ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



First thoughts: The turning point?

Posted: Friday, July 25, 2008 9:18 AM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

From Chuck Todd, Mark Murray, and Domenico Montanaro
*** The turning point? So was this week a turning point in the presidential race? The Obama campaign certainly believes it was, and that this will be the moment that Obama grabs the lead for good. If McCain never catches up at this point, his campaign's actions this week (its blistering criticism of Obama and the media, the visuals it picked, its body language, its VP games) will get second-guessed for months. We know this was a significant week; the question is was it enough to erase the doubts voters have with Obama about his ability to be commander-in-chief? But just asking: Did this week tell us more about Obama or McCain? Watching McCain chasing the news cycle and his inability to not let Obama get under his skin -- and the campaign's -- suggests that they could be reactive from this day forward. Why, for instance, did the campaign insist on the equal treatment (see network interviews) this week and not simply attempt to create its own week of coverage from the nets? They were second fiddle all week, and seemed to almost demand being highlighted in that way.

VIDEO: A Race for the White House panel debates: Where is Barack Obama weak politically and how effectively has the McCain campaign been capitalizing on those weaknesses?

*** This race is McCain’s to win, too: Can the McCain camp win by simply hoping for an Obama slip-up or by reacting faster and faster? Yesterday in First Read, we noted that NBC/WSJ pollster Peter Hart said this election was Obama’s to win. But isn’t that also true for McCain? McCain can't simply hope Obama loses this election or fails to adjust his campaign sail enough to capture the strong Democratic wind. Yesterday, actually, McCain finally seemed comfortable being the broccoli candidate -- embracing his role as the serious guy juxtaposed to the rock star opponent. Will the campaign around him have the patience to accept McCain's "keep on keeping on" promise he made to NBC's Kelly O'Donnell?

*** VP's coming? One of these days the McCain campaign won't be "crying VP" and will actually announce his pick. Today's Washington Post has a defensive “the pick could be coming any day now” story. “Anxious to counter the blanket media coverage that has followed Sen. Barack Obama on his overseas journey, Sen. John McCain is weighing whether to announce his running mate in the coming weeks before the spotlight shifts to China and the opening of the Olympic Games next month. ‘He's in a position to make [the decision] on short notice if he wanted to,’ said McCain's chief strategist Charlie Black. Bottom line: The media is being put on notice that the pick could come at any time, with the campaign hinting big time that McCain's going to make the pick before the Olympics. As for Obama's timing, considering how the campaign likes to let big events sink in, it seems highly unlikely they'll step on their own post-trip bounce (if they believe they'll be getting one) by announcing the VP next week. That leaves just one week before the Olympics if next week is indeed out.

*** About that Landstuhl visit: Perhaps the sole bump the Obama campaign hit this week was the minor controversy that erupted when Obama’s campaign decided to skip a visit to Landstuhl to meet with injured US soldiers. The Obama camp put out two statements, the first from retired Gen. Scott Gration: “Sen. Obama had hoped to and had every intention of visiting our troops to express his appreciation and gratitude for their service to our country. We learned from the Pentagon last night that the visit would be viewed instead as a campaign event. Sen. Obama did not want to have a trip to see our wounded warriors perceived as a campaign event when his visit was to show his appreciation for our troops and decided instead not to go.” The other was from strategist Robert Gibbs: “The senator decided out of respect for these servicemen and women that it would be inappropriate to make a stop to visit troops at a U.S. military facility as part of a trip funded by the campaign."

