ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



U.S. repeats call for Russia to stand down

Posted: Monday, August 11, 2008 11:17 AM by Domenico Montanaro
Filed Under:

From NBC’s Libby Leist
The U.S. is continuing to try to find a diplomatic solution to the fighting between Russia and Georgia. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice made 50 calls over the weekend, her spokesman said, and this morning the U.S. is again calling for the Russians to stand down and accept a ceasefire. [UPDATE: State now says Rice has made 90 calls.]

"We want to see the Russians stand down and to stop attacks on Georgia,” spokesman Robert Wood told reporters. “Most importantly, we want to see an immediate ceasefire. I understand that the Georgians have offered to be party to a ceasefire, the Russians have not responded."

Wood defended Rice for not flying to the region to personally intervene in the crisis by saying she has been working through the weekend and has all the modern technology available to mediate from afar.

In her place, Rice dispatched a lower-level State Department official, Matthew Bryza, to the region to participate in the international efforts to bring about a ceasefire. He left last night.

Wood said the U.S. would continue to try to push for a "strong resolution" condemning Russia in the Security Council, but that seems unlikely given Russia's status as a permanent member of the council.

Tomorrow, French President Sarkozy is expected to begin shuttle diplomacy between Georgia and Russia to help bring about an end to the fighting. France holds the Presidency of the European Union this year.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Maybe Commander Barack Obama could take the brigade that he was going to use to invade Pakistan, take it to Georgia, and see if he can settle this disbute.
I just don't think the bushleage of injustice has much credibility telling others not to attack...especially shrubs good buddy vlad the imperialist...
It looks as though President Bush and his entire family made it over to China. Who is paying for all this?

Meanwhile, Cokie Roberts has a problem with Senator Obama vising his grandmother in Hawaii.

These inside the beltway pundits drive me to drink sometimes. Who is Cokie to decide what's acceptable for a vacation? He's visiting his grandmother. The only parent he has.

Is it true that Washington Insiders are calling Obama 'The Dark Knight'?
McCain is a War Monger, same as Bush. Itching to rush this country into another war. Russia is the winner because of the IRAQ  blunder.
Chris Wallace Exposes McCain Lies and Third Bush Term  by PA mnon Sun Aug 10, 2008 at 03:48:39 PM PDT
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2008/8/10/104952/579/799/565688

"Stand Up" Highlights McCain's Deep Involvement in Deal with
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M_I6GXfDUSM&eurl

Hard-Hitting Ads Go Up Against McCain
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2008/8/10/212716/278/547/565916
Maybe Sarkozy can accomplish something.

It seems unlikely that Putin now can be seen as backing down from U.S. tough talk. That simply won't play at home in Moscow, especially given our hypocrisy of feigning outrage that Russia would violate another country's sovereignty.

So we've maneuvered ourselves in a position of not only being inneffectual, but actually almost forcing Putin to do the opposite of what we want. So hopefully Putin feels he can afford the perception of Sarkozy as diplomatic go-between Russia and Georgia.
Rice should be walking the streets of Georgia. Engaging in hand to hand combat if necessary. Just like Jimmy Carter is doing.
As we stand witness to the U.S. Foreign Policy House of Cards beginning to fall, I couldn't be sadder.

Even though Senator Obama was right about Iraq, and Afghanistan, and the place that diplomacy should have in our foreign policy - I would be just as happy if he were wrong. Why?

Because I don't enjoy seeing America disrespected on the world stage. Because I don't enjoy our soldiers being killed, our politics being reduced to one side trying to make the other side look bad at the expense of our nation.

I know it is an election year. I know that both sides want to win. But things are getting too serious to continue to play politics with our national security.

The Democrats and Republicans should call a cease fire on foreign policy and work TOGETHER to return this country to it's proper place of moral authority and leadership in the world.

Anything less is irresponsible and unacceptable.

I just tried to watch Magoos 9 min video statement on Georgia. I had to shut it off after 1 minute. It was an awful history lesson from the crypt keeper.

He's in front a black funeral back drop, wearing a black funeral suit. This guy is the grim reaper.

With the shear joy of the Olympics here is this negative, angry war monger.

This is sad.
This is what happens when American is fighting the wrong war with the wrong people.  Putin does not have to listen to us.  Bush/McCain are two old men shouting at clouds.  Diplomacy is not giving in.  It is finding solutions before using military solutions.  McCain just doesn't get it!!!
Hopefully Rice and the State Department have a deeper understanding of the situation than that provided by Wikipedia.

Even if they don't, unlike McCain I'm sure her advisors can at least comprehend what that website has to say.

