ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Hillary invokes RFK assassination

Posted: Friday, May 23, 2008 4:23 PM by Mark Murray

From NBC's Mark Murray and Domenico Montanaro
This might not help the Hillary-for-veep chatter... The New York Post writes, "Hillary Clinton today brought up the assassination of Sen. Robert Kennedy while defending her decision to stay in the race against Barack Obama. 'My husband did not wrap up the nomination in 1992 until he won the California primary somewhere in the middle of June, right? We all remember Bobby Kennedy was assassinated in June in California. I don't understand it,' she said, dismissing calls to drop out."

"Clinton made her comments at a meeting with the Sioux Falls Argus-Leader's editorial board while campaigning in South Dakota, where she complained that, 'People have been trying to push me out of this ever since Iowa.'"

Obama spokesman Bill Burton responded to Clinton's remarks. "Senator Clinton's statement before the Argus Leader editorial board was unfortunate and has no place in this campaign."

NBC/NJ's Mike Memoli notes that Clinton said something similar the day after the Indiana and North Carolina primaries. "Sometimes you gotta calm people down a little bit. But if you look at successful presidential campaigns, my husband did not get the nomination until June of 1992," she said. "I remember tragically when Senator Kennedy won California near the end of that process."

In fact, the specter of assassination was first raised in this campaign on January 8, when a Clinton introducer, a retired teacher from New Hampshire, brought it up before Clinton spoke. "If you look back, some people have been comparing one of the other candidates to JFK, and he was a wonderful leader. He gave us a lot of hope," the retired teacher said. "But he was assassinated, and Lyndon Baines Johnson actually did all of his work and got both the Republicans and Democrats to pass those measures."

Clinton spokesman Mo Elleithe just said to a group of reporters in South Dakota -- including Memoli -- that this is "one of the more ridiculous" issues that has come up in a long race. The campaign, he said, will soon send out an official comment.

*** UPDATE *** Here is the official statement from Elleithe: "She was simply referencing her husband in 1992 and Bobby kennedy in 1968 as historical expmales of the nominating contest going well into the summer. Any, any reading into it beyond that is inaccurate."

*** UPDATE *** Here is what Clinton said in a quick avail: "I regret that if my referencing that moment of trauma for our entire nation, particularly for the Kennedy family was in any way offensive. I certainly had no intention of that whatsoever. My view is that we have to look to the past and to our leaders who have inspired us and give us a lot to live up to and I'm honored to hold sen. Kennedy's seat in the United States Senate in the state of New York, and have the highest regard for the entire Kennedy family."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Is it ME, or does it sound like Hillary is calling for someone to carry out "an assassination"?  Once she took that little boy's $400 in KY, I didn't think that snake's belly could actually be LOWER than the dirt's surface!  This proves my point on how GENUINELY DANGEROUS this "woman" truly is and will continue to be!!!  God help us!!!

If the DNC does not do something about the Clintons this weekend they have missed their chance. Letting this type of BS go on, and it coming from a SENATOR no less...If they do not, at a minimum, tell her to shut her vile damn mouth and to quit spreading bad crap and fear-mongering, they by default are condoning it. IF they are so damn scared of the Clintons/Thugs...get a restraining order on the bitch and move on!
My God. Are they totally lacking any morals?
I am pissed!
Hillary appears to be giving a wink-wink to such a possibility.

SDs should have the backbone to end this immediately and this should rule out any talk of Clinton as VP.
Damn, even Britney Spears wasn't talking as crazy as this when they put her into "involuntary confinement" for mental illness. I actually feel a little sorry for Hillary because this is just so completely over the top. For her own good, and the good of the country, please, superdelegates, do an intervention already.
Did she really just make the case that she should stay in this race because there is a precedent of the primary frontrunner being shot and called prior to the convention much later in the primary then we are now?  

Let me say this clearly, she is not a candidate for VP, and has no business being anywhere near the presidency.
This is insane. We have all seen the kooks posting on websites that have their whole life wrapped up in this campaign. This was at the very least idiotically irresponsible. She is incompetent.
This campaign is over the top in regards to such heightened sensitivities regarding race, gender and age that we can no longer make any comment without being negatively pounced on by the other candidates supporters.  Everyone talks about having a dialogue, (especially the Obama Camp) yet, every utterance spoken is twisted to some incredible, unbelieveable gaffe.  This Democratic campaign has become extremely focused on the small, all the while the elephant in the room gets ignored.  To clarify, Obama's inexperience, sexism against Clinton and the fact that come November, if Obama wins the Nomination McCain is the clear winner.  For anyone that's curious, I'm an Independent and glad I left the Democratic Party...I hope the Democrats reflect back on their lack of focus and in November say welcome President McCain!  Life should be about lessons learned, not repeating the same old mistakes.
DNC if you don't stand up now you don't have the guts to bring this to a close.  To promote assination is just spinless and disgusting and these people will stop at nothing no matter what the costs.

