.com/doc/20080505/hayden
Hillary Clinton going after McCain on Rev. Wright? Are you kidding me? The Clintons are coming up with new ways of playing both sides on a weekly basis.
A gas tax holiday will only INCREASE the price of oil by spurring demand higher this summer. We need to find ways to REDUCE our dependency on oil. Knee-jerk reactions will not help. Long-term policy will.
Senator Clinton expects us to believe that her "minor marital disagreements" with Bill Clinton about such things as Colombia, NAFTA, China (all of which have put millions of dollars into her personal bank account) would have no influence on her presidency.  Yet when Bill Clinton is unhappy with how the campaign is going, he steps in, brings his own people and changes the strategy.  

She really does think we're idiots.

With regard to her ridiculous "he never would been my pastor" nonsense - you've been a whole lot closer to some pretty shady figures in your life than Reverend Wright, Senator Clinton.  We are not as stupid as you think we are.
She criticized the republicans for "politicizing" the Wright issue?! Is the sniper fire still ringing in her ears!?
Yeah she "would never" attend Wright's church but she would if it sealed the nomination for her as she and her crazy husband has gone to other black churches to pander to them.
I have to admit,  until yesterday I had never heard an entire sermon by the Reverend Wright. I listened to him for about 15 minutes, about as much as I could take. But I have to tell you, he sounds like a stand up comedian. Actually, he reminds me a lot of George Carlin. The way he discusses language and human behavior. How does this guy get so much play in the media? He's a joke...
Does Rev Wright really matter?
The headlines should read: “If Obama splits the remaining 408 delegates with Senator Clinton, he will need only 89 of 292 super delegates to reach 2025.”
The math is simple and the constant discussion about who wins a debate or a primary or what Rev Wright said is irrelevant.  
The questions should be like:
“will the current kitchen sink approach yield 50% of the remaining primary delegates and 223 of 292 remaining super delegates?”
“Will the Clinton attacks get the numbers required?”
“Or will the results be strictly divisive to the dems?”

Using your numbers:
Obama Clinton
Total Delegates
To Date, Incl Supers 1732     1598

Remaining Primaries (408)
If split 50% each  204   204

Total 1936    1802

Uncommitted supers (292)
 Needed for 2025   89      223
I sent Obama's campaign $50 after hearing Rev Wright.    He is the only one willing to tell the truth about Washington and the Media!   He held up the mirror for us to take a look and it was not pretty.   Please don’t crucify Rev Wright as we did Jesus. Clinton needs to look into that mirror.
Have any people yet realized that Jeremiah Wright has probably been paid a substantial amount of money by the Clinton campaign to be speaking out now?  No one will be able to pin it on the Clintons . . . but I believe that this is the case.  Please do not use my name . . . but I would enjoy hearing comments from Chris Matthews.
"Asked later whether new public comments from Wright, particularly those mocking Presidents Kennedy and Johnson, reflected on Obama..."

Wasn't Rev. Wright referring to the different ways people speak in this country? Wasn't it meant in a humorous way?

Comment I came across this morning: Jefferson had slaves.

Most people aren't aware of this fact I'm sure. We glorify certain Americans and beat down others.

The African Americans lost a lot of lives & a lot of blood for every step forward they took.

The history books need to change - we need to be more honest about our history.
Did she mention that is was nice to have the only impeached President on her side since Andrew Johnson?
That would put it more in context.
How can Hillary claim that the Republicans politisized the Rev. Wright comments?  She brings it up every chance she gets.  Also, there are Democrats in Florida who feel that the candidates need to play by the agreed upon rules.  Stop trying to deceive everyone Hillary and end this contest.
Here is the reason for the deafening MSM silence last Saturday after Bill Moyer's interview with Wright:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dave-winer/why-is-it-so-quiet-after_b_98763.html
OUR TIME HAS COME FOR DEMOCRATS TO FULLY SUPPORT SENATOR CLINTON TO WIN IN NOV.

