ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



McCain makes statement on Georgia

Posted: Monday, August 11, 2008 10:25 AM by Mark Murray
Filed Under:

From NBC/NJ's Adam Aigner-Treworgy and NBC's Chuck Todd
ERIE, PA -- At his hotel here this morning, McCain read a statement (i.e., took no questions) regarding the situation in Georgia. Once again, he condemned Russia's actions in harsh language, and called on the US to begin sending economic and humanitarian aid to Georgia to mitigate the effects of "Russian aggression." And he called on the secretary of state to travel to Europe and outline a "common Euro-Atlantic position" on how to proceed.

"Russian President Medvedev and Prime Minister Putin must understand the severe, long-term negative consequences that their government's actions will have for Russia's relationship with the U.S. and Europe. It is time we moved forward with a number of steps."

"The United States and our allies should continue efforts to bring a resolution before the UN Security Council condemning Russian aggression, noting the withdrawal of Georgian troops from South Ossetia, and calling for an immediate ceasefire and the withdrawal of Russian troops from Georgian territory. We should move ahead with the resolution despite Russian veto threats, and submit Russia to the court of world public opinion."

But if McCain is trying to own this issue while Obama is away on vacation, why isn't he taking questions from this press? Is he afraid of making policy on the fly if reporters press him on what those "negative consequences" for Russia would be? 

Below is McCain's full statement...

STATEMENT BY JOHN MCCAIN ON THE CRISIS IN GEORGIA
For Immediate Release Contact: Press Office
Monday, August 11, 2008 703-650-5550
ARLINGTON, VA - Today, in Erie, Pennsylvania, U.S. Senator John McCain delivered the following statement regarding the current conflict between Georgia and Russia:

"Americans wishing to spend August vacationing with their families or watching the Olympics may wonder why their newspapers and television screens are filled with images of war in the small country of Georgia. Concerns about what occurs there might seem distant and unrelated to the many other interests America has around the world. And yet Russian aggression against Georgia is both a matter of urgent moral and strategic importance to the United States of America.

"Georgia is an ancient country, at the crossroads of Eastern Europe and Central Asia, and one of the world's first nations to adopt Christianity as an official religion. After a brief period of independence following the Russian revolution, the Red Army forced Georgia to join the Soviet Union in 1922. As the Soviet Union crumbled at the end of the Cold War, Georgia regained its independence in 1991, but its early years were marked by instability, corruption, and economic crises.

"Following fraudulent parliamentary elections in 2003, a peaceful, democratic revolution took place, led by the U.S.-educated lawyer Mikheil Saakashvili. The Rose Revolution changed things dramatically and, following his election, President Saakashvili embarked on a series of wide-ranging and successful reforms. I've met with President Saakashvili many times, including during several trips to Georgia.

"What the people of Georgia have accomplished - in terms of democratic governance, a Western orientation, and domestic reform - is nothing short of remarkable. That makes Russia's recent actions against the Georgians all the more alarming. In the face of Russian aggression, the very existence of independent Georgia - and the survival of its democratically-elected government - are at stake.

"In recent days Moscow has sent its tanks and troops across the internationally recognized border into the Georgian region of South Ossetia. Statements by Moscow that it was merely aiding the Ossetians are belied by reports of Russian troops in the region of Abkhazia, repeated Russian bombing raids across Georgia, and reports of a de facto Russian naval blockade of the Georgian coast. Whatever tensions and hostilities might have existed between Georgians and Ossetians, they in no way justify Moscow's path of violent aggression. Russian actions, in clear violation of international law, have no place in 21st century Europe.

"The implications of Russian actions go beyond their threat to the territorial integrity and independence of a democratic Georgia. Russia is using violence against Georgia, in part, to intimidate other neighbors - such as Ukraine - for choosing to associate with the West and adhering to Western political and economic values. As such, the fate of Georgia should be of grave concern to Americans and all people who welcomed the end of a divided of Europe, and the independence of former Soviet republics. The international response to this crisis will determine how Russia manages its relationships with other neighbors. We have other important strategic interests at stake in Georgia, especially the continued flow of oil through the Baku-Tblisi-Ceyhan pipeline, which Russia attempted to bomb in recent days; the operation of a critical communication and trade route from Georgia through Azerbaijan and Central Asia; and the integrity and influence of NATO, whose members reaffirmed last April the territorial integrity, independence, and sovereignty of Georgia.

