ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Clinton goes to church in W.V.

Posted: Sunday, May 11, 2008 12:59 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ’s Mike Memoli
HUNTINGTON, W.V. -- Hillary Clinton, traveling press corps in tow, started her Mother's Day trip through West Virginia with a stop at church, where the pastor's sermon urged the faithful to think of themselves as more than a "comma."

"Maybe you've been a comma at some time in your life," Pastor Paul Russell said. "People don't really listen to you. People don't really value you. Listen -- there is one who listens to you. There is one who values you. What a great thing to know that you and I are not commas to God."

The message seemed appropriate as the New York senator seeks to remain part of the storyline, as Obama begins to look ahead to the general-election match up with McCain.

Clinton arrived at the First United Methodist Church late, but was greeted with a gift of cookies as she and daughter Chelsea sat in the second pew. They listened as Russell read the Pentecost story from Acts Chapter 2, and also noted the secular holiday.

“Sometimes being a mom is a thankless job,” Russell said. “That's why we honor them in a special way today. Mother's Day is an opportunity to say a much-deserved, ‘Thank you.’”

Clinton did not speak at the service, but stood with Russell after it ended, greeting the worshippers. She will also mark this day with a visit to the home of Anna Marie Jarvis, who founded Mother's Day, and with a "Mother's Day Celebration" in Grafton.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Barack has already forgiven her for the way she despitefully used him during the last months...
Hillary needs to know she is forgiven and all Dem's now ask her help to elect Barack Obama as the next President of these United State of America...
The time is for unification not fighting and divisiveness...

God Bless both Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton..

They're going to need it.....  
She really needs to go to church and pray to God for foregiveness for all her divisive comments.  According to her, we are not equal.
Jack Smith are you nuts. All of you people that say you will not vote for Obama, I hope you and your kids will fight in Iraq for 100 years.
"Hillary Clinton appreciates the people she encounters as she travels throughout the nation." (from Jeremy, IN)

++++++++++++++++++++

Clinton appreciates the white, hardworking Americans that she meets, right?

Sorry to be "snippy", but I am quite offended by her racial comments.  I am a hardworking, white, female (over 40) who did NOT vote for her.  I feel she will say anything to get elected.  For example, what happened to her gas tax holiday?  That just evaporated with her loss in NC and near-loss in IN. I would respect Clinton a lot more if she had the "testicular fortitude" to get behind the winner of the Democratic primary (Obama) and help us take back the White House this fall!!!
"Hillary Clinton appreciates the people she encounters as she travels throughout the nation." (from Jeremy, IN)

++++++++++++++++++++

Clinton appreciates the white, hardworking Americans that she meets, right?

Sorry to be "snippy", but I am quite offended by her racial comments.  I am a hardworking, white, female (over 40) who did NOT vote for her.  I feel she will say anything to get elected.  For example, what happened to her gas tax holiday?  That just evaporated with her loss in NC and near-loss in IN. I would respect Clinton a lot more if she had the "testicular fortitude" to get behind the winner of the Democratic primary (Obama) and help us take back the White House this fall!!!
Jacksmith, Dallas, Texas,
    You have escaped the white jackets and gone off your meds once again.  I would hold back on the sarcasm being that it's Mother's Day, but I'm not that strong.  Please log on next time as Jackass, Dallas,TX.
It is sad on Mother's Day HRC could not spend it with her family. She went to exploit this day in WV. It is like her gas tax. I wonder where Bill is. It is over.
"We will not vote for Obama. We will sit on our hands or vote for Mc Cain. Don't soosch this off. This is real."
-- Jo Onalaska,WI (Sent Sunday, May 11, 2008 2:04 PM)
======================

I'd really like to hear how that works in your head.  Seriously.  

You'd rather vote for someone who would appoint Supreme Court justices that would overturn Roe v. Wade and abolish sexual harassment and discrimination laws?  You'd rather vote for someone who will happily continue dragging our country into the abyss or war and economic disaster that Bush has created?

Surely you've noticed that the POLICIES of Obama and Clinton are almost identical when compared to McCain.  Clinton herself has said as much and made it clear that all of her supporters should support the Democratic nominee, whoever it is, and yet you claim that you'd rather spit in her face and support McCain.

Really, how do you make that work in your head?  Doesn't it give you a headache?



