ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Hillary as Goldilocks

Posted: Thursday, May 01, 2008 2:59 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ’s Mike Memoli
BROWNSBURG, Ind. -- Hillary Clinton this morning planted herself in the middle of the three presidential hopefuls when it comes to gas tax plans, joking, “I sometimes feel like the Goldilocks of this campaign.”
 
“You know, not too much, not too little, just right,” she said, after saying Barack Obama viewed a holiday as a “gimmick,” while McCain does not fund his plan.
 
Clinton was answering a question about how to address the high price of oil, and if there was a longer-term solution to the problem than her gas tax plan.
 
“Nobody is arguing it's an answer,” she said. “But, you know what it says -- and boy, we haven't heard this in a long time. It says, guess what? We’re paying attention to how much you are suffering with these increased costs.”
 
Clinton actually began the event by pointing out that it was the National Day of Prayer.
 
“I was privileged before I came in to meet with a group of ministers who prayed with me. And I am very grateful for that,” she said. “I am obviously sustained and strengthened every day by my faith. But it is important that we all recognize that praying for our country, praying for those in positions of authority, is something that people of faith are really called upon to do.”
 
Calling attention to her faith and mentioning the ministers, whether intentionally or not, provided a subtle reference to the Jeremiah Wright flare up. Clinton has made few comments about it of late, most notably in last night’s interview when pressed by Bill O’Reilly.
 
This morning’s event, which also featured the candidate’s mother and daughter, was focused on Clinton’s plan to help families deal with issues related to child care and senior care. She has proposed a $3,000 care-giving tax credit and long-term care insurance tax credit, among other plans.
 
“I think it is harder raising children today than it was even when I was raising my daughter,” she said. “The American family has to adjust and adapt while maintaining our values, and passing those on to the next generation.”

Clinton actually went to the bullpen and called on her daughter at one point to help explain her health-care policy, saying her voice was “getting a little bit raspy.”

Chelsea did so, saying that she was proud her mother “stood up for universal health care coverage before it was popular,” but also “learned from her experiences.”
 
“If you do like your health insurance you can keep it,” she said. “That’s one of the things she learned in ’93 and ’94. I know parents are happy when we learn our lessons, but kids are happy when our parents learn lessons, too.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Who is she kidding?? She hasn't even pumped gas into a car since the early 90s!! Why don't voters see her for the fraud that she is??
I like the comparison... the old goldilocks stole porridge, this goldilocks is looking to steal votes in states where candidates weren't even on the ticket
Hillary is more "Huff 'n Puff" than Goldilocks.
CAN SOMEONE TELL ME WHAT SOLUTION HAS OBAMA OFFERED SO FAR ABOUT THE GAS PRICES?

Is it a matter of waiting for Hilary to come up with something once again then tweak it for his own gains?

Too busy correcting his screw ups? Too busy trying to win to actually focus on real issues?

It is a fact that Hilary attended more to her duties as a Senator than Obama or McCain. So who truly and legitimately cares for the American people?

Now that's not a gimmick. Reacting when it suits you is - as in disown is Pastor when it's convenient.

MSNBC please post this.

Didn't Goldilocks sashay into someone else's house,
  use their things, eat their food??? Yup. Just
like the freeloading, arrogant Clintons.
Good thing it was easier raising children when Chelsea was little. She actually might have had to spend more
time with her instead of the housekeepers and nannies.
ugghhh - she is really is an embarrassment to all women, everywhere, by now.  what a disappointment.
One thing I don't quite get on the gas tax issue is what exactly she's doing to get such a bill passed?  Presumably, since she's arguing for putting THIS summer's gas tax on hold, then you'd need some sort of legislation to do it with.  She'd need to go out and find support for BOTH the gas tax holiday AND the windfall oil tax, AND get it passed (and signed by the president) by June 1.

Has anyone actually asked Clinton how she plans to accomplish this in a month?  Otherwise, this isn't just a BIG pander, it's the ULTIMATE pander.
Oh my god is she clinging to guns and religion?

