ABOUT FIRST READ

First Read is an analysis of the day's political news, from the NBC News political unit. First Read is updated throughout the day, so check back often.

Chuck Todd, NBC Political Director

Mark Murray, NBC Deputy Political Director

Domenico Montanaro, NBC News Political Reporter



McCain vs. Obama: House Party 7 (or 8)

Posted: Friday, August 22, 2008 9:19 AM by Mark Murray

The Washington Post front-pages that McCain’s “inability to recall the number of homes he owns during an interview yesterday jeopardized his campaign's carefully constructed strategy to frame Democratic rival Barack Obama as an out-of-touch elitist and inspired a round of attacks that once again ratcheted up the negative tone of the race for the White House.” More: “For a Democratic candidate suffering from a barrage of attacks on his ‘celebrity,’ McCain's inability to recall the scope of his family holdings was a timely break.” 

The Los Angeles Times: “For Democrats, the kerfuffle carried a clear whiff of payback. Four years ago, Republicans turned a harsh spotlight on the five homes owned by the Democratic nominee, Massachusetts Sen. John F. Kerry, and his heiress wife, Teresa Heinz Kerry. For Republicans, it was deja vu of another kind. Last month, one of McCain's top economic advisors, former Texas Sen. Phil Gramm, was forced to resign from the campaign after he told a newspaper that the United States was "a nation of whiners" who were suffering a "mental recession" over the economy.”

Last night, the McCain campaign released a response ad that played the Tony Rezko card. “Barack Obama knows a lot about housing problems. One of his ‘biggest fundraisers’ helped him buy his million-dollar mansion. Purchasing part of the property he couldn't afford.”

The DNC, meanwhile, pounces yet again on McCain’s multiple houses with a Web video that contains man-on-the-street interviews with people who all know how many homes they own.

Politico puts the number of McCain’s properties at eight, not seven. “John McCain's family owns at least eight properties — not the seven Democrats are alleging or the four McCain's staff identified — according to a Politico analysis of property and tax records, as well as interviews. The presumptive Republican nominee, though, may have some wiggle room in explaining why he couldn't immediately provide an answer when asked by Politico how many houses he and his wife, Cindy, own. Sen. McCain himself does not own any of the properties. They're all owned by Cindy McCain, her dependent children and the trusts and companies they control.” (Just asking, but isn’t that even worse for John McCain, perception-wise?)

More from Politico: “The heightened scrutiny on the candidates’ personal wealth reflects voter anxiety over the still-struggling economy. The issue has particular resonance as the subprime crisis continues to move through the market, forcing a growing number of homeowners into foreclosure. The campaigns — aware that some of the highest foreclosure rates are in key swing states such as Ohio and Florida — jumped on the issue with a vengeance.”

The New York Times also uses the back-and-forth over McCain’s homes to highlight both candidates’ challenges in connecting with voters on the economy. “With both candidates convinced that financially pinched voters might hold the electoral key in November — especially in swing states like Ohio and Pennsylvania — Senators Obama and McCain are taking new, vivid steps to empathize with struggling middle-class and working-class Americans, a tricky task given their own personal wealth.”

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

The McCain campaign is COMPLETELY missing the point about McCain's houses. This has nothing to do with Cindy's money, and is in NO WAY an attack on her. This is ALL about John McCain and the fact that, regardless of where they came from, he has more houses than he can keep track of!!!! And that's TOO MANY! That is what makes him so out of touch with the economic hardships of average Americans.

And Rezko wasn't even related to the charge Obama was making against McCain, they just wanted an excuse to bring him up. But Obama has already answered every question that he's been asked, and EVERYONE has concluded that Obama did nothing wrong. So what's the big deal?
Ah, the RNC can't take what it dishes out...typical republicans, crying when they get a taste of their own medicine.  Maybe they will learn not to mess with the DNC...what's good for the goose, is good for the gander, it's called karma...you did it to Kerry, now we will do it to McCain.  
If he doesn't even know what's going on inside his own house, how can ANYONE trust the old man to run the country?
Finally he has be exposed.McCain is the real elitist.
Lifestyles of the Rich and Clueless - McCain Home Tour Edition
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2008/8/21/17548/4794/434/572131

Fabulous Life of John McCain
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZSrpm3h_40g&eurl

Priceless...
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2008/8/21/192051/895/398/572191