Oh, that's right ... NOT A SINGLE ONE OF YOU WHO SAYS THIS IS LEGITIMATE.  You're all right-wing "concern trolls" trying to plant the idea that every one of Hillary's supporters is going to vote for McCain or stay home.  You're just a bunch of fvcking liars, and some day you'll have to answer for it.  There is no true anonymity on the internet, and there sure as hell isn't any anonymity when you're standing before your creator. (But you're all hypocrites about religion, anyway, so I guess that wouldn't matter to you, would it?)
Okay, this is the same woman that whether she goes to church is irrelevant, and now she goes to church, in, of all places, West Virginia?  Come on people.  She has her mother, something that a lot of people can't say (including Obama), yet she takes Mother's Day to campaign in a state with 28 delegates?  She should be embracing this time with your loved ones, your mother.  It's really sad, and its even more sad that her supporters actually accuse Obama of all sorts of misdeeds, then accuse Obama supporters of being hateful?
Doesn't any body realize Obama probably would not be where he is today, if not for Oprah Winfrey pushing him unto her viewers a while back. I can guarantee you if she had done the same for Hillary, she would have sewn up the nomination long ago.
Bowie Chen
You are one of the many reasons I'd never vote for Clinton. Happy Mothers Day!
Hi,
I just took The Bush-McCain Challenge -- an online quiz to see if you can tell the difference between George W. Bush and John McCain. Check it out, and see if you can do any better than I did!
http://Bush-McCainChallenge.com/?rc=tafbonus

If Hillary can beat McCain....then WHY couldn't she beat OBAMA????? The media didn't beat her ,the DNC didn't beat her...OBAMA beat her fair and square....
U have tried to be cordial and respectful to the Hillary-BOTS....but they are truly stcuk on stupid!!!!
Blaming everybody for Hillary's loss!!!
Get over it...she lost! She's done! NO matter what she does in WVA...The people in WVA are wasting their votes....Because it's not going to matter.....
Happy Mother's Day to you future Madam President.
Debbie (Sent Sunday, May 11, 2008 3:36 PM)



LOL!LOL!LOL!LOL!LOL! Too bad saying it doesn't make it true!!!!LOL!LOL!LOL!LOL!
BTW...WHY  would Obama want Billary on his ticket????
She's proven she's not an asset!!!!!! A Jr.Senator has beating the mighty Clinto machine....WOW!!!! Who would have thunk it!!!!! LOL!LOL!LOL!
OBAMA 08!!!!!!!!
Jo Onalaska: I agree.  Pundits and political types keep saying "oh the party will unite when it's all done."  WRONG. WRONG. WRONG.  I will NOT vote for BO. I soon will be 58 and have voted Democrat in EVERY presidential election since I became eligible to vote.  So, that negates the argument I'm "pouting" that HRC didn't win.  They could run a dog against him, and I'd vote the dog.  This man is dangerous and not who presents himself to be. IF he's elected, which I don't think  he will will be, but if, our country is going to be in such serious trouble.  I expect some terrorist act immediately after his inauguration.  They'll attach a note:  Want to disucss this over a cup of coffee?  They know he's a pansy.  Of course, it will take a while for a response from the person who couldn't make up their 130 times while in the IL Senate.
See how easy this is? A nice uplifting message from the pastor. Not like Wright, who like Obama, hates this country's traditions and values.
********8
Josie, you forgot to mention Michell-ego who also hates this country. Fri, she was out preaching more gloom and doom.  And this from the wife who's husband talks about hope?  Do you people not see the disconnect?  He's the "front" man; she's out telling what he's really like...
If you Obamatons are SO positive BO has the nomination locked up, why so much vitriole still against HRC?  Guess cause there's not that much good to say about BO?  He stands for nothing.
t. When I hear Obama speak I hear a candidate who resonates with my own Christian beliefs.
*********
Hermine, where does "typical white person" fit in Christian beliefs?  Where do criticizing people from small town America who go to church and/or own guns fit in there?  Judge not lest ye be judged.

We will not vote for Obama. We will sit on our hands or vote for Mc Cain.
Jo Onalaska,WI (Sent Sunday, May 11, 2008 2:04 PM)

This sounds like a Clintonista - they are not loyal to the democratic party.  They will bolt and vote for McCain.  They don't care about US casualties in Iraq, they don't care of the appointment of ultra conservative judges to the supreme court, and they don't care about the tax cuts made permanent to the top 1% income people.  Oh you can forget about universal healthcare.

All they care about are themselves.  These two have very similiar platforms.  

Heck, I wanted Edwards, but nothing will keep me from voting for a democrat in the fall no matter who it is.

Vote Democrat 08!!  
jacksmith - you say "It is absolutely essential that the democrats take back the Whitehouse in November."  Then you had better support Barack Obama.  West Virginia, Kentucky and Puerto Rico are not going to change the overall results of the nomination process.  Millions disagree with you that Obama has no chance in November.  And 1.5 million have said so with their hard earned money contributed to the Obama campaign.  If Hillary had that kind of base of campaign contributors, her campaign would not be broke.
Obama sent his grandma a nice pot of flowers along with the message "Happy Mothers Day you Typical Racist White Person".
Bowie Chen, NC (Sent Sunday, May 11, 2008 3:29 PM)

You are definitely sick.
Jeremy, would you please explain to me just exactly what Obama has personally done or said to be labeled deviant or hateful?  I have been studying this man in both words and actions for four years and I am puzzled and disturbed by your vitriol.  Where does this kind of hate come from?  I think given a real chance to govern in a way that brings this nation together, Obama has the talent to be a great president.  But what do I know, I've just been teaching American history and government for a quarter of a century.

