ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Obama links McCain to Bush on Cuba

Posted: Friday, May 23, 2008 4:11 PM by Mark Murray

From NBC/NJ's Adam Aigner-Treworgy
MIAMI -- Democrats often argue that McCain would be a “third Bush term” on Iraq and the economy, but today Obama linked the presumptive GOP nominee and President Bush on yet another issue: Cuban relations.
 
Speaking at a Cuban Independence Day celebration here, Obama delivered what advisors called a “major policy speech” on the United States’ relationship with Central and South America, but he still found plenty of opportunity to throw some punches on McCain’s policy towards our neighbors to the south.

“Instead of offering a strategy, a strategy for change, [McCain] chose to distort my position, embrace George Bush’s, and continue a policy that’s done nothing to advance freedom for the Cuban people,” Obama said, referring to a speech McCain delivered in Miami earlier in the week. “That’s the political posture that John McCain has chosen, and all it shows is that you can’t take his so-called straight talk seriously.”

How did McCain distort Obama’s position you may ask? “John McCain’s been going around the country talking about how much I want to meet with Raul Castro, as if I’m looking for a social gathering, I’m going to invite him over and have some tea. That’s not what I said, John McCain knows it. After eight years of the disastrous policies of George Bush, it is time to pursue direct diplomacy, with friend and foe alike, without preconditions.”

The decision over which foreign leaders to talk to as president and what conditions to set on these hypothetical talks has become a hotly contested issue in this pseudo-general election campaign between Obama and McCain. As previously noted here, this is one of those rare instances where both sides see this as a winning issue.

And in response to Obama, McCain spokesman Tucker Bounds said, "Senator Obama's promises of unilateral concessions to Cuba’s dictators even in advance of an unconditional summit meeting with Raul Castro is exactly the wrong approach to free the people of Cuba."
 
In his speech today, Obama called for the reinstatement of the Special Envoy for the Americas in the White House, and for loosening some of the restrictions placed on Cuban-Americans by the Bush Administration. “I will immediately allow unlimited family travel and remittances to the island,” he said. “It’s time to let Cuban-Americans see their mothers and their fathers, their sisters and their brothers. It’s time to let Cuban-American money make their families less dependent upon the Castro regime.”

And in a briefing before the speech, Obama’s foreign policy advisers conceded that if certain conditions were met -- such as releasing political prisoners and allowing increased freedoms within Cuba -- loosening the trade embargo would also be on the table if Obama were president.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Has the 40+ year-old Cuban policy worked? Is Cuba a democracy? Have all the political prisoners been released? Will the current policy change anything? No? If the US can normalize relations with China then what's the problem with Cuba??? Oh yeah. All those ex-patriot voters down in FLA.
Superdelegates, give the Clintons the well-deserved hook so Obama can concentrate on the important task at hand.  The country shouldn't suffer to satisfy the Clintons' selfish desires.
Good for Obama.  It's about time a Democrat appealed to common sense on this issue.  Sometimes being right matters more than doing what a political adviser would tell you ("it's Florida...don't say that").
McBush has got to be peeing his pants about now.  McBush talks tough and Obama quietly CRUSHES HIM LIKE A BUG!!!  Scrape him off your shoe Senator Obama and move on.
As Pat Buchanon (sp?) said on "Morning Joe" today...Obama simply asked why McCain wasn't supporting the bill and McCain took it personally.  His response acted like he was stung on a personal lever - "How dare you question me!  Don't you know I was in the miliary?"

As for Mr. Obama not having military service...
(a) it's not a requirement to be president
(b) there is no draft, so it wasn't required at all
(c) I dare say there is more people w/o military experience than with - how many senators/congresspeople have experience?
(d) Last I checked, Billary did not serve, either.  Bill actually thought he was too good to answer the draft, so he dodged it
(e) Same goes for GOP gods Bush and Cheney
(f) it was McCain's family business, and it doesn't sound like he was trained to do anything else.

As long as there are knowledgable advisors in his cabinet (and he actually LISTENS to them, unlike Bushie) he should be fine.

Obama is cool headed under fire - while McCain is screaming at clouds and continuing the "how dare you question me!" rhetoric from the last 8 years.

Do we really want to continue down THAT road?  I sure don't.
No surprise that the repugnant ones are trying to twist and distort what Obama said about Cuba in order to try to attack him.  They can't use the truth so they resort to lies as always.  Obama has the correct idea on how to bring Cuba into line as a friend rather than just another enemy that the repugnant ones want to use a boogeyman to scare the Cuban-American community into voting for them.

Hey First Read where's an article on what "Wicked" Hillary said today about staying in the race because Bobby Kennedy got assassinated in June?  Does she know something we don't, like one of her cronies will try to emulate Sirhan Sirhan?