Obama is winning the housing debate... here's how he can keep winning
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2008/8/22/951/65628/635/571946
I know that I own zero homes.  Maybe McCain can lend one to me?  Think of it as a good-will gesture?

http://thepajamapundit.com/
Maybe McCain should give one of his houses to Obama's brother who lives in a shanty town in Africa.
Omg I thought it was only seven.  This guy has too many houses, how could you possibly stay in all of them.  Then should hold a competition and give away one of their house and maybe we'll look past the fact that he doesnt know how many houses he has

Clinton Creates “Whip Team” 4 Convention
http://sensico.wordpress.com/2008/08/21/clinton-creates-whip-team-4-convention/
or
http://sensico2.blogspot.com/2008/07/my-blogs.html
Why are the two candidates bickering with each other about homes, celebrity and the rest of this nonsense? WHO CARES! Get to the real business and issues. This is making me angry and sick, I need to stop reading these blogs and watching the news.

OMG, Dan A. is going off the air! One of the best shows on MSNBC next to Keith O. You will be missed Dan A. and good luck on all future endeavor's.
Man oh man I do love that ad. I sure do hope can get a chuckle out of that one like he does out the attack ads on Obama. You just gotta have a sense of humor, John.
Nice to see the NYTs is putting their shoulder into the McCain housing story. Have they ever bothered to look into the John Edwards affair yet?
Seven, eight... can't be more than a couple million in difference.

But consider all the other stuff McCain does know, sometimes ahead of the fact.

In 2001, he knew the U.S. would invade Iraq, more than a year before the Bush administration claims to have made that decision. And McCain, always thinking national security, kept that secret from everyone except a David Letterman audience.

Years before, he knew the names of the players on the Steel Curtain defense before that defensive unit even existed.

And, sure, he doesn't know the difference between shi'ite and sunni, but he does know the entire region is full of "targets," and from bombing altitude, they all look alike anyway.
Still nothing on the draft statement by McCain...

Why isn't this big news???
I just pray that this gets to the low information voters. Sen. McCain is just too busy (or forgetful or wealthy) to remember how many houses he owns?! Give me a break! Lord help us if he gets in! He is so out of touch with what it means to have to go out and do an honest day's work.      
good for the democratics. Before republicans discuss someone else being an elitist, they should look at the mirror. Obama just finishing paying off his college debt and was raised by a single parent. Yet he is considered an elitist. McCain who is of privelage believes there is nothing wrong with the economy, outsoursing our jobs and the housing crisis. Well, since he has 7-10 homes and is doing well financially I can see why he believes there is nothing wrong with the economy and we are just a nation of whiners as well as suffering from mental recession. What an inconsiderate individual who is insulting working families.
It's hard for me to believe that anyone who doesn't do the grocery shopping or buy gasoline could really have a feel for what's happening.  I suspect that the McCains don't even know anyone who's been in a supermarket in the last 10 years.  

Sean Hannitty laid out the case of how Obama got his house in Chicago with the help of Tony Rezco.  How did he get a house for $300,000 less then the fair market value?  Why would the ReZco's buy the property next to Obama and sell them a portion of it to Obama? Considering Obama's brother is living in a 6 X 9 shack in Kenya and lives on a dollar or less, you would think family comes first.

Now that Obama has taken the genie out of the bottle, we can hear at the debate how his own housing deal came about.  You Liberals need to hold some kind of Telethon or something to raise money to help Obama's brother, since the candidate apparently does not care about his own family.
This couldn't have happened at a better time! People are just now starting to pay attention to this election and this "I don't know how many houses I have" gaffe will go on for awhile. Regardless of his reason for answering that question in this manner, it shows McCain to be the elitist, out-of-touch person he truly is. This is almost as good as the 8 second viagra gaffe he also recently made. BTW has he EVER gotten back to us with THAT answer after having to consult his staff?????? This guy is laughable....NOT presidential.
Let the sideshow shine while America dulls.  In the mean time, I'll go buy a pack of condoms since I know when life begins...
I think this is a total dumb subject for Americans to be worrying about during a time when we need answers to who will best solve the problems Americans face everyday.

I can understand why Senator McCain didn't know.  He wanted to be truthful and many of the properties are owned strictly by Cindy McCain (as FR pointed out) and his name isn't on the deed.  That is all Obama has is John McCain saying he would have to check on that?  The important issue to me would be were they all purchased legally?  Do they pay the taxes on the properties? That is what is important!
I can't believe John McCain wouldn't know how many houses they own...I mean he and Cindy are such "average people" that I'm sure they spend their weekends fixing plumbing, painting their several kitchens and installing installation three seperate rec rooms.  Luckily, they have their private jet to carry them to Home Depot to pick up supplies...as Cindy reminds us "its the ONLY way to get around Arizona".

