ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Veepstakes: Fill out your brackets

Posted: Tuesday, May 27, 2008 9:02 AM by Domenico Montanaro

As mentioned above, debuting on MSNBC.com is our GOP veepstakes tournament.

The Washington Post's Cillizza notes yesterday’s Bob Novak column, which went after potential Obama veep pick Kathleen Sebelius for her pro-choice abortion stance. Is Novak hinting that a Sebelius pick would fire up the pro-life movement in a way that McCain isn't just yet?

So did the New York Times’ David Brooks make a funny in the lead of his column? Ok, funny for the New York Times op-ed page at least. "My first thought on the running mate question is that to balance his ticket, Barack Obama should pick a really old white general. Therefore, he should pick Dwight Eisenhower. John McCain, on the other hand, needs to pick someone younger than himself. Therefore, he also should pick Dwight Eisenhower."

Here's his Obama short list: "Obama will need a vice president who knows the millions of ways that power is exercised and subverted in Washington… Sam Nunn and Tom Daschle seem to fit the bill. Nunn is one of those senior Democrats (like David Boren and Bob Kerrey) who left the Senate lamenting the dumbed-down nature of modern politics. Daschle was more partisan as majority leader, but he is still widely trusted and universally liked. As experienced legislators, both could take Obama’s lofty hopes and translate them into nitty-gritty action."

As for McCain: "If John McCain is elected, he’ll face a political culture threatening to split at the seams. In defeat, Democrats will be enraged at everything and everybody… McCain will need somebody who radiates calm… McCain seems to be looking at business leaders like Meg Whitman. But among politicos, the shining stars would seem to be Rob Portman and Tim Pawlenty."

And the Boston Globe’s Peter Canellos draws a comparison between Indiana Jones and McCain when it comes to young sidekicks and veeps -- and whether or not it’s a good idea (e.g., Bobby Jindal). “When Harrison Ford, now 65, decided to take out his bullwhip and reprise his most famous character, the studio followed a time-honored formula for broadening the appeal of movies with aging stars: They added a kid. So Ford now gets to huff and puff his way through action scenes while 21-year-old Shia LaBeouf gets to learn the ropes from the father that he (and we) never knew he had.”
 
More: “Action stars have faced this reality for generations. In the '60s, a thickening John Wayne was forced to share the marquee with a series of forgettable young heartthrobs whose purpose was less to drive the cattle to market than to drive young people into the theater. Now, the Republican Party is wondering whether the same formula that worked for the Duke and Indiana Jones might work for John McCain.”

NBC's Abby Livingston reports, Another member from the round table of Camelot plunged a dagger in the heart of the Clinton legacy last night. Kennedy speechwriter and Obama backer Ted Sorenson entered the fray last night on PBS’ Charlie Rose. Sorenson does not want another Clinton in the White House in either the number one or two slots.

“He [Obama] must decide who among the possibilities shares his view of the world, his method of governence, who would be a congenial companion or compatriot in the running of the country, and who, if anything happened to Obama, would be prepared to carry on the Obama program and the Obama ideals," he said, adding, "So if you think Mrs. Clinton fits all those criteria, and I don't, then he should pick her.” He also expressed disappointment with Bill Clinton’s performance as president. “After Dick Morris persuaded him to triangulate and step back, he backed away from most of the important international challenges.“

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Obama should select a mid aged white man.   I don't think selecting an older running mate will work.  He should definitely not selecting Hillary Clinton! No offense against Hillary!

I still think John Edwards will be work and be best.

McClain definitely needs someone younger than him!  McClain is showing aroung his medical records to prove that he's 70 and still ticking.....

Obama For President!!

-------------
http://www.MyObamaStore.com (Up to 60% off |  Coupon: Obama-X2Y9-10 - 10% Off)
I'm interested to check out the brackets, link isn't working for me.  I'll keep checking (really can't wait to see Dem brackets though).

Hey, interesting thought about the Hollywood formula, who knows, it may just work for McCain and ?Jindel?, Obama and Nunn??.

I am a fan of Sam Nunn, I think he'd be a great pick.  Daschle seems good too but I will wait to see the advantages and disadvantages of a few more before emailing Obama my pick (LOL).
Maybe McCain should choose a sharp legislator who might actually get something done in the COngress and Obama can choose a younger man to help make him look older.
Nunn would be good, because he is fairly conservative for a Democrat, and he is well-known and respected in military circles.  He'd make a good choice Mccain couldn't call naive and inexperienced, (taking a pointer from HRC's playbook).
Weekend / Weekstart Filler News....Did any Polls lately First Read?
Do not pick Hillary as your running mate, Senator Obama.  Your children need their father.  Hillary is desperate to get back into the White House, because it is the only way that she and her sexual predator husband can escape from the Peter Paul lawsuit.  As President, she could claim immunity and pardon the sexual predator.