FR: It would be nice to "make the cut" for posting.  I have never had anything to say that is hateful or out of line, will people like Patty are here and posted every single day - seriously, every single day.
Obamabots out in force I see.  Did you guys go see you mother or where you found under a rock?

Glad Hillary went to church.  Did Obama? If so, did he go and get his radical batteries recharged?? More will be coming out about his radical friends.

All aboard the Change train that is going nowhere all you wool pulled over my eyes people , so blind you can't see people, so brown you don't want to see people.  Misguided, misdirected voting for a candidate that was driven by the media.  Obama is unqualified, unprepared, too thin resume, he is arrogant, goes around with an air of superiority and Michelle is even worst.  Don't you people see a dud when it is right before your eye???  You have been duped by Obama and the media. It won't sale in November. He and Michelle are laughing saying we fooled them, we fooled them and wasn't it easy thanks to the MSM.
Obamabots out in force I see.  Did you guys go see you mother or where you found under a rock?

Glad Hillary went to church.  Did Obama? If so, did he go and get his radical batteries recharged?? More will be coming out about his radical friends.

All aboard the Change train that is going nowhere all you wool pulled over my eyes people , so blind you can't see people, so brown you don't want to see people.  Misguided, misdirected voting for a candidate that was driven by the media.  Obama is unqualified, unprepared, too thin resume, he is arrogant, goes around with an air of superiority and Michelle is even worst.  Don't you people see a dud when it is right before your eye???  You have been duped by Obama and the media. It won't sale in November. He and Michelle are laughing saying we fooled them, we fooled them and wasn't it easy thanks to the MSM.
FINALLY SOMETHING THAT MAKES SENSE, HILLARY AT "PREY"!
Great.  Fine.  Whatever.

When is the concession speech?  That's what I want to know more about.
God may forgive Hillary for her low-road racist campaign but I sure won't.
CNN is reporting today that the Clinton campaign is continuing to dig for damaging information to use against Obama even though he is the Democratic Party's likely nominee.  Time for the Super Delegates to end this NOW.
I can't believe you can allow these personal below
the belt attacks against the Clintons.No matter how
I dislike Bush's policy,I won't be able to say these
kinds of disrespect to anybody even to Sen.Obama and
his wife.DO UNTO OTHERS AS YOU WOULD LIKE OTHERS DO
UNTO YOU.The Clinton haters always overeact to the
point that what they say reflect what kind of hateful
person you are.Her latest comments were taken out of
context again- only by quoting what the AP said.Isn't
that so sad that it is the truth?Admit it-there are
always lazy and hard working Americans in every race.
We are a country of immigrants.Fortunately,this coun-
try is full of good hard working people who got some
sense.
This is interesting...on the most guilt ridden day of the year, Hillary stumps from the home of the mother who created "call your mother or feel guilty" day. Without this hallmark holiday, most mothers know their children love and appreciate them.
I'm surprised Hillary didn't actually come out and say what she meant..."Nominate me or feel guilty, I am a mother too ya know."
If all else fails there is always prayer!  Classic. Let's hope for divine revelation so that she can join Obama and quit the shenanigans.  
Is it not sad, every corner HRC turns there is found conjecture and scandal! The dirty tricks bag, Her manner to discredit but use of the Racial card, Gender card, Self serving agenda, Biased opinions has Broken the back of her party! The party power base has scorned her and the spouse. The deplorable tactics used has not united the nation, but driven a wedge between Washington and the people! Re-Playing the Gender Card amplifies the self serving agenda's. This Presidential election is a Hoax of deception played with hollow and shallow Washington dialogue.
Hillary going to church with daughter:  Photo-op
Hillary in church:  Oxymoron
Or maybe it was sincere:  Please God, quickly give us something to smear Obama before its too late.

Don't forget, some news colums reported that the Clintons called on Rev. Wright when they had the Lewinsky fracas.  Please, God, get me out of this mess.    
 
Why is GENDER POLITCS allowed and RACE POLITICS DENIED.WE ARE OFF TO THE CONVENTION IF HILLARY'S 16.5 MILLION VOTERS HAVE A SAY.If they are shut out it will be a lousy fall campaign for the DEMOCRATS.
Hillary please run as an Independent!!!!!!!! Let show the people you can win!!!!!!!!!!!
I for one like this article.I am sick to death of everyone in the media with a opinion.Mike you did good....just the facts please.THE VOTERS CAN FORM THIER OWN OPINION....16.5 MILLION HAVE VOTED FOR HILLARY.Go ahead OBAMA supporters BASH HILLARY....but if I was you I would be careful...turn off too many HILLARY voters and well.............YOU KNOW.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1008616

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google