ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Despite absence, McCain battles Obama

Posted: Thursday, May 22, 2008 2:14 PM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

From NBC/NJ's Carrie Dann and NBC's Ken Strickland and Mark Murray
IRVINE, CA -- Today, McCain's pick for "Person of the Year" -- Gen. David Petraeus -- was appearing before the Senate Armed Services Committee, of which the Arizona senator serves as the ranking member. Also, a GI bill that McCain actively debated came to the Senate floor and was passed as part of a larger war-spending bill.

But while Obama and Clinton both left the campaign trail to return to Hill, McCain happens to be in, well, California, where (among other things) he's attending a town hall with Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger.

A McCain spokesman said the Arizona senator's absence was due simply to a scheduling conflict. "We have a schedule that is set far in advance," spokesman Brian Rogers said. (Per a Senate Armed Services press release, the Petraeus hearing was scheduled eight days ago, on May 14.)

But McCain's absence didn't stop the Arizona senator from sparring with Obama over an education bill authored by Sen. Jim Webb, a Vietnam vet who might be a possible Obama veep pick.

McCain, a fellow vet, tried to amend that bill last week after raising objections to the Webb plan, which offers education benefits to service members that would be so attractive that some Republicans (including McCain and President Bush) were worried that the Armed Forces would face declining retention rates as a result. McCain's version failed after being tabled by the Senate last week. But today, the Webb measure passed as part of a larger domestic spending bill. 

On the Senate floor today, Obama blasted McCain's opposition to the Webb bill. "I respect Sen. John McCain's service to our country. He is one of those heroes of which I speak. But I can't understand why he would line up behind the President in his opposition to this GI Bill. I can't believe why he believes it is too generous to our veterans. I could not disagree with him and the president more on this issue. There are many issues that lend themselves to partisan posturing but giving our veterans the chance to go to college should not be one of them."

McCain, however, shot back with this fiery response, which included a sharp jab at the fact that Obama didn't serve in the military. 

"It is typical, but no less offensive that Sen. Obama uses the Senate floor to take cheap shots at an opponent and easy advantage of an issue he has less than zero understanding of," the Arizona senator said in a statement. "I know that my friend and fellow veteran, Sen. Jim Webb, an honorable man who takes his responsibility to veterans very seriously, has offered legislation with very generous benefits. I respect and admire his position, and I would never suggest that he has anything other than the best of intentions to honor the service of deserving veterans. Both Sen. Webb and I are united in our deep appreciation for the men and women who risk their lives so that the rest of us may be secure in our freedom."

McCain added, "And I take a backseat to no one in my affection, respect and devotion to veterans. And I will not accept from Sen. Obama, who did not feel it was his responsibility to serve our country in uniform, any lectures on my regard for those who did."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Why is that every time something important is happening at McCain's job, which he is elected and paid to do, he is never there?

Jesus people, you want this idiot for president?????

http://www.politivine.com
Superdelegates, stop the evil being attempted in increments by the Clintons, so Obama can fight McCain without one hand tied behind his back.
http://twocanpete.blogspot.com/
It must be nice to double dip three bills a year from the government and still not show up to work.
In all of McCane's rhetoric and attacks on Senator Obama I didn't read where he said he would support the Webb Bill.  Did I miss it?  Bottom Line--McCain doesn't support the veterans because his actions/lack of support demonstrates that he does not support our veterans.  McCain is shameful for not helping the veterans but is willing to spend billions on another country.  Backstabbing Hypocrit!
McCain goes after Obama while the SuperDelegates and the DNC sit on their hands.  I've never been more disgusted with my party.  Apparently they'd prefer to lose in Nov. than stand up to the mighty Clintons.  
McFlop what a low blow, because Obama didn't serve in the Armed Forces.

Wait a minute McFLOP...before you defend any veteran...why haven't you signed the new GI BILL, increasing the benefits for our Service Members?

Obama will squash McCain with one hand tied behind his back in one word...BUSH!

McCain is wearing clown shoes, get him outta here!
McCain is a sad phony and deserves respect for serving this country, but even doing that should have given him more leave way with taking care of our veterans.

He has been in government for 20 plus years, well where is his outrage of homeless veterans, what about the care of the Soldiers returning from war, and what about veterans begging for benefits?  

