ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



RNC notes hypocrisy on Obama pledge

Posted: Friday, June 06, 2008 2:01 PM by Mark Murray
Filed Under: ,

From NBC's Mark Murray
On Thursday, Obama announced that the Democratic National Committee -- as his campaign does -- would no longer accept financial contributions from federal lobbyists.

"We will not take a dime from Washington lobbyists or special interest PACs," he said. "We're going to change how Washington works. They will not fund my party. They will not run our White House."

But today, the Republican National Committee is noting all the holes in this pledge. In addition to the fact that Obama accepts money from employees of lobbying firms (as long as those folks aren't themselves federal lobbyists), the RNC points out that the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee and the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee take money from lobbyists. Moreover, at least one prominent DNC member -- vice chair Lottie Shackelford -- is a lobbyist.

RNC spokesman Danny Diaz called these holes "amazingly hypocritical."

But Obama spokesman Bill Burton told First Read that the RNC itself was being hypocritical here -- because the GOP and the McCain campaign accept money from federal lobbyists. "Instead of partisan attacks, we would welcome John McCain to the same strict policy" that Obama has, he said. "This attack is an attempt to distract from the fact that [the McCain] campaign is paid for and run by some of the most powerful lobbyists in Washington."

DNC spokeswoman Stacie Paxton adds, "Sen. Obama has made an unprecedented and important step to stop taking money from PACs and Washington lobbyists at the DNC -- a standard that John McCain’s own campaign and the RNC he claims to control have refused to follow. Officers of the DNC are elected and are not paid staff -- no members of the DNC staff, however, are federal lobbyists."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

The GOP have been the party of hypocrisy for the last 20 years and they want to call someone else on it???

Yeah, this election is going to be too easy this time around.

http://www.politivine.com
McCain's entire campaign is being run by lobbyists, or at least the ones he has not fired yet.

Give me a break here, The DNC and Obama campaign are stepping up with a valiant effort to reform the way Washington works so it is so surprise that the GOP would be all over them for it.

http://www.politivine.com
Who can honestly say, they were so tired they didn't know there were 50 states in America?
Just the fact that Barack himself said 3 weeks ago "I have been to 57 uh 58 states with 2 more to go" is enough to disqualify him from running this country. Or unpatriotic enough. Oh yeah, I doubt they cover USA geography in a foreign country pre-school or primary school. Good luck with that, as my 12 and 13 year olds love to say. I can't wait to see Barack get his "here's your sign" award on Blue Collar Comedy. If I were the Republicans I would run that footage over and over as a campaign add. What a classic. Even Dan Quayle is jealous. Can you imagine the meeting after that news conference?
“you tell him”
“no, you tell him”
“uh, sir, actually there are only 50 states in the USA”
“no really sir, it’s true”
“look here’s the map, let’s count all of them together”
Well people to do work for those organizations however that doesnt mean he is taking funds directly, get over it!  Common sense.
The Democrats have built their party on hypocrisy. Say one thing, do another, is their motto. Now Obama is talking about 'reducing the level of the seas'? Does this man think he is God? Listening to him, it appears he does. The man is the biggest bag of wind since Jimmy Carter, and is just a corrupt as the people he hung around with in Chicago (see Pfleger/Wright/Rezco/Ayers for details).

In a year where the Democrats should have easily won the White House, now it appears certain they will lose.
Don't play their game. Let's not get baited the same way Hillary did. Obama needs to learn he doesn't make the rules. That's like being in the middle of NBA chanpionship and saying "let's change the rules to make it more even." How obsurd.
A Little Humor Before We Say Goodbye to Senator Clinton:

A Vanity Fair article comes out recently with the sorry details of Bill Clinton’s possible escapades on the road.

The following Tuesday afternoon (primary day) - a press release comes out that Senator Clinton will concede later than night during her speech.

Late Tuesday afternoon - a press release comes out with a minor correction - Senator Clinton will not concede, however, she will state that in fact Senator Obama does have the required delegates to clinch the nomination.

She elects to do neither.

Everyone is furious. Obama supporters, Clinton superdelegate supporters, portions of the media.

____________________________

After all this has occurred, a commentator late Tuesday night echoes what I thought was the funniest line of the entire campaign:

Bill and Hillary Clinton are the Ike and Tina Turner of politics.

Say goodnight Hillary.
Check oil prices today, this is what the rethuglicans stand for when it comes to federal lobbyists.
Onward and upward!!

Obama '08!