VOTERS ARE SICK OF THE MEDIA EXCUSING OBAMA NO MATTER WHAT HE DOES, HIS AWFUL SENATE RECORD, CORRUPT FINANCIAL BACKERS, TERRORIST CONNECTIONS OR WHO HE OFFENDS!!!!
Obama camp makes excuses for no-shows in Philly's black neighborhoods! Obamas view of Americans is extremely disturbing!

http://www.theproblemwithobama.com/

http://truthinconviction.us/weblog.php?id=3


VOTERS DEMAND OBAMA DROP OUT NOW, WITH ALL THE NEW POLITICAL DAMAGING STUFF COMING FROM HIM AND MICHELLE OBAMA, IN ADDITION TO WRIGHTS CONTINUED OBAMA DEFENDED ATTACKS ON WHITE AMERICA. HE WILL SURLY LOOSE THE GENERAL ELECTION FOR DEMOCRATS.
Obama looses another pledged delegate!
Obama supporter has given up her role as pledged delegate after her “unacceptable”  description of  PA neighbor children as “monkeys,” because they were climbing in trees.
Linda Ramirez-Sliwinski, an a Hispanic trustee for the Village of Carpentersville, Ill., was accused of racism following the interaction with her African-American neighbors.
Obama Connection to Terrorists Revealed National Association of Chiefs of Police.  http://www.theconservativevoice.com/article/31408.html

Obama has a dual citizenship with Kenya Al-Qaeda chief Osama bin Laden would be praying for an Obama victory because it would help the militants win in Iraq.  Citizen Wells 3/08

Memories of Obama's recent racial stereotype of the 'typical White person' are still fresh. Add to this now his view of the 'typical small town person.' Obama is quoted as disparaging residents of small towns in Pennsylvania as being “like a lot of small towns in the Midwest” where “it's not surprising then they get bitter, they cling to guns or religion or antipathy to people who aren't like them or anti-immigrant sentiment or anti-trade sentiment as a way to explain their frustrations.”

Obama is unapologetic, even dissing of voters in Florida and Michigan one has to wonder what groups of Americans he really respects?

Racist wife, Michelle, saying she was proud of America "for the first time" only because of her husband's presidential run.

Obama explained he doesn't wear an American flag lapel pin or hold his hands to his heart during the Pledge of Allegiance because it is a substitute for patriotism,

Obama confirms his own moral obliviousness and he seems to have disdain for those who are troubled by his own unwillingness to break with The Great White hater Rev Wright

Rev Wright says you don't have to wait for the afterlife for the mansion on the hilltop, he’s right! To shut him up Trinity United Church of Christ is building Rev. Wright a $1 mil house on a lot that was purchased for $345,000. According to federal income tax return Obama gave $222,500

Wright continues his Obama supported attacks on non-blacks Wright states Jesus death on the cross was a public lynching Italian style.

Obamas senate record shows he infact did support the war voted against bringing America's troops home, voted for war appropriations giving our money to Halliburton and Blackwater, voted with Bush/Chaney latest bit of posturing S433 to suspend any troop withdrawal, if not suspended, keeps the troops in Iraq for a long time to come.

Washington Post- Fact Check- Senator Obama CAUGHT LYING about Kennedy Role in Helping His Father Contrary to Obama's claims in speeches Kennedy family did not.

Chicago Daily Herald- Obama refers to himself as 'a constitutional law professor on the campaign trail. TRUTH: He never held any such title!

The Democratic candidate Obama and his wife earned $4.2 million last year -- four times as much as they had in 2006. Made $240,370 in charitable contributions. Their largest gifts were to the United Negro College Fund ($50,000), the international relief organization CARE ($35,000) and Trinity United Church of Christ in Chicago ($26,270). The Obamas contributed just $6 in 2007 to the federal fund that provides public financing for presidential campaigns in exchange for limits on spending. Not so struggling middle class and Michelle says they struggle to pay for piano lessons.  


What?? Reverend Wright was not "mocking" presidents Kennedy and Johnson (why not mention he was a cardiopulmonary technician SERVING Johnson after he VOLUNTEERED for the military, Chuck?).  He good-naturedly pointed out that NONE OF US in the United States speaks true "English," and while African American kids are often singled out as speaking incorrectly, the Boston and Texas accents of two of our former presidents shows that NO ONE speaks the same way.  What in the world are you talking about??  Do you realize what you're doing?  I'm starting to sense something sinister in your motives that I never sensed before--I used to rely on this blog for clear-eyed reason (maybe I was dumb, which is quite possible).  I hope the sheep don't rely on the media for information to determine something as important as this election. God help us all.
Hillary ..Think about the way you answer questions relating to Obama.
You wonder why you've lost the AA support.
That's rich; Clinton defending Obama....
Must e something in the water....

Hillary lies again.....
Gasoline prices are based on supply and demand.....
Hillary can flap her gums about taking money away from the gas and oil companies all she wants.  All that will do is drive the prices up to $6.00 a gallon.  While having a tax holiday is always a good thing, once again Hillary misses the point.  We need to drill in ANWAR and Florida and California and build more refineries.  But thanks to the Liberals, we have higher gas prices.
What's interesting is that Obama has been portrayed as a uniter, a healer, a negotiator, and a visionary. Yet, the people that are his friends, mentors, pastors, associates, and business partners are the biggest dividers, haters, racists, and criminals this country has ever seen.
"Clinton said she regretted that Republicans have “politicized” the matter and criticized McCain for not acting more strongly to put a stop to ads by local Republicans that invoke Obama’s former pastor."