Here's a new campaign slogan: McCain, the best foreign policy experience Wikipedia has to offer.
Why won't Putin listen to George W.?  Aren't they buddies?  Maybe Putin knows all of our military is tied up Iraq!  We have no leverage what-so-ever because we are in war that should have never been fought.  We are all 'surged' in Iraq!  We are a laughing stock to the world!  See how well they listen!  
Barack Obama helped out by recommending the Georgian  fighters check the tire pressure on their vehicles.
Why won't Putin listen to George W.?  Aren't they buddies?  Maybe Putin knows all of our military is tied up Iraq!  We have no leverage what-so-ever because we are in war that should have never been fought.  We are all 'surged' in Iraq!  We are a laughing stock to the world!  See how well they listen!  
Everyone is advocating diplomacy except McCain (the world's oldest warrior) and Cheney (the world's oldest coward). This country has a depleted military and we a "war broke" and this senile old fool is talking about war. HE'S NOT GOING !!! HE CAN'T EVEN RAISE HIS ARM UP!!!
I wonder what Bush sees now when he looks longingly into Putin's eyes. http://twocanpete.blogspot.com
Folks....It's started!  World War Number Three is about to happen...if Bush/Cheney/McCain get into this fray.  This country has lost all credibility in the world!  How the hell can you ask someone to stand down after the Iraq invasion!  WTF is Condi thinking?  Don't touch this one...it's gonna get HOT!  
Guess what? Russia won't listen to the Security Council any more than the US did regarding Iraq. I'm not blaming the US for Russia's ignoring of the Council, and I think that they might be acting the same even if we hadn't started an illegal and unjustified war in Iraq, but I am saying that they learned or were at least reassured from our example that a superpower can basically do anything it wants apart from directly engaging in conflict with another super (or at least developed) power. And what can the Bush do about it? Nothing, since he is considered a hypocrite around the world without a moral leg to stand upon. Not to mention that he has obviously all but given up on trying to do anyone any good as President. He should just resign now and go back to the Olympics as a private citizen.
This is a great example of why you need credibility in matters of diplomacy.  Unfortunatly this Administration has none...

I hope the new Obama administration can fix our image before its too late...these are scary times...even scarier if McCain wins the election...
I'm a democrat and totally ashamed of the response of the Bush administration to this incident that places one of our allies into great peril.  

First, exactly what did Bush's looking into Vladimir Putin's eyes do to prevent this?  Apparently, not much.  Rook takes pawn.

Check Second, exactly what is the famous Russia expert Condoleezza Rice doing about this?  Didn't she see this coming with her super X-ray vision?  Check.

And third, why shouldn't we do something militarily, like send a few NATO planes to back the Russians off?  Oh, I forgot, Putin blocked the attempt to get Georgia into NATO, and Bush let him get away with it.  So no help from NATO, I guess.  Checkmate.

http://www.eurasianet.org/departments/insight/articles/eav040408.shtml

Vote for McCain and see if you don't get more of the same.  

I dare you, just like Putin is now daring Bush.
You think maybe the U.S. would hold a bit more sway, if say we didn't unjustly invade a country too? Just asking.
Tomorrow the French PRESIDENT will begin talks with the Russian and Georgian officals.Where have I heard this before?Obama,yes thats who.While Mcbush is not playing Prez anymore and has let darth handle this.Since Condi has sent a LOW LEVEL paper boy to shore up this situation we have nothing to worrie about right?, since she has choose to not give up her weekend and the bomber has chosen to not answer questions.So all you chicken hawks out there,the Russians are not scared of you saber rattlers,so now what BOMB,BOMB,BOMB,Moscow?
"Stop...or...or...or we'll say stop again!"

Yeah, that oughta work!
So Russia invades Georgia (or do we disagree on this), and McCain is a war monger.  BO wants to bomb Pakistan and he is a diplomat?

The logic is astounding!
Nashville Fan:
Because I don't enjoy seeing America disrespected on the world stage.

Perhaps, all those Americans can NOW appreciate what Obama was trying to do in GERMANY, GREAT BRITAIN AND FRANCE.

He was trying to get the world to TRUST US AGAIN!!!
Nancy Pelosi could call for an end to the war, but she and the rest of the democratic controlled do nothing congress is on vacation and cannot do anything until they get back and even if they could do anything, they cannot do anything about it so they may as well just stay on vacation like they have for the last two years.
Oh my Gawd, dude, Wikipedia????  Ya can't even make this stuff up
Pat in Beantown, I'm with ya dude
Cokie--------with a name like that you got no bidness beefin up someone else
Bush destroyed our relationship with Putin,  an ex-KGB and marital artist who pays no attention to this man. A shrub cannot go against a bear.
Condi has no creditability. This statement she made about Israel… Israel can do her what she wants with Iran. It makes no sense in other words is Condi suggesting bomb bomb bomb Iran?
Why should Russia listen to the likes of Bush? Didn't we go to war with an innocent country, destroy thousands of lives and now won't leave because it would be losing?  And that dirty McShame going around singing bomb, bomb, bomb? Give me a break - we have NO credibility.
As serious as this is, and as much as I hate to see things like this going on in the World, I would like to know: What can we do about it? Bush/McCain have absolutely ZERO credibility when talking about the severity of attacking a sovereign nation, such as Georgia. All Putin needs to do is point to Iraq as an example of the American Hypocrisy.