Sen. Kennedy is very ill and she chooses this time to show complete and total DISRESPECT to the Sen. and his family after all they have given in service and lives to this country that they love so much.

This woman would not know thit to her in a bucket.
I think she will try to get Obama killed
HRC it seems is simply giving voice to what she has wished for all this time. Elleithe's attempt to nonchalant dismiss an indefensible comment ring hollow. HRC has lost all support of self-respecting Democrats. What scum she is.
THE ADACITY OF HILLARY IS ASTONDING. IF ANYTHING HAPPENS TO OBAMA THAT WOMAN WILL NEVER BE ELECTED. AND FOR SURE DO NOT PUT HER ON AS VP,SHE WOULD PLOT TO HARM OBAMA,JUST AS SHE HAS BEEN PLOTTING ALL ALONG.
This should be the proverbial straw.

and it's not sexist to say so.

She knows she has no chance in hell of winning, even if she won the next contests.. so shes banking on the fact that someone will kill Obama and she can win.

shes soooo desperate to win, she is trying to say
"folks he could die, before the primary and then i would win by default,"
thats her last hope
because apart from that shes done!
Shes trash, she doesnt want to represent the American people, she just wants to prove something to herself
Shes selfish and prideful!
Hillary Supporters, deflect.
This is the last straw,  this woman has no sense of of the moment and how hurtful her words are.  And she was ready from Day 1!!!!

SDs, if now, you still need to make up your mind or hedge your bets this would be the time to step out into the sunlight and support Obama. This statement, more than anything would show this horrible woman her words are not acceptable and for sure neither is she.

Not even for VP.    To her supporters how can you continue to enable her?

I personally thought she deserved to stay until the end.  The supers should not let it go on one more hour.

http://infogiant.wordpress.com/2008/05/20/clinton-begs-superdelegates-to-allow-her-to-stay-in-the-race/
HRC has disgraced her party, her family, her supporters and her country. This is a truly sad day in the history of American politics.
Another potion of bat wing, and eye of knute cooked up in Hillary's cauldron brewed arguments.
How many people associated with the Clintons have lost their lives...It is an interesting list..I am sure that MSNBC has it somewhere handy..I wouldn't be surprised if they have "hit men" on call.
WOULD YOU SUPERDELEGATES JUST PLEASE SHUT THIS WOMAN UP - SHE IS CRAZY AND THIS HAS TO STOP NOW!!
Didn't Hillary kill Vince Foster back in the day? This is like a twi-light zone episode.  This lady is bonkers completely.
First Read team did good job to mislead the reader and fan the fire, shameless.
I cannot believe that she would bring up the assasination of Bobby Kennedy in answering a question justifying why she should stay in the race. The implication is that she is staying in because she believes that Senator Obama might get assasinated. That's truly disgusting! More proof that this is a woman who has no morals and not an ounce of class.

And who in their right mind would want a running mate who is green with envy because they lost and who is talking about assasinations!!!  I can just hear Bill and Hillary commiserating in private: Bill: "Stay in it honey, Obama still might get assasinated, and then you could still wind up as president; or, you could be Vice President and then we could have him assasinated".

WHEN ARE THE SUPER DELEGATES GOING TO FINISH OFF THIS HILLARY BEAST ?
...and with Ted just finding out he has cancer....what private world does she live in?
Now, that's a superdelegate!
How can Obama's supporters be faulted for going ballistic over her doings?
I'm speechless. Has she NO decency whatsoever?
There goes Vice President Hillary Clinton!
SICK! SICK! SICK!

These comments make me physically ill.  For someone to bring up Kennedy's Assassination as we approach the 40th Anniversary of RFK's Death to try to make an argument as to why she should win the nomination is absolutely sickening.  What's worse is she brings this up as Ted Kennedy the last remaining brother of the late President struggles against Brain Cancer.  Talk about complete insensitivity!

