ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



Obama on security with Bayh, Nunn

Posted: Wednesday, July 16, 2008 4:38 PM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

From NBC/NJ's Athena Jones


WEST LAFAYETTE, Ind. -- The Bush administration has not done enough to confront the national security threats of tomorrow, from bio-terrorism and cyber-terrorism to the potential for nuclear weapons to get into the hands of not only nations but individuals, Obama said Wednesday.

The Illinois senator, who has spent this week talking about national security issues, hosted a panel with experts on how to confront the security challenges of the 21st century, saying that as president he would work with government, industry and academia to prevent these kinds of attacks and prepare for them should they ever occur.

VIDEO: A Race for the White House panel discusses the new ad from the Obama campaign which focuses on national security and is set to air in key battleground states.

Former Georgia Sen. Sam Nunn and Indiana Sen. Evan Bayh -- both of whom have worked on national security issues and whose names have come up amid speculation over potential running mates -- joined the Illinois senator on the panel. It was his first appearance with either politician on the campaign trail, though Obama traveled to Iraq with Bayh in 2006.

The presumptive Democratic nominee complimented Bayh -- calling him “one of the finest senators, prior to that one of the finest governors that we’ve had in the country” -- as well as Nunn and Republican Sen. Richard Lugar, who was not present.

“Other than the fact that he’s a Republican I can’t find wrong anything with that guy,” Obama said to laughter and applause. “He is a great friend and much of the work that I’ve done in this area has been with him and his office. His staff is outstanding. We’ve traveled together, and so I want to make sure to acknowledge his outstanding leadership along with Sam Nunn in some of these critical areas. The two of them working together probably did more in the 1990s and continue to do more than just about any other American citizens in making sure that we are safe from cataclysm, and so we are very grateful to both of them for their outstanding efforts.”

Bayh, who introduced Obama, had kind words for the senator from the  neighboring state.

“Sen. Obama was speaking out about the importance of supporting the Nunn-Lugar initiative and the risks of nuclear proliferation when he was running for the Senate, a long time before he was running for president, so you were ahead on the curve on this from a long way back, just as on Iraq,” Bayh noted.

In his brief opening remarks, Obama noted what the 9/11 Commission called America’s “failure of imagination” when it came to anticipating future threats and tied the issue to Iraq, arguing that the Bush administration had wasted resources because it had invaded and occupied Iraq, a country that had nothing to do with al Qaeda and had no weapons of mass destruction, rather than adjusting to the stateless threats of the new century and taking steps to secure dangers technology like nuclear weapons.

“It’s time to look ahead at the dangers of today and tomorrow rather than those of yesterday,” he said. “America cannot afford another president who doesn’t understand the threats that confront us now and in the future.”

The senator has spent this week talking about national security issues, an area where polls show voters favor John McCain even as Obama leads his Republican rival overall among registered voters in several national polls. In the latest Washington Post/ABC poll, the Arizona senator was seen as the one with greater knowledge of the world by more than 2 to 1 and also beat Obama when it came to the question of which candidate was more trusted on the issue of fighting terrorism.

Obama said he would make cyber security a top priority of his presidency by appointing a National Cyber Advisor to help implement a national cyber-security policy.

He said he would invest in efforts to improve analysis, information sharing and the capacity of intelligence agencies to identify and intercept dangerous bio-weapons around the world, proposing to invest $5 billion over three years to create an international intelligence and law enforcement infrastructure to take down terrorist networks and said improving the education system, especially in the areas of science, engineering and computer programming was key to keeping America safe.

