ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Clinton argues Native rights, electability

Posted: Wednesday, May 28, 2008 4:26 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ's Mike Memoli
KYLE, S.D. -- In a somber speech before a small crowd on the Pine Ridge Indian reservation, Hillary Clinton again pledged that Indian Country “will have a seat at the table in my White House.” She also argued that the “ultimate question” facing primary voters is which candidate can win in November.
 
“It is so close, neither of us have the number of delegates necessary to be the nominee,” she said. “We have three more contests in Puerto Rico Sunday, in Montana and South Dakota on Tuesday. We have to resolve Michigan and Illinois. I mean Michigan and Florida. And then what we have to do is determine who would be the best president, and who would be the stronger candidate against Sen. McCain. I believe I am, and I believe the states that I have won and the electoral votes I will win make a very strong argument for that.”
 
Interestingly, as Republicans have begun criticizing Barack Obama for not having visited Iraq since 2006, Clinton mentioned that she has visited both Iraq and Afghanistan with the Arizona senator. Her last visit was in early 2007.
 
“I have the deepest respect for his service to our country,” Clinton said of McCain. “But he offers four more years of the same -- the same failed economic policies and the same failed policy in Iraq. We need a change. The question for people who want to see a Democrat sworn in as president next January is who is most likely to win. That is the ultimate question to ask yourselves, because if you look at the electoral map, if you look at the sates I have won, these are the states that form the base of a Democratic victory.”
 
As Clinton began her speech here, in the poorest county in the nation, she said she didn’t come to “make a big speech,” adding that the people here have “seen too many speeches” and heard “too many words that never translated into reality.”
 
“I don’t run for president because I need any more publicity,” she said. “I don’t run for president because I need the adulation or the celebrity. I don’t run for president to live in the White House again. … I run because I believe that we can do so much better in our country, and that the unkept promises are corrosive. They undermine trust and accountability. They begin to eat away at what should be the relationship between our people and our government, and between government to government in Indian Country.

“So I’m here to make a solemn pledge, a pledge I have done my best to honor already as your first lady and as a senator, a pledge I will continue to honor as your president. I will be your champion. I will fight for you. I will stand up for you. And I will work my heart out for you.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

The ramblings of a Japanese World War II fighter who does not know that the war is over.
Keep her away from the guns.
The only place this race is close is in her mind. The woman is delusional.
"It is so close."

All evidence to the contrary...you trail by almost 200 delegates.
Yea hillary lets resolve michigan and illinois, you are sounding more tired than ever, please just stop,
Hillary, you can't even win the primary--how in the world are you going to win the general???  You've mentioned time and again how McBush is better than Obama, yet you can't even beat Obama.  How could you ever beat your hero McBush???
Is it me or is does she sound just like Obama?
HRC must be planning to have a very large table since every demographic group she meets with is promised a seat at it (also known as pandering).  Clinton followers suffer from a CULT OF PERSONALITY, meaning NOTHING, and I mean NOTHING, the Clintons say or do will ever turn away their followers because their followers have already decided that HRC is the only choice because she is their choice.  For every Clinton supporter who says they will not support Obama, fine, be that way, but understand that for every one of you there are at least five people who would not support HRC if she is allowed to bully her way to the nomination.  Best part, HRC did this to herself, ran a terrible campaign, no one to blame but herself.  
She's GOT A POINT !!

First Sen. Obama (May 18th) states Iran IS NOT A THREAT.... Um, but in usual fashion, changes his mind several days later (May 20th) and states that they are a threat.

So which is it Sen. Obama??  They are or they are not?  What color are the flip flops today!!
And here is Exhibit A for her argeument per today's Gallup web site www.gallup.com:

In the 20 states where Hillary Clinton has claimed victory in the 2008 Democratic primary and caucus elections (winning the popular vote), she has led John McCain in Gallup Poll Daily trial heats for the general election over the past two weeks of Gallup Poll Daily tracking by 50% to 43%. In those same states, Barack Obama is about tied with McCain among national registered voters, 45% to 46%.

In contrast, in the 28 states and the District of Columbia where Obama has won a higher share of the popular vote against Clinton in the 2008 Democratic primaries and caucuses, there is essentially no difference in how Obama and Clinton each fare against McCain. Both Democrats are statistically tied with him for the fall election.

All of this speaks to Sen. Clinton's claim that her primary-state victories over Obama indicate her potential superiority in the general election.

This woman needs help, badly.  
Q: Has this gone too far?
A: Yes,
“I don’t run for president because I need any more publicity,” she said. “I don’t run for president because I need the adulation or the celebrity. I don’t run for president to live in the White House again."

ROTFLMAO!  Supers, please, please put this to rest.  You can do so...today.
We need to begin tying McCain to Bush by pointing out that McCain's foreign policy is even more Neo-Con than Bush's.  The term Neo-Con is the new "liberal" in the sense that it is reviled.  McCain's interventionalist foreign policy is more of the same.