*** The rules: NBC’s Pentagon correspondent Jim Miklaszewski breaks down the rules for these kind of visits: “Political candidates, including the president, are not permitted to use military facilities as a campaign backdrop or anything that could be perceived as being part of a political campaign. Now, of course, we know those lines can be blurred in the president for example has some official purpose for appearing at a military installation. As a member of the Armed Service Committee John McCain could also have a legitimate reason for visiting a military base and attracting media coverage, but it hasn't happened and I think both sides would take a serious look at the implications. The other issue is concern over exploitation of the wounded, for any reason. When the president, the Defense secretary, or any member of Congress visit the wounded at a military hospital the media are not invited to cover the event.” Bottom line from us: The Obama campaign was being overly cautious, worried about the exploitation factor. (The real cynic might believe Obama realized he couldn't bring cameras so THAT's why he canceled). The McCain campaign decided to hit him -- and probably would have done it either way. It was a tiny press victory for McCain in a sea of disasters for the week.

*** Meet Tim Kaine: Tim Kaine is yet another Harvard law grad in those up for consideration for VP this cycle… While he eventually got his degree from Harvard law, Kaine -- a devout Catholic -- left midway through to embark on a nine-month Jesuit mission in Honduras, where he taught welding and carpentry to teenagers… He speaks fluent Spanish… Plays harmonica, sings in the church choir, and apparently likes Charlie Parker-era jazz… Kaine's father-in-law was Virginia's first Republican governor in the 20th century… He and Obama are close; Obama campaigned for Kaine during his governor's race… Like Obama, Kaine was a civil-rights attorney before going into politics… While Kaine is from the key battleground of Virginia, he isn’t as popular in the GOP-leaning southwest part of the state as Mark Warner is.

VIDEO: President Bush and Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki have agreed to pursue a "general time horizon" for withdrawal from Iraq, even as Maliki announces support for Barack Obama's proposal. NBC's Patty Culhane reports.

*** Bush’s shifts: Because of the presidential contest -- which is sucking the air out of most other news -- we haven’t paid much attention as we should to all the significant policy shifts coming from Bush Administration. They’re stunning, in fact. The “time horizon” for troop withdrawal from Iraq. Sending envoys to both Iran and North Korea. Just asking: Would the Republican Party and McCain be in a better position heading into this election had Bush announced these changes two years ago, when he still captured the public’s attention?

*** On the trail: McCain is in Colorado, speaking to the GI Forum Convention in Denver and then heading to Aspen to meet with the Dalai Lama. (The Lama is already a big hitter, no telling what the thin air of Colorado will do for the Lama's driving abilities.) Obama, meanwhile, flies from Berlin to Paris -- where he chats with President Nicolas Sarkozy -- before heading to London.
 
Countdown to Dem convention: 31 days
Countdown to GOP convention: 38 days
Countdown to Election Day 2008: 102 days
Countdown to Inauguration Day 2009: 179 days
 
Click here to sign up for First Read emails.
Text FIRST to 622639, to sign up for First Read alerts to your mobile phone.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I knew there was more to the Landshtul cancelation than McWeenie was spouting...having been in the military for 23 years, I recognized the machinations of military policy and am glad someone finally reported it correctly. I knew Obama would not bail on our troops "just cuz"...now let's see if anyone else cancels out McWeenie's lies with the truth..any bets?
I have noticed a few things about Obama. Hilary (after she lost) said to him he needs to help with her debt, HE AGREED. Then in a press conference, he was asked if she was a candidate for his VP spot and she grabbed him by the arm and whispered to him, and then HE DIDN'T ANSWER THE QUESTION. MCCain says he needs to go oversea's and HE GOES. McCain says, that you need to look at conditions on the ground before you can make a decision on the Iraq poul-out, and Obama "refines" his position to INCLUDE conditions on the ground. I like Obama, but he is really starting to look lik eh eis being led around by the nose.
Some right-wing consrvative banter here...

Translation: blah blah blah blah blah - yawnnnnnnnnn.
Did anyone see the special 'Black in America' on CNN?
That certainly explains the closeness of the Poll numbers. . . .  McCain's flip-flops and obvious inability to grasp facts and communicate them to the American people, is profound !!!! If this were any other election, well. . . Obama would be ahead, and stay ahead, until election day.  But he's Black !!!
And Corporate media will NOT let you forget it !!!!!
You see, that's supposed to be NEGATIVE. . which certainly  appeals to the GOP (grumpy old people) . . .they love it.
McCain is the cheesey candidant, grocery whatever that was, he seems desperate, and lame~!
It seems the McCain campaign has decided that their target audience is soooo stooopid that these really lame reactive tactics -- like running ads in little US towns named Berlin, Paris and London -- will actually work.