Obama '08
Wasn't Goldilocks devoured at the end of the story?
At least she is talking about the issues and how she will solve them.

Barack just talks about change.  
Her gas plan IS a gimmick - it will be incredibly difficult to pass a windfall tax on the oil companies through Congress...and she KNOWS this. The Presidency is NOT a monarchy or a dictatorship - she would need to get these things through Congress -

Stop and THINK People!

1) If both the gas tax vacation and that windfall tax were included in the same bill - the winfall tax would almost certainly be either amended OUT all together OR amended to the point that it wouldn't pay for the gas tax break.

2) If two separate bills were introduced - the liklihood is that the gas tax break may pass - but the windfall tax would NOT or it would be amended to the point that it would not make up the money the gas tax break would lose.

3) In the unlikely event that both passed - wouldn't a windfall tax be better spent to create the green jobs all the candidates are talking about - Rather than to backfill money lost through her gas tax break.

4) Reinstating the Gas tax would be painful for everyone b/c the price of gas - after the holiday would jump and this would be politically unpopular

5) Without the money brought in by the gas tax - our crumbling infrastructure suffers more and we LOSE jobs.

There are several other arguments against this - but it is CLEARLY PANDERING - People need to THINK!!!!! Don't let Hillary (or McCain or Obama - for that matter) Play you for a fool - use your common sense before you vote....
Was Rev. wright invloved with the National Day of Prayer?
Hillary is embarrassing me as a Democrat. The superdelegates need to jump in and tell her to get the hell out.

Just because her base is stupid doesn't mean the rest of us are.
HRC is not in the White House and she already has a foreign policy blunder.  She wanted to appear tough, but now she appears to have egg in her face.  That's what happens when you talk or act without considering all the consequences.  Bad judgement!  In return, Iran is probably going to increase its support of terrorists in Iraq.

MSNBC, report what the others are reporting not just Wright.

http://www.cnn.com/2008/POLITICS/05/01/clinton.iran/index.html

http://elections.foxnews.com/2008/04/30/iran-condemns-clinton-for-threatening-to-attack/

Paul v. Clinton, MSNBC where is it?

HRC’s ties to black revolutionaries while at Yale, MSNBC where is it?

HCR criticizes Indiana plant closings which Bill approved while in office, MSNBC where is it?

http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/Vote2008/story?id=4757257&page=1
She's so disingenuous.  If she cares so much about her precious gas tax plan, why hasn't she submitted a bill in the Senate for it like John McCain has?  Oh, that's right, she is only pandering for votes.  She knows she'll never have to actually deliver on those promises because by time the Election is over the "holiday" will have passed.
Go away already clinton you can FOOL some people sometime BUT you cant fool all of the people all time
We all know you are DISHONEST
This story will end nicely.

Goldilocks ends up being mauled and eaten by the bears when she is dazed after being filled up with porridge (PA win).
I pray everyday that people like you Hillary do not become president because your record in helping the middle class is awful. You are devious, flip flopper and do not stand on principle. I am seeking a president who will stand up and defend the working class from being shafted due to NAFTA and the gas tax holiday which you support. I also want a president who speaks about peace instead of obilerating countries which you support.
Wow! I can see the 1st 3 comments are full of real substance! Way to make intelligent arguments Obama-trons!
Clinton = Pinnochio.
As for electability, a recent ABC News/Washington Post poll found nearly 60 percent of voters think Hillary is dishonest. ---Think about that ---  Only 4 in 10 voters do not think she lies when she needs to.  A majority hold an unfavorable view of her.  Will those numbers improve if she wins the nomination and Republicans resurrect the Clinton scandals, like the Bill Clinton sexual affairs and her Bosnia lie?

The Clintons were a disaster for the Democratic party throughout the 1990s.  When Bill Clinton became president, Democrats were a congressional majority, with 258 seats in the House.  When he left in 2001, they were a minority with 46 fewer seats.  There were 30 Democratic governors when he arrived, 21 when he left.  Hillary’s 2008 presidential campaign has always been about the Clintons’ own self-interests.  Hillary has deliberately tried to undermine Obama’s electability in the general election, knowing that could be ruinous for the Democrats in November.  


