ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Obama camp hits McCain on Afghanistan

Posted: Wednesday, July 16, 2008 10:41 AM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

From NBC/NJ's Athena Jones


This morning, the Obama campaign held a conference call arguing that McCain has shifted his position on sending additional troops to Afghanistan, which has seen a resurgence of the Taliban and increased US casualties.

After months of saying additional troops were not needed in Afghanistan, McCain changed position Tuesday and called for an additional three brigades -- or roughly 15,000 troops -- to be sent to the country. It was unclear if those troops would be redeployed from Iraq or come from NATO forces.

VIDEO: In the Hardball Big Number, Chris Matthews talks about the 22 times Barack Obama mentioned Afghanistan in his "major address" on foreign policy.

Obama adviser Susan Rice said McCain was out of touch and divorced from reality when it came to dealing with Iraq and Afghanistan, calling the Arizona senator's speech yesterday "surreal" and arguing that he has "no credible plan for either conflict and it's resolution."

"He says he wants to surge in Afghanistan without reducing our presence in Iraq, which the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff has repeatedly said is impossible," she said. "And he wants to balance our budget by 2013, in part on the basis of troop withdrawals from Afghanistan and Iraq which he opposes."

Obama communications strategist Robert Gibbs suggested McCain's stance on troops in Afghanistan had changed several times over the course of Tuesday -- and could change again in short order.
 
The goal of the call appeared to be to raise questions about John McCain's ability to lead on national security issues, an area where polls show voters favor the Republican.

McCain spokesman Tucker Bounds sent this email in response to the Obama conference call: “By committing to a policy for the war in Afghanistan before he visits the country and meets with our commanders for the first time, before he holds a single oversight hearing and after he voted against war-funding for the troops serving there -- Barack Obama has shown he views foreign policy through a lens of ideology rather than through looking at facts. Americans are tired of that brand of leadership, and are ready for a leader that will be prepared and put country first.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

To John, MI

Your statement is inaccurate.  Senator Obama has never said that he is against all war.  He has said from the very beginning that our main focus should be Afghanistan and Pakistan, since that is where Al-Quaeda has been hiding out.  Not Iraq.  John McCain had been claiming that focusing on Afghanistan was the wrong strategy.  Now he is all for it, because it is correct.  

Please stop spouting your misinformation.  
Hey, let's all talk about Barack Obama instead!
so McCaine says Obama can't say we need two more brigades in Afgan because Obama has not visited there yet, but McCaine wants to send 3 brigades? Where is the logic? Mccaine wants to redeploy troops from Czechoslavakia maybe?
Richard Holbrooke, the former US Ambassador to the UN said this morning that Bush having sent Ambassador William Burns to Tehran, without preconditions, and with the intent to 'listen' to the Iranians, was a result of the pressure Senator Obama has brought to bear, that we should return to seeking diplomatic solutions, before waging war.

Though Bush, McCain, and the repubs ridiculed him, GW employed Barack's foreign policy of diplomacy with regard to Korea, and as a result, they have abandoned their path to attain nuclear weapons.

Ambassador Holbrooke said that this is going to be a real bugaboo for McCain's campaign, because he has taken a hard stance against employing diplomatic measures.
Chess or a checkers player.... which one can fix our country.  You can call him all the names you want, but no one can't deny the fact he is thinker.... and that's what we need.  The cowboy days are gone, put away the guns and pull out pins and papers.  McCain finished last in his class, how hungry are you to finish at the bottom. He never be a thinker and he never will, he will depend on Gramm and friends to tell him what to think.  

Obama/? 08
Is that the only way the Republicans can respond?? Is that ALL they've got??

The Republican response was a series of distortions and half-truths (which, I guess is better than MOST of their responses wherein they simply outright lie)

The sad thing is that these are treated like legitimate responses and people believe them. Come ON - hasn't this hearing thing been rehashed enough times - Joe Biden is the chairman of the larger committee that meets to hold those hearings and his vote "against" funding was not actually against funding the troops...but hey - they may just be able to lie their way into into the White House again.  
Glad to see the Obama camp finally pouncing on these McCain flip-flops and not waiting for the MSM to do it for them!
"I know how to win wars, I know how to win wars".

Sounds like Dr. Strangelove to me. I think he is really crazy; and the GOP must be kicking themselves in the rear for actually nominating this crazy old man.

He just said that we should invade Lower California for a quick victory.
where is Nobama?......
Can we just put Obama in and get over this GOP strangle hold on America?? This country in=s in THE TANK thaks to The GOP

Time for CHANGE
McCain himself has made so many serious mistakes in referencing the wrong leaders(Putin),the wrong numbers(surge) and the wrong countries(Chech Republic) that it is clear most folks are not reading and are only relying on AP news for their information.  McCain clearly is not as knowledgable, nor versed in foreign affairs as the media has pushed him to be. I went to one of my local stations NBC13 website and  all, I mean ALL, stories were from AP, which is a republican spewing machine.  The state of the media is sad, sad, sad.
It will be interesting to see how this Afghanistan issue will play out.  With many distortions and favor for mccain I am sure.  

The sum total of mccain's "gaffes" equals incompetence.  The media is made up of people, so it is not in their best interest, nor their families to continue covering up his inadequacies.
What a child McCain has become. I guess he needs to appeal to his base voters though, so he really doesn't have much of a choice.
mcCain will be completely senile before election day.
Cant wait a year from now when all the obammatrons are spinning that its someone else keeping us in IRAQ and abortions used to be legal and afganistan needs the MARSHALL PLAN problem you still havent won the war,repuckers keep funding the war in Iraq and president obamma signs the bill same ole same ole proove me wrong it will be the happiest day of my life to be so wrong but i got a feeling its going to look the same a year 2 years 3 years nothing will change but hope.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1201834

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google