ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Hillary as Teddy Roosevelt?

Posted: Wednesday, April 30, 2008 2:54 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ’s Mike Memoli
SOUTH BEND, Ind. -- Hillary Clinton portrayed herself as a modern-day Teddy Roosevelt this morning, saying she’d build the political will to take on oil companies as president.

“At the turn of the last century, Teddy Roosevelt took on the oil companies,” she said at the Deluxe Sheet Metal factory this morning. “We need a president who will take on the oil companies again, and I will do that. I will take away their tax subsidies. They don’t need them to make these outrageous profits.”

All week, Clinton has been beating the drum on her plan for a gas tax holiday. Today she used some different language on the issue, not calling it a tax holiday but saying she wanted “the oil companies to pay the federal gas tax this summer.”

She also criticized McCain when asked about his statement that he’d use treasury funds to replace revenues the tax provides for the highway trust fund.

“I think that’s a typical Republican response: don’t pay for anything,” she said of McCain’s plan. “We haven’t paid for the war in Iraq; we haven’t paid for the tax cuts for the wealthy, so now we’re not going to pay to replenish the Highway Trust Fund. … He is just driving us deeper and deeper into deficit and debt.”

And she continued to knock Obama for, in her view, ignoring the short-term solution to the price crunch, adding that she hopes voters will consider this next Tuesday.

“I have no illusions about how difficult this would be, but you got to start somewhere,” she said. “Going after the oil companies, which we’re going to have to do in order take on our energy challenges and to get back into some balance in this country economically … means that we gotta start now to build the political momentum. I want this to be a voting issue. I hope people in Indiana and North Carolina on Tuesday will vote for me, because I’m willing to take on the oil companies.”

Clinton took a few questions from reporters after her remarks, but carefully dodged one about Obama’s comments yesterday distancing himself from the Rev. Jeremiah Wright. (She addresses it on Bill O’Reilly tonight, calling Wright’s comments “offensive” and “outrageous.”)

“You know what? I wanted to call on somebody from Indiana,” she said, after hearing the start of the question. “I was looking for a hand from Indiana.”

Clinton started her morning with a carefully choreographed photo op, commuting to work with Jason Wilfing, an employee of the Deluxe factory, stopping for gas along the way. After the tank filled at the Marathon station, Clinton acknowledged that she hasn’t pumped gas herself in some time.

“I have a unique situation,” she said, noting her Secret Service protection. “But I sure have heard a lot from so many people about what it costs them to buy gas, and you know, what we were just talking about is how the price of petroleum, as it goes up, everything else goes up.”

Clinton picked up the tab for the $63 fill-up, got a French Vanilla cappuccino inside the mini mart, and then got back in the Ford F-250 pickup Wilfing borrowed from his boss for the drive to get work. Wilfing’s own pick-up did not meet Secret Service specs for the drive, which also included Clinton’s traveling aide and an armed agent.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Can someone please explain how Hillary Clinton will be in a position to remove a gas tax for the summer of 2008. She is still running for the Democratic nomination. She isn't going to be putting any policies into place this summer. She is blabbering this all over like it is some grand policy she will be putting into place.
Why isn't this question being asked?
Oil is not well in the Hillary camp. Put a cap on it Hillary and go home.
I have no doubt that Clinton will face the oil companies.  It's time someone did.  And I think she's tough enough to make some headway.  I still don't know about Obama.  'Please be good Americans' to the companies just doesn't seem enough.
Billary has a point...the new bushleague republicans are borrow and spenders...they cut taxes and encouraged americans to become debtors in the name of patriotism...
THE TURN OUT OF NEW VOTER FOR THE DEMOCRATS IS GREAT!
With that said:
WE WANT SOMETHING NEW AND NOT RUINED BY WASHINGTON

I really don`t know why the media insist that if HRC steals the nomination that Obama`s supporters will vote for her and that if Obama WINS the nomination that HRC supporters will not vote for him .


Well if HRC somehow steals this from Obama, the turn out of the democratic voters that the party are getting now will be far less for the general  election as 90% of the Obama supporters will not even show up to vote, black or white. Thus we have another republican in the white house.

NONE OF US WANTS TO SEE THE Clintons BACK IN THE WHITE HOUSE. DON`T THEY GET IT YET!!

So you see while HRC thinks that she has Obama supporters for the general election she really doesn`t.
I for one will not be voting if HRC steals this by cheating and LYING.

So says a lot of the people I have conversed with and general everyday talk. These people Are not friends of mine nor do I see them on a daily basis.
These are people that I run into with my everyday chores such as going to stores, cleaners, parks with the kids & to fill my gas tank.
A lot of these people believe that she has already ruin the party chances this fall and I think that they are right,  HRC  has  every right to keep running but the way it`s looking now it is not good for the party.

NONE OF US WANTS TO SEE THE Clintons BACK IN THE WHITE HOUSE. DON`T THEY GET IT YET!!

GO OBAMA '08
I have already posted a comment but don't see it yet. It was about giving us a break this summer. Let Hilary go after the Oil companies. They haven't built an oil refinery in the United States for 30 years.
THE TURN OUT OF NEW VOTER FOR THE DEMOCRATS IS GREAT!
With that said:
WE WANT SOMETHING NEW AND NOT RUINED BY WASHINGTON

I really don`t know why the media insist that if HRC steals the nomination that Obama`s supporters will vote for her and that if Obama WINS the nomination that HRC supporters will not vote for him .


