ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Clinton: Finding her voice, but too late?

Posted: Tuesday, May 20, 2008 9:13 AM by Mark Murray

Has Clinton become Al Gore? She found her voice too late? Still, the fact remains: Clinton has re-made her image and created a distinctive brand from her husband. Frankly, she has accomplished a lot, it's just come a bit too late, just like Al Gore. (It also came with a favorable post-February primary calendar.) Maybe, Hillary and Gore have a lot more in common than they realize; it takes years, not months, to grow out of Bill's shadow.

The Washington Post's Romano writes: "No one is quite sure when Clinton hit her stride, when she stopped caring about the polls, when she took her campaign to the people and gave voters a window into her soul. She said she found her voice in New Hampshire, but then all we heard was Bill's. Some say it was when senior strategist Mark Penn was forced to leave the campaign; he did not put a premium on the personal side of politics. Or it could have simply been when she was losing and so had nothing to lose by being herself.”

“‘The irony is that candidates often find their voices once the pressure is off,’ said Peter D. Hart, a Democratic pollster and strategist. They are comfortable with ‘who they are and what they are. It comes at a point in the campaign when the candidate says this is what I want to say and this is who I am. For Hillary Clinton, as you stripped away all the varnish, the core person is the most attractive of all.’”

The New York Times’ Nagourney, in a fascinating online look at individual dominoes in the Clinton collapse, pulls back the curtain on the Drudge effect: “In October, The New York Times published an article examining the relationship between Mrs. Clinton and the Drudge Report. The article related how the Drudge Report, which historically had tormented the Clintons, had begun routinely posting items boosting Mrs. Clinton’s campaign, at the prompting of an intermediary between Mrs. Clinton’s campaign and the Web site. For the Clinton campaign, things changed almost overnight after that: The Drudge Report returned to being a vehicle driving negative stories about Mrs. Clinton, bad news about the Clinton campaign got extensive attention, and Mrs. Clinton’s war room spent many hours trying to tamp down rumors and suspect information being trumpeted on the site.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

This reminds me of how Gore used to re-invent himself every 3 weeks. Obama better not let his guard down , I sense a smiley face lets bring the party together rope-a-dope here. This is going to a floor fight in Denver . This woman is unstable and borderline insane.
I don't think she found her voice.  I think as we are coming to the end of this process, she reinvented her voice to speak to the people of West Virginia and Kentucky who support her strongly and have from the beginning.  They are not new constituents.  For the most part, they are at the bottom rung of the economic and educational index, with much to lose if they sink further down in this time of economic crises.  The politics of fear is an easy sell for Hillary Clinton in these area and she has capitalized on it.  In the process of doing so she has offended many others who supported her "prior voice."  

I would like to know who the real Hillary Clinton is?  I don't think we have seen her yet.
When a candidate has to be told what to say, to whom to say it, and how to say it vs. taking control of their own destiny, well, that's a problem.  Why pretend or take advice for someone to "Not Be Yourself"  That's called Pandering.  We cannot afford to have this kind of representation in the White house.

Unfortunately has done a huge disservice to women by always blaming someone else for her troubled campaign.  She also set a very Poor Example by refusing to this day to accept the Party Rules.  Changing the goal post is not what we teach our children nor do we want someone else teaching them to win by dishonesty.

At the end of the day we have a candidate, and being a woman has nothing to do with it as millions of women will tell you, that simply could not play by the rules and used women to further her own cause.  That continues to this day.

There are millions of women world wide that play by the rules and accept when they loose according to the rules by looking into the mirror and learning from any mistakes they made along the way.  That's how we learn from our mistakes.

Sen. Clinton has dissapointed millions the press is not the problem because she enjoyed 90% better press than Sen. Obama as he had to struggle to get any favorable press until the numbers just weren't there.

Sen. Obama has been and continues to be very respectful of Sen. Clinton reagardless of what those women like Geraldine Ferarrer say.  We are dissapointed in her to to use a campaign to question our intellect.  Sen. Obama defended her publicy and her work in the Civil Rigthts movement, yet because she received critism for those she thinks are Sen. Obama's supporters for her awful remarks she is laying the blame at his feet.  Even this morning Ms. Farrer showed how completely out of touch she was by mistreperting Sen. Obama' JZ move to letting the negative comments role off to "Brushing Off Sen. Clinton".   So NOT TRUE.  These women must decide what they stand for, either the betterment of the American People or for Self.  Bottom line

This campaign is not about any candidate never has been it's about the suffering of the American People and this Recession.  Anyone who does not understand that should not be a part of this process.

Fortunately, when you take a selfish position for self vs. the American people that tells the American just who you are and what you stand for.

There's been too much self in Washington that's what got us into this mess in the first place.  The American people are tired and will take back this country.

Sen. Clinton may have a lot of women that support her behavior rather placing the blame where it belongs on her failed campaign strategy, took certain things for granted, did not follow the rules or did not fully understand them or take them serious, made a pledge in writing that Michigan and Fl. would not count even said publicly they did not count and changed her mind when her numbers fell behind.  A great Candidate must keep their no matter what.  If they cannot keep their word or accept responsibility for their own campaign, then this is not someone we want in the White House.  Yes this is a woman talking anf many millions of Women across American feel the same.  We don't need protecting.  We earn our way and accept responsibility for those things that are within our power to change, correct and did not

So it's time for Sen. Clinton to Play By the Rules, accept responsibility for her own campaign errors/mismanagement and either join her party or choose to join her Republican counter parts which she continues to look to for guidance.  
A canidate's voice should never be determined by how well they are doing in polls. Hillary has never felt authentic - from her forced smiles to her politically motivated opinions and pandering for votes.

Hillary is a student of "old politics" who has a masters degree in pandering from the school of spin.
I thought she was "ready on day one"????????
This seems to be the third or fourth time Clinton has found her voice. Each time it is a new voice, with a different accent (matched to the region) and a new take on the election.
Hill/Bill's biggest problem is she is in the "adolescent" stage of her political life. She wants to be an adult and play like an adult...problem is she is covered in blemishes and her "VOICE" keeps changing!
Didn't she find her voice in New Hampshire? What... did she lose it again until now?

At the urging of other posters, I'm trying to be nice to her for the sake of unity, but its hard. This constant drama of watching the Hillary Clinton personal journey through the American electoral process and her own ego had already jumped the shark a long time ago.
This clarifies exactly why Hillary is not suited to the presidency. One doesn't "find their voice" in the middle of a campaign -- it's something you develop over years of study and thought and action, not in reaction to polls.

My number one criticism of her has always been that she's artificial and a creation of spin doctors and political calculation. This latest reinvention is proof positive that she lacks authenticity.
Howard, New York (Sent Tuesday, May 20, 2008 9:27 AM)

Amen, brother!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1042892

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google