ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



McCain: On energy, Obama = Bush

Posted: Thursday, August 07, 2008 3:24 PM by Domenico Montanaro

From NBC/NJ’s Adam Aigner-Treworgy
LIMA, Ohio -- After an uncharacteristic week free of any town-hall events, McCain held a public question-and-answer session here this afternoon and returned to the stump speech he debuted last week. Most of the speech is spent going through specific key issues in this election and outlining the differences between McCain and his opponent.

Today, the issue that attracted the most applause was energy and offshore drilling, a subject on which McCain has been trading jabs with Obama for more than a week.

"I spoke up against the administration and Congress and Sen. Obama when they gave us an energy bill with more than giveaways to big oil and really no solution to our energy problems," McCain said. "I want to take a minute here on this issue ’cause I think Sen. Obama might be a little bit confused. Yesterday he accused me of having President Bush's policies on energy. That's odd because he voted for the president's energy bill and I voted against it."

This is a topic that the McCain campaign has been pushing back against ever since Obama released a television commercial earlier this week accusing McCain of being the candidate of big oil. One senior advisor questioned why the media had not called Obama out on his support of the so-called 'Bush-Cheney' energy bill, when McCain's opposition was specifically based on the big tax breaks for oil companies. 

"It had $2.8 billion in corporate welfare to big oil companies and they're already making record profits as you know," McCain said of the 2005 energy bill. "Sen. Obama voted for that bill, and it's big oil giveaways. I know he hasn't been in the senate that long, but even in the real world, voting for something -- voting for something means your support, and voting against something means you oppose it."

Adding to the ongoing debate over whether inflating the tires on Americans' automobiles is an adequate solution to the country's energy crisis, today McCain said that such an idea did not constitute an energy plan.

"He actually thinks that raising taxes on oil is gonna bring down the price at the pump," McCain said of his opponent. "He's claiming that putting air in your tires is the equivalent, is the equivalent of new offshore drilling. That's not an energy plan my friends. That's a public service announcement."

While energy was clearly important to this northwestern Ohio crowd, one man seemed preoccupied with the veepstakes. The man stood up and said he wanted the race in November to be a "landslide" and he was hoping to vote for a McCain-Rice ticket, referring to Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice. At that point other members of the audience chimed in as both Joe Lieberman and Mitt Romney's name were yelled from different sides of the crowd.

McCain simply repeated his favorite joke about the role of a running mate saying that a vice president only has two jobs, break a tie in the senate and inquire daily about the health of the president.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Good luck with that, McCain.  One thing nobody believes about Obama is that he'll be another Bush.
WHAT A LOSER!
So mccain wants to continue the same miserable failure of an energy policy from the bushleague...how's that 4 dollar gas trailer trash
In McCain's case the VP will be checking on the President's health hourly
Senator Magoo realizes no one will even listens to him unless he says Obama's name.

This guy makes me sick. Perhaps he missed it when Obama explained why he voted for Cheney's energy bill. And, seriously, he's still trying pass off Obama's tire gauge suggestion as Obama's energy policy? What a disingenuous hack.
This guy makes me sick. Perhaps he missed it when Obama explained why he voted for Cheney's energy bill. And, seriously, he's still trying pass off Obama's tire gauge suggestion as Obama's energy policy? What a disingenuous hack.
Obama has no understanding of energy issues, no experience and no outstanding achievements and he has a history of shady dealing and poor judgment.

(1) He's been wrong on key issues (the surge, for example - he's just scrubbed his website to take down all references to his opposition to the surge in hope that we won't realize exactly how wrong he was).

(2) His time working for a "civil rights law firm" wasn't spent working on civil rights cases - he was representing shady developers such as Rezko who took government money to build "affordable" housing and then ran, leaving the "affordable" housing to fall into ruins.

(3) At one point during this spring, he even said he thought $5/gallon gas would be a good thing (as long as the price rise was "gradual") because high priced gas would encourage conservation. So he's not exactly a populist.

Why is ANYBODY planning to vote for this man?
My friends. My energy policy is to blow smoke up you know what
Let's pull McCain's voting record since Bush became president. they MATCH 95% of the time. He's a fraud. Oh,BTW, he hasn't even BEEN to the Senate since April 8th for any votes. That's someone who is interested in helping the American people, eh? Can't even bother to show up for a vote.
McDunce still does not get it.  Everyone agrees to include the dunce in chief that"Offshore drilling will not bring immediate relief at the pumo but might change the mindset"  The analogy of inflating your tires equating to what drilling would do is pretty clear, not much to gain if anything at all.  The repukes had their chance and what did they do for us, raised the cost of daily living, thats what.
McCain said. "I want to take a minute here on this issue ’cause I think Sen. Obama might be a little bit confused.

Confused; the Albino Chipmunk cracks me up how can he call anyone confused?
Am I that stupid or it's simply just that the American people and media are ignorant?

Robert Mugabe of Zimbabwe even makes more sense than McCain.
"Adding to the ongoing debate over whether inflating the tires on Americans' automobiles is an adequate solution to the country's energy crisis"

Obama never said correctly inflating tires was a solution to the energy crisis. He said it would be equivalent to lifting the ban on off shore drilling, i.e. NOT a long term solution. It bugs me how the media picks up these lines, dropping the real meaning behind them. Laziness or bias? I think most of the time it's laziness and group think. Once you start to notice how often reporters and pundits do this it gets really annoying. I know: everyone is a media critic these days, still.
"He actually thinks that raising taxes on oil is gonna bring down the price at the pump," McCain said of his opponent. "He's claiming that putting air in your tires is the equivalent, is the equivalent of new offshore drilling. That's not an energy plan my friends. That's a public service announcement."

My Friends; please I just used up my last depends!

My Friends; My wife Cindy just lost one of her inplants.

My Friends; I cannot remember what my next line was.
Why are you saying McCain wants to continue Bush's energy policies? He voted against them, as it says above. I think people are brainwashed by Obama and the media to just think one-sided. I am not pro-McCain, but people just avoid his policies and argument 100% and just say, "no...Obama is right" without even thinking about it.
Obama also voted alongside Bush for 90 ECONOMIC LAWS!! (not 90%, but 90 laws that Bush pushed or tried to push through for the economy)


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1253667

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google