ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



West Virginia: the results

Posted: Wednesday, May 14, 2008 9:14 AM by Mark Murray
Filed Under: ,

With 100% of precincts reporting, Clinton beat Obama last night, 67%-26%; Edwards, who left the race several months ago, got as much as 7% of the vote.

The front page of the Boston Globe: “Clinton crushes Obama in W.Va.” “While her win does not change the dynamics of the race, the margin -- Clinton led Obama 67 percent to 26 percent with 92 percent of precincts reporting last night - was striking given that much of the Democratic political establishment has already coalesced behind Obama as the party's nominee.

The New York Times says that “racial considerations emerged as an unusually salient factor” in last night’s primary. “The number of white Democratic voters who said race had influenced their choices on Tuesday was among the highest recorded in voter surveys in the nomination fight. Two in 10 white West Virginia voters said race was an important factor in their votes. More than 8 in 10 who said it factored in their votes backed Mrs. Clinton, according to exit polls.”

More: “According to the West Virginia surveys, 95 percent of the Democratic primary voters were white, 70 percent did not graduate from college, and 54 percent had household incomes less than $50,000.”

The AP’s analysis: “At Obama's Chicago headquarters, advisers said there was no reason to worry — West Virginia was demographically suited to Clinton and won't be part of their general election plans. It's also true that Clinton's win is unlikely to slow his march toward the nomination — Obama picked up 30 superdelegates this week, more than the 28 total pledged delegates up for grabs in West Virginia. But maybe the Obama camp should be more worried. The voters who went against Obama Tuesday night — white, rural, older, low-income and without college degrees — don't just live in West Virginia. They live everywhere in the country, in places Obama needs to win.”

The Los Angeles Times: “Clinton is no longer resting her candidacy on the delegate count. She hopes to persuade party leaders, who hold the balance of power, that she would be the more electable candidate against McCain, based on her support among white, blue-collar voters who have not embraced Obama's candidacy in the same way as black, more affluent and better-educated voters.”

The New York Post: “Mountain landslide for hope-less Hill.” The subhead: W.Va. win is meaningless.”

The New York Daily News’ cover is equally sardonic: “Hil Billy Win.” Subheadline: “Clinton’s ‘so what’ victory in W.Va. primary as campaign winds down.” The paper also writes, “[H]er ultimate defeat only loomed closer.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

That Obama character, there's a problem! Blue collar people don't take kindly to elitists. See AlGore and John F. Kerry for additional details on how elitists don't do well with the common working man/woman.
A win is a win!!!!
MSNBC operates on such false premises that it is becoming a joke.  I realize that there is only a small percentage of African American voters in W VA -- what percentage of them said that race was a factor in their vote?  For that matter, what percentage of African-Americans in NC, MS, GA, SC said that race was a factor in their votes?  I am guessing it is more than 2 out of 10.  If you want to make race an issue, make sure you realize that it plays out even more looked at the other way.
Remember…D day is closing in! And I know from these post many Obama supporters are shaking in their shoes that a large Hillary constituent will not support Obama!!!!!!….well your nightmare will be reality when McCain wins November….and you know without us (large majority) your guy CAN'T WIN! Even media commentators are worried………well this is what you get you nasty obama elitist….and no not all of us are old, uneducated or set on our ways….start worrying obamabots, your bitter and hateful comments on our candidate got you this…..GET IT THROUGH YOUR HEAD! WE WILL NOT SUPPORT YOUR GUY! WE WILL N0T BACK HIM UP…..**YOU ARE ON YOUR OWN**
ITS HILLARY OR MCCAIN …NEVER THE ELITIST OBAMA WHO LOOKS DOWN ON REGULAR PEOPLE…….YOU DESERVE TO LOSE THIS NOVEMBER!!

What was the number of black voters who said race had influenced their vote in NC and Mississippi, seeing that Obama won over 90% of those votes? 90% of black voters going for the Dem Nominee in the GE is normal, but not in the Primaries.
The number of white Democratic voters who said race had influenced their choices on Tuesday was among the highest recorded in voter surveys in the nomination fight. Two in 10 white West Virginia voters said race was an important factor in their votes. More than 8 in 10 who said it factored in their votes backed Mrs. Clinton, according to exit polls.
***************************************************

Sad.  How can RACE factor into things?  I just don't get it.  That argument is akin to saying, 'I won't vote for her because she's a woman.'  Ugh.

http://thepajamapundit.com/
I'm from WV and I'm appalled at yesterday's outcome.  I'm ashamed to admit that several people I know, people I thought were intelligent, told me yesterday they still thought Mr. Obama was a Muslim terrorist - and they were serious.  Good GAWD!  Mr. Obama better make a greater effort to reach out to the poor and middle class (the so-called non-educated whites) and let them get to know him better.  He won't win in November without their support.  I also believe he would have done much better in WV had he (and his wife) actually spent some time here.  While my vote (and my husband's) didn't do Mr. Obama much good, I am glad I was able to cast my vote for hope.
So much for the so-called experts.

