ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



The Obama camp's memo on WV

Posted: Tuesday, May 13, 2008 5:30 PM by Mark Murray

From NBC's Mark Murray
The Obama campaign has issued its own West Virginia memo, which makes three points: 1) Clinton is going to win West Virginia BIG; 2) Obama has already picked up more superdelegates in the last week than Clinton will gain from West Virginia; and 3) look at the crosstabs in national polls, not the exit polls, to see how Obama might fare against McCain in a national election.

Below is the memo...

TO: Interested Parties
FR: The Obama Campaign
RE: West Virginia and Obama’s Strong Position in the Race Ahead
DA: 5/13/08

West Virginia
There is no question that Senator Clinton is going to win by huge margins in the upcoming primaries in West Virginia today and Kentucky next weeks. She has poured resources into both states and she, former President Clinton, and Chelsea Clinton have all campaigned extraordinarily hard there.

The Clinton campaign has already been touting their margins in these states – In fact, Bill Clinton said that Hillary can win West Virginia with 80 percent—and the West Virginia Senate Majority Leader said Clinton needs to win by “80-20 or 90-10.” And in keeping large margins in perspective, it is worth noting that, while Senator Clinton will win big in West Virginia, Barack Obama won neighboring Virginia by 29 points.

But with 49 contests behind us and only six to go -- including several states where we expect to do well -- Barack Obama leads in pledged delegates, contests won, and superdelegates. And for perspective, while 28 pledged delegates are up for grabs this evening, Obama has won the support of 27 superdelegates in the course of just the last week putting him less than 150 total delegates away from clinching the Democratic nomination.

Obama’s Strong Position in the Race Ahead
Nationally, Obama is running stronger among Independent voters than any winning Presidential candidate since 1988 and is significantly outperforming Sen. Clinton among these voters as well in general election polling. 

To understand a potential general election match-up between Obama and McCain, the only analysis and data that should be considered valid are the current head-to-head National polls rather than extrapolating irrelevant assumptions from exit poll data in Democratic primaries.

And, on the issue of Democratic unity in the Fall, analysts need only consider that in April of 1992, on a night when Bill Clinton won four primaries and was the presumptive nominee, 6 in 10 Democratic primary voters said they wanted another candidate in the race.  Despite this, five months later, Democratic voters were unified behind Clinton and he won his first of two terms in office. 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Latest polls suggest that Clinton is picking up support from John McCain’s base which is the following:

White Americans that hate people of color.

White Christians that hate people that do not look like them.

White Americans that have very little education.

White Americans who do not care about their own personal economic condition.

White Americans that want to see the sons die in an un-justifiable war.

White Women who hate man still seams to be Hillary Clinton’s primary support.

The New York Times Op-Ed: By BOB HERBERT

"I don’t know if Senator Obama can win the White House. No one knows. But to deliberately convey the idea that most white people — or most working-class white people — are unwilling to give an African-American candidate a fair hearing in a presidential election is a slur against whites."

So what she is saying to all of you is if you are White Trash I am your girl. So vote for me so the South can rise one more time. If I was White I would run as far away from her as a could. This is not the vision for America. Remember everyone she was a Goldwater girl when she was younger.

THE SOUTH WILL RISE AGAIN ACCORING TO HILLARY AND BILL

(No need to post, just wanted to let you know how I feel about your program)

Thank GOD for Keith Olberman! I would NOT watch MSNBC primary coverage if Matthews did this alone. He should bring a mirror to work so he can talk to himself.  I think he's a bit racist. Please do something about his tone.

Thank you!
Darlene, from Huntington, my apologies for some of the posts about your state today.  Regardless of the margin tonite we shouldn't make generalizations.  Hope you got out and voted.
'n drove o'er' drunk too
Hillary is running on Obama's money right now. He is basically paying to have Hillary campaign against him. She can't find money donors and knows that at the end of this process she can dump her debt in Obama's lap to pay. Yep, that Hillary, she's a fighter. Hillary is broke, desperate and clinging to the spotlight. OK, enjoy WV.
yeah, i get the math, but the Obama campaign and Democrats more generally in the Fall are in trouble if it doesn't start appealing to the HIllary Democrats.
See there goes that Obama again; living only in the real world.

Just think what the world would be like if everyone just rolled up their sleeves and worked together; rather than trying to marginalize both white and black races to "fit" into their campaign rethoric.

Please try to understand, "You must hurt everyone; in order to pigeon-hole anyone"!

Hillary, we still care about you, but we need to know that somehow in all of this; you still care about our Nation and it's people, over your own desires and aspirations.

The public has spoken; and even the non-college graduates among us can do the math!

after an 8-year draught, it's quite refreshing to see someone behaving presidentially...
This is what Senator Obama faces in West Virginia...

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/05/13/west-virginia-primary-igo_n_101512.html

Now, obviously, not everyone from West Virginia is ignorant or uninformed or backwater or whatever other term you want to use...

...but the lady in this picture does not help.


The story will remain unchanged, however, with tonight's results.  Senator Clinton needs an incredible margin of victory in every state down the stretch to try and wrestle away the nomination.

And let's throw Michigan and Florida back in the equation for a moment...Senator Obama was not on the Michigan ballot (and if you call it a rookie mistake remember that John Edwards also withdrew his name) so Senator Clinton won a 15-point victory over "Uncommitted"...as for Florida, on name recognition alone she only received 50% of the vote meaning that 50% voted for someone else with no campaigning.

Terry McAuliffe can spout until he's blue in the face that how a state votes in a primary is how they will vote in the fall but we're not buying it.  We expect both candidates to live up to their word that they will work for the nominee whoever that is because it's certainly a smarter choice than McJunta.
Big State - no
Electoral votes - 5
More important than 45 other states - no
Bill Clinton's coat tails finally (he won this state) - yes
Demographics reflective of the other 45 states - only a few at best

It's terrible that rumors of Obama being a Muslim are still perpetuated. This looks bad good people in West Virginia.

oops! jend in tucson, az meant "drought" not "draught"...she's started hitting the vino a bit early...this campaign has been good for the local beer distributorship....
Chad, Salt Lake City Utah:

I tried to make sense of what you wrote. Blacks make up less than 13% of the population, of that less than 20% turn out to vote. Of that Obama got 80-90%. Clinton on the other hand has whitey, Latinos, Asians, etc. Yet she is losing the nomination. Now she cliams that whitey has got her back. But whitey don't like Hillary and that's a fact.  Obama could not be leading without whitey, Ok.
Bravo!! I am glad to be on the winning team. Let's face it, the folks that runs Obama's campaign are good.

You gotta love those guys. They know their math and statistics.
Q. What does winning WV mean for Clinton?

A. It means Obama wins the nomination.
Okay, I would like to say that none of my comments get posted either and I'm not bashing anyone what I'm trying to get across to people who are Hilary supporter's that nobody is to blame but Hilary the way she ran her campaign and the result are what they are please stop blaming Obama because he done a better job at running his.

Obama for President
From the exit polls, it appears that Obama will do slightly better than expected.
Excellent memo -- statistically sound and 100% accurate.

Small unimportant states don't matter to HRC, unless she wins them of course.

The general election has started. Choose sides.
Our governor and first lady were front seat at a HIllary event here......I suely do hope once this is over they will be front and center at the next Obama event......


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1017002

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google