Well if HRC somehow steals this from Obama, the turn out of the democratic voters that the party are getting now will be far less for the general  election as 90% of the Obama supporters will not even show up to vote, black or white. Thus we have another republican in the white house.

NONE OF US WANTS TO SEE THE Clintons BACK IN THE WHITE HOUSE. DON`T THEY GET IT YET!!

So you see while HRC thinks that she has Obama supporters for the general election she really doesn`t.
I for one will not be voting if HRC steals this by cheating and LYING.

So says a lot of the people I have conversed with and general everyday talk. These people Are not friends of mine nor do I see them on a daily basis.
These are people that I run into with my everyday chores such as going to stores, cleaners, parks with the kids & to fill my gas tank.
A lot of these people believe that she has already ruin the party chances this fall and I think that they are right,  HRC  has  every right to keep running but the way it`s looking now it is not good for the party.

NONE OF US WANTS TO SEE THE Clintons BACK IN THE WHITE HOUSE. DON`T THEY GET IT YET!!

GO OBAMA '08
When will Hillary understand the large profits are there due to the two large companies forming one company.  She never mentions they spend billions every year on R @ D.  A profit margin of 8.3% is low in our country.  how many jobs would be lost the way she plans on attcking them.  She is a sad joke as she panders.
Hillary is too much- her cappucino?- he has to borrow a truck?- she must have a traveling aide?  Too, too much...

She's trying to find better ways to phrase the horrible gas tax holiday because she is taking heat (appropriate heat)for promoting such an asinine idea.
Hillary who stormed the tarmac in Bosnia comparing herself to Teddy Roosevelt. She has triangulated herself more then Sybil did with all of her personalities. As it stands she is losing the superdelegate pickups and has already lost the elected delegates and the popular vote , not counting Fl and MI. As to the derogatory comments(Obamabots) at least we can add. As to the Gas Holiday how are you going to get it passed with a new windfall profits tax by summer with George Bush signing it. This is the ultimate pander sound like you are leading when you have no say or influence in the outcome.  What kind of judgement is this?  
Did you guys hear? OJ got away with murder!
as long as she grows a mustache like teddy, then i'll vote for her
"Clinton acknowledged that she hasn’t pumped gas herself in some time."

the last time was when she put gas in her 'tank' as she headed into Bosnia......
Whatever Hillary....just follow the wind...
hillary's economic plans are very scary indeed
I was a hillary Supporter until last month. She has totally lost me now.There is no question that I will not vote for her in the general election if she is there.  She is really the one who will do anything , say anything to get elected.
Hillary definitely "gets it" now.

You Go Hill!
She has the power to fix everything. Must be nice to be the smartest person in the world. Wait, i'm sure she'll be offended by that... I mean the smartest person in the universe. Sorry martians.

GET REAL - OBAMA '08
Yes Hillary and Teddy Roosevelt. I just have one question will the real Hilary please stand up. Hey I said real! No not the senator from New York, Daughter of PA neither the hick from AR. Oh well who cares she will say and do anything to get nominated. Ok its Teddy Roosevelt now. Oops did the president just do a complete turn in his grave.
Is there a backroom deal in place for Hillary Clinton to be John McCain's running mate if she doesn't win the Democratic nomination.
Reasons:
1)The number 2 man/woman on the ticket is suppose to take out the opponent, while the number 1 man stay above board.
2)Hillary Clinton grew up as a Republican (so the Republican way of doing things is must natural to her).
3)Hillary Clinton for the past several months have been saying that only her and McCain are ready to be President.
4)The racial divide is a page from the Republican playbook.
Do you need more?
Good or Bad,
We know what we are getting with Hillary, She loves this country, she will fight for us and she won't give up on us!!! No one really knows what Barack is thinking... Twenty years being close to someone and you don't know how they feel about issues, if he wasn't there his wife and kids were and they heard. And how is that for judgement, let your kids hear this hate every Sunday!!!

Sorry, I will take the few bad things you say about Hillary, because I know where she stands...With Us.
People will grasp at anything to for fill their own selfish satisfaction.  We are going to be so in trouble with Sen Clinton.  Is this a lie or the truth? Don't know do we?  Keep listening to Sen Clinton we will all be s*ckers.
"Clinton acknowledged that she hasn’t pumped gas herself in some time."

the last time was when she put gas in her 'tank' as she headed into Bosnia......
i dont see any teddy in her... maybe some elenor. definitly not teddy.
The Hillary/TR analogy is apt if you mean the 1912 Roosevelt who ruptured his own party and let Wilson win the White House for the other side.
Well if Barack Obama can compare himself to JFK, MLK, RFK and Abraham Lincoln for no reason at all, with little to zero merit backing it up...well, seeing how Senator Clinton is actually serious about taking on the oil companies then the "vague comparison is just fine.
However you want to turn it into a snide attack on her, AS USUAL. Basically all she said is that no one SINCE Teddy has taken on the oil companies, so be it, it's true. She didn't say that SHE WAS HIM.

Unlike Obama, Clinton has humility and is humble instead of being overly cocky, arrogant and condescending to America.

Obama instead likes to think himself some genius when he hasn't done much of anything at all and doesn't promise much of anything at all either. Yet no one questioned him when he compared himself to GREAT LEADERS. It's so absurd.
no matter what, the american people just can't get enough of these LIES, they still for some odd reason thinks that Clinton is the better candidate!

COME ON AMERICA, WAKE UP,

OBAMA "08"


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=963809

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google