Get her out of the race!  For Gods Sakes!  She is destroying the Democratic Party, and her own character assassinations on Obama have now turned into talk of ACTUAL ASSASSINATION!  What In Gods Name is wrong with Hillary Clinton?  Has She Lost Her Mind??
RFK's assassination: one of the more ridiculous issues to come up in a long race? Wow, yeah, how ridiculous that was, the murder of RFK. What a joke. Zany! Might work well as an opening anecdote to one of HRC's speeches. "Did I ever tell you about the time RFK was assassinated?"  (Chuckle chuckle).

WTF IS WRONG WITH THESE PEOPLE?

I've never been so glad I was an independent. Any party that would allow this woman to tear things up the way she has needs to grow a pair and learn to stand up to her. Seriously, I think she's missing her entire frontal cortex.
I remember when I use to love the Clintons.... now I kinda wish we had have kicked Bill out of office, they both make me sick.... thier name will forever be tarnished, maybe those Republicans were right, Bill and Hillary are pathetic, I'll be glad when they are both out of the political scene forever.
Here's something even scarier to think about. Perhaps Hillary would take the VP spot and then let Bill get back to his dirty work of knocking people off in Washington - in this case, President Obama. That would be one way for her to become President.

Scary, downright scary.
Sen. Clinton's desperation has now clouded her judgement. Is there nobody in Camp Clinton who will tell the Empress that she has no clothes?  
Hopefully after the "..hard working americans, white americans.." and now this I am staying in the race in case of assination the supers will move in mass and there will be no more talk of Clinton for VP.
I wonder what Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Kathleen Kennedy Townsend feel aboutinvoking the tragic assination of their father as justification to stay in the race and tear the Democratic party apart? Her tlak as VP should stop right now. If she is named Obama's VP running mate and they win Obama should be aware of the Ides of March and Billary "Brutus" Clinton.
Honestly, I believe this is what Clinton is hoping for, there isn't any other way for her to be President.  She once again has said what is exactly on her mind.  Its like when we hear a tape of bin laden and the US is trying to read between the words what is the message he is giving to his cells...this is what Clinton is doing.  This just my opinion.
This is BS! This is BS! Elleithe's official statement trying to explian Hillary's intent is BS! Hillary is supposed to be smart enough to know how this kind of statement would be taken. She is NUTS! She needs to be REMOVED!

Keith Olbermann: You better hit her hard on this one tonight and I mean hard. Call for the Dem Leaders to end this now!
OMG. This can't be real.
Sounds to me like she was just trying to make the point that other races haven't been decided until later in the summer, and people are reading things into it that she didn't say.
How dare they raise the spector of the RFK assassination where recent evidence suggests a 2nd gun was involved. The Clintons must be required to stand down before they do any more damage!

Pleasse step up Supers and "stop the insanity"!
HRC is clearly trying to destroy Obama - so she can run again in 2012.  But it is clear now that she also still believes a miracle might happen.  It is sick, however, that her "miracle" would be the shooting of Barack Obama.  If she thought she could get away with it, I have no doubt she'd put a hit out on him.
I agrre wit6h all who say SHAMELESS!!!
Okay, I've got my voice back. Every time I think she can't go any lower, she does. She or one of her spin-boys will come out later tonight and say we "misunderstood" her or that she "mis-spoke" once again. The woman needs to go away once and for all; she is an embarrassment.
I am outraged. Are there any Hillary supporters on this blog defending this BS? It is stunning and sad.
Vote for Al Gore!!!
One benefit to thus unbelievable foot-in-mouth, it should kill off (no pun intended) any talk of a joint ticket. It's one thing for Huckabee to make this kind of crack at an NRA event, it's quite another for it to come from a supposed Dem. party leader. Proof positive that her sights are on 2012. Ironically, the way she has handled that past month or so, she is not doing herself any favors in that regard.
MAYBE HILLARY OUGHT TO GET A DIVORCE, MARRY
YOU KNOW WHO, AND WE CAN HAVE THREE FOR ONE.
ha.
I am a bit shocked that there is such a shocked reaction to Hillary's remarks.  People seem to be responding in a way that suggests that they believed Hillary had ethics prior to this presidential race.  i can see no difference in her behavior today than in how she behaved when she and Slick Willie roamed the Arkansas Governor's mansion or the White House.

She was just as unethical and power hungry then as she is now.  How in the world could you not see her true character back then as well as you see it now?

WOW! You dems are a real piece of work!
Keep it up!
I LOVE IT! THANKS!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1058940

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google