Depending on who tells the story, The 3 Bears either scare Goldilocks away or kill her outright at the end of the story.
Hillary,

I am truly praying for you. This is such unjust world. But you will overcome. Hang on in there...
"Who's your minister, Hillary?"  Someone safe, I am, sure.  Today is Ascension Thursday.  She should have been in church, without cameras.  
Goldilocks, indeed!  Perhaps you misread the talking points.   It's really PINOCHIO.  

Disney/ABC is remaking the classic, and as part of its recompense to Bubba over the Path to 9/11 flub, Hillary will be cast as the wooden boy and Bubba as...drum roll...NOT Geppetto but Stromboli!

There is no word from the Obama camp about Disney's desire to cast him as Jiminy Cricket.  But John McCain is telling lumber lobbyists that  "You can count on me, my Friends, to take on the role of Pinocchio if Hillary flips."
Man she has more characters up he sleaves. Heck come to find out it was her Not Elton John that performed at her benifit.He just loaned her one of his pantsuits ,she lip sanc it. The funny one is now Hillary has B*lls I wonder if they are Bills. To think next she will tell you Clintontard that Goldilocks was real , and you will believe it. A fictional character for her fictional gas tax plan.
well hillarys right about this if we can save on gas now  we can depend on her to pass bills to tax those billon-air oil companys to pay for it next year and we need the break now thats better then doing nothing like obama wants to do and how many roads and bridges are being fixed now anyway none in my arera
There she goes again.  The wolf (boys) are picking on me.  Grow-up .

You lived in public housing until 2001.  The last time you pumped gas was pre-1980, probably when Bill ran out.

Thank goodness that Indy time trials are not for a couple weeks - you'd probably try that with DP.
First she was the Queen, (as in ready for her coronation), then she was the under dog, then Rocky, then Calamity Jane, (Barack said Annie Oakley, but Calamity is a better 'literal' description for Hillary), as well as, Paulette Revere, Teddy Roosevelt, now Goldilocks. I'm sure I missed some of Clinton's manifestations of her mental health debacle.
Perhaps the polls are worrying Obama-trons? When will u all understand that the guy is unelectable? Gotta go clean my gun and get ready for bible study at my place tonite. "Typical White Folks" like myself won't vote for Obama. I guess that makes US racist. Oh well!
sounds about right...the chances of her campaign succeeding is indeed a fairy tale
Clinton has referred to herself as Paulette Revere, Teddy Roosevelt and now Goldilocks.  A week ago, she was acting like Annie Oaklie.  Will the real Hillary Rodham Clinton please stand up?
Or the Wicked Witch of the East!
In the sense that Goldlilocks was a criminal . . . breaking and entering . . . destruction of private propertly . . . felony theft . . .

I would tend to agree . . . I do see her as Goldilocks
OK I spit my coffee out laughing!
She is goldilocks????
lol
HEY....... she is the duck hunter!
She is the sniper fire dodger.
She is the tough fighter!
She is human, get over it, when she makes a mistake!
She is from Arkansas (ya'll), New York, Pennsylvania (grab your gun), Nooo...Illinois and Indiana (ahhh doesn't she look like goldilocks?)!!
She has had "the grace of god in my life, since I was a little girl".  While the night before she was throwing back shots and beer in a bar!  I'm sure God is sending her more grace for that one!
She is the candidate for women, who shoots shots & beers with "the boys"!
Now she has "testicular fortitude".  What a role model for the young American girls...better grow some or you can't compete with men!
Now...she is a "character" in a children's book....she's "juuuuuuust right"!

Yes...we should bow our heads and pray with the Clinton's today.  She is a multi-personality, multi-"state", multi-experienced, duck and booze shooting "fighter", that has the Lord in her life even with a hangover, and poridge in her breakfast bowl!!!!!!!!!