The biggest problem here?  They may be right.
Wouldn't it be nice to have differant post times for those on the west coast and any in between. I get up at 6:30 and still I don't have time to read all the articles and submit posts before you stop accepting them. People on the west coast and every where inbetween should be allowed time to respond at their same times respectivly.
IDTT, Laurel, MD - Couldn't have written it better!
McCain is not moving up in the state polls. If you want a clear vision of how good a poll is read the fine print. For example where the new poll said that McCain picked up 15 points in one month in Minnesota. If you read that poll you will see that McCain only got beat 50% to 45% by voters between the age of 18 to 34. if you look at the same poll for Minnesota a month ago Obama beat Mccain with that age group by 63% to 33%. If you look at the national polls and other state polls you will see consistantly that Obama is beating McCain with this age group by 25 -35 percent. How on earth could there be this large of difference with this voting group in Minnesota this month opposed to last month. (The media wants it to be close)
The Morning Joe show is so slanted that it is SICKENING TO WATCH.  I have to go else where.  Has anone else had it with that guy and his yes men/woman???
(The real cynic might believe Obama realized he couldn't bring cameras so THAT's why he canceled). The McCain campaign decided to hit him -- and probably would have done it either way. It was a tiny press victory for McCain in a sea of disasters for the week.........

- First Read

****

Let us look at the other side of the coin. Obama had no intention of taking cameras with him to Landstuhl to visit our wounded troops, just as he didn't when he visited the wounded in Iraq.

If 'war hero' McCain cared anything for our troops, (war heros too), he would not have jeapordized the soldier's opportunity to meet Senator Obama, which they were clearly excited about. Senator McCain would not have made a political firestorm of that part of Barack's itinerary. Those are not the actions of a hero. They are the actions of a low down dirty.....

However, what else can be expected of McCain who fought against Senator Webb's GI Bill, then lied about it by taking credit for it in one of his towm hall mettings, after it passed Congress.  
I agree with you Pat in Boston.
It is increasingly frustrating that McCain, with all of his gaffes, misstatements and downright lies, that the MSM will not call him on it. This week has been an utter disaster for McLame, and yet the "press" has given him a pass; like making excuses for a crazy uncle no one talks about at family reunions.
How I miss Tim Russert. For that matter, Chancellor, Huntley and Brinkley as well. Is there anyone that will step up and ask McCain the tough questions about this weeks' gaffe filled medley of sound bites? (Chuck Todd? Mark Murray? Domenico Montanaro? Ron Allen? Brian Williams? Norah O'Donnell? Jim Miklaszewski? anybody?)
It is increasingly clear that Obama has been put under much more scrutiny. The "bitter" comments and "Rev Wright" were played 24/7 non stop; while McLame's MANY gaffes and demonstrations that he is quite frankly inept have been largely ignored, passed over, enabled, and justified. (Andrea Mitchell, Kelly O'Donnell).
This is the reason why the polls are tightening; the American public trusts their news organizations; the news organizations have not been worthy of that trust. Therefore, McLame's many lies are not challenged.
Is it a "corporate edict"? Is there some reason that NBC, C(more)BS, CNN, or ABC will not truly ask McLame about his many troubled positions?
I understand there is a clear delineation between pundits (Keith Olbermann, Rachel Maddow), and news "reporters" (Mitchell, et. al.) It seems in the so called "Objective reporting", that line has been blurred in favor of McCain. It also seems that the "pundits" are more objective than the "reporters".
I am asking that NBC returns to its roots of stellar journalism and please do your job. The American people are depending on you.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1221903

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google