McFLOP has no shame and he needs to shut his trap about Obama and sign the new GI BILL!  More signing and less talking MCFLOP!  
My grandad once told me.........you may not ever be able to build a clock, but make damn sure you can tell time........OBAMA 08
Old man yells at cloud!!
Old Man Yells At Cloud ...
How convenient that he skipped the vote for the G.I. Bill, too ... rather than to keep opposing it ... what a coward!

Old Man Yells At Cloud ...

OBAMA '08
Apparently you need a refresher lecture. You've seemed to have forgotten how to defend vets. I guess if I married a woman worth a 100 million, I might forget about the common man too.
Hey, McSame:  You can run, but you can't hide --- you still have to answer for HAGEE!!!
If McCain is united with Webb in appreiciating the men and women who fight for our country, then why did he join Bush in opposing the GI Bill?
Typical GOP response to our troops. We want your bodies on the line but your minds can rot because if you start learning and thinking for yourself you may not want this military lifesytle. The point of a small, effeciant army is to defend our nation in the time of need (not greed i.e. Iraq) and use our superior technology and diplomacy as our primary weapons. The GOP wants to keep our troop ignorant and uneducated so they have no other choice but the military. What Nation do we live in again?
Soooo....all that bluster but no explanation as to why he opposes the bill. So much for Straight Talk.
...and McSame, you DID wear the uniform (which makes your lack of action even more despicable), but I guess since you were fortunate enough to marry into your fortune and will have no problem attaining healtcare etc., you couldn't care less whether or not other vets have the same opportunity for these rights and privileges.  What a selfish old man.

OBAMA/BIDEN, 2008!
*********************************

ITS EITHER CLINTON OR REGAN DEMS GO FOR MCCAIN COME NOV !!

DNC ---you chose!
Well, so much for the "positive campaign" that they both promised we'd have. I had hoped we'd be past the Republican attack dogs, but no such luck. Hillary is now damaging the prospects for a woman candidate anytime soon with her attacks; and McCain seems to have no compassion for the current crop of vets in the field, who will not be able to afford college without some help. What is wrong with these people?
That's right, McAbsent, keep trying to convince us that you're strong on National Security.
Obviously, McCain cannot multitask. I guess we can certainly say the Dems care about our troops more than McCain since they set aside their schedule to be in DC. McCain is a shadow of his former self. No Dem should ever vote for McCain, regardless, of their perceived dislike for the other DEM candidate. It is a shame to see McCain go down this path. He was a viable candidate in 2000 whom I could have voted for, but no this Dr. Jekyll, Mr. Hyde act he doing.
McCain you @#$%$%^!!!  Your speech and actions are blatantly antithetical!!  Stop yelling at the Clouds!!
Actions speak louder than words, Senator McCain.
Obama touch a little nerve with McBag-o-Bones???

you'll blast Obama for supporting the bill, but won't blast Webb for creating it?  Double talk!!!

It's a double edged sword McClueless!!  With your Buddy in office, stop loss will stop the exodus you fear.  From Obama and Webb's perspective, you may lose some folks, but you'll be replacing them with the huge incentive joining would then offer.

What a complete tool!!  

Lastly... I served in the the military for a decade, and won't condemn anyone for NOT choosing to volunteer to join the military.  

With that said, I also realize there are other ways to give back to this country... being a public servant and ensuring the people you represent are heard is just as important... McNoodle!

McShame: Blah! Blah! Blah! And full of you know what!!!

I support Senator Webb and his proposal to give benefits to the soldiers who are fighting this war in Iraq. Too many soldiers come home with feelings of despair. Having a future for them to look forward to can only benefit all of us. It will give them something to look forward to and sustain them. They are already giving 200% to the war effort even without this GI bill.

Thank you, Jim Webb





"And I take a backseat to no one in my affection, respect and devotion to veterans. And I will not accept from Sen. Obama, who did not feel it was his responsibility to serve our country in uniform, any lectures on my regard for those who did."


HOW PATHETIC Sen McSame......You treat those that serve after you like SHI$
I honestly pray that all of you McCain "Crazies" get your just desert if McCain is voted into office.  Because when we are all paying $8.00 for a gallon of gas, $10.00 for a loaf of bread, 4000 more dead in Iraq, and then IRAN, our troops serving 7 15 month tours, Bin Laden still living, and the unemployment rate at 10%... I honestly wonder how you could call yourselves American? If that is the America you want then I would gladly join you in HELL where it would be most fitting for the U.S. after 4 years of McCain.