Incidentally, Eric from Salinas, I love your posts.  I am also in California and you seem to echo my thoughts in most of your comments.  Thanks!
Can you post this after ANY story please.  I've tried multiple times and First Read will not post this and I don't know why.  There is no foul language and nothing that isn't truth - so why won't you post this????  I'm going to try again to explain to democrats why people are defecting to McCain:

I’m sorry, but I have to get something off my chest when it comes to these “Frustrated Clinton Supporters” ‘switching’ to McCain.  I have kept to myself over the past few months they’ve been making these threats, but no longer.
(Disclaimer: There are many Clinton supporters who are true Democrats and are disappointed that Clinton lost the nomination, but they will vote for Obama.  These aren’t the people making the threats and now doing what they threatened to do.  These aren’t the people I’m talking about.)
1. We democrats having been hearing for months, “If Hillary doesn’t get the nomination, I’m voting for McCain”.  I, for one, am sick and tired of being bullied by threats if you people don’t get your way.  Obama won a nominating contest by amassing the most delegates, which is how democratic nominees are elected so get over it.  It was fair and Hillary lost.  What was that?  “If you can’t stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.” <HRC> and “Politics is a contact sport; if you can’t handle the pressure, don’t put on the pads.” <Bill Clinton>.  Why don’t you crybabies take the advice of your precious Clintons?  In fact, why didn’t they also take their own advice?

2. You were not democrats – you were Clinton supporters who would never vote for Obama, so don’t act like “It’s Obama, the DNC and his hateful supporters who pushed me out of the party”.  That is such a manipulative lie and the dumbest attempt at a guilt trip I’ve ever heard.  Obama has been nothing but gracious to your queen, even after all the insults she’s thrown his way “I have experience, John McCain has experience, and Sen Obama has a speech he gave back in 2002.  The white, working, hard-working Americans chose me.  Karl Rove said I’m the stronger candidate”.  You guys were never democrats and all Hillary did was appeal to your right-wing leanings and boy, was she successful.  Obama and his supporters didn’t drive you to McCain – Hillary gave you the map and compass to lead you back to where you’re most comfortable.  So don’t go on trying to make us feel guilty for turning you into a bunch of republicans.  Does anyone else notice all their posts are always started with “I’ve been a democrat all my life and this is the first time I’ll be voting for a republican”.  Yea, right.  I can tell by reading your posts, that this is the first time many of you have ever voted, period!  Go to McCain’s website to get your sympathy, I’m all out of sympathy for the lot of you!
For those of you who will fear this post will not help “unify the party”, please don’t worry.  These fair weather friends of the democrats will be exactly the same to the republicans.  They’re already over on John McCain’s website blogging and demanding things from them, like a joint McCain/Clinton ticket and the republicans are having none of it.  Several Clinton supporters have said, “I sent John McCain an email today telling him to choose Hillary as his running mate” and they get offended by the real McCain supporters when they tell them it’s not going to happen.  I’m sure McCain gave those emails their due attention (straight into the circular filing cabinet!)  These republicans, who really hate Clinton, are standing there, arms open wide, saying “there there”, but now these Hillary supporters are starting to demand things of them, like a VP slot.  Let the republicans deal with them for awhile.  I, for one, am glad to be rid of them!  Get this straight, fellow democrats, these people would NEVER vote for Obama.  Now it’s time to ramp up the voter registration drives for the general election so we can sign up a bunch of new, informed people who will replace these yahoos who won’t even vote their interests!
Risky:

...

You are an idiot.

Of course he was joking.
Note the above from "Risky," and its consistency with the RNC blast: We can't dare address our performance, so we have to rely on half-truth and personal slurs.

Yeah, good luck with THAT.
Hey Risky.....grow up.
So please explain....will Obama as head of the party ask the lobbyists to step down? Specifically the vice chair of the DNC? I'm for Obama, but find this confusing.
Risky Obama

He misspoke, you know, like when decorated military veteran Hillary Clinton was recounting the harrowing experience she had in Bosnia.

By the way, as long as we are counting states, let's count the states where Hillary Clinton is a defendant in a major campaign finance fraud lawsuit.  California is one.  Any others?

Obama/Sebelius in 2008.  Integrity matters and the Clintons have none.
Hey Risky ... How about I voted for Katrina investigations, NOT!
Hey Risky ... How about Sunni/Shiite, whatever!
Hey Risky ... How about I didn't boff the lobbysist that looks like my wife, no not the paralyzed one I left flopping on the floor, the drugged up pill stealing beer one.
Hey Risky ... enjoy your fun now, in 5 months you will be "saluting" Obama!
Where does one think all the GOP money comes from?  It certainly isn't "grass roots".

It's all Big Businees to continue Big Business control of DC.  These scary people are scared.  Some of the CEO's may have to sell a couple of their houses!, er, mansions!

