ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



Obama vs. McCain: The trade war

Posted: Wednesday, July 02, 2008 9:33 AM by Domenico Montanaro

As the Washington Post puts it, politics for McCain may stop at the water’s edge -- but not above it.  “The moment Sen. John McCain touches down on foreign soil, he says, he will not criticize his Democratic rival for the presidency, Sen. Barack Obama. In international airspace, though? Well, that's a different matter. In two separate interviews with reporters en route to Colombia on Tuesday, McCain questioned Obama's shifting position on trade as well as his experience with Latino voters. Voters, he argued, will ultimately vote Republican once they see the two candidates side by side.”

VIDEO: MSNBC's Contessa Brewer talks with John McCain's senior policy advisor Nancy Pfetenhauer.

The New York Times says that McCain “called Mr. Obama ‘a protectionist’ and cast him as ignorant about economic forces in the United States. ‘We just have a difference of opinion,’ Mr. McCain said, ‘and I’m a student of history.’ He added: ‘An overwhelming majority of historians will tell you that protectionism and isolationism were a major factor in one of the greatest depressions in the modern history of this country. I’m not going to sit by and see that happen.’”

“The trade deal, which would lift tariffs on the majority of goods traded between the United States and Colombia, has recently moved from the political sidelines to the center of the presidential campaign. Mr. McCain supports the deal as essential to free trade and relations with a crucial ally that receives about $600 million a year in counterinsurgency and anti-narcotics aid, but Mr. Obama and many Democrats oppose it because of workers’ fears about job losses overseas and American labor’s concern over the killings of union leaders in Colombia.” 

The Washington Post adds, “McCain's latest trip -- to Colombia and Mexico -- is designed to highlight his positions on trade and, to a lesser degree, immigration. Its value has been questioned by campaign strategists in both parties, since neither issue seems a winner for his campaign. His insistence on the virtues of free trade remain suspect in Rust Belt swing states, and his position on immigration continues to make many conservatives wary.”  

Reuters: “McCain, in an unusual trip to Colombia as a U.S. presidential candidate, called on President Alvaro Uribe on Tuesday to make further progress on human rights while pushing the U.S. Congress to vote on a trade pact between the two countries.”

Per NBC/NJ’s Adam Aigner-Treworgy, McCain and his traveling companions Sens. Joe Lieberman and Lindsey Graham met with Colombian President Alvaro Uribe at Casa de Huespedes -- the Colombian Camp David, per the campaign -- in Cartagena, Colombia last night.
 
The campaign reported that the politicians’ meeting lasted one hour and 40 minutes, and according to McCain’s comments to the press after their meeting, the two discussed the issue of human right in Colombia for at least part of the time. During his opening comments, Uribe thanked McCain for coming and summarized the portion of their meeting that the pool camera caught on film – basically the two politicians, along with Cindy and Sens. Lieberman and Graham, looked at plaques commemorating the visits of President Clinton and President H.W. Bush.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Obama will do more for the economny that the current administration!  Reminder: 4.00 Gas, Terrible R.E,etc..

The time for change is NOW!!

** 20% JULY BLOW-OUT SALE on Barack Obama products $8.99 & Up ( up to 80% Off). Use this coupon at this Obama Store.
http://www.MyObamaStore.com
Coupon - Obama20Now (20% OFF)
The only ignorant one in this election is McCain.  I see he has his trusted sidekicks/handlers along with him on the trip to Columbia ( Lieberman and Graham (his dumpling)Trying to keep the old coot straight on his talking points, I suppose.

Hey, MSNBC, how about asking McCain to release ALL his military records !! What is he hiding? John Kerry released his !!

McCain is all for trashing Gen.Clark,who is also a Hero and four star general, so why is McCain getting a pass on this.

Release ALL your military records, McCain....  
"McCain and his traveling companions Sens. Joe Lieberman and Lindsey Graham..."
*********************************

Seriously, does this guy go to the bathroom with these two?

http://thepajamapundit.com/
Another racial comment from McCain?  "McCain questioned Obama's shifting position on trade as well as his experience with Latino voters. Voters, he argued, will ultimately vote Republican once they see the two candidates side by side.”