"The DNC, meanwhile, pounces yet again on McCain’s multiple houses with a Web video that contains man-on-the-street interviews with people who all know how many homes they own."


Yea, How many mansions do Edwards, Kerry, Clinton, Gore, etc. own?

Give me a break.

Wow First Read, STILL no mention of the fact that McBush agrees that we need to REINSTATE THE DRAFT.

Why are you afraid to mention this?

Maybe because when this gets out to the general public McBush would be TOAST???

What about all those mothers out there that will be FURIOUS when they find out that McBush wants to ship their kids off to DIE in one of his ridiculous wars??

What about all those young voters that will come out in DROVES when  they learn that McBush has plans for their future, which includes sending them off to DIE in one of his disgusting wars??

Why don;t you want this to get out their First Read????

Glad I get my real news from a different source, and just come hear for laughs.

I suggest everyone else do the same.
HI,  I just heard an interview with John McCain regarding his 7 houses, as well as comment he
added.. I can't remember the exact quote... but he essentially  said " I have also lived where we didn't have a table". Well, where and when was that??? Please have someone ask him that in the 1st Presidential Debate.  I'd like to know when he was poor as a child growing up , or as a young man , where did live , ever that he didn't have a table??? His father came to be an Admiral in the Military... and I believe that Mr. McCain was not ever lacking for a table in his life.  The only time I can think he would make that comment about, is when he himself would have been in the Military and would not have owned his own table, certainly not as Prisoner of
War. I have total respect for his Military Service, as I do for the Many Millions of other Servicemen & Women who are serving and have served and have been Prisoners of war.

 He does major disservice to just poor like me... I grew up in Attics and Basement ... we always had a table.... not always a bathtub. But I truly resent his implication to all the American people that he grew up in a poor environment.   This is his misleading Voters , & especially his Republican supporters.

 And he has so overplayed his Prisoner-of-War/Hero Status... as though no one else who has served our Country was a POW!  There are so many other POWs who didn't even come back from serving our country in war with a complete body. I think his Hero Status being repeating over and over does the most INJUSTICE TO ALL OF OUR TROOPS THAT HAVE EVER SERVED AND HAVE BEEN POWS, AND especially all those who are permanetly withoout limbs or the ability to move on with a normal life.

MR. MCCAIN SOULD BE ASHAMED OF ANY ADS OR MORE STATEMENTS that are MISLEADING &  MAKING IT SEEM THAT HE WAS THE ONLY WAR HERO IN THE HISTORY OF THIS COUNTRY.... as well as Slapping the POOR AND MIDDLE CLASS CITIZENS IN THE FACE BY CLAIMING... " I didn't always have a table to eat off of"... AND NOW HAS 7 HOUSES AND DIDN'T KNOW IT??? DON'T KNOW WHERE THEY ARE?  MAYBE 1 OF THOSE HOUSES ISN'T FURNISHED... IS THAT WHERE HE DOESN'T HAVE A TABLE....

WOW!!!  TALK ABOUT ELITEST !!!!  GIVE ME A BREAK!!!!

I AM RIGHT NOW IN NEAR TEARS, BECAUSE OF MY OWN SITUATION & ALL THE OTHER THAT JOHN MCCAIN PUTS BENEATH HIM AS THOUGH THERE ARE NO STRUGGLING AMERICANS AND THAT HIS LIFE WAS THE ONLY TRAGIC STORY IN THIS COUNTRY- I HAVE A COLLEGE DEGREE AND NOW AM DISABLED... I DON'T HAVE ENOUGH MONEY FOR 1 HOUSE.... BUT I HAVE 2 TABLES!!!!  

 HE CONTINUES TO SHOW LITTLE REGARD FOR ALL THE STRUGGLING MILLIONS IN THIS COUNTRY;  HIS ATTITUDE DOES NOT REPRESENT ME IN LEAST.    

KATE M. , MILW. , WIS.  , OBAMA & BIDEN SUPPORTER


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1283489

First Read e-mail alerts


Sign up for First Read alerts
The first place for key political news and analysis

Syndicate This Site

Add First Read to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google