ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Obama: 'Operation Patriotism'

Posted: Monday, May 19, 2008 9:18 AM by Domenico Montanaro

Bloomberg News looks at Obama's "Operation Patriotism." Obama is now regularly wearing a flag pin. "Obama, 46, may be vulnerable on the patriotism question because he doesn't have a personal narrative that people can easily understand, and not wearing a flag pin and other issues have ‘put him on the non-patriot side,' said Peter Hart, a Democratic poll-taker unaligned with a candidate. ‘He has to plant his roots,' Hart said. ‘His mother has to become an important part of his story and he has to show people he lives an all-American life, with his children and other things, so voters can say, “we understand that; he's one of us.”’” 

More: "Obama plans to use speeches and campaign events to reinforce his patriotic image to America by evoking his grandparent's military background. He also plans to speak sometime this summer near Punchbowl National Cemetery in Honolulu, where his grandfather is buried. ‘My grandfather -- Stanley Dunham -- enlisted after Pearl Harbor and went on to march in Patton's Army,'' Obama said in Charleston. ‘My grandmother, meanwhile, worked on a bomber assembly line while he was gone, and my mother was born at Fort Leavenworth.'”

Obama is starting to pivot a bit on the issue of Social Security as an attempt to improve his standing with older voters. "Let me be clear, privatizing Social Security was a bad idea when George W. Bush proposed it, it's a bad idea today," Obama said. "That's why I stood up against this plan in the Senate and that's why I won't stand for it as president." 

Obama will not QUITE declare victory on Tuesday, but he'll be in Iowa, which isn’t a future primary state. "Obama explained today why he will spend election night on Tuesday in Iowa, a state whose caucuses took place in January, and in doing so continued to flirt with a declaration of victory in the presidential nominating process. ‘We thought it was a terrific way to bring things full circle,’ he told reporters after buying his kids ice cream at a diner here. ‘If Kentucky and Oregon go as we hope then we think we will have a majority of pledged delegates at that point and that's a pretty significant mark,’ he said.”

“Asked if that would be tantamount to securing the Democratic nomination, Obama said no. ‘It doesn't mean we declare victory because I won't be the nominee until we have a combination of both pledged delegates and super delegates to hit the mark, but what it does mean is that the voters have given us the majority of delegates that they can assign and obviously that's what this process is about.’”

The RNC has a new Web video hitting Obama on taxes.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

What a tool Obama has become. He thinks wearing a flag pin is going to make things all better for him. Face facts, Obama is more of the 'World Leader' kind of guy, and not so much this 'United States' leader. Obama would be better for the UN then he would be for the US. He really doesn't much care about people in this country. The white working class have figured that out, now others are too.
Karl Rove looks like Elmer Fudd....
"where's tha wabit?"

Flag pins are for symbols not a real issue...look how far Obama went without wearing a flag pin...
Why is she still fighting this?  I guess she is still trying to get FL & MI in so she can be ahead in the popular vote by a few thousand votes.  It's funny that she wasn't at all interested in those two states when she agreed to sign (in 2007 when she just KNEW she would have the nomination wrapped up by Super Tuesday) the declaration stating that their votes wouldn't count.  She agreed to the rules and now she wants to back down.  The entire DNC decided on the rules, but even so, it was the two states' legislature (mostly Republican) that voted and paid to have their primaries early.  She then tried to say that Barack was trying to disenfranchise the voters from those states.  I think they should be po'd at their elected officals for doing it to them.  
As far as privitizing SS..what good would it do now?  I always thought that the amount that was taken out of your check was based upon how much you made (shows how much I know) because it should be like taxes...the more you make the more they take...
I understand that there's a special lapel pin with 57 stars that Barack may want to use-afterall he said that he's campaigned in 57 states so far-and that must not include Kentucky or West Virginia. We already know were you stand on this one Barry-pandering to the center won't work.
Obama may not have the typical American story of old, of previous generations.  But it is a typical story of many of us now.  America is more diverse than ever before, more families are living without two parents at home, many of us (including myself) are multi-racial (I am 1/4 Asian, 3/4 white), many of us have come here in recent generations from another Country and have relatives that live in other countries.