He did not talk about policy differences, he did not talk about a debate, he said "see" the two candidates side-by-side.  This is a racial dig if there ever was one.
Dear John, Just what is it that we trade with Colombia? Last time I looked , Colombia's largest import was drugs. Background please, or is this just another pathtic attempt to court the Latino vote.
obama will do more for the economy.  obviously the trade agreements need to be changed to benefit workers here in america and obama wants to renegoiate them whil mccain wants to keep them the way they are now.

http://www.sensico.wordpress.com
After the unsafe, sub-standard imports from China, you can be your sweet a** that I want some "protection".  I want jobs IN America and I want to see the signs "Made in America" again!

The repucklicans have outsourced America, so that a few fatcats can get fatter.  Look, around!  The repucklicans have pillaged the American economy and we sit back and let them terrorize us with fear of another attack?  Not me!  It is time to restore AMERICANS!  

Obama 08
After the unsafe, sub-standard imports from China, you can be your sweet a** that I want some "protection".  I want jobs IN America and I want to see the signs "Made in America" again!

The repucklicans have outsourced America, so that a few fatcats can get fatter.  Look, around!  The repucklicans have pillaged the American economy and we sit back and let them terrorize us with fear of another attack?  Not me!  It is time to restore AMERICANS!  

Obama 08
GOP's Worse Nightmare..on Trade

Change in Washington D.C..

Obama/Biden'08
It's somewhat puzzling why McOld is going to Columbia and Mexico.  Clarlie Black has connections in Columbia so John can get a chance to talk to government people.  But why? The trip seems without purpose. I wish the media would focus on that question.  He has so much work to do on his campaign, so many states that are turning blue. so many subgroups to pursuade.  Why? Why? Why?
Has anyone noticed that John McCains rhetoric is mainly NAME CALLING. How substantial is that?
McCain is a student of history? I don't think so.

Comparing the causes of the Great Depression to the current NAFTA debate only displays ignorance, either wilful or not.

McCain himself said he doesn't understand much about economics. But now he's presented himself as a student of economic history? Not buying it.
McCain touts platitudes about his concern for the economy invoking the words protectionism, and isolationism, but he never gives any facts, or statistics to support his rhetoric. He never tells us exactly how these would erode our economic growth, health, and well being.

If we were to question him on it in a town hall, it would be quite a sight watching him fumble around, flipping his microphone like a clown, and finally change the subject to when, as a POW he............
You really gotta wonder why democrats & labor are in favor of protecting communist drug runners in South America.
At one time, I was for NAFTA, too, because I believed it would help poor countries rise to our standard of living.  Over time, though, I've seen that it only helped big companies outsource American jobs to cheaper foreign workers.  So, my view has changed. So has Obama's.  That means he's actually THOUGHT  about this issue.That's a good thing.  And protectionism and isolationism were not responsible for the depression; the REPUBLICAN PRESIDENT AND HIS ADMINISTRATION AND POLICIES were the cause.  A little protection right now might help keep American jobs in America, and a little isolation might keep American kids in military uniform in America, too.
Notice how Mccain only talks up NAFTA in OTHER countries, not in the good ole USofA, where American workers are being hurt by it?
You see navy man John McCain going to Mexico and Iraq and showing people who America is.  Sissy liberal Obama stays here and lies about McCains record in the war when he would lose all our wars and just surrender.  McCain is a hero and will never surrender or give away his high taxing to welfare like Jimmy Obama.  Vote for President John McCain and I hope Huckabee because America needs a more moral way.
Just because you are old enough to be part of history does not make you a student of history.  And, if he was such a student of history he would realize that a large American presence in the Middle East would be a constant conflict.  Has anyone notice that one or more of the Middle East countries have be in conflict due to dislike of outsiders for many years.  What part of history would tell McOutsource that our presence would be different; Russia in Afgan, or maybe Khobar Towers.
Cults start with an idea, an idea of deliverance, a hope for the future, salvation.  Once the followers have been steeped in that awhile, the leader starts testing their faith with trials to prove their devotion to see if they are blind enough.  If the leader sees the people will blindly follow them, and have forgotten the original idea that brought them there in the first place (hope), The leader can then do what they like.