F*****g Loonies.  People should check their local mental hospitals for any patients that might have escaped.
What a crock.  He won't take a backseat in his affection and devotion to his veterans, but won't pull out his pocketbook to do so?  Not every soldier can marry a beer heiress for 8 homes and a private jet.  How does McCain believe the veterans are going to pay for the life challenges of PTSD and the knowledge of over 100,000 of your countrymen who have died.  This man is less a war hero and more an opportunist.
Dear Sen. McCain,
Do you feel personal animosity toward Sen. Obama, or is this political posturing.  Sen. Obama has plenty of information on the subject.  There is no requirement that a president serve in the military, and for Sen. Obama (unlike George Bush and Bill Clinton) no draft.  Nor are women required to register with draft boards at age 18, and yet women are full participants in discussions on military issues.  
I think McCain's Senate pay check should be suspended...he's almost totally absent from work...unlike his competitors, Hillary and Obama, who have much better attendance records that him.
You voted for the Iraqi war; then flip--flopped; and Obama as naive for his stance on Afganistan. I trust nothing you say.



Sen. Clinton superdelegates have chosen the stronger nominee against John McCain.


Hillary, if McCain and Bush are criticizing and focusing their energies on Obama, shouldn’t that tell you something?

In plain English, it means the Republicans think; no matter how strong you think you are, Obama is their presumptive nominee.

Step it of lady. Real women move on and take care of the business. Hillary you have a lot of business to attend to. First and foremost, UNITY of the party,  and the nation is needed in these troubling days. The world is watching and waiting for America to restore her face. You can start by DEBUNKING these lies….

Obama does not share Rev Wright’s values; that’s why he disavowed the reverend.
Obama, AS YOU NOW KNOW; is not a Muslim.
Minister Louis Farrakhan has no association with Obama; Obama rejects his support.
Your husband, PRESIDENT BILL CLINTON PRAISED MINISTER FARRAKHAN AND THE MILLIONS MORE MOVEMENT DESCRIBING IT AS A POSITIVE IDEA.
Minister Louis Farrakhan was invited to Philadelphia by the then Mayor Rendell to speak and help heal the racial divide; while holding hands, singing and lavishing praise in April 15, 1997.
You should stress that it should be known… Obama’s won more states some big, some little; Pennsylvania, Ohio, West Virginia and Kentucky may tout your claims of rural whites not voting Obama. Yet, the real truth is states like Wisconsin, Colorado, Michigan, and Oregon Obama has won.

Most importantly, Senator Jim Webb said in The Wall Street Journal Saturday, October 23, 2004… “THE GREATEST REALIGNMENT IN MODERN POLITICS WOULD TAKE PLACE RATHER QUICKLY IF THE RIGHT NATIONAL LEADER FOUND A WAY TO BRING THE SCOTS-IRISH AND AFRICAN-AMERICANS TO THE SAME TABLE, AND SO TO REDEFINE A FORMULA THAT HAS CONSCIOUSLY SET THEM APART FOR THE PAST TWO CENTURIES”.  ALSO SENATOR WEBB SAID…“THE DECLINE IN PUBLIC EDUCATION AND THE OUTSOURCING OF JOBS HAS HIT THIS CULTURE HARD.”

Once you complete this task history will record you as one of the most courageous and persuasive women the world.

Neither you nor Obama will walk almost lame into the Democratic National Convention if you put together this coalition. Surely this will be historic for you.

Right on Mac! You hit the nail in the head. BO does not even have a clue what he is talking about.

Will he include any mental health records when he releases his medical records tomorrow? Seriously. You cannot be a POW and be tortured like he was WITHOUT some kind of mental problems arising afterwards. Is he even STABLE enough to be running for office? A lot of us are wondering.  Where does all his anger stem from? Something people should be asking or will he get a free ride on this subject also?
As usual, McCain is deflecting the issue to mean something entirely different than what was said.  And, if he really so respects the troops, let him explain why he opposes a GI Bill that would give them an opportunity to advance their education.  That is a pretty "shoddy" way to "keep them in the military".  This is still a free country ... their staying or going is a free choice and should not be manipulated by this administration or any other.
McCain cares so much for veterans that he skipped the vote today on the Webb GI Bill. One of the most important pieces of legislation for our veterans in recent years.

