ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Obama plays metaphor-filled game

Posted: Friday, May 02, 2008 3:28 PM by Mark Murray

From NBC/NJ's Athena Jones
UNION MILLS, IN -- Yesterday, Obama finished off a day-long tour of Indiana that focused on rural issues with a roundtable chat at a hog farmer's house, followed by a game of P-I-G that might have served as a metaphor for the protracted primary race. It even featured a direct mention of his rival.

The farmer, Andy Evers, was an undecided voter who was leaning toward Obama and who also raises corn and soy. After the Illinois senator spent about 20 minutes talking about health care, not taking money from lobbyists, gas prices, uniting Congress, immigration, and his children, the farmer asked if he would shoot a few hoops with his 14-year-old son Aaron, who he said had been practicing all night.

"We'll play a quick game of P-I-G," Obama said, noting they were on a farm. He joked that Aaron would have home court advantage and that the dimming light -- it was dusk -- was a disadvantage as an older guy.

The assembled press joined the family to watch the game from the edge of the court.

It took Obama -- an avid basketball fan, who was taking part in his fourth hoops-related event in the last six days -- roughly seven minutes to win the game. But it felt like a long seven minutes. 

Early on, he ventured off the pavement into the grass to what could be described as modified three-point range, saying "We're gonna go out into the fields here. Alright, whaddya think? Right here?" He missed. The shot was "way short" as he put it.

An onlooker allowed that maybe the wind was an excuse -- a moderate wind was blowing -- and Obama agreed that the wind could be to blame.

The senator seemed concerned with playing by the rules. A couple times he questioned whether the teen had called the shots he was making.

"Did you call bank shot on that one?," he asked.

"I'm feeling a little pressure, here" Obama said at another point.

"You have to," Aaron said.

The crowd oohed and ahhed as the men tried to best one another. Several of Obama's shots went in like swoosh -- nothing but net -- but he also hit the rim several times or saw the ball appear to be going in but then roll around the rim and pop back out.

"I gotta finish you up right here," Obama said, before missing a shot. 

The game seemed like a baller's mini-version of the on-going election saga. Political observers have begun to echo a question the Clinton campaign has been asking for weeks: With more pledged delegates, more states won and a lead in the popular vote, why can't Obama close the deal and grab the nomination? Some pundits argue a win in both North Carolina and Indiana on Tuesday would help him do so.

As the game dragged on, Obama offered some of the best lines of the night.

"Now we could be here for another couple weeks," he said.

To which an older man standing on the sidelines said: "You better end it."

"I better end it," Obama said.

A few minutes later, the senator told Aaron he should not be nervous "'cause my shot is broke" and then joked they were in Indiana and should be able to make it.

At one point, as it started to drizzle, the senator said "I think we gotta get going. So I think we're gonna have to end it right here. Whaddya think? Let me make this one.". He missed.

For the briefest of moments it seemed that Obama might be flirting with ending the game early, but the political reporters-cum-sports-writers quickly concluded he had no choice but to finish.

"We want to make it close and add to the drama don't we?" he said.

Someone commented: "When the pressure's on, you do pretty well."

"Sometimes, I lose my concentration when there's no pressure," Obama responded.

He wrapped up the game a few moments later, but not before another funny exchange.

"Come on senator, put it to bed," said a man in the crowd.

"You know, he's tough. He keeps on coming back. He's like Hillary," Obama said to laughs before sinking the winning shot.

After the game, Obama posed for a picture with the teen and signed the ball, before heading back to his bus and the campaign trail.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Wish I was that teen!

(and embarrassed to say that I don't know what playing PIG is in basketball terms, not elitist though, just raised more on softball and soccer!)

Obama for our best future.
sounds like a few more hoosier votes
This seems a lot more real to me than pretending to be poor and pumping gas (truly insulting).  Maybe the coffee machine senses her disengenuousness.
Do 'elistists' play basketball?



Obama drama (to be continued...)


This is the kind of President you need. Someone who is not afraid to be the trenches with the American people and yet still finds solace in the most important part of life -- living it.  This was no pre-arranged political ploy like the Clinton "let's go out for gas" run or let's "throw a few back".  This is someone who has a love of a game (basketball) and does not mind sharing that love with just the regular folks even when things are not great. That's far from elitist to me. He still sees a future out there we can strive to.  The glass IS half-full, people, and although we are struggling, there is hope for a brighter and better day ahead.
Lisa, I think PIG is an abbreviated version of HORSE (where one player calls the shot, and if he/she makes it, the other player has to make it also, or the 1st player gets an H, or in this case, a P. )First player to get all the letters wins.
CBS news is reporting that Obama is running an ad showing real solutions for oil.

