ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Obama: A flip-flop on Jerusalem?

Posted: Friday, June 06, 2008 9:18 AM by Mark Murray

Um, it took Obama just 24 hours to backtrack on something he said on Wednesday at the AIPAC conference. The Washington Post: "Facing criticism from Palestinians, Sen. Barack Obama acknowledged today that the status of Jerusalem will need to be negotiated in future peace talks, amending a statement earlier in the week that Jerusalem ‘must remain undivided.’ Obama, during a speech Wednesday to the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, a pro-Israel lobbying group, had called for Jerusalem to become the site of the U.S. embassy, a frequent pledge for U.S. presidential candidates. (It is now in Tel Aviv.) But his statement that Jerusalem should be the undivided capital of Israel drew a swift rebuke from Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas.”

“‘This statement is totally rejected,’ Abbas told reporters in Ramallah. ‘The whole world knows that holy Jerusalem was occupied in 1967 and we will not accept a Palestinian state without having Jerusalem as the capital of a Palestinian state.’ The Bush administration's official position is that the status of Jerusalem is among the most sensitive issues and must be decided by the parties. Former President Bill Clinton, before he left office, had proposed a formula under which ‘Jerusalem should be an open and undivided city,’ including locating the Palestian capital in East Jerusalem.”

“Obama quickly backtracked today in an interview with CNN. ‘Well, obviously, it's going to be up to the parties to negotiate a range of these issues. And Jerusalem will be part of those negotiations,’ Obama said when asked whether Palestinians had no future claim to the city.’”

Wright dominated. "The story of Wright and his race-based rants against United States policies surfaced in March and received four times more coverage than any other theme or event throughout the campaign, according to data compiled by the Project for Excellence in Journalism, an arm of the Pew Research Center in Washington. The issue undercut Obama with working-class white voters in the later primaries, most analysts have said."

More: "Excluding the horse race-type coverage of tactics and strategy, the Obama-Wright story accounted for 6.4 percent of the campaign coverage of the media outlets surveyed between Jan. 6 and May 4. The next closest campaign story, at 1.6 percent, was the running story about the role of so-called superdelegates in determining the Democratic nomination, followed at 1.5 percent by Obama's remarks in April at a San Francisco fund-raiser that white working-class and small-town voters were 'bitter' and 'cling to guns or religion' in frustration."

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid today endorsed Obama. "Over the past 16 months, tens of millions of Americans from all walks of life have been inspired to support Barack Obama's historic campaign for President, and with good reason: he is a once-in-a-generation leader who connects with the hopes and dreams of the American people and will deliver the long-overdue change that our country desperately needs,” he said in a statement. “I could not be more excited to have Senator Obama lead a united Democratic Party to victory in November and I am committed to doing everything I can to help.”

"I also congratulate Hillary Clinton for her tremendous contributions in this campaign and for our country. She is a wonderful Senator and friend whose vision and determination have made our party stronger. There is no question that she will continue to be a force for change.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Wright dominated. "The story of Wright and his race-based rants against United States policies surfaced in March and received four times more coverage than any other theme or event throughout the campaign, according to data compiled by the Project for Excellence in Journalism, an arm of the Pew Research Center in Washington. The issue undercut Obama with working-class white voters in the later primaries, most analysts have said."

More: "Excluding the horse race-type coverage of tactics and strategy, the Obama-Wright story accounted for 6.4 percent of the campaign coverage of the media outlets surveyed between Jan. 6 and May 4. The next closest campaign story, at 1.6 percent, was the running story about the role of so-called superdelegates in determining the Democratic nomination, followed at 1.5 percent by Obama's remarks in April at a San Francisco fund-raiser that white working-class and small-town voters were 'bitter' and 'cling to guns or religion' in frustration."

----------------------------------------------------

At what point did you folks get together and decide that this was the most important issue during the primaries?

Not the economy...not Iraq...not the environment...THIS.

Shame on you.
He did NOT back off his undivided Jerusalem position. Nevertheless, it IS the case that, re his pandering, the so-called "bitter" remark was to that 'Frisco crowd as was the Jerusalem undivided remark was to the AIPAC crowd.
All you Obama-haters will latch on to the Wright stuff, so spew your venom.  I care not a whit.