"Yesterday Georgia withdrew its troops from South Ossetia and offered a ceasefire. The Russians responded by bombing the civilian airport in Georgia's capital, Tblisi, and by stepping up its offensive in Abkhazia. This pattern of attack appears aimed not at restoring any status quo ante in South Ossetia, but rather at toppling the democratically elected government of Georgia. This should be unacceptable to all the democratic countries of the world, and should draw us together in universal condemnation of Russian aggression.

"Russian President Medvedev and Prime Minister Putin must understand the severe, long-term negative consequences that their government's actions will have for Russia's relationship with the U.S. and Europe. It is time we moved forward with a number of steps.

"The United States and our allies should continue efforts to bring a resolution before the UN Security Council condemning Russian aggression, noting the withdrawal of Georgian troops from South Ossetia, and calling for an immediate ceasefire and the withdrawal of Russian troops from Georgian territory. We should move ahead with the resolution despite Russian veto threats, and submit Russia to the court of world public opinion.

"NATO's North Atlantic Council should convene in emergency session to demand a ceasefire and begin discussions on both the deployment of an international peacekeeping force to South Ossetia and the implications for NATO's future relationship with Russia, a Partnership for Peace nation. NATO's decision to withhold a Membership Action Plan for Georgia might have been viewed as a green light by Russia for its attacks on Georgia, and I urge the NATO allies to revisit the decision.

"The Secretary of State should begin high-level diplomacy, including visiting Europe, to establish a common Euro-Atlantic position aimed at ending the war and supporting the independence of Georgia. With the same aim, the U.S. should coordinate with our partners in Germany, France, and Britain, to seek an emergency meeting of the G-7 foreign ministers to discuss the current crisis. The visit of French President Sarkozy to Moscow this week is a welcome expression of transatlantic activism.

"Working with allied partners, the U.S. should immediately consult with the Ukrainian government and other concerned countries on steps to secure their continued independence. This is particularly important as a number of Russian Black Sea fleet vessels currently in Georgian territorial waters are stationed at Russia's base in the Ukrainian Crimea.

"The U.S. should work with Azerbaijan and Turkey, and other interested friends, to develop plans to strengthen the security of the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil pipeline.

"The U.S. should send immediate economic and humanitarian assistance to help mitigate the impact the invasion has had on the people of Georgia.
Our united purpose should be to persuade the Russian government to cease its attacks, withdraw its troops, and enter into negotiations with Georgia. We must remind Russia's leaders that the benefits they enjoy from being part of the civilized world require their respect for the values, stability and peace of that world. World history is often made in remote, obscure countries. It is being made in Georgia today. It is the responsibility of the leading nations of the world to ensure that history continues to be a record of humanity's progress toward respecting the values and security of free people.

"Thank you."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

The "Straight Talker" no longer wants questions since some members of the press no longer fawn all over him.  When he actually has to justify his positions he doesn't come off very well.
I watched McGoo on tv, and he read his whole statement that someone else wrote for him, then rudely walked away when a question was asked. The creepy white haired dude should scare all of us.
"And he called on the secretary of state to travel to Europe and outline a "common Euro-Atlantic position" on how to proceed.

"Russian President Medvedev and Prime Minister Putin must understand the severe, long-term negative consequences that their government's actions will have for Russia's relationship with the U.S. and Europe. It is time we moved forward with a number of steps."
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Who's presumptuous now?

Shouldn't President Bush be speaking for the Republican Party on this matter, especially when it comes to when and where the Secretary of State will travel?

I'm am sure the media will feign just as much outrage about this presumptuous statement as it has about Obama's "exotic" vacation choice.

(I'm not holding my breath.)



Trying to post AGAIN from earlier thread...


This woman knew exactly what she was doing.  Disgusting.  However, it doesn't mean he had to fall for it.

What is the reason that she wouldn't want the DNA test?  My theories are (a) it's NOT his and she wants to keep riding the gravy train, or (b) it IS his and she wants to keep the story going.

Anyone else?
-----------------
"Having thought about this for thirty minutes, I still think the guy would be one hell of a VP.  Not to minimize the misstep, but...

(MI Chick--okay, you're right.)
iowan (Sent Friday, August 08, 2008 4:45 PM)"

Not sure what I was right about, iowan, but thank you!  It's always a good way to start a Monday!
Cooler heads must prevail in this circumstance.