OMG - who is this woman think she's fooling?


"But she did not answer -- even in a follow up -- concerns that have been raised by some party leaders, most notably Rep. Jim Clyburn, that some of his public comments are having a detrimental role. "

Really? The silence is telling, isn't it?


Do you really want to resolve FL and MI?  How about you spend some of your $109M for a revote?  Yeah, that's what I thought.
Her hands are every bit as dirty as the Republican Party on this.
Chuck you now are acting and talking like CNN and Fox.  When will you stop the Wright stories both in First Read and on TV?  I get it slow news day????Welcome to the gutter.

Bob, Chicago
The Gas Tax Holiday is stupid.

It was stupid when McSame proposed it and it's stupid now that Senator Clinton is proposing it.  The price drop will be artificial, negligible and temporary.
The real wright statement:
I am sorry your local political analysts and your neighboring county executives think my being here is polarizing and my sermons are divisive, but I'm not here to address an analyst's opinion or a county executive's point of view. I am here to address your 2008 theme, and I stand here as one representative of the African American religious tradition which works in concert with other faith traditions, believing as we work together that a change is going to come.

On that point, about other faith traditions, in addition to Pastor Anthony, Pastor Nicholas Hood (ph), Pastor Charles Adams (ph), Pastor William Revelly (ph), Pastor James Perkins (ph), Pastor Wilma Rudolph (ph), Pastor Holly (ph) who is suffering from a stroke, Father Michael Flager (ph), Father Jeremy Tobin (ph), Pastor Dee Dee Coleman (ph), Dr. Georgia Hill (ph) and Reverend Lonnie Peak (ph), I would also like to thank Sister Melanie Marah (ph), the former executive director of the Chicago chapter of the American Jewish Committee and the current executive director of the Washington, D.C., chapter of the American Jewish committee. I would like to thank my good friend and Jewish author Tim Wise for his support, and I would like to offer a special shookran (ph) to Imam Muhammad Ali Ilakhi (ph) of the Islamic House of Wisdom in Dearborn Heights for his courage, his conviction and his support.

The support of the Jewish community, the Muslim community, and the Christian community, Protestant and Catholic, is in concert with the credo of the NAACP and a definite sign that a change is definitely going to come. An additional special thank you is offered to Soledad O'Brien for CNN's outstanding "Black in America" and my long-term friend Roland Martin.

Democrats cannot come to terms with the fact that they are biggest dividers and racists in this country. They all seem to have this 'white guilt' that they are all trying to compensate for, and they never seem to get it right.
First read: i think I need to find a new blog site. One that has more relevant qusetions to ask the politicians and one that is less up Hillary's butt!!!!
Be more objective and show the whole speech not just sound bites or at least put it in context. And QUIT demonizing Rev. Wright. If you can not do thatam gonna have to boycott. You are getting ridiculous. i now see why Jaycee form Ventura and other good commenters are avoiding the site.
Hillary just hates it when people politicize things!  She would never do that.

Michigan and Florida were resolved when she signed the documents stating that they would not count.

I am amazed that she cannot close the deal.  A year ago, the idea of Obama beating her for the nomination would have been a joke.  The media are giving her a free ride.  They don't even ask her about Peter Paul.  If Obama was the defendant in that case, they would crucify him.

Obama in 2008.  Integrity matters and the Clintons have none.  Time to go furniture shopping, Hillary!  Looks like you won't be stealing any more from the White House!
How are Wright's jokes about Kennedy and Johnson a reflection on Obama at all?  Could someone in the media ask a real question instead of trying to instigate sniping comments between the candidates.  What a joke of a question.  What are they teaching in journalism schools?  
Didn't Hillary say during the 2006 elections "Elect Democrats to congress, and gas prices will go down!"?

Still waiting Hillary.
Hey Paul Krugman!
When are you going to add Hillary Clinton to your Monday  article?
President Clinton will not cause anything detrimental to Hillary's campaign as he has a similar relationship with the media as Senator McCain. His good-natured stories help give him a free pass. And since Senator Clinton complained during a debate on how she is picked on, she now has nearly a free pass. Good job, MSNBC.
Temporary windfall tax.....where have I heard that before?