This only goes further to show that not only that invading Iraq was a mistake, but that staying there keeps us from responding to these kinds of crisis around the World. This is the same policy McCain wishes to continue. Good luck with all that!
the McCain Cheney  old war  stance has put us HERE.

complicating factors by having a foreign policy chief on his campaign who was the lobbyist for one side of this disagreement who helped the President of Georgia play tough guy to crazy KGB man Putin...

this was all stupid and mcCain's stance (which is a heck of a lot closer to Cheney on ALL of his foreign policy than it is even to Bush)

has made this an impossible situation where we can't legitimately and credibly call for Russia to drawdown because we are in the meantime occupying a land using the same reasons that Medvedev is using for Georgia.

It is crazy that anyone is trying to sweep what mccain's comments, stances and policy promises  have done to us in this situation...on so many levels.
We've spent the last 7 years insulting Russia while using Iraq to prove we are not the invincible superpower.  No wonder Putin treats us with disdain...that's how Bush treated him.
Perhaps Condi would be more effective about Georgia if she went to Dubya and told him to "sand down in Iraq". Get that through his thick skull and perhaps Vlad will follow that example. After all, they are "good friends".
Totally off the subject, but, does Lou Dobbs write what Kitty Pilgram says when she takes his place? She sounds more like him every day. Two disgusting commentators.
Magoo is confused again. Here are 2 AP headlines:
# McCain calls for diplomatic effort with Russia  AP, 1 minute ago
# McCain accuses Russia of bidding to wipe out Georgia AFP, 19 minutes ago

Senator Magoo, you can't accuse Russia of genocide then try to make nice nice. Denying you said something won't work on other countries.

He would be a disaster as president.
Who is that creepy white haired old guy waving his hands ar Russia?
WHY should Russia listen to Bush when Bush invaded Iraq when everyone was crying that the US should NOT invade? Who is he to tell the Russians to cease fire? Pleeze. This is not the guy you want negotiating. About like McCain trying to negotiate....he'd rather just bomb, bomb, bomb. That's all he knows. Obama '08
FR, why aren't you talking about the fake birth certificate the republicans to use as fodder before the Democratic convention? FR, why aren't you talking about the fake birth certificate the Republicans to use as fodder before the Democratic convention?

Nobody but Obama
This is rich:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UHoXkCprdL4&feature=related

It shows McCain in his 2000 campaign complaining about Bush's negative, untruthful ads. At the end of this ad, McCain emphasizes that he is the truthful one.  Wow, I wish.
>> The world doesn't listen to the US anymore. (Sent Monday, August 11, 2008 11:31 AM) <<

Good. That should save us some money. What say we start with that $45 billion we sent to Africa for AIDS treatment and prevention? Hopefully that check didn't clear yet.
Bush has no crediability anywhere. He has no shame either, this administration is the worst we have ever had.  Bush goes to China and thinks he is the center of attention, this is the Olympics, not Bushs stage. Why waste time on Bush when, the sports is what is important. January can not come fast enough.
All of Senator John McCain's Celebrity appearances can be seen here.  I would have listed them all, but there were 42 different shows, and mulitiple appearances per show.  

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0564587/

Obama 08
The Democrats and Republicans should call a cease fire on foreign policy and work TOGETHER to return this country to it's proper place of moral authority and leadership in the world.

Anything less is irresponsible and unacceptable.


Nashville_fan

----------

Excellent post. Certainly the Bush administration is working hard to solve the problem. Pelosi and Reid should schedule a vote today to do the same. Oops, nevermind, they're on vacation for another 4 weeks. They'll get right on it when they get back though.
Why would Putin listen to GB, he already knows that Bush is a cowboy and weak. he is the worst president that we have ever had. We need a president that is smart like Barack Obama.
Once again, the shattered remains of the "government" Shrub left behind when he went to kiss the Chinese's keester is making another ineffectual statement.  I'm sure Putin is crying his soulful eyes out that he's betrayed shrub, the only person stupid enough to think he was a "good man"---or maybe he's laughing his butt off at shrub and the rest of us.
didn't he look him him the eye, BUSH IS SUCH A MORON,
"Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice made 50 calls over the weekend"


Wow. What more could be asked of the Russian specialist, Kindalousy Rice? Unless the calls were over some shoes she likes - didn't say, did it?

Don't worry, everybody! The Shrubster looked into Putin's eyes years ago and declared hima truly great guy, and if you can't believe a president you'd liek to have a beer with - well, what have you gout, really?
On just what grounds do W-Dumb and his boys think they have a right to criticize Russia's invasion of the former Soviet Republic of Georgia?  Do they own a map?  Does anyone remember Iraq?
Didn't Russia tell Bush & his war buddies to stand down in Iraq? The USA has set a precedent now, where we cant do anything about it now because we would be Hyporcrites as usual !!
Make sure the Russians don't hold any of their prisoners in 'stress positions'

Do you think the Russians are 'water boarding' their prisoners ?

The nerve of those people, attacking a smaller country

John McCain, Endless War
Why didn't Bush leave China when he found out that Russia invaded an ally? He sat there and watched olympic games with American in a country being invaded! This guys has no clue!

Obama/Hagel 08 Real Unity


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1259532

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google