Also on the panel were Dr. David Relman, a professor of medicine at Stanford University; Dr. Tara O'Toole, who is CEO and Director of the Center for Biosecurity at the Univ. of Pittsburgh Medical Center; Dr. Graham Allison, a professor of government at Harvard’s Kennedy School, Alan Wade, former CIA chief information officer and Paul Kurtz, a cyber and homeland security expert

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I'm looking forward to the next round of polls to see how much this spate of security-themed speeches and events and new found focus on the issue helps Obama. It was the biggest anchor on his numbers, so there has got to be a sizable bounce from this.

http://www.political-buzz.com/
Obama sure whines a lot. For a man that has done absolutely nothing, he sure complains a lot about others that have done a lot.

Barack H. Obama - The babbling man!
Some one should ask Obama what he imagines when he lights up a doobie.
Indiana is Obama country... count on it
Maggie aka McCain reputhug intern troll


If McCain is elected President, I will kindly take you up on your offer, because I will not want to live here anymore.  But this time, please, I want to go on a luxury cruise ship, no slave ship for me... thank you very much.
Peg, Chicago, IL (Sent Wednesday, July 16, 2008 3:35 PM)


==========

Good. See ya. And be sure to take a friend, or six. What accommodations you prefer are up to you, I really don't care.
Yesterday the lunatic leftists went all out because McCain said that Czechoslovakia still exists even thought it hasn't for the last 15 years, Well here's a link  To a Sam Nunn quote at Obama event, note he mentioned that Czechoslovakia still exists

http://hotair.com/archives/2008/07/16/video-elderly-out-of-touch-aspirant-for-national-office-calls-czech-republic-czechoslovakia/
It seems to me that McCain is getting a lot of mileage out of his Vietnam experiences.  How else can you explain that people view him as more knowledgeable about  foreign policy when he makes repeated mistakes between Sunni and Shia, where Al Qaeda is or isn't and doesn't even know that Czechoslovakia hasn't been a country for some time??  Obama has been ahead of the curve on Iraq, on shifting troops to Afganistan and Pakistan and also understands there are other security issues such as cyber-security etc.  No more free passes for Mc Cain.  (P.s. he's my senator and no great shakes, let me tell you)
"America cannot afford another president who does not understand the threats that face us now and in the future"

That's why I'll be voting for McCain.  
Holy cow.

This guy is running an incredible campaign.  Just like in the primary, he's demonstrating an amazing sense of timing and intelligent commentary.

WRT to cyber attacks, I suspect that his opponent thinks that is a description of the tooth of a wild tiger on the loose.
Thanks, Mr. Todd, for today's excellent Newsvine discussion. Please see if Chris Matthews will do one!  

One thing that is apparent from the Newvine discussion as well as posts here: McCain IS getting off easy from most in the media on his flip-flops, gaffes, and senior moments.  You say it is up to Obama to take the lead in pointing these out, you guys just report the news that's there, yet Obama wants to rise above this stuff and so do the voters. If that's the case, then stop with these knee-jerk reactions to the right's every-day attempts to set the news agenda. More substance, less BS please!
In the latest Washington Post/ABC poll, the Arizona senator was seen as the one with greater knowledge of the world by more than 2 to 1
-------------------------------------------

McCain probably knows more about nonexistent countries like Czhechoslovakia than Obama does. McCain seems to be living in the 1960s. He more trouble with countries that exist in the present, like Iran, which he didn't seem to know was Shiite.
The only reason the polls currently show McSame ahead on National Security is because the American public assume that because you were in the military you must know something about foreign relations. I believe if Obama continues his current course, the voters will see the candidate with the best judgment. The Iraqi leadership is now calling for timetables; McSame flip flopped his position on Afghanistan; and Bush/McSame flip flopped their position on negotiating with Iran.
The repugs are only interested in maintaining their wealth through oil.
Obama's new ad says it best. Continued reliance on foreign oil funds the terrorists. So their whole foreign policy, the war in Iraq, the reluctance to aggressively pursue Bin Laden in Afghanistan (Bush Sr did business with the Bin Laden family; the Bin Laden family plane was the only one allowed to fly on 9-11-2001 to evacuate the Bin Ladens), and the desire to invade Iran revolve around controlling the flow of  oil; nothing more, nothing less.
These criminals have got to go.
Mean-while back at McWar’s Iranian death camp, McWar pushes his final solution for all Persians and Iranians.
Did anybody notice that in McCain's statement yesterday he said that the commanders on the ground want three more brigades?  It wasn't even his idea.  Now he is "forcefully" calling for more troops.  He's being credited with this strategy that Obama came up with on his own.  I really dislike him.  Best to lead the nation.  Whatever.
Somebody leveled a snipe at Senator Obama yesterday saying he 'horned in' on Senator Luger's loose nukes finding mission. Clearly Barack is giving Nunn, and Luger credit for their leadership with that effort. That carping comment had no merit.