However, I did notice that many Obama supporters did point out that he shouldn't have said that about Jerusalem.  That's quite a hot button topic, and if he has any chance of brokering peace (which is already a looooong shot) that's not the type of comments that he should make now.

Meanwhile, McCain is still trying to remember what he said to AIPAC and who the Palestinians are.  "Are they Shia or Sunni?"
I would endorse any Middle Eastern policy that is fair, and bipartisan. Partisanship has wrought nothing but bitterness, blood, suspicion, and fear.
Obama needs to learn to think on his feet a little better. His big speeches/rhetoric that worked for democrats will not work in the GE.

I worry that his real inexperience is going to come shinning through.

The Wright story dominated the media coverage, because as a nation, we knew nothing about Barak and Wright's message seemed in direct contrast with his message. And his failure to drop him sooner only added to the media frenzy.

He really needs to bring Hillary along with him.

Experience really does matter.
Barack should not have said the Jerusalem belongs to Israel. Israel, and the billions we give give every year, along with their weapons, are the reason the Middle East hates the USA. Why does the Jews have the right to anything that they want? Wake up America!!!!
This accusation of "flipflopping" is beginning to irritate me beyond endurance.

Does that mean it is so much better to do what Shrub did, have one fixed idea in his mini brain and push it even when the evidence contradicts what he is doing?

Seriously, that is why we are in the mess we are in.  I would rather have someone grow as the evidence changes.

And do find new hosts for "Morning Joe."  That show is back to being terrible.
We need to have a president who is not in the pocket of Isreal, but who will treat the Palestinians with respect for the land they've lost.  The Jews said that they needed a buffer zone for security when they took land from the Arabs in 1967 and 1973.  Sounds a lot like Hitler's "Lebensraum" claim.  After 40 years it's been proven that this extra land has provided Isreal with no security as the Arabs have gone to unconventional warfare and have just been inflamed for that whole time wanting their land back.

The way the Jews are mistreating the Palestinians in Gaza is abhorent and they will never have peace until they stop that illegal blockade and start talking with Hamas's government.  After over two years it's rather obvious that the blockade has only hardened support for Hamas against Isreal.  Time to try treating them like real human beings so that they change their position with Isreal.

Go Obama 08/12!
I'm glad he did flip flop or whatever you wanna call it.  I was extremely disappointed with his comments at AIPAC.
sotiredofignorance:

I am afraid that won't happen, my friend.  Please read the link below:
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/05/arts/television/05joe.html?_r=1&partner=rssnyt&emc=rss&oref=slogin

FR - I would appreciate it if you would post this.  Thanks.
I realize you guys over here at first read actually want people to read your articles, but the general election has begun.  You can't just focus on Obama and every little thing that you find interesting.  How about starting to REPORT on the daily gaffes of John McCain?  John has tried to ACT so different than Bush, but now supports the continued illegal action of spying on Americans without a warrant (a flip flop...of which he's had about 20 that continue to elude you guys).

http://infogiant.wordpress.com/
First off, Obama can't make the Israelis give back the united Jerusalem.  I don't think he should.  If the Israelis are foolish enough to do that, let them.  I think the item that Obama should state clearly is that Jerusalem is the capital of Israel and move the embassy there as soon as he is elected.  

Can we lay off the Wright story?  It is dead and should be buried back with the classifeds of the newspaper as non-relevent.  Who cares what this retired pastor has to say?  I don't.
Wow, two days as the presumptive nominee and BO's already caused a stir in the mideast.  And, yes, he did flipflop.  The man sure does like to hear himself talk.  He doesn't know how to keep his mouth shout. And, he sure better learn to think before he speaks!  I'm so tired of him saying things and then he or his surrogates coming back to say "that's not what he meant."  The mideast is so volatile; too many gaffes like this and BO could cause a war!  Things like this are way experience IS important. BO's out of his league.   Go back to the Chicago streets.
I think that Senator Obama somethimes leaves out what he believes normal,thoughtful people should already know and understand.  He needs to get better at making complete answers and not assume that people have all the surrounding information working in their reasoning.  I like Senator Obama very much and I have seen much improvement over thise months.  I do believe his mistake is honest and is more of his wanting to believe that Americans think logically.   He will need to take more time to give a more complete explantion of his positions and not assume everyone "gets it".


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1119341

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google