ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



M. Obama avoids veterans hit on McCain

Posted: Wednesday, August 06, 2008 4:11 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ’s Carrie Dann
NORFOLK, Va. -- In the midst of a blistering exchange of ads between the two presidential candidates, Michelle Obama chose not to mention her husband's opponent today, even during discussion of a major policy difference with vivid resonance in the military community.
 
Continuing a series of roundtable discussions with military spouses, Michelle Obama called for a brighter spotlight on the needs of veterans, including post-deployment health care and education services for service members. Appearing in battleground state Virginia, Obama listened to a panel of women who lamented the unique challenges that face the husbands and wives of soldiers.

One of the event's biggest applause lines came as she touted her husband's support of a G.I. education bill, sponsored by Virginia Democrat Jim Webb. The bill, which passed the Senate in May and was signed into law in June, will give more than $50 billion in college aid to returning service members over the next 10 years.

What Michelle Obama did not mention was a key part of the discussion among veterans watching the presidential race -- namely, that GOP presumptive nominee and Navy veteran McCain opposed Webb's bill. The aspiring First Lady steered clear of alluding to her husband's bitter counterpunches with his rival after McCain faced a battery of criticism for his resistance to the measure, which is particularly popular with veterans.

A campaign surrogate who shared the stage with her did not let the issue go unmentioned.

"Michelle's too polite. I can say it," said Paul Bucha, a decorated Vietnam veteran and Medal of Honor winner, who has joined Obama at each roundtable in the series. "We're moving forward on the plan that Barack supported and John McCain opposed."

During the spring debate over the legislation, McCain objected to two aspects of the bill: that it did not offer transferability of educational benefits to family members, and that its benefits would be so attractive to service members that they would fail to re-up after only a single tour of duty. A countering proposal offered by McCain, which included transferability, lower payments to recipients, and a tiered system of benefits based on time of service -- was defeated in the Senate.

Michelle Obama described Webb's bill as "legislation that allows service members to share their benefits with their families and achieve the American dream."

A post-passage compromise on the Webb bill meant that the final legislation signed into law by President Bush included McCain's provision that soldiers can transfer their educational benefits to their children and spouses if they choose not to use them themselves.

Obama lamented the economic, personal and medical issues that military families face, saying that she will "transfer that information into the heart and mind of my husband."

Veepstakes speculators will wonder if she'll do the same with her take on Virginia Gov. Tim Kaine, with whom she attends a fundraiser tonight.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

McCain is a proven hypocrit on veterans rights and issues.  He ought to be ashamed, but I don't think he has enough sense to realize it.
McCain's Vet record speaks for itself.
John McCain Gets Testy With Vet Over GI Bill
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hzr3pdXqZ98&eurl

Union Vets Speak Out Against McCain
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2008/7/10/152638/680/650/549557

http://www.vietnamveteransagainstjohnmccain.com/index.htm

Vietnam Veterans Against McCain
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vFM1xqqTX_g


Video Questions John McCain's POW Record by Progressive East Texas
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2008/8/2/183515/5744/954/561457
Michelle Obama, keeping it classy.
"Michelle's too polite..."

Far cry from that New Yorker cover (which is supposed to be a caricature of the average American's fear of the Obamas). Seems to me that Americans let their fear of change distort their viewpoint... hm...
Michelle was wise not to mention McCain. She'd just open herself to attack; who needs that? Her husband's coverage is already more than 70 percent negative; why do anything to cause the MSM to pounce on her, too?
Hey, FR!  What's with not updating comments for "McCain Calls for Economic Surge" thread?

C'mon - we don't write posts to have them sent to the abyss.  This is the second time I've seen you do this in a week.
The contrast is too much to not bring up:

One candidate's wife speaking on bread-and-butter issues to veterans' families and not attacking an opponent. The other candidate offering up his wife as the butt of sexist jokes in front of bikers.