The Libs are still feeding from the Obama trough even though he is now supporting gun rights, wire tapping, and faith based charity.  This unabashed blindness by his supporters is bringing me down today.  Are we really this dumb as a species?
McCain is a FRUIT AND TERRORIST PROTECTIONIST.  
His friend and fundraiser, Carl Lindner Jr, former CEO of Chiquita, was involved in FINANCING the COLOMBIAN TERRORIST GROUP, AUC.  (AUC, who MCCAIN HIMSELF has said ARE a TERRORIST GROUP!) After Chiquita relized they were breaking U.S. laws, they then paid in cash! A Justice department indictment last year, had Chiquita paying $25 MILLION in FINES.  

Charles BLACK, campaign advisor to McCain, (infamous quote "If terrorists attack the US, it benefits McCain's campaign!) was paid $80,000 for LOBBYING for CHIQUITA.  BLACKS company also made $1.6 MILLION for LOBBYING for OCCIDENTAL PETROLEUM, who's security arm was accused of bombing a COLOMBIAN village, killing 17 civilians.
LINDNER co-hosted a fundraiser LAST WEEK for MCCAIN, at $25,000. a PERSON.  In the late 90's McCain promoted a deal for LINDNER in the Arizona TONTO National FOREST!

And McCAIN is IN COLOMBIA TODAY...
PUSHING FOR THE BUSH/CHENEY TRADE DEAL WITH COLOMBIA!
McCAIN is the Presdiental Candidate FOR LOBBYISTS, INTERNATIONAL CORPORATIONS, and FOREIGN COUNTRIES!!!
HE cares NOTHING ABOUT AMERICAN WORKERS LOSING THEIR JOBS!  Why??
Well, NEXT he is on to MEXICO, where he will probably make closed door deals about getting MEXICAN WORKERS to come into the U.S. to take the high paying jobs left for Americans, and get the Mexicans to work for less at the same job!  What a savings for his CEO buddies!  Will he push for the MEXICAN TRUCK DRIVER too, that will close down all U.S. trucking companies, that BUSH TRIED TO RAM DOWN OUR THROATS??
I supposed he will choose Bill GATES for VP, so BILL CAN GET ALL THE WORKERS FROM INDIA he wants, to take all telecom and Technological jobs from Americans too!

McSAME...selling out the American BLUE COLLAR working people...
for his rich corporate freinds for cheaper labor...
and his LOBBYISTS friends...
that keep THE MONEY ROLLING IN!!!

HE is a TRADER to the AMERICAN PEOPLE!


After the unsafe, sub-standard imports from China, you can be your sweet a** that I want some "protection".  I want jobs IN America and I want to see the signs "Made in America" again!

The repucklicans have outsourced America, so that a few fatcats can get fatter.  Look, around!  The repucklicans have pillaged the American economy and we sit back and let them terrorize us with fear of another attack?  Not me!  It is time to restore AMERICANS!  

Obama 08

------------------------------------

Actually it was Clinton who created the outsourcing mess we are in today.  It was just Bush who failed to stop it or even try for that matter, but he should not be given credit for the crappy chinese toys, you can thank Bill.
It's hard to imagine a dumber move McCain could make.  He's telling American workers they can take a hike.
McCain himself said he doesn't understand much about economics.

Just this morning I heard him say he never said that.
Hum...there must be something wrong with my hearing.
I don't trust a word that comes out of McCains mouth.  He can't be trusted, nor can you trust that he'll follow through on his promises.  He has changed his positions on most all of the important issues to secure the gop nomination.  It seems that on his way to the nomination, he lost all his principles and convictions.  Now he's just a doddering old man that can't defend his own positions, and spends all his time criticizing Obama.  I personally don't care what he thinks of Obama - where does he stand on the issues!  It's getting harder to tell every day.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1179645

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google