Calling for the UN to 'condemn' stuff is not the right move right now.  Helping the situation would be providing food and aid for those innocents who are caught in the middle of the fighting.  Humanitarian aid should be the first priority -- not condemnation.

http://thepajamapundit.com/
This candidate is flying the banner of the party with absolutely 0% credibility in the realm of foreign relations and policy. Did he not see Bob Costas own Bush in his interview yesterday?  He is sewn up in the hem of this debacle of an Admistration, and any and all statements he makes fall on ears tuned elsewhere.
you know how ridiculous it is for the u.s. to criticize russia about this deal while we occupy someone else’s sovereign nation, please. I suspect mccains comments will have a somewhat muted impact.
Everyone should read this...

It explains why my spidey-sense goes off whenever Johnny Mac is on my screen.

Obama '08

http://phoenixnewtimes.com/content/printVersion/848709
Has anybody seen the movie, "Wag the Dog"?  This situation with Russia/Georgia seems eerily similar. The way McCain is seizing on it and politicizing it is sickening, like a "meal ticket" issue to garner support.

BTW, I saw "Swing Vote" this weekend. Pretty good flick. The main point is that every vote counts and that we should be informed of the issues.  So true!
Russia doesn't care what we think. They are out to reclaim some Soviet-era power. What moral authority to protest do we have anymore? Can we sell them one used Mission Accomplished sign for 5 trillion dollars?
Asked for a comment, Barack Obama just said, "Hey, can't I just finish my waffle?".
"Georgia is an ancient country, at the crossroads of Eastern Europe and Central Asia, and one of the world's first nations to adopt Christianity as an official religion."
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Why is Georgia's religion relevant? What is Senator McCain trying to imply, that this is a Holy War?

Partisanship aside, John McCain scares the hell out of me. Seriously.
>> Calling for the UN to 'condemn' stuff is not the right move right now. <<

What do want the UN to do - say they support it?
Knowing that band of third world thugs though, they just might.
The Obamas went to Hawaii to see Obama's grandmother - but only Obama visited with her - for only an hour.
McCain: "Georgia is an ancient country, at the crossroads of Eastern Europe and Central Asia, and one of the world's first nations to adopt Christianity as an official religion."

I don't think so. I thought Georgia became a country somewhere in the 10th or 11th century. This is hardly ancient and well after many others established Christianity as an official religion.
The reason McCain does not want to answer press questions is that he can not explain why it is acceptable for America to do a preemptive attack on Iraq and not acceptable for Russia to do a preemptive attack on Georgia.  Such a hypocrite!!!

Also I'm not sure he knows the geography of the area, or the issues involved. Bush talks tough, Chaney talks tough, McOld talks tough. But we are so bogged down in Iraq and Afghanistan, there is little we can do...other than start WWIII.  What Republicans do not understand is that diplomacy is not giving in.  It is finding solutions do difficult problems. Putin knows we are "busy" with Iraq and he can do what he wishes.  Another reason to get out of Iraq.  Note: the Iraqis want a definite time table for us to LEAVE.
"We have other important strategic interests at stake in Georgia, especially the continued flow of oil through the Baku-Tblisi-Ceyhan pipeline, which Russia attempted to bomb in recent days"
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Did somebody say oil? Funny how that keeps coming up . . . it's almost like we are a slave to oil and those who sell it - and yet the solution to every problem is to drill for more of it. Go figure.
This guy is so unqualified to take questions of importance it's sad that he's gotten this far.  Keating Five McCain is not in Barack Obama's league.  I hope the press makes as much of McBlinky's refusal to answer questions (acting like he's already president)as they have about things Obama has done like drawing 200,000 people to his speech in Berlin.  
That's going to make a great commerical this fall for McCain. Barack Obama standing on the stage at that huge Michigan event with John Edwards, and Edwards endorsing him.

And, haven't the Michigan voters been abused enough by the Democrats? Not even counting Kilpatrick.
His "handlers" won't allow McFossil to take questions. #1. He won't know the answer without someone whispering it in his ear. #2. He still thinks Georgia is a state in US. #3. He might forget the question. This man should scare the bejesus out of everyone even remotely THINKING about voting for him. Obama '08
But if McCain is trying to own this issue while Obama is away on vacation, why isn't he taking questions from this press? Is he afraid of making policy on the fly if reporters press him on what those "negative consequences" for Russia would be?  

----------------------------------------

Shhhh...don't bother him.  He's trying to look "Presidential" and pass the "Commander-In-Chief" test.

