Gramm: In or out?
Posted: Tuesday, July 22, 2008 11:58 AM by Domenico Montanaro
From NBC's Domenico Montanaro
There is outrage on the liberal blogs with cries of hypocrisy over the unsure status of Phil Gramm -- and some disappointment on the right that Gramm would be out at all.
Is he in or is he out? Bob Novak and CNBC's Larry Kudlow say he's in. In addition to Kudlow's reporting, Steve Forbes told Kudlow he thinks Gramm would still be at least giving "advice" to the candidate.
VIDEO: The Nation's Chris Hayes talks with Countdown's Keith Olbermann about the resignation of Phil Gramm, McCain campaign co-chairman.
"Oh, I think in terms of advice Phil Gramm will be critical, which is good because on things like trade he is absolutely right," Forbes told Kudlow. "I think John McCain has a long friendship with Phil Gramm, so this was something, Phil Gramm said something that you're not supposed to say these days, and he paid a price for it, but in terms of the relationship, I think it's as strong as ever, and in the McCain administration, I think phil Gramm's advice will be taken to heart." More: "Gramm's been in presidential politics, as I have, and when these things happen, somebody walks the plank, but I think in terms of relationship and the philosophy, that's not going to change."
This, as well as the Gramm news in general, has set off some ideological irritation/debate/hand wringing on both sides.
The conservative TownHall: "As Kudlow notes, Gramm's influence is sorely missed on the trail. His absence seems to have removed the fiscal conservative moorings from the campaign, and as a result, McCain has apparently lapsed back into a more populist message."
Powerline: "The comments were not baseless, but they were highly impolitic. ... After Gramm made his remarks, McCain joked that there might be a role in his administration for Gramm as ambassador to Belarus. I suspect that Gramm would have a more prominent role to play, and that's a good thing."
On RedState, Mike DeVine lambastes the "MSM," -- and TV conservatives -- which he said, "lives for taking conservatives' words out of context and fitting it into their template of Republicans’ as racist, bigot, heartless warmongers." He then lauds Gramm as "a conservative icon of the Reagan Revolution" and "an architect of supply-side economics that produced the recovery in the 1980’s that we still technically live in."
Michelle Malkin even throws an immigration shot in there. "Too bad it was him and not open-borders zealot Juan Hernandez."
The liberal AmericaBlog: Forbes "seemed to suggest that Gramm will continue to advise McCain during the campaign, and he'll get an appointment in a McCain administration. So the McCain campaign lied when they said Phil Gramm was out."
Carpetbagger: "Gramm’s resignation prompted plenty of headlines, which is presumably what the McCain campaign wanted — people are supposed to know that Gramm said something crazy, and now he’s no longer on the team as a result. But the co-chairman designation was little more than an honorary title. The real problems were more substantive, most notably the fact that McCain was shaping his economic worldview on Gramm’s guidance, and that the campaign’s economic policies were the result of Gramm’s advice. Is Gramm gone, or is he only kinda sorta gone?"
On the TownHall point, a populist message is certainly what McCain sounded when he originally rebuked Gramm's comments -- to the chagrin of the Club for Growths of the world.
Before telling Gramm where to go -- Belarus, apparently -- McCain sounded every bit John Edwards: “I don’t agree with Sen. Gramm,” McCain said July 10 in Michigan. “I believe that the person here in Michigan who just lost their job, isn’t suffering from a ‘mental recession.’ The mother here who is trying to get enough money to feed her children, isn’t ‘whining.’”
Does this highlight an internal debate, as Kudlow reports? "[W]hen Robert Novak’s Saturday column was initially published Friday evening, correctly reporting that McCain and Gramm had patched up their relationship, McCain insiders apparently went ballistic, even though their boss wanted to keep Gramm inside the tent. Once Gramm got wind of this internal war dance last Friday night, he resigned as campaign co-chairman, relegating himself to rank-and-file supporter status."
Either way, Gramm's influence is an open question.