They called it a victory for Senator Clinton at exactly 7:31 last night right after the polls closed.

Big deal.

I called her the winner of that primary last Thursday!

Sorry...it's West Virginia.  Does anyone really think Senator Clinton is going to spend a lot of time and energy on the state if she's the nominee?
I suggest that blacks consider voting for the republicans this election since the the media and Hillary are promoting racism.  Maybe blacks could negotiating a better deal with McCain. He would value their votes just as the democratic party value whites, hard working white people votes over everyone else.  At least their votes would be with the winning party because at the end of the elections the republicans would have won because of the lack of leadership of the democratic party.
Wow, so if black people vote for Obama, we're not allowed to call that racism. Yet if the whites vote for Hilary, it's all about race. How fair is that?

Had it occured to you folks that maybe just maybe people that did not vote for Barack are truly not convinced that he is the right choice?

That he is not ready to lead this country for lack of experience to show forth, questionable judgements, performance in the Senate and associations among other things such as Foreigh affairs know how.

Sure many are inspired by his monologues and speeches. But I for one am not convinced that is enough to get us out of the mess we're in. Haven't we learned our lessons about putting a neophyte who run on a "uniter" campaign?

We're missing a great oppurtunity here of having Hilary lead the country. Her resolve, expertise and experience and needless to say input from Bill who managed the economy very well in the 90s.

MSNBC post this even if it's not catering to your Obama crowd.
what is working is the racism which the hypocritical clintons have injected into the race. by november, people would have realised the ill-motives of the clintons, and they will vote Obama.

so, chill out!!
I think its a mixture of racial and low information voting (the anecdotes on this were endless and also I'm aware that that doesn't speak for everyone in the State, just some overall trends).

I'm not concerned about it, at least not overly concerned, but I do think it can't be ignored.  Obama will have to do more work in populaces with this demographic to get more information out to people (via many means) and to let more people get to "know" him.

I don't at all buy that he cannot win a lot of these types of votes (to generalize although I don't like to) for the General.  I do think its a difficult task for him to do with the Clintons everywhere selling their pander ("I'm just like you, I'll fight for you" whatever the best message is for the State she's in at the time, no consistent tone to her campaign is not encouraging to me).  Obama is running to be President of all the people (and that includes low informatio voters and people inclined towards racism).

Obama for our best future.
Monica, Wheeling, WV,

Thank you for your intelligent vote yesterday. Too bad your state is proud of this toothless win for Hillary. The only thing yesterday told the nation was that you are living in a very racist state. Obama knew this going in and that isn't going to change in November. He won't be spending much time over the summer there because it won't make a difference in the outcome. The uneducated white folks in your state still won't vote for a black man....they ARE part of the reason, though, that he will win going in a different direction and showing that he doesn't need the uneducated vote! Please vote for him come November, because YES WE CAN!
"based on her support among white, blue-collar voters who have not embraced Obama's candidacy"

So basically she's trying to rest her case by championing that the real America that is uneducated and racist should be electing their next president, and that makes her no better than them. To be proud of this and tout it as American is disgusting and only encourages the very ideals we as a country are trying to shed.

Let's just continue the racism shall we? Ridiculous. The media seriously should be making an example out of the idiots in West Virginia in this day and age. Racism and prejudice have no place in our society if we as a nation care to actually evolve.
When 90% of blacks in a given state vote for Obama because he's black, that's ok...

But when only 20% of whites, not even close to 90%, say they didn't vote Obama because of race, that's racist....