What are those "negative consequences"?  Well, again, he represents the GOP...not big on details.
Re:"Russia’s assault on the sovereign nation of Georgia",it seems to me that USA is in no position to respond in word or deed against  this conflict. Russia assault on Georgia,although it may be disproportionate,was provoked.The war declared and carried out by the USA on the sovereign nation of Iraq was unprovoked by Iraq.Perhaps any response of the USA to Russia should be prefaced with the qualifier,"Remember, Russia, to do as we say,not do as we do."
While our next president spends time taking a much deserved break on his "exotic" vacation, McCain sees fit to try and fill the president's shoes...and the press runs amuck over details of an affair over someone who is no longer in the running for president, while they ignore McCain's gesture to offer up his wife's body parts to be oogled by a bunch of bikers, known for their illicit conduct at an annual outing...what a circus.

Enjoy your rest, but please hurry back Senator Obama, and bring some semblance of order, balance and sanity to this world.
Nashville_fan:  I think the administration purposely stepped back and let McCain speak for them on this issue to trot him out him as the next Republican
"commander-in-chief."  Nice political move, though obvious.

I'm no John McCain fan, but this is a nice history lesson and a pretty good statement.

Obama '08  
Oh my gosh. I just looked up Georgia in Wikipedia, to see if my memory was correct regarding when Georgia became a kingdom under that name.

What I found was... the first few paragraphs of the McCain statement. They very quickly read through Wikipedia and then wrote the historical background to the McCain statement... making a couple mistakes, such as stating that Georgia was one of the first countries to establish Christianity. Its predecessor tribe countries, particularly Iberia, were among the first.

This is too funny. McCain went to the Cliff Notes of world history, and then misread that material.
Let's see - we practice unilateral, first strike aggression anytime the administration thinks it can lie us into it, but the world should condemn this. The world condemned Iraq, but never mind that - that's us.

Besides, didn't prezidunt Puddin' head look into Putin's eyes and see a saint? ANd his judgement has always been so good.
you know how ridiculous it is for the u.s. to criticize Russia about this deal while we occupy someone else’s sovereign nation, please. I suspect mccains comments will have a somewhat muted impact.
MK,MO (Sent Monday, August 11, 2008 10:37 AM)

So you're saying Russia is in Georgia under UN mandate like we have in Iraq?
It's because he thinks Putin is the Prime Minister of Germany; hate to have that come up again.
McCain is showing his inability to answer tough questions in real time, something an effective president of our free country must do.
McCain: "That makes Russia's recent actions against the Georgians all the more alarming. In the face of Russian aggression..."

It seems to come down to how one sees Ossetia. The Ossetians don't see themselves as Georgian. They don't want to be in Georgia.

The Georgians sent troops into this area, and the Russians responded to that move.

So if we see Ossetia as part of Georgia, then in a fairy tale world of black and white, Russia is clearly the aggressor. But if we see Ossetia's status as something more complex, then we see Georgia as a potential initial aggressor.
"The Obamas went to Hawaii to see Obama's grandmother - but only Obama visited with her - for only an hour.

- carla"
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^\
Carla,

Why?

Surely you are not this small, and no amount of "McCain blogger points" is worth selling your soul over.

Don't be one of those little people talking about little things this year.

Be the change.
Response to McLame's "celebrity" ad:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yGIqGaWZOo0
Great rersponse to the McLame lies.
What’s all this fuss about Georgia?  I thought that General Sherman took care of that problem when he burned Atlanta.  And we even moved the “Home of the Braves” to Atlanta to make sure they were firmly in the Union.  

Oh, you mean the old Soviet Georgia?

Never mind.  

(And by the way, stop trying to confuse Miss South Carolina, who’s still looking for the State of Georgia on her map.)
Also, did anyone notice this was a different message than hot head initially delivered?

I seem to remember McCain calling for peace keeping troops. That was his big initial move. Where did that one go? Just another case of McCain being McCain?
I am sure McCain has no understanding of what he said. He is not the one who wrote the statement, that is so obvious.
At this time the U.S. can not any creditable request of the Russians to stop and pull-out. This is the Russian equivalent of "Shock and Aweski." When you live in a glass house. Besides when you are a "bully," every once and a while you gotta smack someone to gain the fear factor.
David Gregory is a disappointment:

Hello Chuck,

Please you guys need to save the MTP program from the partisanship that David Gregory is bringing to into. Agreed, he can do whatever he likes with his race to white house probramme but not MTP, the programme is too sacred to be left in the hand of a biased anchor like David. I know he deserves the right to support any candidate but he must realise that he is talking to a diverse audience so he needs to bury his partisanship and give the programme the crdibility that was given it by uncle Tim. People like David continue to let our hearts broken for the sudden death of uncle Tim by the biased mind. Watch his own race to the white house programme and see what am talking about. Ones again please stop him from anchoring MTP before he spoils this show for us.