This will be one very interesting campaign.
You don't have to go far to find the hypocrisy of Obama. He says he's a uniter, but yet he insults working white people on what seems to be a daily basis. He says he doesn't take lobbying money, but yet he does, and it's worth mentioning he comes from the Mother of all Cesspools when it comes to corrupt and dirty money, that being Chicago and Illinois. So for a man that one of the most politically dirty people today in politics, Obama certainly acts all pious and above the frey. Instead, he's just as bad, if not worse, then most others.
Let me get this straight:  he decrees the DNC won't accept lobbyist money, but he and his campaign will continue to do so.  What is so honorable about that?
Does he think we're a bunch of idiots?  (Though reading some of the posts on here, apparently most of his followers ARE a bunch of idiots.)
Hey Risky - That he said that ONE time.  It's better than confusing Shia and Sunni 4 TIMES like your new best friend has done.  If you can't keep the players straight in an active war in which we're involved, without the help of Joe Lieberman, THAT makes you unqualified to be President.  Not by saying the word "fifty" instead of "forty" by mistake.
The McCain campaign's lobbyist ties have proved to be a persistent source of criticism as well as questioning during this election season, and it shows no immediate signs of letting up.

Talking Points Memo reported Friday that McCain campaign manager Rick Davis' lobbying firm worked for a client with ties to Iran:

Before Rick Davis began serving as John McCain's campaign manager, his lobbying firm had a pretty cosmopolitan set of clients.


For example, Ukranian billionaire Rinat Akhmetov, who has several business links to Iran.

To be sure, there's a good crowd of lobbyists in Washington who work for international firms with ties to Iran.

But Davis isn't just any lobbyist. He's a lobbyist-turn-presidential campaign manager who just a couple weeks ago was drawing up rules on how to build a wall between lobbyists and McCain's political operatives. And McCain has been more hawkish than most of his colleagues about confronting Iran.

Personal donations from people who happen to be lobbyists (and ONE person on DNC that is a lobbyist) is so ridiculous for McSame to point out.  He's running a campaign of the lobbysist, by the lobbysist, for the lobbyists.
For years, both parties have sworn how they would herald a change in how washington treats the rest of the country. George Bush (the first) promissed it and when he failed we chose the democrat who promissed it. when he failed we elected the the next George who, surprise promissed a change in washington.  What I haven't realised before today, all of them had the oportunity to start making changes before they were elected and none of them did. Barak Obama has made a small step toward changing how washington views and respects the actual people of the country. I am not impressed by the change he proposes but that he has promissed something and delivered. Who else can say that.

Obama '08
the repugnants have built their party on hypocracy...never trust a repuke!
The GOP should worry about Uncle Fluffy's campaign first...

"6 Other Things that Aren't 'Change We Can Believe In'"

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/seth-grahamesmith/6-other-things-that-arent_b_105505.html
Risky:   You are the one who should have a sign.  If you really think BO doesn't know there are 50 states you are kidding yourself.  Oh, I'm sure you've never said one thing when you meant to say another.  Give me a break.  If this is all you've got your candidate is in trouble.
Check oil prices today, this is what the rethuglicans stand for when it comes to federal lobbyists.
Capt. Smash, Salt Lake City, Utah (Sent Friday, June 06, 2008 2:14 PM)

----------

So Capt. Smashed - what is Obama's plan to reduce the price of gas? He's long on complaining and whining about things, but short on solutions, so enquiring minds would like to hear just what Obama will do. To the best of my thinking, he's talking about raising taxes on the oil companies. Could you explain how that reduces the price of fuel?

Um, "Risky", he had went on to confirm that the "57 states" included the additional TERRITORIES who ALSO voted in our primary elections!  "no really sir, it's true", "look, here's the MAP, let's count ALL of them together"!  You go right on ahead & support McBu$h with his campaign leaders like Blake, Gramm, and the rest of them - who, by the way, lobbied FOR the Iraq war (which has MURDERED 4100 of our loved ones), and helped to de-regulate the mortage/lending industry!  Good move; hope you're all proud of yourselves when you're relocating to your neighborhood BRIDGE for protection from the harsh elements!
Dear John, You know the best things in life are free.I know you will give them to the birds and bees, cause you want money. MONEY THATS WHAT I SAID. Money so you can continue an unjust war. How many of our loved ones are you willing to sacrifice???????? Having a bout of survivors guilt? Deal with it, but not at the cost of our youth.
The Hypocrisy is all in the repugnant ones' corner, they've been lying to us for decades.  They kept telling us that all those tax cuts for the rich and greedy wouldn't harm the economy and now Social Security is going bankrupt because of them.  They told us that war in Iraq was in our nation's security interest yet Iraq posed no threat to us that they could deliver on.

Nope all we have to do is listen to "Bush Hugger" McCain say yesterday that he always voted for Katrina investigations when he voted twice against Hillary's proposed legislation to have an investigation.  Nope the repugnant ones have turned lying into an art form.  Every time they screw something up they then start screaming about how the Democrats did it.