What a joke John McCain is!

http://laststopmidwest.blogspot.com
Nice comback for J Mac\ about being lectured.

But, he now can be labeled as non-commital on a bill that supports veterans.  By not being there to vote, he didn't have to get stuck with the No vote he was planning to make.
"which offers education benefits to service members that would be so attractive that some Republicans (including McCain and President Bush) were worried that the Armed Forces would face declining retention rates as a result. "



Ooohhhhhh, PUKE!

How in hell could it? Between "stop loss" where no one gets out, and just the fact that who in hell would want to miss their chance to die in a Baghdad alley fighting for Bush's oil friends just to go to college? It's impossible to make college attractive enough to lure anyone from that glory. Too bad Bush is such a coward and McCain is so crazy, or they'd see that.
Then why not back the bill.  Talk is cheap.
That was a sharp attack by McCain to call out Obama for not serving.

But McCain has his own issues being that he is one of the VERY FEW politicians in history who have served in the military and been this hawkish and irresponsible with war spending as a politician.  Eisenhower gave a speech about the military industrial complex and how it would doom America.  Sorry McCain, you are no Eisenhower.
McCain added, "And I take a backseat to no one in my affection, respect and devotion to veterans. And I will not accept from Sen. Obama, who did not feel it was his responsibility to serve our country in uniform, any lectures on my regard for those who did."

-John McCain

So does that mean McCain will suffer only Military Service Persons in his Cabinet, and as Advisors?
McCain wants soldiers for life because they'll have no options if they leave.

Obama wants soldiers to serve because they feel called to do so, even when they can choose otherwise.

Which stance is more respectful to soldiers?  Do we want our soldiers proud to serve, for fearful of leaving?
I don't care if McCain did serve in the Armed Services. He is still wrong. In fact it was Senator Obama that went out of his way to improve the situation at Walter Reed Hospital........where was McCain then?

You don't have to be in the military to want to CARE for our troops. To me, it looks like Mccain would rather be in California than do anything constructive for the troops. he is just happy to keep them fighting in a nonsensicle war.
God, save this country from McCain
Again, Not in the Senate for the voting?
Hello, John Dubya?!? Name me more than a bare minimum of chickenhawks in the Bush admin who felt it was their responsibility to serve their country---including that creepy Veep of Bush's.  Sorry if your notorious temper is getting the best of you.  At least Obama felt it was his responsibility to come off the trail and vote FOR these vets you SAY you care so much about! Who supports the troops NOW, grandpa?!?
Ouch!!! Obama is a wimp.
McCAIN Doesn't have need to care for the Veterans, because he is sitting on 100s of millions of his wife's money unlike the Veterans. So, he is against the GI bill.
"an issue he has less than zero understanding of" ?

Senator McCain,
All of us who are children of WWII veterans understand and have had their lives affected by the WWII era G.I. Bill. It created the middle class that your party is so eager to destroy. Your opposition to Webb's bill only serves to illustrate the intensity of your flip-flopping as you scrounged for a nomination that will prove to be worthless in November. 8 years ago you would have co-sponsored this bill. 8 years ago you would have put down with a few words and a smile your demagog  Rev. Haggee  and his assertions that the death of 6 million jews at the hands of the Nazis was somehow met with Gods approval. 8 years ago your political integrity was intact. Now it is in tatters. Your personal Honor, bravery and devotion to Country can and should never be challenged but your Political credibility is at an end.

Obama '08
My My same old dog and pony show how I served the country well their are lot of different ways you serve the country. Joing the forces is not the only way and by the way not everyone like to go out there and get killed for what "politicians".
Wow, double talk express is a good label for McCan't do anyting right.
I wonder how Sen. McCain feels about those who do step forward to serve in the military and then shirk their responsibilities to fulfill that commitment?  Maybe he would be good enough, for example, to comment on the current President's illustrious military career. And while he's at it, maybe he would comment on our current Vice President's statement that he had better things to do than serve in his nation's military.

Regarding the objection that the G.I. Bill benefits are too great and that active duty personnel would use it rather than re-enlist, is the Senator from Arizona saying that perhaps we should revisit the issue of a draft?


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1053059

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google