ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC Political Researcher



McCain: Stay away from the oil rigs!

Posted: Thursday, August 07, 2008 9:16 AM by Mark Murray
Filed Under: ,

Karl Rove's free advice in the Wall Street Journal today: "To win, Mr. McCain must also make a compelling case for electing John McCain. Voters trust him on terrorism and Iraq and they see him as a patriot who puts country first. But they want to know for what purpose? In the coming weeks, he needs to lay out a bold domestic reform program. He gave a taste on energy, but with a few missteps. He should appear in front of manufacturing plants where jobs depend on affordable energy, small businesses affected by fuel prices, and farms hurt by skyrocketing fertilizer costs -- and not in front of oil rigs. He needs to describe the consequences of specific domestic policy decisions. He must explain how his proposals on energy, health care, jobs and education will make a difference for ordinary families.”

“Mr. McCain also needs to elevate his arguments. It's not only that he opposes tax increases and Mr. Obama favors them. Mr. McCain must also make the principled case that there should be a limit to what government can take from its citizens. This argument will appeal to a large majority of voters. The top income tax rate is 35% and, according to the Tax Foundation, 89% of Americans believe that government should take no more than 30% from anyone's paycheck."

“McCain is taking up the issue of possible job losses due to the closure of a DHL shipping site in Ohio, the result of a corporate merger aided by his campaign manager during his work as a lobbyist,” the AP writes. “In 2003, McCain campaign manager Rick Davis lobbied Congress to accept a proposal by German-owned DHL to buy Airborne Express, which kept its domestic hub in Wilmington in southwest Ohio.  McCain campaign spokesman Brian Rogers said Wednesday that Davis had not worked with DHL since 2005, long before DHL announced plans to move its work out of Wilmington. The companies merged in 2003. ‘At the time of the merger, no one anticipated an impact on jobs in Wilmington,’ Rogers said.”

The New York Times picks up on the curious story of Harry Sargeant. “The Jordanian business partner of a prominent Florida businessman, who has raised more than $500,000 for Senator John McCain, appears to be at the center of a cluster of questionable donations to his presidential campaign. Campaign finance records show Mr. McCain collected a little more than $50,000 in March from members of a single extended family, the Abdullahs, in California and several of their friends.”

More: “Amid a sea of contributions to the McCain campaign, the Abdullahs stand out. The checks come not from the usual exclusive coastal addresses, but from relatively hardscrabble inland towns like Downey and Colton. The donations are also startling because of their size: several donors initially wrote checks of $9,200, exceeding the $2,300 limit for an individual gift.”

Did McCain flip-flop on taxes when he talked about everything being on the table re: Social Security? Bloomberg News is the latest news organization to examine his various contortions on this issue.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Somebody clue in Mr. Rove...

John McCain needs to elevate his arguments?  How do you expect him to do that when he's still figuring out what he stands for?

McCain has only just now adopted his positions...

...drill, drill, drill.
...make the Bush tax cuts for the rich permanent.
...waterboarding is cool.

And, if you listen to John McCain, how can he elevate his arguments when they're arguments that he only seems to half-heartedly believe himself?
"...Mr. McCain must also make the principled case that there should be a limit to what government can take from its citizens..."
--------
And conversely, There should be a limit as to what the citizens should 'take' from their government.  By that I mean the lies, misinformation, dishonesy, etc.  or even, the exact source of donations to one's campaign?  Capt Smash has been on top of these stories, long before MSM.  Stay with Capt!  We are watching, listening and reading and we will make informed choices this year.
Karl, Mr. McCain also needs to elevate his arguments. It's not only that he opposes tax increases and Mr. Obama favors them.
karl did you miss the big flap in the last few weeks!! you guy has says that every thing is on the table reguarding tax increases for SS, i know your were inconptemt of congress and you have been hiding but you about 2 weeks,too late on that, john has already opened his big mouth 2 weeks ago on ABC'S THIS WEEK, and said that it is an option!!!
karl, go back in to hiding!! or you should have goan to china with george!!!
McCain is close to even with an incoherient campaign so far. Rove is right, McCain needs to get focused, and if he does, it will be easy win this fall.
Why is Karl Rove relevent?

He is a disgrace and a political thug. He even got too dastardly for Bush to be seen with.

McCain is really desperate to rely on his tactics.

By the way, why does McCain use Obama's crowds in all his political ads? Doesn't he have any "crowds" of his own to use?

The Republican Party and McCain are showing Americans just how JEALOUS and ENVIOUS of Obama they really are!!
The common wisdom is that President Clinton's comments were a swipe at Obama.  The press is avoiding the other view is that he was saying the John McCain does not have any advantages in being prepared to be President.  Clinton answers the question "Is McCain ready to read?", and Clinton is saying a loud, "No!".
Maybe if John McCain could decide WHAT plan he would like to present to the American public, then, perhaps he could elevate that plan. He doesn't seem to believe in ANY plan, other than whatever Obama wants, too! Apparently the McCain camp didn't learn from the Clinton loss as to how to run against Obama. They are going down the same road Hillary went and look what happened to her! Makes me laugh all the way around. McCain is NO match for Obama! Obama '08
I second LB,Virgina.  Rove is in contempt and he is a contemptable person.  His days of influence are coming to an end.  He is a has-been wanna-be with a disrespected reputation.
You can thank Rove for leading America on the path to becoming a third-world nation.  
Karl Rove is not welcome in my ear. The most convincing liar always mixes truth with falsehood. Rove ia a manipulative snake, and should never be trusted.

Harry Sargeant, and the donations from The Abdullahs is scandal fodder for sure. I hope you will follow it to it's conclusion First Read.

Don't people know that oil is millions of years old...McCain feels akinship with old things...
but ...we now can see and laugh and giggle...
I'm sorry, but the idea that Rove is dispensing strategic "wisdom" from atop his protected little mountain while at the same time defying a Congressional subpoena makes me ill. No matter the content of his column, the mere fact of its existence is a disgrace. The WSJ ought to be ashamed for giving this man a platform. The only time I'll read something he writes is when he's writing his memoirs in prison.
My advise for McCain (or any other candidate for ANY office):

Don't take advise from Karl Rove.

http://thepajamapundit.com/
SEEEE, even the Republican party doesn't have a clue WHAT the heck McCain is standing on.  People that support him only do so because they are die hard republicans and don't know any better.  I mean seriously, can you really be doing THAT well now versus a few years ago or even 8 yrs. ago???  I make more money but I'm no better off because things cost more than they did a year ago.

I will tell you this though, if McCain gets elected and he decides to get rid of SS all together, I would like this to be stated for the record that I want ALL the money back that I've been putting into SS since I was 17 yrs. old PLUS the same interest and penalities that the IRS charges!
At this point, I'd like to know what John McCain stands FOR - all I've heard is that he's AGAINST everything Obama says.  Not very effective, in fact, I've tuned McCain out.  I hear more intelligent conversations from my 6 year olds that I do from McCain.
Karl Rove and nasty politics are going to be the same thing for quite a while.  The idea that McCain can show off his ideas seems to have failed already.  He has made the campaign about his opponent.  Is Obama too risky?  Is Obama too much of a celebrity?  No wonder Rove is saying talk about yourself.
God...I hate Carl Rove!
WHO ARE THE ABDULLAHS?
Now that would be a story to look into, but that would mean someone in the media would need to do some work instead of just parroting each other.
Anyone want to win a Pulitzer?
What we really need to see is Karl Rove in front of Congress, under oath.  That's all we want to hear from him.  Oh, and a perp walk.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1251793

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

More First Read

Recent Posts:


Archives:


Topics:

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google