Indian Country???  Are you serious? Did she promise that the great, white father/mother of the palefaces would no longer speak with forked tongue? Did she promise them cattle if they give up their savage ways and remain on the reservation? Did they celebrate with wampum and firewater? Does she visit Little Bighorn tomorrow?

For crying out loud, how many votes even come from "indian country"?
Hillary - in case you didn't know...Barack Obama is not only likely to win.  He will.  Moreover, any chance of you likely winning..is few and far between.  Even if you somehow stole this nomiation..you have created so much damage for this party and yourselve...you likely wouldn't win the GE.  

Thank you and GOD Bless America
One question:  What did she do to honor native peoples as *either* first lady or NY senator???!??
Same old sang and dance from the Wicked Witch of the East.  I can't wait until next Wednesday so that it will be game over for her and she can shut her lying mouth.

I would like to thank Barack Obama for not visiting Iraq since 2006 and not wasting our tax dollars.  "Warmonger" McCain has just been wasting our tax dollars going over there so many times solely for political gain.  At least the Wicked Witch of the East hasn't wasted as much of our tax dollars strutting her stuff over there just for political again.

Go Obama 08/12!
Woman yells at cloud!  ;-)
Yeah maybe...what did the Clinton's do the first time, since it was a co-presidency?

Did they give her a native name yet?

I don't get visiting Iraq making you a leader, when you don't take care of them on the homefront.

Off in another direction we go again.  Now it's Obama hasn't visited Iraq.  Well McCain has and still don't know who is who over there.  Now Clinton follows the republican again.  Hellooooo, she authorized this war and sent the troops over there without proper equipment.
   
Hillary, you do not know the meaning of honor.
"I will be your champion. I will fight for you. I will stand up for you. And I will work my heart out for you.”

Yes, she will take care of us all and do everything for us.  We just have to sit back and be quiet and wait for the free lunch to arrive.......
Please... just go away.

Bob Jackson
American Government Teacher
Orange HS, Orange, CA
Whatever Hillie wants Hillie gets so give in you fools.  The dame is anything but a musical.  Contact Howard Dean through dnc.org and tell him to urge all super delegates to announce their choice by the end of the primaries.  Mrs. Clinton doesn't care about party and will take it to the convention unless the super d's put an end to it.
Senator Clinton, what more can be said?

You bought into GWB's propaganda war - hook line and sinker.

That's not leadership. It's complicity.
Silly old woman thinks she ie a camellion.
Hilarious Clinton - old west injun panderer. I mean injun fighter.
please dear Lord, get her out of this race....since when will it be "HER" white house???  i always thought it was the "PEOPLE'S" house........just more delusional denials from someone bent on destroying the democratic party just for her own agenda
Hillary, you can gain as many yards as you want, but if you dont score as many touchdowns, the other side wins. Even if you manage to steal more total yardage, your still the loser. Every yard should be counted, but if there not in the endzone you dont score points.
OMG .... she is really beating the dead horse. I can't listen to this nagging anymore.
The tribes have seen Hillary work for them and will not forget. Obama will have a headdress soon now and tell them how his family helped them out when those white men were after them. The world and all that happens revolves around Obama or if not he will make it so. If arragance counted he would be at top. It doesnt. Popular votes the votes of the people do though. Hillary is only one to bring this country togeather. Vote Hillary
What heart, Hillary? What you're showing isn't heart; it's the same kind of stubbornness that Scott McClellan has indicated is Dubya's tragic flaw.
The only reason the Wicked Witch of the East is still running is because she's afraid to lose all that adulation from the crowds.  She's going to be suffering Attention Deficit Disorder next week as she gets dumped from the race.

No way that Obama should pick this backstabbing witch as his running mate.  She has been running her mouth off about being more electable and ready to lead that she has done more to help "Bush Hugger" McCain than the repugnant ones have.

No way Obama should be forced to carry the Clinton baggage all the way to November.  She didn't earn the right nor has she done anything to deserve it.  It's back to being Senator #36 of 49.

Go Obama 08/12!
I love how she tells people they don't need any more speeches, then tells them why in a speech.

Obama '08
If Hillary doesn't recognize caucus states, why did she have her name on the ballots?  I don't see her rejecting the elected delegates she got from them, either.
I heard Hillary will give voting rights to Martians if the Mars rover finds any.
All Clinton did was make a speech about what her husband did for Native Americans.  She really has no track record herself, except maybe as a co-sponsor on a bill.

The interesting thing about listening to sen Clinton's rationale for staying in the race is her assumptions -- that Clinton-McCain will yield the same results for her that Obama-Clinton yielded.  She also seems to have scrapped the Democratic party rules for primary elections and made up rules of her own that I am trusting, will not stand.  She can say all she wants, but it boils down to the number of delegates and not the popular vote (which certainly did not count in my caucus state!)

Sandra from Alaska


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1073170

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google