"Take on price-gouging by oil companies. Tax their windfall profits. Invest in alternative energy. Give working families a permanent, thousand-dollar tax cut to help with rising costs."

Obama, I'll give a family $1000 every year.
Hillary, I'll give you 18 cents a gallon of gas for 14 weeks.
Athena,

Terrific article. I'm glad Obama is out there, doing his thing, and the people are getting to know him.

Reading this,I felt as though I was there. This was a welcome break from tougher by-lines of late.
Good man that Obama.

Ok MSNBC were the info I requested regarding the
Paul vs Clinton Fraud case?

Where, oh where is MSNBC info on
Paul vs Clinton trial news ?

Where, oh where is MSNBC info on
Paul vs Clinton trial news ?


She`s a FRAUD and you guys know it.

             Bunch of pansies.....


Go Obama ' 08
You Gotta Love It!  The proof is in the P-I-G.
Good man that Obama.

Ok MSNBC were the info I requested regarding the
Paul vs Clinton Fraud case?

Where, oh where is MSNBC info on
Paul vs Clinton trial news ?

Where, oh where is MSNBC info on
Paul vs Clinton trial news ?


She`s a FRAUD and you guys know it.

             Bunch of pansies.....


Go Obama ' 08
Wow a positive story on Obama The weekened before an election. How did this happen? Oh Ok a good reporter this time. At least Mark Murrays reports are to both sides of the coin.
Multi tasking Barack. Kicking multi butt, and taking muti names.
Ok MSNBC were the info I requested regarding the
Paul vs Clinton Fraud case?

Where, oh where is MSNBC info on
Paul vs Clinton trial news ?
From Huffington Post:

United States Senators are the only ones who have worked with both Obama and Hillary in the same capacity and in the same setting. One might have expected the Clintons' long history that antedated Hillary's Senate career with many of these members to have won their support. Moreover, they have worked with her longer in the Senate because her tenure is longer, as the Clintons continually point out. They know her better.

These are the people who can best judge the claims to judgment, competence experience, likely success and unifying capacity. Making any choice in this situation is difficult because all know that they are going to have to work together in the future with one of them as a colleague and the other as president.

By 18-13 United States Senators have endorsed Barack Obama.

Is P-I-G the same as H-O-R-S-E?  lol.  I've played horse before but never pig.  

Good one for Obama, and too funny!  I can hardly wait to vote for Obama in OR.

Obama '08


Has Jones never played HORSE? Or ever been around a basketball court?

Guys kid each other about calling banks all the time.

I wasn't even there and I know she's misrepresenting what happened.

And if she's so disinterested or against Obama that she'll complain how long the seven minutes felt, maybe MSNBC.com should relieve her of the trouble and hire someone who wants to do the job … like me.   :)

http://gibbsv.blogspot.com/
In Indiana (and I am sure NC) there is a hoop in every yard (at least where there are youngsters).  Gosh! I remember playing HORSE and PIG growing up.

T - probably a few more NC votes too.
PIG is a short version of HORSE. If your opponent makes a basket and you miss, you get a letter, like P. First person to spell pig loses.  In Hoosier country that will get more votes than that one farmer.  

It is too bad MSNBC and Chris Mathews had to trumpet the noise of Rev Wrong and not get to American values of honesty, truthfullness and the importance of handling in a respectful manner two rough weeks.  The Indina superdelegate who switched to Obama noticed the dignified way Obama handled adversity.  Obama will make a great president.
Barack can shoot hoops, and kick McBillary behind, at the same time.  
Lisa - PIG is a game where if your opponent makes a shot, and you miss the same shot, you get a letter, such as "P." If your opponent misses their shot, you get to shoot any shot you want, and if you make it, your opponent must also make it or they also get a letter.

The first to miss three required shots (P-I-G) is defeated. Another popular version of the game is HORSE.
maybe next farm he could go snipe hunting. Give him the bag not the gun ok? What a duce he is. The only thing worse than an elitist is an offending one trying not to be. He should play pig chaseing bet he could do good.Good old bommy never pass a chance to make fun of Hillary kind of the ol boys club thing I guess.(He is good enough)>Maybe monday he can help with the sloppin-sue-eeeeeeeeeeeet
Obama seems to enjoy playing MANY games with the typicle white, bitter, bible clinging, gun totting, ignorant middle class voters!
The two leading candidates for governor of NC endorsing B Obama- Way to go. Current Governor Easley is in trouble anyway for destroying emails (Sound like Bush).
If he intended to play P-I-G and drag Sen. Clinton into it...they needed to play H-O-G! After all she has testicles right?