Obama '08
At 18 cents a gallon, the savings on one 15 gallon tank of gas is about $2.70.  The fill-up would be between $45 and $60.  The almost $3 goes towards the repair and inspection of bridges, tunnels and roads. My portion of the savings would be about $27 for the entire summer.  I think that the $27 is better spent on infrastructure than at the local Walmart.  

Just my two cents worth.

Vote with your head, vote for the economy, vote for jobs.

Vote Democratic 2008 -- don't let the corporations and their Republican stooges win again.  
Don't blame Mr.McCain for Obamas rev. we all heard his hate today..you should have stated in church Barack
If Hillary thinks this cat fight between Obama and her is good for the Democratic party, then she is not qualified to run a lemonade stand, let alone the country.
Senator Clinton DID attend Church services led by Reverend Wright on at least one occasion and neither did she get up and walk out, nor did she scold Reverend Wright for his sermon.  She and her husband also invited Reverend Wright to the White House and prayed with him.  This is the height of hypocrisy and what is more despicable is that she first said these things to Richard Mellon Scaiffe (the man who IS the godfather of that vast right-wing conspiracy Senator Clinton used to be so angry about).

Senator McCain has behaved with more dignity than Senator Clinton on this issue as has Governor Huckabee (who said he would not want his parishioners held to every word he had spoken-- wise man, Gov. Huckabee).  

Senator Clinton has lost all respect I had for her.  I don't believe she has any racial animosities, but I do believe she is attempting to stir the racial pot and wake up sleeping fears any way she can in the hopes that it will benefit her politically.  This is unbelievably unethical and not at all good for this Country.  We have made so much progress and it is inconceivable to me that anyone (much less a Democrat like Senator Clinton) would even consider throwing this progress away for the sake of political gain.

I am white, not close to being young and a woman.  I seriously wish it was not necessary to identify myself in this manner.  Reverend Wright is his own unique person-- as is Senator Obama.  Reverend Wright is not seeking any office.  AND Senator Clinton if she has any morals left should stand up for the African American Church tradition, instead of attempting to use this for her own political gain.

The ends do not justify the means, unless you accept the twisting of your soul that your unethical, immoral means cause.  In this Country, as Justice Louis Brandeis said -- to keep our Country free, "liberty must be the ends and liberty must be the means."  Anyone still capable of hearing TRUTH amidst all of this candidate preference, please heed Justice Brandeis' words as they are as true today as they were in his own time.

Yes we can!  And if we don't, goodbye to healthcare reform, hello to global warming, goodbye to good public education and we may be in World War III with Iran with either Senators Clinton or McCain.  
Hillary Clinton is a member of "The Family".  The press should be asking why she supports, along with McCain chief strategist Charlie Black to coronation of Rev. Moon as the King of America?
Yep. Hillary is a Moonie.
As soon as Obama wins the nomination, Hillary will file for divorce.
The Clinton's are no friends of America. I was glad when they left office. I have no idea why they are trying to kill the Democratic party except they have gotten all the money anyone could spend in one lifetime and now they are bored and want something else. What is wrong with these people? We should have know when on the last day of office, Bill Clinton pardoned the FLAners. They are terrorists who killed innocent people in New York City. Oh, by the way, Hillary was running for New York Senate so she could run for president later. Oh, by the way, there are one and a half million PUerto Ricans in New York City who now would vote for her. Play a race card? What about the race card that the Clinton's played on Bill's last day in office to gain the Puerto Rican vote? Come on people, HRC in not your friend. She does not care for the Democratic party. She ought to listen to Reverend Wright and start seeing others as somewhat valuable as people other than just voters.
Oh stop flapping your jaws about Bill.
The rev'd up Wright is the gift that keeps on giving!
I say the man is beyond belief, Barry has to wonder what the hell is happening?
Is this a path of destruction Wright has planned for BO?
Seems he is destroying the very fabric of Barry's grab for the office next to god himself! Jealous Wright?
Where is his next speech? Is he a decoy? Is he Bi polar?
NO REAL NEWS and no real surprises likely in the next month of the vote.  Someone will win IN narrowly, and the rest are pre-determined.  Obama needs a big endorsement, or a Hillary gaff, so the media has something advantageous to him to chew upon.
Again I say Obama MUST DISOWN HIMSELF NOW.

This Narcissistic Pastor will be the death of Obama.

Not happy
With the amount of fighting betwwen CLinton and Obama, you'd think that they had man differences in their view, policies, and outlook. But they don't! They agree on most everything. Just think how much political blood would be spilled if they did differ.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=952278

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google