Kathleen Sebelius would be a better choice.  She is female, which is apparently the only qualification that Hillary supporters care about, and she is very popular in Kansas.  She might even put Kansas in play in November.

Obama/Sebelius in 2008.  Integrity matters and the Clintons have none.
For those of you who think age isn't a problem for McCain, please visit www.thingsyoungerthanmccain.com for a real look at just how old he is.....things like the zip code, spam, nylon, cheerios, and Alaska are ALL younger than he is! As Bill Clinton would say, "It's a hoot!"
VEEP stakes, as our first article today is right on.

For Obama, the possibility of Clinton as his Veep is too dangerous. I like the idea of Hagel. I find it an absolutely exciting idea. Though my first choice would be Powell, I don't think America could handle too many AA shoved in their faces all at once!

McCain definitely needs a calming presence, with smarts to boot.
I have a question: will McCain insist that his vice-presidential running mate have a sterling military record? His critique of Obama on this point would indicate that his own running mate could not be weak in this area, thus negating criticism of Obama's lack of military cridentials. Just asking.
I like Nunn - I wish he were a little younger, though.

I think Biden would be excellent in debates and discussions on substantive foreign policy issues.

Hagel - interesting, but no.

Sebelius - No: too boring.

Jim Webb - good because of military credentials.  But sometimes he has that serial-killer expression on his face (McCain has it too sometimes - must be a veteran thing)

Daschle - I like him, but I don't have a good feeling about him as a VP pick - he doesn't seem forceful enough (he's no Biden)

Clinton: for God's sake NO!  Chris Matthews: wake up  - this is a terrible idea!



i hope he chooses chuck hagel but I think he will choose either jim webb or gov. of vermont

Hillary Blogs
Obamas resume
Want to know the difference between Clinton and Obama supporters
And Find out What has been bothering me

This and more on…

http://sensico.wordpress.com/


i pray obama does not win . it would be a disater for America.........................................his wife and he deep down after siting in a church 20 years agree with rev. wright and his other friends gosh u guys need to get head examined. obama boooooooooooooooooooooooooo
Who knows who should be his running mate, who can tell?

Hillary is still running this race and Obama is running against her and McBush Administration.

 
RE:marie

Why would you say this?  What is your reasoning for feeling that way?

Said by marie (Sent Tuesday, May 27, 2008 9:32 AM)
"
i pray obama does not win . it would be a disater for America.........................................his wife and he deep down after siting in a church 20 years agree with rev. wright and his other friends gosh u guys need to get head examined. obama boooooooooooooooooooooooooo
"

---
http://www.MyObamaStore.com (Up to 60% off |  Coupon: Obama-X2Y9-10 - 10% Off)

Anyone but Hillary for President .....
Anyone but Hillary for Vice-President....
Any questions?
I hope McCain does choose Pawlenty.  First, it would get him out of our state, and second, McCain doesn't seem to realize that Pawlenty barely got reelected here.  The only reason he did is that his opponent imploded at the end of the race.
NO HILLARY ON OBAMA'S TICKET.

The surest way for Obama to lose against McCain is to put Hillary on his ticket as VP.

The fastest way to ENERGIZE & UNITE Republicans & Conservatives is to wave the RED FLAG --- HILLARY!
-----------------------------------------------------
britt,CA

Thanks for turning me on to the web site.  I watched the videos comparing Hillary's supporters with Barack's.  It really made me understand the difference between hope and fear.  Barack has his work cut out for him; to know him is to hope.  I think he can influence those who are less recalcitrant; it's a process.  I urge others to view the videos on:

http://sensico.wordpress.com/

Obama '08
Marie, I guess that's why Obama took a low-paying job working with the poor in Chicago when he graduated from Harvard???  Because he doesn't care about America or Americans?  Oh, and his wife did also. I can honestly say, at age 50, it has been a VERY long time since I have been proud of my country.  I am looking forward to saying that I am finally proud again!!!  By the way, I don't think that makes me unpatriotic!  I think? it was Jefferson who said, it is the dissenters who keep democracy going. . . I see nothing wrong in teaching our children that this country is not always right.  But that we can always correct the wrong.
Why do people keep suggesting Chuck Hagel for Obama's veep?  Have any of you looked at his voting record in depth? I want solid Democrats in the White House this time around.  Dems shouldn't even think of diluting our power by bringing in a Republican as a running mate.  Very dumb idea no matter how much you might admire Hagel for a few selected stances.
I think Hagal is the best ticket for Oboma, Nun is my second choice. What would McCain do with an Oboma/Hagal ticket. For that matter how would the country embrace that political change. WoW!!!!!
Obama needs to pick a governor.  Female would be good.  Too many problems with congresspersons (given its' approval status overall in the country).

NO CLINgONs!

i am an obama sweetie and i approve this message


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1066346

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google