Or would that be Rodham-Clinton-Hog. Want to insure her identity and all is observed.
Let's see Hillary do that.

I can't wait until Indiana puts this race to bed.
I'm sick of Obama playing basketball. It's such a ploy. Reminds me of those staged football games the Kennedy's always had. Nothing more than a lame photo op.
He cannt get it.People farmers,small towners,middle road folks cannt be bought,and can see through phoneys.He just keeps comeing back for more than wonders what the heck happened. Why arent they fallin in line or drinking the kool aid. Obama like in Ca. to his rich friends has to be someone elses fault couldnt be his.He spends 3 or 4 to one but cannt bring it home.This is what we want to go against the Repubs?The fact that he was at a billionair friends house in a closed meeting (no one must know) warns me to dig deeper .This isnt the one we need to get us back into th ewhite house. I think he just wanted to get his name known this time . Next time he can walk right through.good for us.
Wow!  That is the coolest thing.  I'm a mother a young adult (19 years) and he would of loved to of shot a round of basketball with him; he became a fan in 2004.  Obama you seem so down to earth and real!  Finally, someone many can relate too!
Jimmy Chitwood for the Win!
Yeah, he shoots pretty good when Final Four players aren't defending. Oh well, we'll just have to settle with having a decent hoops player in the White House rather than a phenomenal hoops player.
I can remember playing many games of Pig as a youth.
The game is about besting your opponent at making
shots count. It can get real ugly, too, depending on
the player's and if they played "dirty" or not.

Sounds like the Dem campaign, so far.

Anyway, that kid got an experience he can remember for
a long time and replay it to all his friends.

Obama '08
Did these people relate to him?  It certainly sounds like it.  How elitist does that sound?  Not much to me...
PREDICTION:
Obama will win Indiana 51-48% and will beat her in North Carolina 56-44%. By Thursday, next week, the Superdelegates rally around their nominee.

Game Over!!!
I'm glad Obama won.  If he lost to the kid on purpose the MSM would say that he's pandering :-)
It's a good thing they weren't playing horse!  They might still be there...but knowing Indiana...that would have been just fine too!

Barack's a nice guy!  He just isn't ready to be the president.

Sounds like Pig poop to me. Hey If you cant bowl,have a beer ,if that dont work play b ball. Keep trying Snob-ama, maybe some of this "common man " stuff will work unless of course you get frustrated and cling to your guns and religion. Uh oh forgot you already junked your pastor.  Hmmmmmm I got an idea .How about a game whre we see how many people can fit under the bus with your typical white grammaw. hee heee.Bye bye Barry. Hillary Rising
LISA - Playing PIG is a shorter version of playing HORSE.  The game is pretty simplelike a basketball version of Follow-the-Leader.  

Basically whatever shot your opponent takes and makes (assuming he/she goes first), you have to take and make the exact same shot in the exact same way in the exact same place.  So if you were playing Obama, and he stood at the three point line with his back facing the rim, and he threw the ball of his head and made it, then you'd have to go to that exact same spot, turn you back to the basket, and throw the ball over your head and make it.  If you miss the shot, then you get a letter which would be P in this case.  If Obama made another trick shot, and you duplicated but missed it, then you'd get a I.  If he missed the shot, then you can take your own trick shot and if you made it, he'd have to take the same type of shot and try to make it.  The goal is to take a easy enough shot that you can make with some luck, but hard enough so that your opponent will most likely miss and get a letter.  

The first one to spell out PIG or HORSE is the loser.
it's like H-O-R-S-E.  Each time you make a shot, the opposing playing has to make that same one.  If he/she misses, you get a letter.  First one to spell HORSE (or PIG) wins.

Wow. 7 whole minutes? That is a whole news cycle for you guys. Could've spent that time playing Wright clips.
..."before sinking the winning shot"

exactly!
To my fellow Democrats:

We are all perched at the egde of the cliff like a bunch of lemmings ready for the fall.  Any idea who is leading this charge to defeat?  That's right, the conservative wing of the Republican Party.  They pulled it off masterfully in 2004 and they about to pull it off again under greater odds against in 2008.  Why?  Because we as democrats do not learn from our mistakes.

In 2004 Karl Rove made it clear that they were desperately hoping that Howard Dean won the nomination as he would be so easliy defeated by Bush.  What did we democrats do?  We ACTUALY LISTENED to him, panicked, and ended up with magoo Kerry for a candidate.  We did exactly what Rove wanted in his clever reverse psychology plan.  Dean was the war opposition candidate, Washington outsider, and person energizing youth voters.  His claim, as head of the Deaniacs, was that in order to win the White House we couldn't run on the same old tired electoral map, that we had to change voting demographics and bring new voters into the party or we risked year 2000 results every year.  That is what Rove was afraid of, and he got what he wanted in an older Washington insider opponent in Kerry, who could not bring in new voters to the party.