I'll be grateful to see some class returned to the White House.
She's a class act. I can't wait to have her as First Lady.
Michelle Obama...
What a class act !!
Of course McCain supports his plan - he got his education because of his daddy.
Our veterans also know that McSame is a fraud.  This speaks volumes.

OBAMA/BIDEN, 2008!
MI Chick

you think FR is doing a poor job of moderating? try getting the folks.....over at the News Hole to post anything that resembles intelligent discourse in a TIMELY basis. free speech is being shut down everywhere.
Michelle has been so malaigned and mis-characterised by the republicans.  She is a brilliant, caring, talented woman, who could easily run a counrty herself.  She is an honest, straight-forward woman, but isn't a bitter, angry person.  Any anger she may have is when she encounters injustice, which should anger us all.
TOTALLY A CLASS ACT A WONDERFUL LADY, WIFE ,MOTHER AND SOON TO BE FIRST LADY OF UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Stay Classy Michelle, we are all proud of you. Please leave the Republican talking head to their ignorant. We all know they don’t like the troop. Even McCain voted against a 21st century GI bill.

Please continue to speak out on the issues that matter to the Americans.
McCain is no friend of Vets.  My daughter is active duty Navy and just received her Masters as a Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner.  She will be treating returning Vets for PTSD.  The Navy has been allocated only 8 billets (positions) for this specialty.  MSN, do the math and figure this one out for yourself. I dare you to call the Deptartment of the Navy to verify this. Our vets are being srcrewed and tatooed royally by McCain.
Michelle Obama is a intelligent and lovely woman who I
would be so proud to have as this countrys first lady.
As this is one of our most important issues in this election it should be noted that John McCain who voted to send our fighting men to Iraq, has one of the worst voting record possible for those soliders.
I am from a family where all the men has been in the service- father ,army WW11- brother air force-korea
brother-army VietNam.  Husband killed in Viet Nam.
John McCain does not deserve the right to be CIC, Oh I know he is a veteren, a war hero. But when you have the voting record he has I call it a moot point. I have the right to say so.  No, to the lying, cheating,
stealing GOP        Michelle dont go anywhere near Sturgis, other candidates are acting like future first ladies would stoop so low as to be strippers.
So Proud of you Michelle.  Stay strong
whie lady 62 years old from S.C.
proudley voting for Barak Obama
marty
I watched this event and I have to say that Michelle is a very compelling speaker. She’s learned during her time on the stump what is effective and how to connect to those she’s speaking with. Michelle is a brilliant woman that conveys her husband’s message in a way that realistic and down to earth. Michelle brings the substance (which is there but not always stressed) out of Barack’s rhetoric. I’m sure she’ll make a great first lady.
Did she mention that her husband chose vacationing in Hawaii over speaking with troops and families at Fort Hood?
The crowd was invitation only - how cute.
While McSame, I mean McBush, I mean McCain approaches this election like a mean old man frustrated with the world, Mrs Obama gives us a glimps of The First Lady.  McSame ought to be ashamed of opposing educational benefits for military enlisted members.
She is a class act!!!!!

I can't wait to Michelle Obama (Barack's rock as he calls her) in the WHITEHOUSE. She is such a role model as people will see of this lady of couture, wife, mother, cum laude graduate brilliant attorney, and soon to be First Lady.
   
NOBODY, BUT OBAMA!
Did she mention that her husband chose vacationing in Hawaii over speaking with troops and families at Fort Hood?
The crowd was invitation only - how cute.
Denise Haerman Homer Louisiana (Sent Wednesday, August 06, 2008 4:49 PM)

Proof, please!!!  Or is this just a "cute" way to disparage Ms. Obama???  Standing by...
Denise Haerman Homer Louisiana (Sent Wednesday, August 06, 2008 4:49 PM) - Did she mention that her husband chose vacationing in Hawaii over speaking with troops and families at Fort Hood?
The crowd was invitation only - how cute.

Denise:

Did we mention that you appear to be someone who choses to be a jerk. How is that for cute. Nothing is uglier where it counts (on the inside) than a neo-con female.    




SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1250915

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google