Hysterical!
I have been reading most of the comments on your post Chuck Todd and it seems that many are asking why MSNBC, NBC and the rest of MSM isn't reporting about Peter Paul's lawsuit against the Clintons filed in California. Why is the networks so afraid to talk about this?
Goldilocks, Dr. Strangleove and 'he hate me' are vying to run the nation...we are so screwed
Hillary is Goldilocks alright.  Goldilocks got caught burglarizing someones home, and just like Goldilocks she thought she had a perfect right to do it.  When confronted she ran away, lets hope Hillary does the same thing.
She can't pump gas and she doesn't know how to get coffee from the machine. Who's the true elitist?
I'm Hillary Clinton and I approve of this message.  Pander, Pander, pander.  Oh, I didn't know the Magnequench defense plant was closed during Bill's Administration.  I'm goldilocks and the only thing I know to do is twist the truth.
We love the Goldilocks economy of the 1990's.

Please bring it back Hillary.
I have to say that I am disappointed that it appears that hillary clinton supporters beleive everything they watch on tv. I see why her appeal is so widesrpead.. hillary supporters just hear what sounds goods and like the dumb asses they are they just jump on it like its gold and don't bother to research it.. oh thats right her base of voters consists of over 65 and uneducated white women.. Lol.. most of the people that beleive in her probably haven't been out of their own county 3 times in their life.. so of course they don't understand Barack Obama... they probably haven't ever seen a smart African American person.. or just an African American person...

There is a saying that the older you get you revert back to your childhood ways.. so I guess as long as Moma hillary says something you dummies are so gullable(that means stupid) and don't have the mental make up to think the situation through..

I mean when I look at Hillary Clinton, I just see corruption... but her base just looks past ALL of her flaws and just blindly believe in her.. she smiles in your face and says what you want to hear (typical woman) and then crap in your face behind closed doors..
You run Barack Obama through the ringer because of what his pastor said.. I mean how racist is that.. hell hillary clintons priest molested a little boy and you stupid people can look beyond that.. dumb asses that a person that likes little boys booties has an influence over your choice for president. Not to mention her husband has a reputation of having sex with other women and was impeached because of his SEXUAL relations with a woman NOT named HILLARY.. Hello this fool will be back in the White house influencing her decisions..
She is being investigated for campaign fraud. the clintons were involved in the sale of the company in Indiana that sent jobs to china..

Its a shame that there are american people supporting a person like that, but I guess it just goes to show how WHITE ELDERLY UNEDUCATED WOMEN vote based on their dislike and ignorance about a BLACK MAN.. Relax dumb asses your RACIST daddies are dead.. Wake up and get a mind of your own.. Hillary isn't the one to save you from him, she is the person that you look at with disgust when she leads him to your hiding spot(after she got financial compensation for your whereabouts) this is an easy choice..

she'd rather have a vote than retain any amount of shame.
Rocky to Goldilocks to Pandering(LYING} to BYE BYE!!!

She didn't even know how to pump gas - Elist????
I wonder why she has such an affinity to fictional characters....
Oh now now Obamabots. lighten up. You do know the gas tax is regressive since it impacts most on those who can least afford it Hmmmmm come to think of it maybe you dont know. Well lets see hmmmm ok lets pretend we are talking about the price of Arugala at whole foods.,get it now.Heee Hee. Bye Bye Barry. Hillary on the rise
Yeah, she's like Goldilocks alright.  She'll come into your house uninvited, steals food off your table, and doesn't lose a wink of sleep over it.

Unlike Goldilocks, she doesn't know when to leave.
Rocky, Paulette Revere, Annie Oakley, Teddy Roosevelt, Goldilocks...

Who's next?

Who's Hillary?
To all of you Hillary haters and Obama lovers:

You can not and you will not win in November without us (Hillary Supports), and we (Hillary Supports), can not an will not win with out the MSNBC/Obama people.  Stop the hate and let everyone vote.

Stop the hate.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=968614

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google