Let me re-state what Howard Dean was -- opposed to the war from the start, a Washington outsider, and someone energizing the youth vote.  Minus the Dean-scream, does that sound like someone you know??

(Insert Barack Obama answer here)

The Republicans are loving this right now as Rush Limbaugh calls for Operation Chaos, Bill O'Reilly is actually nice to HRC, etc.  When EVER in the past have they been nice to any Clinton?  The Repubs HATE Hillary Clinton.  They love that Barack is running a positive campaign and leaving all the scandals untouched right now so they can have at them if she were lucky enough to rest the nomination away from the person leading in pledged delagates, popular vote, and states won.

I care not who you think is actually the better Democratic candidate, I do care that we take back the White House, and HRC stands no chance in November as she will fully energize the conservative base which John McCain can't.  Ironic isn't it that the conservatives are looking for HRC to do their work for them that McCain can't.  Please do not let it happen, not again.

Learn from history.
See that is a real everyday competitive engagement by the next president and it is genuine.. Not riding to work with a guy(with the secret service in the truck) and doing a radio interview along the way.. and then not even being able to use a frickin coffee machine..  definitely shows he is in touch with the American people, having good american fun..
This spin that Senator Obama should close the deal is rather funny.  Remember Senator Clinton was inevitable just 4 short months ago?  How soon we forget!

Senator Obama always needs time for the voters to get to know him.  His numbers always go up, while her always go down.  Senator Clinton started with every imaginable advantage -- and even some UNimaginable advantages, from a historical perspective, she is the former First Lady and her husband, a former President is stumping actively for her.  Nobody would have thunk this before 1992.

Senator Obama is a political phenomenom who has already changed the face of politics and who is still up against a very formidable candidate with a very formidable political machine.  This machine (I might add) took over 20 years to build.  

I find it funny that no-one is asking why the machine has not delivered.  It is odd that no-one is wondering why the establishment got clobbered in 11 straight contests.  

Oh well, it truly does not matter in the end, because I can tell that Senator Obama is the presumptive Democratic nominee.  How?  The Republican attack machine is already lobbing fast ones at him on an almost daily basis.  This would not be happening unless that machine KNEW he was the presumptive nominee.

Senator Obama will be our 44th President and we, the People, will help him change Washington, green our environment, get out of Iraq with honor and carefully, get us real healthcare reform and fix our public educational system so that it is once more the envy and the model of the world.

This is what change means to me -- what does it mean to you?  We are the change we have been waiting for!  

Yes we can!
HRC = Utter Nonsense
HRC = Republican
HRC = V.P. for McCain
HRC = Untrust worthy
HRC = LIAR
HRC = Panderer for votes.


LOL

Go Obama ' 08
Once again... WHO CARES?!?! This isn't "American Idol." This isn't "Choose Your New Best Friend." This is an election for the highest office in the land. I don't give a darn if Barack Obama can play basketball, or if Hillary Clinton came under sniper fire, or if John McCain sought out an anti-Catholic preacher's endorsement. I care about one thing, and one thing only: Who can lead this country out of the darkness in which it currently finds itself?

If MSNBC and the other news networks would pay more attention to actual issues rather than this kind of garbage, maybe Americans would care more. As it is, we're still going to have the lowest voter turnout in the civilized world.

Does anybody care if Gordon Brown plays soccer, or if Robert Mugabe enjoys cartoons? No. People care what their policies are, and what they're going to do for us as a nation and as individuals. This kind of garbage is why no one in the United States except insiders really cares about or trusts in American politics.
Great story.  It was nice to read something positive for a change.  I'm so tired of the negative, tabloid-like reporting that I've decided to volunteer for the Obama campaign.  My plan is to make as many phone calls to Indiana as time allows.  This is the first politician who has inspired me enough to win my time.
BIG DEAL! SO HE PLAYS THE P-I-G EQUIVALENT OF H-O-R-S-E WITH A BOY IN INDIANA. THAT REALLY TELLS ME ALOT ABOUT HIM? THE FACT HE ATTENDED CHURCH FOR 20 YEARS WITH THE "DOWN-ON-AMERICA" REVEREND WRIGHT IS MUCH MORE TELLING ABOUT HIM!

I'M FOR HILLARY AND I KNOW SHE CAN BEAT JOHN MCCAIN!!
Gary-IND: Apparently there are more senators who want to get him the h___ out of there then want him to stick around! Can't say as I blame them.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=974577

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google