So regardless of him not having the traditional American narrative, he has one of more recent Americans.  It is sellable, it is one that should resonate.  I think as he continues to talk it up, a lot of us (not all) will continue to understand this quiet and fierce patriotism.  It is a patriotism that is much longer on action and much shorter on symbolism and empty rhetoric.  I maintain there is no more greater act of patriotism (other than serving in the military) than helping our poorer by working as community activists and organizers.

From the ground up, is how this country was founded.  Barack Obama stands for that.

Obama for our best future, on a new but old narrative.
The RNC apparently doesn't have any reason to talk up its own candidate, so it wants to bring down another. Perhaps if the ad talked about a plausible alternative, it might be more believable.  And the ad seems to have the same male voiceover as used by the Clinton campaign, the voice of doom and gloom.  If that is all the RNC can offer, one can see why its party is doomed to failure.  
It's sad that Barack Obama has to wear a meaningless flag pin to prove to the knuckledraggers that he's a patriot.  Flag Pins and Support our Troops ribbon bumper stickers are poor substitutes for real patriotism.

Why do republicans hate our troops so much?  Why do they cry about paying higher taxes to pay for their dirty little war instead of putting it on credit?

A real patriot would gladly pay more taxes to properly fund our troops and pay for the war.  Only a self serving piece of garbage wants tax cuts at times like this.

The repugnant ones are just the second coming of Tory Traitors, boot licking lackeys of their King George!

Go Obama 08/12!
Senator Obama can wear a flag pin if he likes and he can not wear one of he likes, he is will remain my choice for President of the US.  Rove wears a flag pin, yet he will have to be forced to testify in a committee hearing.  How patriotic is that?  It isn't.  I'm sick of the repugnants outward signs of patriotism while the break laws all the time.  If Senator Obama chooses to wear a flag pin so as not to offend others, then he certainly has my permission.  What is going to be hilarious are the comments now about flip-flopping.  Isn't it sad with Americans dying overseas, houses being foreclosed on and an economy in the red--that this has to be an issue.  
More data to suggest that the Obama campaign is politically brilliant.
1. Reintroduce the flag pin now & start talking about patriotism.  We're in a lull while the Dem nomination winds down - this is a period where he can't suffer in the primary because of this "flip flop".  But, the General hasn't started, so he can define his patriotism before he has to go up against the war hero McCain.  
2. Tuesday victory speech in Iowa will symbolize the fact that this primary season is over.  He won in Iowa on Jan 3rd and he'll implicitly declare victory there on May 20th.  Not being in Oregon insinuates that the point for him is not winning primaries anymore.  It's not about thanking Oregon, it's about key November battleground states.  
His entire campaign (well, except Rev. Wright) has been tonally spot-on.  Bodes well for the General.
I'm glad that Barack Obama will stand up against privatizing Social Security.  "RobberBaron" Bush tried to steal Social Security away from the vast majority people it was meant to help and give the majority of the benefits to the rich and greedy who don't even need social security.

Just more Sheriff of Notingham government from the repugnant ones who only believe in taking from the poor and needy to give to the rich and greedy.

Time for some Robin Hood government with Obama taking from the rich and greedy and giving it to the poor and needy, not to mention the shrinking middle class who are taking a bath at the hands of the robberbaron party.

Go Obama 08/12!
Obama said the military should be properly trained, properly equiped and treated right when they come home from war, too bad bush/cheney/rummy didn't believe that.
We're in a ridiculous place when someone who worked his entire adult life in public service, starting at the level of neighborhood activist needs to defend his patriotism against attacks that are already known to be phony.
Why can't "Desperate" Hillary make any inroads on Obama's lead in states where he leads?  Considering Obama has decided to ignore her and campaign in general election mode she has not been able to make a dent in his commanding delegate lead.

With a split tomorrow Obama just keeps making a comeback more and more mathmatically impossible.  Even adding in Florida and Michigan will not save the big loser from stealing away a nomination that was hers to lose and she did with a pathetically run campaign.

Like we're supposed to trust her to not run a stupid campaign in the general election, not me that's for sure.

