ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



First thoughts: McCain's rough weekend

Posted: Monday, July 21, 2008 9:19 AM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

From Chuck Todd, Mark Murray, and Domenico Montanaro
*** McCain's rough weekend: You know you had a problematic weekend when: 1) one of your top economic advisers/surrogates finally steps down from the campaign after his “nation of whiners” remark; 2) you get panned for breaking CODEL protocol/etiquette by announcing (incorrectly) at a fundraiser that your opponent is headed to Iraq on Friday or Saturday; 3) the prime minister of Iraq tells a German magazine that he backs your opponent's plan for withdrawing troops from that country; and 4) when the Iraqi government tries to walk back that support, it does so unconvincingly. On the bright side for McCain, his campaign seized on remarks from Joint Chiefs Chairman Mike Mullen that withdrawing US troops over the next two years would be “dangerous.” And he starts this week anew with a tour of battleground states -- taking him to Colorado, New Hampshire, Ohio, and Pennsylvania -- as well as with an interview on TODAY in which he defended his position on Iraq (“I was right about the surge at the darkest time”) and talked about Maliki’s Der Spiegel interview (saying that Iraq wants us out of the country, but based on conditions on the ground).

VIDEO: Barack Obama meets with Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri Al-Maliki in Baghdad. NBC's Ned Colt reports.

*** Already time to go home? Per NBC’s Andrea Mitchell, Obama has arrived in Baghdad and he spoke with Maliki. The headline after their photo-op: Maliki’s spokesman said afterwards (in English) that the Iraqi vision is for all US troops to be out of Iraq by 2010. And with this news -- as well as the Der Spiegel interview, in which Maliki seemed to back Obama’s withdrawal plan -- the trip seems like it has already been a PR success for the Illinois senator. If he could, Obama should probably come home from right now. But he won’t. After visiting Iraq, his overseas trip will take him to Jordan, Israel, Germany (where he will speak at the Victory Column, not the Brandenburg Gate), France, and the United Kingdom. How bad was the Maliki interview for the McCain campaign? As one GOP strategist who occasionally provides advice to the campaign told the Atlantic’s Marc Ambinder: “We’re fu&$@#.” It's hard to imagine the trip can get better at this point for Obama. If anything, there are two big moments left which are fraught with peril: Israel and the campaign speech on foreign soil. 

*** Surge vs. withdrawal: Obama has the easier fact to sell: Maliki wants troops out in 16 months. But how about the fact that this weekend -- after a yearlong boycott -- a key Sunni bloc rejoined the Iraqi government? Doesn't this mean that the surge which, coincidentally started over a year ago, provided breathing space for political reconciliation? And herein lies McCain's frustration with the coverage of this trip and with Maliki in particular: Does Maliki talk up the surge or focus on withdrawal? It also shouldn’t be ignored that Maliki is playing politics with Bush here. This is yet another nail in the Lame Duck coffin, which has to make the current 1600 Pennsylvania Ave. occupant a little nuts.

*** Conventional vs. comfort: Turning back home, all indications are pointing to Obama's veep pick getting announced in the 10-day window after he gets back from Europe and before the Olympics. (Maybe, given the calendar, we're stating the obvious at this point, but everything is about timetables in the Obama campaign, right?) Speaking of the veepstakes process, one criterion that is too often overlooked is the "comfort factor." Both nominees are the leaders who prefer to surround themselves with people they like and respect. Sure, both have attempted to sell themselves as politicians who will sit down with anyone with any point of view. But both hate to hear calculation enter the equation in a hiring decision. Would it be that much of a surprise if both men end up making politically risky picks in the name of comfort? For instance, there's a lot of chatter that McCain is particularly fond of both Tom Ridge and Mike Bloomberg, and that he could see himself partnering with either of these two to help run the country. But politically, both would be tough sells to the socially conservative crowd. For Obama, a comfort pick would be Tim Kaine, Kathleen Sebelius, or even Jack Reed. Will the Obama and McCain picks end up being picks of comfort or conventional? Stay tuned. 

*** Meet Jack Reed: Speaking of Reed… The Rhode Island senator, who is on the overseas trip with Obama, has been to Iraq 11 times (and voted against the original Iraq war resolution)… The widely respected voice on national security is a 1971 West Point grad, though he did not fight in Vietnam. The Army Ranger paratrooper, who eventually commanded the 82nd Airborne, was assigned elsewhere… Father was a school custodian and WWII vet… Was on a trip to Afghanistan with McCain and Lieberman when he first met his wife… Took weekly art classes at the age of 5 at the Rhode Island School of Design… Big Will Ferrell fan and drives a 1991 Ford Escort… Differing with Obama, he was against the 1991 Gulf War and voted against the recent compromise FISA legislation.

VIDEO: Days after outlining a plan to expand President Bush's faith-based initiative, Barack Obama was back before another church group, as he and John McCain jostle for religious voters.

*** A Purpose-Driven forum: The New York Times is reporting that McCain and Obama will speak at a forum at Rev. Rick Warren’s megachurch on August 16, and they will appear on stage together for a brief amount of time. This is the blueprint for groups who are trying to get Obama and McCain together on the same stage. Why did Obama agree to this Rick Warren forum? Because it provides him two things: 1) access to a constituency group he might not win over and 2) an opportunity to prove his Christianity bona fides. McCain gets less out of this because he's appealing to voters he needs to have, but it does give him a bigger spotlight at a time he made need it.