I just heard Dianne Feinstein say that Barack has to pick the Wicked Witch as his running mate.  I sent her an e-mail telling her I'll never, ever vote for her again because she's appeased "Tyrant" Bush on too many court appointments and now this attempt to sabotage Barack's chances of winning in November.  I suggest other Californians send "Appeaser" Dianne an e-mail that she just lost their votes as well.

Go Obama 08/12!
This is getting old. Obama is nothing more then the  first coming of Michael Dukakis, and second coming of that great foreign and domestic mind(less) wonder, Jimmy Carter. The man (Obama) hasn't a clue what he's talking about, but only plays these silly little games were he tries to relate McCain to Bush.

So Obama, rather then continue with the negative attacks all the time, please, tell us about all your great accomplishments in the US Senate (I count zero), in the Illinois Senate (still none) and as a so-called "community organizer" (what ever that is).
name absolutely one thing that the Republicans have done for the American Cuban people beside make them promises year after year, no delivery while they are separated from their loved ones in Cuba.  Can you imagine being separated from your family possibly forever and people come in an make speeches, won't even consider talking to use smart depolmacy to effect potential change and you keep voting for them year after year after year.  Votes should be earned!
God help us.  This man, Obama, has gone mad.

He isn't even the nominee for the dems and he is acting like he is in charge of the presidency.

God save our country from this man.  
Barack, when you flying to Cuba to meet with Castro? While you're down that way, might as well make a quick stop in Venezuela to see your buddy Chavez. All three of you can chat about which one of you is the biggest socialist.
We now enjoy good trading and other relations with VietNam, the very same commie country we fought for so long because someone was willing to meet with them and negotiate good treaties that help us bring VietNam along as a friend.

Obama wants to do the same thing, bring an old enemy into line as a new friend.  "Warmonger" McCain and the repugnant ones only want to keep Cuba as a boogeyman so they can scare the Cuban-American voters into voting for them.  They want to maintain the status quo of smear and fear for political gain.

Go Obama 08/12!
Shhh. Listen real close. You can hear the sound of Florida slipping away from Obama for the GE. It sounds like, victory for McCain.
God help us.  This man, Obama, has gone mad.

He isn't even the nominee for the dems and he is acting like he is in charge of the presidency.

God save our country from this man.  
If Obama continues to push for free talks "without preconditions," he will lose this election, and he will lose it badly.  All of his asserted "examples" of this type of action are fabricated mis-remembrances.  To hell with historical accuracy, says Obama.  JFK's attempt at this type of diplomacy made him look like a fool and directly threatened American security in the worst possible way.  "Without preconditions" is Obama's "I voted for it before I voted against it" moment, and it will be his downfall in a war-time election.
HRC just cited Robert Kennedy's assassination in June as justification for staying in the race--to the Sioux Falls Argus Leader in South Dakota!!!
When Barack becomes POTUS, he can lift this embargo, we can open trade relations, just like with do with so called other communist countries in China (which basically owns us) and Vietnam (which we fought a disastrous war there). Then he can lift the equal disastrous wet foot/dry foot policy which gives Cubans carte blanche here in Miami, they claim they are fleeing communism which is false, they are fleeing economic hardships,which puts an equal strain on this community when they come over. That's why we need open dialogue Mr. McSame to solve these problems and not stay with the status quo.

Obama 08/12  
Now that's "Change"....not McSame!!

Prediction: The Bush administration will announce new Cuban travel rules in the coming months to help McSame win the election.
So when will you report that Sen. Clinton, in an interview today with a South Dakota news outfit, referred to RFK's assasination as a new reason for her to stay in the race?  Really, how much more can even her most loyal supporters take of this toxic person?
A new day is dawning for America.  The Great Nation that we all dreamed to live in and raise our children to be proud of ..is about to be upon us.

Barack Obama...Will not only heal our nation but bring great ideas and do great things for the citizens of our country.

He will certainly plant the true nature of our Democracy seed to other nations around the world...

We will once again be the mighty respected United States of American - but better 10 times over.

This man will be one of the best leaders of all times. He speaks the truth without slander and focuses on the issues and the differences between sustains and just talk without action.

Barack Obama is a man of sustains and rest assured he will come through and not let U.S. down.

Thank you and GOD Bless America
There you go again Barack, telling us how you're going to talk with every little tin-pot dictator that shows up on the doorstep. By this time next year, you'll have negotated that Cuba gets half of Florida. Please, do try to keep DisneyWorld in the US. It's for the children.
I have to say that the Cuba policy hasn't done much.  I would have hoped that presidents past, current and future would do more to inspire the people of Cuba to demand change to a more open form of government.  We, as Americans, must be open to the idea that we need to do something more proactive with Cuba to help them become a more open society, politically speaking.  


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1058841

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google