Go Obama 08/12!
As always the RNC has to fall back on lying about taxes and trying to bribe the electorate with tax cuts that can't be afforded because the repugnant ones don't have a plan for this country that people want to hear.

The RNC is responsible for bankrupting social security with "Alzheimer" Reagan's big tax cuts for the rich and greedy and running up massive national debt.  The RNC is responsible for allowing the politicians to waste my generation's social security overpayments and now they're telling us to expect less than we were promised.

Go Obama 08/12!
What sound does Mike Huckabee make when someone points a gun at him?

The sound of a body thudding to the floor and him shrieking like a terrified little girl!

Go Obama 08/12!
How can Obama prove his patriotism when he and his wife worked so hard in the primary to show how much they despise America??

RevWrightGate
BitterGate
BillAyersGate
FlagPinGate
NationalAnthemGate
ProudofMyCountryGate

Anyone sense a theme here?
Good Grief!  All the candidates are patriotic.  What a non-issue!
I don't think he should use his grandparent's narrative to introduce himself. I understand he spent alot of his early childhood overseas..but he'd do better to craft his vision and experience of America into an easily digestible speech. That would be a better way b/c it'd be about him..not his family.
What a hypocrite.  For a year and a half he refused to wear a pin. When he kept getting asked why he didn't wear one, he said that he felt wearing an American flag pin on his lapel represented a false sign of patriotism.

After months and months of getting dinged for it, he started wearing one the day that he was endorsed by Edwards and has been wearing one ever since trying to pander to the people that don't like him, the people that are supporting Clinton and the working class voters that he can't connect with.

This guy is as BIG a phony as they come.

And Claire McCaskill this morning when asked about WV, she said that Obama would have done better in WV if he had spent more time in WV.  She said that it was unfortunate that he was only able to go to WV one time.

These people really do think that everyone who isn't supporting Obama is stupid.

There was an entire week between the primaries in IN & NC and on the day that WV voted, there were no other elections anywhere in the entire country on that day.

The day after IN & NC, Clinton went to WV and campaigned there every day and all day long while Obama was everywhere else but.

He had the time and the money to be in WV for an entire week and campaign just like Clinton did, but he DELIBERATELY chose not to go to WV more than one time.

He knew he was going to lose WV so his campaign didn't see the point in spending any time there at all.  However, they also knew that they couldn't skip the state completely.  So they figured if they went there one time (literally), they could claim that they went there, but avoid wasting any time there, and by only going once, they could whine and cry as they have for the past week about how he would have done better if they had spent more time there.

If he would have done better if he had spent more time in WV, then why didn’t he?

What a load of crap.

And they're doing the same thing right now in KY, and when he loses KY, he and his campaign will say the exact same thing about KY that they said about WV.  They'll say that he could have done better if he had only had more time to spend in KY even though he is once again DELIBERATELY choosing to spent no time in KY but instead, spend all of his time in the state that he’s supposed to win anyway.

It’s not about time.  It’s not about how much or little time he has.  It’s about how much of his time he has chosen to deliberately spend, and where he has chosen to deliberately spend it.
I FIND IT FUNNY THAT THE QUESTION OF ANY AMERICANS PATROITISM IS STILL A TALKING POINT!I AM DEEPLY OFFEND BY THIS.I LOVE MY COUNTRY BUT I HATE MY GOVERNMENT.THE REPUBILICAN PARTY HAS TRASHED THIS COUNTRY AND THE MILITARY DOES THAT MAKE THEM UN-PATROITIC? THIS IS A STUPID TALKING POINT!
So, we're back to the flag lapel pin again?  Don't we have better things to do than get the candidates into a contest over who is the most patriotic?
Yes, it's back to the flag pin. This is what people who don't support him have to go with, If they said the real reason why they don't support him is because he's half black they would look bad. So they go for the little things and try to turn them into something big. Most of the people who don't support him have no interest in even finding out where he stands on the issues. He's half black and that's all they need to know.
The insanity, what is a picture worth? The want to be a president is not enough, The new president can't move with out Congress! So all the insane masks they want to paint over failed issue is just that ""a Mask""! In reality "Nothing" shall change with the present Congress"! Does that not void the meaning of ""NEW""?


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1037754

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google