Hypocracy is becoming the Obamabot Campaign hallmark!
To the Obama haters, if you choose not to vote for him - let it be because of his views or experience not because of his race. If you dislike him because he's black - Thank God he's not your doctor to bring back to life from a trauma.
That Obama character, there's a problem! Blue collar people don't take kindly to elitists. See AlGore and John F. Kerry for additional details on how elitists don't do well with the common working man/woman.
Gage Wilson (Sent Wednesday, May 14, 2008 9:22 AM)

-------------------------------------------------

Heaven forbid the common working man/woman should find out they have more in common with the Obamas than they do the Clintons who made $109M since leaving the White House.
I loved the way they had the one black guy in the victory crowd in yellow and right behind her...if you looked out at the crowd, it was mostly overweight white people! And Terry McAuliffe claiming it was the greatest speech ever given? What the heck? I had to mute it, she has the worst speaking voice ever!! I can't go through four years of that noise!! HELP US Kentucky and Oregon--kick that pantsuit out of the race!
Can we please stop calling the Clinton supporters white working class.  I'm white, work, less than $50k, and I think Obama is the best candidate to lead our country into the future.  Lets call them what they are... uninformed, racisists.  Is this really the group that should be deciding our next president? It's not like they have a very good record (i.e. GWB).

Elitist?? this is exactly what I'm talking about, I don't remember the Obama family living in the white house, living in any gov. mansion.  I bet he has atleast pumped his own gas once or twice since the 80's, come on people, stop spreading the filth and distractions, read something.

Truth leads to discovery  
The West Virginia turnout was much lighter than expected.  Goes to show the dazed and confused "Desperate" Hillary voters didn't bother to show.  Also 7% voted for Edwards, the other white meat, as they showed they're too prejudiced to even vote for a white woman.

Nope just an insignificant state voting an irrelevant candidate to a meaningless victory.  The math says Obama will win and the supers will come out in the next few days and erase her gains of yesterday.

Go Obama 08/12!
In addition to Hillary Clinton's 41-point landslide victory (an actual landslide, as opposed to Obama's meager 14-point, soley-demographic-driven victory in NC), let's discuss the idiocy of Obama's recent decision to bring back the flag pin (an underreported incident).  This man goes after Hillary Clinton for her gas-tax holidy (designed, for the most part, to ease the pain felt by truckers (not $30 savings to Jane Doe) and to, as a result, reduce food prices), calling her policy "pandering."  Well, he will rue the day this week that he chose re-don the flag pin (in, of all places, WV).  If Hillary pandered, which I do not believe she did, then it was with the goal of helping the American people.  He has pandered to help his own image.  It's clear to me which is worse.  Good luck in November, Barry.
Mav, although Obama is no elitist and doesn't loook down on you, I sure do because you're dumber than a bag of hammers.  If you want to elect a guy who will support all of Dubya's foreign policies and then some (to include singing about starting new wars), who has stated he doesn't understand how economics works, who will do nothing to expand healthcare coverage other than trust in his faith in the markets, who will appoint more Roberts and Alitos to the courts, etc., rather than support a Dem who agrees with Hillary on virtually all the issues, you are simply dumb.  Sorry, there's just no other way to put it.
Mav -- GET IT THROUGH YOUR HEAD! WE WILL NOT SUPPORT YOUR GUY! WE WILL N0T BACK HIM UP...
_____________________________________________________

Hey, Mav...you got a turd in your pocket?  What's this "we" stuff?  I am a Clinton supporter who will vote for Obama in November because I know that both Clinton and Obama are better for this country than McCain.  So please do not generalize and lump all Hillary supporters together as Obama haters.
The New York Times got it right....thank you!  I have been shouting this for awhile now.....and now I read it in the Times.  It was about race - not issues...how awfull - 8 in 10 voted for Hillary because of race. I also believe that happened in Pa as well as other states she suppose to have won. Everyone is afraid to talk about it.  But it is alive and well and biting everyone in the you know what.  The question I have is how can we band together and stop this disgrace one and for all!
And Hillary is NOT for the working class - I am one of them...a Nurse...in NY. She is preceived to be for us ..only comes out of the woodwork when it suits her. She lives lavishly in Washington DC - not here in NY.  She only has a house here. She is Not one of us...they just paint the picture of her for you by the "WorldComm" executive Terry McCaulif(not sure how to spell his name).....her campain chief and money bags.
Mav.   Are you a Democrat or a Republican?  I can't even fathom how people will vote against their economic interest in the general election either because someone is black or they think he is an elitist.  You have fallen for the Republican and HRC spin.  BHO is not an elitist if you compare incomes of the 3 candidates and the fact that he and his wife just paid off student loans a few years ago.  Over 4,000 of our young men and women have died in a war that should have never been, the economy is in the tank, people are losing their jobs and their homes but hey at least West Virginia can say they didn't vote for a black man.  This is beyond pathetic.
95 percent of Hillary and Baracks policy are the same.  It comes down to character.  I don't believe a word out of Hillary Clintons mouth.
I see a number of people complaining b/c black voters may be motivated by race as well - There is a HUGE difference here - They are NOT voting AGAINST a condidate SOLELY because of race. Claims of reverse racism here are intellectually dishonest.
GET IT THROUGH YOUR HEAD! WE WILL NOT SUPPORT YOUR GUY! WE WILL N0T BACK HIM UP…..**YOU ARE ON YOUR OWN**
-Mav