I love the title 'Cyber Advisor'. The 'Czar' handle is getting stupid.

Obama's plan to use the latest technologies, and forge new frontiers for fighting terrorism, etc., by networking around the globe with other nations, is wonderful. Using the most sophisticated lines of communication, and ideas imagined by coordinated think tankers would be quite a change from the backward thinking of the Bush Administration, and what we could expect from McCain.

Bush, and McCain are so far behind, they could never wrap their brains around Obama's 21st century vision.

The google, the internets, and the 'they get me maps' leader's have had their day.

Obama is the future.

HE IS SOOOOO PRESIDENTIAL!

OBAMA '08
Obama has to keep hammering home his positions.  Then when McCain follows Obama on a policy( like Afg.), he has to be relentless on his criticism of McCain.  He has to realize the media will not do this for him.  McCain doesnt get the same scrutiny that Obama gets, for whatever reason.  All I know is when Obama said he would "refine his position" on Iraq, it was news for a week.  Last week McCain said we dont need more troops in Afg., and then this week pretty much puts forth the exact same plan as Obama.  Yet, the media really hasnt said anything about it.  So, Obama has to do the hammering himself.  Apparently the media isnt going to do its job, so he has to.
Lybia
A.Q. Khan Network
Iraq isn't in a nuke race with Iran.
Maybe N. Korea but who really knows.
Clinton, Gore or Kerry aren't in the white house right now.

Listening to "Hardball" today on John McCain's need to reintroduce himself as an "American Hero" like John Wayne or Audie Murphy. What is not needed is a biographical push but an understanding of the 21st century geo-politics and the need to utilize all of U.S. diplomatic skills to better our country politically and economically.  Going "Teddy Roosevelt" who is much admired by us but not swo much by other countries is not the answer. The 20th century of 100 years ago can not be repeated.  The days of "Gunship" diplomacy of Teddy and European colonial hegemony reaped the world wind of WWI an WWII.  We can not act like the Great White Hope of the world educating and christianing the heathen Asian and Africans of the 21st century.  History does not have to repeat itself but if you want Teddy Rossevelts "walk softly and carry a big stick" approach to the world you will repeat the ills of the 20th century.
Obama is ahead of the curve while Mccain is still trying to figure out where it is!!

Obama has ideas, while McCain is trying to steal them.

Obama will soon be living in the White House, while McCain is livin in a retirement home!!
Re The Panel:  But NOT including Richard Clarke who via his book ("Your Government Failed You") has presented in essence an extended resume for the post of counter- terrorism head in a new administration!!??
Obama said something very important today when he referenced the 9/11 Commission and Americans' "lack of imagination" in regards to terrorist threats. There is a very potent way that he can use that. Not as fear-mongering, but as framing the argument from a readiness perspective. We went into the same country we went into in 1991. Where's the imagination in that? Are we really anticipating the "new" threats posed in a post-9/11 world?
I intend to vote for Obama although I still prefer Hillary. I have never voted for a Republican for President. However, over the years there have others running that I would have preferred be the nominee. I think of Hillary this year, Joe Biden in years past and Bayh though he has never run. In my opinion this should have been a private meet where Senator Obama should have listened more and talked less. He needs to increase his understanding of specifics on these issues not just the talking points that we as Democrats have come to agree upon.
Obama/Bayh sounds good. It's the kind of ticket that pleases almost nobody and yet is acceptable by about everybody. Which in politics is (seriously) about as good as you can get these days. Liberals don't like Bayh, he's not Hillary, but he's not a right winger like Nunn is either.
Obama is right.  We need a president who has brains, is interested in the world at large, and has a healthy open-minded curiosity that can comprehend the complex security issues facing us.  