Time to bring honesty and integrity back to the White House and only Barack Obama and the Democrats can save our democracy from the lying thugs currently trashing it.

Go Obama 08/12!
Risky Obama 08 = Risky future for America: Is that really all you've got??? The fact that Obama made a "verbal typo" after campaigning non-stop for months on end?  Let me explain this so you might understand:  He was thinking 48 and 58 came out of his mouth.  And this makes him unqualified and unpatriotic???  That is a breathtaking jump beyond all logic!  Hardly surprising from the GOP, which is perhaps the point you have inadvertently made to anyone with the capacity to think for themselves.
DROP THE $2.50 GALLON GAS hammer on OBAMA-nobody cares about Iraq-or paper tiger of IRAN.


OTHER THAN BILLIONS WASTED-AND STILL-NO DOMESTIC OIL/NUCLEAR POWER. .and now desalination.
John McCain is Georgie Bush's lapdog!  No third term!
Let me get this straight:  he decrees the DNC won't accept lobbyist money, but he and his campaign will continue to do so.  What is so honorable about that?
Does he think we're a bunch of idiots?  (Though reading some of the posts on here, apparently most of his followers ARE a bunch of idiots.)
Jack, Dallas (Sent Friday, June 06, 2008 2:17 PM)

--------------

Not only does Obama think you are bunch of idiots, but he's depending on it. One day the media in this country is going to get sick of this goofy notion that Obama is the next Camelot, and they're going to start calling this doofus on some his nutty rhetoric. Looks like Jack in Dallas has figured it out, but it will take the so called journalists a while longer to have their brains kick into gear and start to finally ask some questions of this Obama character.
The Republican argument is tant amount to saying that Obama taking a donation from a cashier at a gas station is the same as taking one from an oil company.

Grow up, kids.

Obama '08
Risky

Get over yourself he miss spoke. At least he knows the difference between Shiites and Sunnis and didn’t support the needless deaths of 4,000 over our brave young men and women.
Heidi in Houston:

You spoke my sentiments completely!  The Democratic (Obama) Party does NOT need Hillary's die hard devotees who threaten to turn traitors to the American people by voting for McCain...or staying at home for that matter.

Of course that is their choice but I personally would invite them to do either.  We don't want you or need you!  Grow up first!
Just the fact that Barack himself said 3 weeks ago "I have been to 57 uh 58 states with 2 more to go" is enough to disqualify him from running this country.
Risky Obama 08 = Risky future for America (Sent Friday, June 06, 2008 2:07 PM)
******************************************

Quick - How many primaries and caucuses were there Risky? Hmmm? Do you know?  The man has been working around the clock for over 17 months to GOTV in all of the contests...that includes places like Puerto Rico, Guam, the U.S. Virgin islands, American Samoa, Democrats Abroad, in total there are FIFTY SIX seperate contests that make up the Democratic Primary, and he campaigned in several States more than once. So he may have meant total of state visits, not total states but if you maybe had a better understanding of the Primary Schedule that thought might have occurred to you? Naaaahhhhh...you are looking for any reason no matter how thin to justify why you don't want to vote for him. What a great example you are for your kids.  

The RNC can't run an issue debate, only a character debate for their nominee.

This says so much...

The Democrats own the issues this season.
Remember Hillary attempted to spin Obama's individual contributors, and fund raisers, (that just happened to be employed by Oil corporations), as hypocritical, because Obama had scored huge political points with the voters, for running a financially clean campaign, while she, as well as, McCain where up to their eyeballs in PAC, and lobbyist's Benjamins!

How'd that work for her?

The RNC should forfeit come November.

Maybe with McCain, as their candidate, along with their stupid strategy to fight Obama as the clone of a campaign that failed to defeat him, they are  declaring, 'no contest'.

Somebody posted a comment earlier today that they believed Obama won the Presidency, when he rose as the victor over Hillary.

Well, G-D knows best, but that would appear to be what Carol referred to as, 'something in the air'.
GOP = party of excuses and excuses.

GOPers are even turning on their congress men.  One had a feel for that on C-SPAN here:

http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2008/6/6/125622/0794/810/531091
So if employees donate money to his campaign - that's tied in as lobbist money??  Employees not the employer. Come on folks!
OBAMA? why?

By the way, Mr. Murray:

I think the verb you were (or should have been looking for in the headline was "claims," not "notes." RNC "noted holes" in the Obama pledge (while diverting the focus from their own unabashed dependence on lobbyists); if there's any hypocrisy to be NOTED, it was on their side.

"Note" as a verb implies recognition of fact, here unsubstantiated; "claim" suggests mere assertion, as in the curiously paradoxical GOP message.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1120808

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google