Sorry Mav, but no, we are not on our own, when Obama loses and the country gets McCain- the country loses (including u)- not just Obama supporters

Like it or not- WE R ALL IN THIS TOGETHER
Even if ur guy/girl loses- maybe u should consider doing what's best for the country (including yourself)-instead of trying to harm Obama supporters- u will only end up harming us all (including yourself)
Interesting that Hillary Clinton would win West Virgina and leading in Kentucky, where these two states lead the nation in the number of people with more then three missing teeth......
As it now stands neither McCain nor Hillary could win the dog-catchers spot on any ticket,McCain will retire after Nov. and Clinton will have a hard time getting re-elected in N.Y. After the race baiting in S.C. and her Black Boy can't win but White Girl can in W.V.it will make her chance of re-election slim to none.Lets face it Hillary is as much Republican as her father and his father.W.V. is a beautiful state,its just that the people that inhabit it are and as in most states simply un-educated and wish to remain so...
The promotion of racism is the problem.  Of course whites can vote for Hillary and blacks for Obama, but to say openly that one did not vote for Obama because of race, shows it's racism.  On top of this the media continuation of repeating it over and over shows it's racism because after all most of them are white.  This degradation of America makeup needs to stop.
What A Sad Day In Our Political Era, She Really Has Bought Out The Worst. To Suggest She Isn't Playing The Race Card Is Mind Blowing. Clearly The People In West Virginia Will Never Vote FOR Someone Different.It Has Nothing To Do With Working Class Voters.Lets Call It Like It Is. Hillary Knows This And So Do You Pundits.And To Suggest That They Are Thee Only One That Votes In America. Pleeeeeeeeeesseee.She Is Using Every Bit Of It, That These Die Hard Women Who Are Rooting For Her Are Delusional Just Like Her.She Doesn't Represent Me,She Is Not Srong In My Book. She Is Weak And Pathetic.
Can someone please point out the contradiction in Hillary's logic?  She claims to be more electable than Obama yet is behind in contests won, elected delegates, super-delegates, and popular vote. And she discounts races that included independents and Republicans as somehow invalid.  Seems to me that being ahead in all metrics AND drawing more independents and Republicans makes Obama the more electable candidate by far.
Does Hilary even realize what she's saying here? Uneduacted racist white people making less than 50,000 wont vote for Obama so She should be the nominee? lol because that's who we need deciding the election. Who cares about color or WV.. SMART people for Obama!
Joyce of NY
As a former NYer of 50+ years I can't believe that you are still pro Hillary considering that she has done nothing for NY except to use it as a political launching board and to hide behind Schumers coattails.

As a Wall Strret executive for 30+years with a masters in economics, Bill did not maanager the economy very well, his management led to the problems of the early 2000's.  The true impact of economic economic change is often felt years later.  Hillary's wonderful idea of gas tax holiday is another sign of her lack of understanding of a market economy.

As for race, I am a white 50+ college educated former Republican who switched to Independent to vote for Obama.  Obama gets it, you don't have to be an "expert" in everything you need to have sound judgement, pick the correct staff one that adds value and challenges each other and the ability to sell resolutions across party lines.  Hillary's problem is that she like Bush thinks she is never wrong and does not have the native skills or ingrained character to work across party lines.

I am not a bleeding heart liberal demonstrating black guilt by voting for Obama but rather someone who understands what leaders need to be sucessful in either business or government in today's world.
It is a shame that race is still a big part of our life. The voter in WVA is saying I would vote a DOG before I vote for a BLack Man. They also saying I do not care if that Black Man can being about a change in my life that would help everyone. Black Man no way in Hell.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1018618

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google