*** Hillary’s debt: Looking at her June FEC filing, the New York Times reports that Clinton loaned herself an additional $1 million (up to a total of $13.2 million), and that her debt to her vendors rose from $10.4 million to $12 million. The paper also writes that in June, “the Clinton campaign took in just $2.7 million from donors in June, less than the $5.4 million it spent.” 

*** On the trail: McCain is in Maine, where he meets with former President George H.W. Bush in Kennebunkport and later raises money there before heading to a picnic at the Maine Military Museum in South Portland. Obama is in Iraq.

Countdown to Dem convention: 35 days
Countdown to GOP convention: 42 days
Countdown to Election Day 2008: 106 days
Countdown to Inauguration Day 2009: 183 days
 
Click here to sign up for First Read emails. 
Text FIRST to 622639, to sign up for First Read alerts to your mobile phone. 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Hello Mr Todd,

I know my message may not be publish as usual but I have made a point of duty to daily send you and your team my thoughts.

I think you and your team has in your hand a rare opportunity to contribute your quota to the progress of this country and I believe posterity will judge if you use this opportunity well.

I want to say that what Andrea Mitchel is doing in this election will be judged sooner or later. I do not need to go into details but I am very sure she has a heart and conscience. As a journalist, of course you have the right to like or hate a candidate but you still have to understand that you are speaking to a diverse public hence you own it as a duty to report the truth. She has chosen to be bias in this election and it is very glaring, we all can see it. I will advise her to adjust or she will do herself, her image and the organization she works for a lot of damage by the time she realises it. Uncle Tim did not plan what happened to him but I wish he was alive to see the way everybody from both aisle were celebrating him, nobody knows what can happen in the next minute and that is why is good to use every opportunity very well. Yes she is making some people happy by choosing to be biased but she must do some soul searching and ask herself hard questions about what she is doing or what her motives are. I have purposely put my email address here, she can mail, I will even give her my phone number if she wants. The bottom line is that she is too biased and she must change.
Hey Nashville Fan- I am skeptical about anything that I hear, or see, from the US Military. They have gone a long way to control what the American people are told about their activities. Many recent examples of that from Jessica Lynch (is she the plucky little fighting non-com rescued in a dramtic raid or a simple country girl who did nothing extaordinary and was rescued from an undefended compoint without a shot fired?) to Pat Tillman (hero who gave up a lucrative career to fight for the US tragically killed in a fire fight or hero shot to pieces by his own outfit because of multiple errors. They lied to us about this for months!). I am completely suspicious after watching the softballs being lobbed by Faux New's Chris Wallace to Joint Chiefs Chairman/Political General Mike Mullen. That whole episode was set up to assist McCain! Don't lecture us about the veracity of the military.
the surge was part of the strategy of the iraq study group (ISG).  however it was supposed to be accompanied by agressive diplomacy.

bush was emphatic about NOT using the agressive dplomacy especially as it involved "the neighbors."

in essence the ISG said send more now but tell them you are leaving.  Talk to the neighbors and get some buy in as its their mutual gaol to avert chaos.  The surge will give them some time to stamp out rampant violence curb militias and get reconcilitaion, oil sharing and the governemnt going.

unforutnately what we did was only the surge really.  So the "time horizon" was never improved for leaving which was the goal.  That is McCAin warns that things can revert precisely BECAUSE he does not follow the rest of the ISG advice.

McCain wants to keep this part of the failure (IGORING ISG other than the surge) alive.

ISG had it right

...agressive diplomacy
...tell em were outta here soon if you dont get a handle
...surge then plan for troops to leave.

the Obama plan is basically the ISG but he was not in favor of the surge per se. SO IMO both MCAin and Obama erred in that regard.  If Obama was for the ISG he should have supprted the surge and THEN his plan whih is the rest of ISG.  even the ISG said you need a surge to avert chaos.

but now Obama's plan is the ISG and McCain is not.  

Go figure.



Where has Senator Reed been all my life? Why haven't I heard of this politician before? I like this guy!

PS How awesome were Al Gore and Tom Brokaw on Meet The Press? What a joy to hear two people speaking intelligently and with civility on TV, about matters crucial to our country and the world.
Chuck,
There is no point arguing about what Maliki said or how it is bein spinned. Everybody in this country can speak and understand English. Most of us also know that what the chairman of the joint chief of staff were not totally his mind and most especially Iraq is a sovereign nation which means dangerous or no dangerous, they have the right to ask us to leave.
I can believe Sen. McCain is talking about judgement. Let us look at the facts.

*Whose judgement was it to go into this war which turned out to be the wrong war?
*Have we forgotten so soon that we lied to and decived into going to this war?
*Why can't we give credit to the man that saw all this and was able to make the right judgement by opposing this war from the beginning?
*Agreed the surge has reduced violence and kudos to our men ans women in the uniform but hasn't this war last long enough?
*Have forgotten that afganistan is the home of alqaeda?
*McCain has always opposed military surge in afganistan until last week
I believe win or loose in Nov. Sen. Obama has used good judgement in all these and should be creditted for it.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1211571

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google