Thank you
Oh, I see that McWarrior has backed off of his call from last week for NATO and EU to send troops.  The thing that REALLY bothers me about this candidate is that his entire mindset and comfort zone revolves around military movements.  Not a good sign for the future of American diplomacy as a first resort and WAR as a last resort.
Mccain's camp can't even put out a factual statement. I'm sure they don't want their candidate 'shooting from the hip', so they have supressed him.

Major warning flags are going up all over folks!  Pay close attention!

Mccain does ONE event a day and sleeps in late.  This is absurd,to push off this candidate as fit to enter the White House.  Mccain is not fit physically, morally or dispostionally. The thought just scares me with shudders to think of him in the White House, but if the majority of Americans buy the lies, like they did with Bush, I hope they get all they deserve and more.  It will not bode well for them.

Mccain's camp can't even put out a factual statement. I'm sure they don't want their candidate 'shooting from the hip', so they have supressed him.

Major warning flags are going up all over folks!  Pay close attention!

Mccain does ONE event a day and sleeps in late.  This is absurd,to push off this candidate as fit to enter the White House.  Mccain is not fit physically, morally or dispostionally. The thought just scares me with shudders to think of him in the White House, but if the majority of Americans buy the lies, like they did with Bush, I hope they get all they deserve and more.  It will not bode well for them.

He's not taking questions because his handlers, who haven't been real successful at handling him, can't afford to find themselves in the position of having nothing better to say than that McCain doesn't speak for the McCain campaign.  Best to just let him  read his piece and give him the hook.

How can any sane American can contemplate putting this man in the White House at a time like this?  He constantly demonstrates lack of knowledge, wisdom and complete inability to manage his own campaign. How's he going to manage his administration?  

That's exactly what we've had with the Bush and another 4 years of it could guarantee for good that the 21st century will NOT be another American century.
Sen. Obama has done a superbly effective job of joining McCain and Presi-dunce Bush together on a number of issues, particularly foreign policy. McCain is posturing and trying to act presidential, but can't quite pull it off, especially when he begins to speak from his Cliff Notes. No surprise that he will not take questions since he clearly is not capable of answering on the fly.

GWB has had a perpetual look of "deer caught in headlights" for 7.5 yrs and the U.S. cannot afford to take a chance on John McCain's obvious lack of know-how, judgement, and brain power to govern in these dangerous times. That is, unless, he can get Dick Cheney to run as hs V.P. The Bush apron strings would therefore, be complete.

Hurry Back Sen Obama!
John McCain... The War Monger?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IlX9l1g1ZE0&eurl
Good catch on that Wikipedia article!  McCain just doesn't know what he is doing and it becomes more evident by the day.  Since he has the whole week to himself he should have to field some questions about the Russia-Georgia situation.  Remember this is the guy that claims that he "knows how to win wars" and also has been crowned by our lazy media to be a foreign policy expert.  My 5th grade social studies is 10x the expert that John McCain is.  Just make sure that Lieberman or any of his other cronies aren't there to whisper the answers in his ear.
He didn't take questions - b/c when he does, it becomes glaringly obvious that he thinks it is still 1983.
why isn't first read commenting on the event that john mccain was at on friday where he spoke to a group of veterans, barack spoke as will, what came out from this was that the veterans were not happy that mccain spoke very bad about obama and did not talk about veterans issues!! in the end they did a pool and 80% of those who attended said they are not voting for john mccain, including a decorated vietman vet!!!

this is the type of story you should be commenting on, not the silly stupid ads!!!
Black children are told by their elders that a Black man has to be twice as good. Well, Obama is that and more. He’s not only twice as good, but I’m convinced that there’s a depth to his character that we haven’t even begun to recognize. So if by some chance Obama happens to fail in this effort, it won’t be his failure, it’ll be ours.
Did McShame really say Russia should withdraw their troops?  Isn't that cutting and running and deciding to lose a war?
Magoo is delusional. He's so obvious. No one is listening to all these statements he's making. He's a toothless tiger.

What I see is that under Magoo we would have a very impotent military that would be continually over extended.

And with all of Magoo's undiplomatic statements, there would be no other influence in critical matters like this.

In other words 4 more Bush years.
Carla, Senator Obama's grandmother is 85 yrs. old and in poor health.  She may be dying.  She may not be able to handle alot of commotion going on around her.  I'm sure Senator Obama is trying to respect her as you appear not be by insinuating that he isn't doing the right thing.   Bill Clinton's mother died shortly after the convention that she attended and looked great!  I was surprised when she died and hated it for President Clinton.  


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1259345

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google