Our current idiot-in-chief, Resident Dumbush, who lacked the intellectual capacity, has little knowledge, and is gifted with a trulyan inferior imagination, has made it clear just how big a price we must pay for our mistakes.  A trillion dollars on the Iraq war, more Americans killed because of his stupid decision about that war than even Osama could claim credit to, and hundreds of thousands of innocent casualties all around. . . .  

We need a national enema to be rid of Dumbush, but that won't happen until next January.  But please, dear voters, choose much more carefully next time.  Please, for the sake of out beloved country and the world!
Obama has everything I want in a President: honesty, integrity, intelligence and good judgment. He's kind and thoughtful and definitely a family man. What else could anyone want?
Contrast that with Bush's third term -- McCain, who's BFF is Phil Gramm (don't you believe for a minute that he's out of the picture), all those lobbyists on McCain's campaign team, and McCain's desperate embrace of Bush's dogma. John "I'll NEVER surrender" McCain claims to "know how to win a war" but WHAT war has he ever won? Unless he plans to crash jets ontop of the terrorists, I don't think his Vietnam experiences bring much to the table. He's just scary and I don't want him anywhere near the red phone at 3am.

I feel safe choosing Obama to be there. I know he won't be cranky, forgetful, mistaken or confused. I just hope he brings an FDR approach to his plans for economic recovery -- a NEW DEAL focused on jobs creating infrastructure and developing alternative energy.... jobs that cannot be outsourced!
"Sen. McCain might be old and forgetful at times, but he can handle his own when it comes to Q&A's and debates.
The Truth Hurts a lot (Sent Wednesday, July 16, 2008 4:28 PM)"

HAHAHAHAHAHA...wait, you are SERIOUS?  

McCain can't read a TelePrompter unless he squints and then he still can't make it out.  ("beer" vs. "bill" anyone?)

My mom always told me "if the truth hurts, change it".  So what are you doing about it?
"Other than the fact that he's a Republican, I can't find anything wrong with him"...  This from a guy who claims to be the candidate of unity and bi-partisanship.. What a joke.

Mccain2008
i saw it today online and it was great. very helpful and insightful.  I wish mccain would do the same, expect mccain should hold a summit on economics maybe he would actually learn something

Awkward Exchange between McCain’s press aides and St. Louis Reporter
http://sensico.wordpress.com/2008/07/16/awkward-exchange-between-mccains-press-aides-and-st-louis-reporter/
or
http://sensico2.blogspot.com/2008/07/my-blogs.html
Love these posts.  I hear ppl like that maggie thing say stuff like they are afraid of Obama.  With all of the new threats to this country, I'm more afraid of a president that doesn't know the "internetS" for goodness sakes.  I hope ppl that hate Obama and the idea of a Barack Obama as POTUS are as disgusted when he's elected as I would be if mccain were elected, that they all MOVE OUT! Nothing would do more good for this country than to get rid of the dregs, the 27% that still think GW is doing a good job.

For the crazies like that Maggie, Peg, we've already paid our dues in blood, sweat and tears.  The damn white house was built on slave labor, pretty symbolic for this country, huh?  I'm not going anywhere!  Maggie should leave!  
To Maggie White,DALLAS,TX:  You represent the sick, racist trash that this country needs to purge itself of! I know you will be leaving the country when Obama wins and all that can be said is "good riddance to bad rubbish!"  


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1202811

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google